ma_guy
Internet Perv
- Joined
- May 26, 2002
- Posts
- 12,880
The Heretic said:It seems to me that there are two questions here:
1) Should public computers (such as those in libraries) be configured such that they do not allow children to access inappropriate content?
2) Can public computers (such as those in libraries) be configured such that they do not allow children to access inappropriate content?
The answer to #1 is a qualified maybe, but it really depends on the answer to #2. There is no real sense in asking if we should do something if we don't know if we can do something.
Given the current state of computers and the internet, I believe the answer to #2 is no. As others have pointed out filters are just too crude to be able to filter out inappropriate material.
I would disagree with this assesment. While it IS true that there is no perfect software filter the point isn't really significant.
1. The law in question doesn't require any specific filter. It is entirely up to the library staff to determine what words are filtered. If they choose to the system dictionary can be empty and it would still comply with the letter of the law.
2. Even if a word list IS used there is nothing that says the customer can't walk up to the librarian and ask to have a specific site unblocked. The Librarians will of course scream that "It's not my job!" as all government employees are bound to do but their claim is on shakey ground already. It is already standard practice for libraries to keep collections off the normal shelves and require patrons to ask for it.
But.. The law in question is all about FUNDING. While many scream about this law infringing on free speech it infringes no more than the Federal Government's refusal to pay for my daily newspaper subscription.
The 1st Amendment may protect the paper's right to report what they want and my right to read it but it doesn't say that the taxpayers have to foot the bill for either of those actions.

