Should Public Computers Be Childproof?

The Heretic said:
It seems to me that there are two questions here:

1) Should public computers (such as those in libraries) be configured such that they do not allow children to access inappropriate content?

2) Can public computers (such as those in libraries) be configured such that they do not allow children to access inappropriate content?

The answer to #1 is a qualified maybe, but it really depends on the answer to #2. There is no real sense in asking if we should do something if we don't know if we can do something.

Given the current state of computers and the internet, I believe the answer to #2 is no. As others have pointed out filters are just too crude to be able to filter out inappropriate material.

I would disagree with this assesment. While it IS true that there is no perfect software filter the point isn't really significant.

1. The law in question doesn't require any specific filter. It is entirely up to the library staff to determine what words are filtered. If they choose to the system dictionary can be empty and it would still comply with the letter of the law.

2. Even if a word list IS used there is nothing that says the customer can't walk up to the librarian and ask to have a specific site unblocked. The Librarians will of course scream that "It's not my job!" as all government employees are bound to do but their claim is on shakey ground already. It is already standard practice for libraries to keep collections off the normal shelves and require patrons to ask for it.

But.. The law in question is all about FUNDING. While many scream about this law infringing on free speech it infringes no more than the Federal Government's refusal to pay for my daily newspaper subscription.

The 1st Amendment may protect the paper's right to report what they want and my right to read it but it doesn't say that the taxpayers have to foot the bill for either of those actions.
 
I could go for something like this.

When the programs are developed they should be installed on certain computers for the kids section of the libraries.

IMHO libraries need more money anyway. (yes i give.)

Funding should not be restricted in anyway no matter what/how/who or why.

Tie your schools and libraries up in knots with a bunch of rules and not enough money and you get what we have in this country today.
 
Thrillhouse said:
I agree 100%. But I just love the irony of misspelling "illiteracy."
Hey - with some people it is "nucular", with others it is "illeteracy", and yet others it is potatoe (which by the way is a legitimate spelling - me I can't pronounce chrysthanimum (and I probably spelled it wrong too). But yes, it is highly ironic - and pretty damned funny too. :D

Spelling buddy says check your spelling before you speak of somebody else's "illeteracy".
 
ma_guy said:
But.. The law in question is all about FUNDING. While many scream about this law infringing on free speech it infringes no more than the Federal Government's refusal to pay for my daily newspaper subscription.

The 1st Amendment may protect the paper's right to report what they want and my right to read it but it doesn't say that the taxpayers have to foot the bill for either of those actions.
Very good elucidation of what I was trying to say.
icon14.gif
 
I guess a good way to think of public computers (anywhere, including libraries) is to consider them a communications/information appliance similar to a telephone. A library should not be responsible for enforcing any kind of control over where any person, including minors, may call from a public telephone situated in a library - whether it be a call to home or a call to a porn number. Same goes for the responsibility of paying for or providing the appliance.

Eventually this will all be a completely moot issue; every person will have their own personal mobile computer with a wireless internet connection, and libraries won't need to nor be able to filter content provided to those computers any more than they can censor content provided to cell phones (some of which BTW do have builtin web browsers).
 
Originally posted by Nora
... The problem with that is that we have hacked and slashed at the education budgets nationwide to the point where there simply aren't enough adults to help monitor the sites the kids would hit. Parents are going to have to decide when they vote if spending cuts are more important than their kids getting into porn sites at school.
What cuts? There's more money spent on the pretense of education today than ever before. And in gereral, the more money spent by a district, the poorer the product.

The real issue here should not be the question of filtering on public computers but why is government even in the business of providing computers?

The Federal government is completely in violation of its Constitutional powers to be involved in edcuation, welfare, libraries, computers, medication, business management and a myriad of other things.

This is the root of the problem, not the filtering software.

If a parent wants their kid to access porn, it's their responsibility to provide the access and to monitor it; not the government's.
Originally posted by Laurel
...They're ineffective and discriminatory.
I was right with you up to this sentence, Laurel.

Just think about what you said here for a second, please! What is a filter but a discriminatory device? It selects (discriminates) based on its design parameters.

And the problem is, if you make the parameters effective enough to filter out all porn, you also filter out lots of non-porn that can be relevant and useful to the subscriber. Another aspect of the problem is that porn purveyors are sharp enough to evade most filters that aren't extremely limiting by the nature of their deisgn parameters.
Originally posted by The Heretic
... me I can't pronounce chrysthanimum (and I probably spelled it wrong too). ...
You did; chrysanthemum :kiss:
 
Spinaroonie said:
Great. If you censor the internet at the library, then they'll start censoring books from the library. This will break down the door. If this goes through you'll have a restricted internet at the library, then they'll start pulling books. "Too contraversial, too liberal, this book could help the terrists, etc."

Been in a library lately? In case you haven't noticed, they already DO censor books (or at least my local library does). Walk along the current periodicals looking for Penthouse, Playboy or Hustler? You won't find them. Try to find the X-rated section of videotapes? It's not there. Searching for those plain-covered books with the explicit stories? No luck, Chuck.

And the last time I checked, the doors were still intact.
 
sigh said:
Been in a library lately? In case you haven't noticed, they already DO censor books (or at least my local library does). Walk along the current periodicals looking for Penthouse, Playboy or Hustler?
Actually you do find Penthouse and/or Playboy in many libraries now, albeit with much of the pictorals removed.

As a number of people have pointed out, not paying for the provision of something is not equivalent to censorship. A library is not preventing you from buying a Penthouse, nor preventing Guccione from publishing Penthouse - both of which would be censorship.
 
The Heretic said:
Actually you do find Penthouse and/or Playboy in many libraries now, albeit with much of the pictorals removed.

As a number of people have pointed out, not paying for the provision of something is not equivalent to censorship. A library is not preventing you from buying a Penthouse, nor preventing Guccione from publishing Penthouse - both of which would be censorship.

Oh for God's sake, STG. You say potato.....

Personally, I think that if a public institution established to provide open access to written and artistic materials chooses to not allow a certain type of material to be available based on the concept of obscenity, then that's censorship, but hey, why argue the definition of the word because it's totally irrelevant to what I was talking about.

Pay attention now because the POINT I was making was that libraries already filter (do you prefer that word?) pornography from their shelves. It's nothing new. In fact, it's something ancient. And despite that, libraries continue to provide an excellent and needed service to our communities. I was commenting against Spinner's "chicken-little-sky-is-falling" overreaction when he worried that if you let in a little, suddenly the dribble becomes a flood.

That sort of argument is a favorite of both the left and the right. The left loves to use it as a scare tactic to protect the first amendment while the right uses it in exactly the same way to protect the second.

(But now I bet you're still gonna argue about the definition of censorship, aren't you? Ah well, such is the beauty of the first amendment. Feel free to censure me at will. :) )
 
sigh said:
(But now I bet you're still gonna argue about the definition of censorship, aren't you? Ah well, such is the beauty of the first amendment. Feel free to censure me at will. :) )
Yup! :D

Actually you are right - it is censorship, but it isn't Censorship. If you want to be technical, which is good, then everybody censors everything they read, just as we all discriminate in one way or another. But when we talk about Censorship with a capital "C" we are talking about the government banning the publication and/or distribution of content. We are not talking about the government withdrawing funds which would be used (innappropriately I might add) for publication and/or distribution of content. For example, it is not Censorship for the government to not fund certain artists, even if it does fund other artists, as it still does not prevent those non-funded artists from creating and publishing their works.

I would assert that a library that does not carry certain publications, or puts filters on their computers, does not infringe on any person's right to say, write, publish or read whatever they want. Now if libraries held book burning parties, helped enact legislation to prohibit publication of any content - then that would maybe be infringing on someone's rights.

Oh, and yes, I did get your point - I am just coming to the same conclusion in a different fashion; it is a moot point. The government is not in the content providing business and whether it decides to provide certain content or not does not consititute Censorship by the government.

Finally, I still do not believe libraries should bother with filters, and there shouldn't be any laws forcing them too either - but then when you get right down to it, the government shouldn't be funding libraries period.
 
Back
Top