"She sucked off the wrong guy!"

[scsinclair]

One of my most potent recurring fantasies is the "mistaken identity" blowjob - a scenario in which a woman goes down on a man she wrongly believes is her husband, boyfriend, lover, etc., but is in fact someone entirely different. I've seen it done in a variety of ways in films, so I suppose it's more of a trope than a story idea by this point. Among the variations I've seen are a mix-up at a costume party, somebody gets in the wrong bed in a dark room, girl under the table doesn't know the men have changed seats, drunk girl comes back from the bathroom in a dark movie theater and sits down next to the wrong guy, guy gets into the shower while the girl already there has soap in her eyes, and (my personal favorite) new bride Sheri St. Clair sucks off a man in a full body cast she believes to be her injured groom in the classic XXX film CANDY STRIPERS 2.

The idea of getting enthusiastically blown by a woman who doesn't realize until I've already cum in her mouth that I'm not who she thought I was is so deliriously hot that I'm interested in reading any variation on the theme. I'd love to see stories built on any or all of the scenarios cited above, or any other twist on the basic theme. If you've already written one or know of one, please share the link. If you'd like to take a crack at writing one, that would be awesome. Even if you just have ideas for scenarios in which this could happen in a story, I'd love to hear them!

 

[Hedo_Harry]

That happened to me in real life! I included it in my story "Anything Goes At Hedo."

 

[scsinclair]

That happened to me in real life! I included it in my story "Anything Goes At Hedo."

That's awesome!!! Definitely have to read that story!!!

 

[alexchubbs2014]

I remember going to a Halloween party that had a vibe to it that anything could happen. In the garage the host had a few couches for people to sit on but the lighting was so low you could barely see your hands in front of your face and there was definitely fooling around going on...along with a lot of smoking. anyhow, I remember thinking this exact thing could happen but my girlfriend at that time would not go out to the garage without me holding her hand.

 

[scsinclair]

I remember going to a Halloween party that had a vibe to it that anything could happen. In the garage the host had a few couches for people to sit on but the lighting was so low you could barely see your hands in front of your face and there was definitely fooling around going on...along with a lot of smoking. anyhow, I remember thinking this exact thing could happen but my girlfriend at that time would not go out to the garage without me holding her hand.

Sounds like a great set-up for a story! Though with this particular variation, I might be inclined to write it not as a mistaken identity thing, but rather as an infidelity story. The girl in the story (not your girlfriend, mind you, but a fictional woman) says she won't go out there without her man, but later on the guy goes to the bathroom and can't find his girl when he comes out. Though he was only in there for a couple of minutes, sure enough he walks out into the garage and there she is with someone's dick down her throat. Different fantasy, of course, but still a fun one. And if you wanted there to be some payback, maybe she finishes what she's doing and looks up to find the guy sitting on another nearby sofa, getting his dick sucked by her sister or best friend.

 

[CuttingEdge]

What about a sex party where a husband and wife are asked to join in a sex game where the wife is blind folded and has to take a few men standing in a row, into her mouth. The wife is very reluctant, BUT it seems innocent, there are only a few guys, she has been wed to her husband for many years, and knows she can identify him.

Unfortunately she doesn't. The man she identifies as her husband turns out to be his best friend and the rules are simple, no matter who is chosen it is the wife's duty to bring the man to orgasm through fellatio. She shows her choice but not stopping with a simple exploratory taste, lets the man come in her mouth and then has the blindfold removed to discover who she has actually given a blowjob to. All to the anger of her husband and the mans wife!

 

[scsinclair]

What about a sex party where a husband and wife are asked to join in a sex game where the wife is blind folded and has to take a few men standing in a row, into her mouth. The wife is very reluctant, BUT it seems innocent, there are only a few guys, she has been wed to her husband for many years, and knows she can identify him.

Unfortunately she doesn't. The man she identifies as her husband turns out to be his best friend and the rules are simple, no matter who is chosen it is the wife's duty to bring the man to orgasm through fellatio. She shows her choice but not stopping with a simple exploratory taste, lets the man come in her mouth and then has the blindfold removed to discover who she has actually given a blowjob to. All to the anger of her husband and the mans wife!

The only problem with this idea is that it's sort of inherent in the premise of the game that there's a possibility she'll pick the wrong dick, and it seems like a man who would be okay with his wife sampling all the cocks at the party probably wouldn't be too surprised or upset if his wife enjoyed sucking someone else's. He might still be mad that she didn't recognize his, but he couldn't really get too pissed that she finished the other guy, in light of the nature & rules of the game.

A better variation on this might be if the husband deliberately tricked his wife by telling her he's going to give her some signal that it's him (a brush on the shoulder, a whistle, a whispered word) before he puts his dick in her mouth. The wife insists she doesn't need a signal because she knows his cock, but he says better safe than sorry. Then, without her knowing it, he tells another guy to give her the signal when it's his turn. The guy gives her the signal and the wife, convinced it's her husband, eagerly sucks him off, to the delight of everyone else at the party who is in on the prank. The woman finishes the man off and smugly removes her blindfold, shocked to see a stranger's cock in her hand and everyone standing around grinning at her. It works better with the husband in on it.

You also gave me another idea. A husband and wife, wanting a little excitement, decide to visit the local adult bookstore or nightclub which is known for its gloryholes. They're both excited but very nervous, their plan being that each will enter the booth on the opposite side of the hole, pretending to be complete strangers. They're convinced that roleplaying like they don't know one another while she sucks him off through the hole will really spice things up in their love life. But when they enter the store, the husband is momentarily distracted as his wife enters a booth, and he inadvertently goes in the wrong one. The wife enthusiastically blows the first cock that comes through the hole, believing it's her husband's. Meanwhile, the husband gets great head from someone he thinks is his wife. But when they both exit the booths, they realize they weren't even adjacent to one another. The people they've really had sex with emerge from their booths, smiling knowingly at the shocked and embarrassed couple.

You could also stretch this scenario out to have both of them fuck someone, too. After the wife finishes blowing the dick, she's about to leave when she's surprised to see it come back through the hole. Turned on, she stands up, lifts her skirt, bends over, and backs her ass against the wall, letting the cock impale her until it cums. This could even happen a couple of times, the wife shocked that her husband is so horny he can keep going like that. But, of course, when she leaves the booth, she finds multiple strangers smiling at her & realizes she's just drained all of their sacks of cum.

And an even better twist on the last scenario is if the husband never makes it into the booth for some reason. Maybe he has to take an emergency phone call, or some other delay which would keep him from entering the booth for several minutes. Then, as he's about to go into his booth, his wife comes out looking flushed and freshly fucked, and all the other guys in the shop are smiling at her.

 

[CuttingEdge]

I concur. You have taken a nugget of an idea and made it even better! That is why I LOVE this sub-forum, people build off other peoples ideas and why I am so free to share my thoughts.

Thank you for taking a half idea and improving it 10 fold!

 

[scsinclair]

I concur. You have taken a nugget of an idea and made it even better! That is why I LOVE this sub-forum, people build off other peoples ideas and why I am so free to share my thoughts.

Thank you for taking a half idea and improving it 10 fold!

It was a great set-up, so thank you!

 

[hpycpl]

how about another twist?

How about another twist?

The couple have been toying with the idea of her playing with another man, but she is reluctant.

At a pool party they go to, there is a very mild version of the blind mans bluff game played. The men keep their bathing suits on and the woman is blindfolded and must recognize her mate by feel alone. Most all of the women players keep it "pg" rated and only feel faces, chest, arms, and maybe ass.

Our couple decides they want to get a laugh and want to wow everyone so they decide to have some fun. They devise a signal (like flexing his pec muscles when she feels them) to let her know it's hubby. That will be her cue to get more risque' and go for his cock through the suit and just about jerk him off in front of everyone. They figure this will get a great laugh from everyone!

Only without telling her, Hubby tells his buddy to flex when she gets to him and hubby makes sure his buddy is before him in line. When the wife gets to him (the buddy) and he flexes, the wife starts to feel his cock through the suit snd reaches inside to kick it up a notch, she then starts stroking it while sucking his nipples etc. all the while getting herself turned in in the process!

After she declares that this is her husband and takes off the blindfold she is shocked but still very horny. She goes back to Hubby and they talk about going further now that she has broken the ice.....

what do you think?

 

[scsinclair]

How about another twist?

The couple have been toying with the idea of her playing with another man, but she is reluctant.

At a pool party they go to, there is a very mild version of the blind mans bluff game played. The men keep their bathing suits on and the woman is blindfolded and must recognize her mate by feel alone. Most all of the women players keep it "pg" rated and only feel faces, chest, arms, and maybe ass.

Our couple decides they want to get a laugh and want to wow everyone so they decide to have some fun. They devise a signal (like flexing his pec muscles when she feels them) to let her know it's hubby. That will be her cue to get more risque' and go for his cock through the suit and just about jerk him off in front of everyone. They figure this will get a great laugh from everyone!

Only without telling her, Hubby tells his buddy to flex when she gets to him and hubby makes sure his buddy is before him in line. When the wife gets to him (the buddy) and he flexes, the wife starts to feel his cock through the suit snd reaches inside to kick it up a notch, she then starts stroking it while sucking his nipples etc. all the while getting herself turned in in the process!

After she declares that this is her husband and takes off the blindfold she is shocked but still very horny. She goes back to Hubby and they talk about going further now that she has broken the ice.....

what do you think?

I love it, but I'd still prefer she finish the guy off right there in front of everyone, before she even realizes it's not her husband. Since she's blindfolded, she'd assume that everyone is gasping and laughing simply because she's going so far, when in fact they're all reacting to the fact that she's jacking off a total stranger with her husband standing tight there. Then the husband leans over and says, "Suck it, baby! Please!"

The wife is not sure, asking, "In front of all these people?!?" She's even about to take her blindfold off, but the guy whose dick she's stroking stops her, and the husband (still right there, so she can't tell it's not him right in front of her) tells her that he doesn't care. He needs it right now.

She drops to her knees, to the delight of the crowd, and proceeds to suck the dick in front of her off. Everyone hoots and hollers, and the husband keeps talking as though it's him she's blowing, until the guy is about to cum. "On your face, baby!" the husband pleads. "I want it all over your face!" The wife agrees, jacking the cock off until it plasters her smiling face, hair, and blindfold with semen. Now the blindfold comes off, and she realizes she's just sucked off a complete stranger in front of all their friends, with her hubby egging her on.

Of course, a nice final twist might be that the wife stands up, looks at the guy she's just blown (perhaps even dabbing a bit of cum off her face with her finger and tasting it, to the randy crowd's delight) who she's not supposed to have ever even met before, and says, "Thanks, Dave. Delicious, as always!" The hubby goes batshit, not sure whether she's serious or teasing him, but she won't tell. Turns out, though, that the lucky guy's name is, in fact, Dave...

 

[loquere]

Illusions Amongst the Pines

{Dreams seep into reality, a nerd & the wrong tent.}

https://www.literotica.com/s/illusions-amongst-the-pines-1