Prediction Time

J

JAMESBJOHNSON

Guest
Next week the Supremes rule on DOMA and Proposition 8.

Take it to the bank: DOMA goes down, and Prop 8 prevails. The Supremes are gonna rule that marriage is a state right and the Feds have no jurisdiction.
 
Whatever it is the Obama administration will have no idea about it but there will be an investigation.
 
Take it to the bank: DOMA goes down, and Prop 8 prevails. The Supremes are gonna rule that marriage is a state right and the Feds have no jurisdiction.

Actually, that's pretty much my take on it and I said so when the court was hearing the cases.
 
Actually, that's pretty much my take on it and I said so when the court was hearing the cases.

Marriage has always been a states right; the Supremes wont create a new right for gays, they'll leave marriage to the states to work out, because that's how its done since the nation was founded.
 
Marriage has always been a states right; the Supremes wont create a new right for gays, they'll leave marriage to the states to work out, because that's how its done since the nation was founded.
Sounds reasonable.

Was that how interracial marriage got legal - state by state? Or did the federal government at some point step in and say "Guys, here's the deal..."?
 
Sounds reasonable.

Was that how interracial marriage got legal - state by state? Or did the federal government at some point step in and say "Guys, here's the deal..."?

I have no idea. I imagine law change was part of some appropriations bill, that's how it usually works. If the state wants the money it has to change its law. Its how some of the ObamaCare law is handled, if the state wants more Medicaid money it has to setup the insurance exchange.

Interracial marriage exists on a different level of abstraction than same-sex or other combinations-permutations folks can imagine. Its one male, one female, non-familial union like traditional marriage.
 
DOMA will be an interesting ruling. Justice Kennedy has a long history of saying Congress has a right to define "dependent", "employer" and "employee" and force states to recognize federal definitions. It stands to reason that "spouse" would follow.

However, Kennedy also has a deep-seated revulsion for homosexuals, he's at least a Vetty-class homophobe and very close to an AJ-class homophobe.

My prediction is he'll punt the ball and either rule so narrowly as not to offend his parish priest, or declare the plaintiffs have no standing to sue.
 
I have no idea. I imagine law change was part of some appropriations bill, that's how it usually works. If the state wants the money it has to change its law. Its how some of the ObamaCare law is handled, if the state wants more Medicaid money it has to setup the insurance exchange.

Interracial marriage exists on a different level of abstraction than same-sex or other combinations-permutations folks can imagine. Its one male, one female, non-familial union like traditional marriage.

It all boils down to "protected classes".

The 14th Amendment, as interpreted by Supreme Court precedents, deals with something called "protected classes", whether you think something is a choice (conduct) or not (status).

If homosexuality (or any sexual orientation) is NOT a "choice" (legally), then "protected class" status applies.

If "protected class" status applies, gay marriage is legal, just like interracial marriage.

The Supreme Court decided in Loving v. Virginia that race was a "protected class", so NO state could invalidate/prohibit interracial marriages.

And if you don't think homosexuality is a "choice" (aka "lifestyle"), please share with us exactly when you decided to become "heterosexual".

Personally, I've been hetero all my life, so I believe it's not a "choice".
 
For sidebar purposes same-sex marriage has always been allowed but in those cases one of the males has androgen insensitivity syndrome...they look and act female naturally from birth. Their bodies ignore testosterone. Its the only allowance I make for gender in lieu of sex.
 
It all boils down to "protected classes".

The 14th Amendment, as interpreted by Supreme Court precedents, deals with something called "protected classes", whether you think something is a choice (conduct) or not (status).

If homosexuality (or any sexual orientation) is NOT a "choice" (legally), then "protected class" status applies.

If "protected class" status applies, gay marriage is legal, just like interracial marriage.

The Supreme Court decided in Loving v. Virginia that race was a "protected class", so NO state could invalidate/prohibit interracial marriages.

And if you don't think homosexuality is a "choice" (aka "lifestyle"), please share with us exactly when you decided to become "heterosexual".

Personally, I've been hetero all my life, so I believe it's not a "choice".

Youre prancing thru the land of combinations & permutations. Is your boner for your sister a choice or natural?
 
Next week the Supremes rule on DOMA and Proposition 8.

Take it to the bank: DOMA goes down, and Prop 8 prevails. The Supremes are gonna rule that marriage is a state right and the Feds have no jurisdiction.

“The federal government, yes, can do most anything in this country.”
Fortney Hillman "Pete" Stark, Jr. (D)

It really doesn’t prohibit the government from doing virtually anything — the federal government. So I don’t know the answer to your question, because I am not sure there is anything under current interpretation of the commerce clause that the government couldn’t do.
John Yarmuth (D)

“Are you serious? Are you serious?”
Nancy Pelosi (D) (on being asked, “Can you find it in The Constitution?”)
 
Back
Top