NotWise
Desert Rat
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2015
- Posts
- 16,083
I like Urban's list but agree that she's overboard on the dialogue tags. Her example here:
“You have a map,” said Ramona. “Figure it out.”
versus
“You have a map.” Ramona took a drag from her cigarette. “Figure it out."
That doesn't fulfill her mandate to avoid slowing down the pace or being distracting, nor does it tell you anything necessarily interesting about her characters or their situation. The smoking business is just that, business, which may add a little color but not enough to support Urban's mandate.
Since this is porn, "slowly" and "pleasure..." but it's difficult to do without either of them.
I think her example is a little too short for me to be critical. Overall, her version with the tags on every sentence was dreadful, and the version with the cigarette was better even though that line didn't work for me very well.
Most of what I've written in the last year-and-a-half has been with very reduced dialog tags. The little actions I insert to focus the reader on the speaker need to illustrate the scene. If they don't, then they're a bigger pause than a dialog tag.
In Urban's example, there isn't enough of the scene to tell whether Ramona dragging on the cigarette helps the scene or not.