Ooops! So sorry. Wrong board.

Rhys,

I agree the BDSM forum is different now. I think Cym added quite a bit to it through her knowledge and experience. She also detracted from it at the same time, by stifling new opinions. I think she should be commended for all she did to get it to where it was. I think it was time for the forum to eveolve again once she left.

Hecate is profoundly insightful in her posts and it is a joy to read them. Many other posters have now found a voice there and add to the conversations we have.

I read your post the same way Hecate did. Either we are both defensive because we post there, or you came off as more critical than you meant.

Bottom line is, no harm no foul in my book. I was just clarifying a few points.
 
Desert Rose, you post on an impressive range of topics, and frequently add substantive comments (when the topic merits such; I don't think there's such a thing as substantive frolicking and merriment).

Lancecastor said:
I see this observation as being emblematic of the prevalent attitude on the GB as espoused primarily by its most vocally prolific posters...i.e. Black & White, you're either with us or you're agin' us...and if we judge you as agin' us, you're worthless.
  1. Lance posts on the GB.
  2. Lance is a vocally prolific poster, with over 7,000 posts.
  3. Lance is a master at painting issues in black and white terms, and dismissing the comments and posts of anyone he deigns within "the Clique."
You know what, looks like I agree with Lance. Tunnel-vision is a problem around here.
 
Mischka said:
Desert Rose, you post on an impressive range of topics, and frequently add substantive comments (when the topic merits such; I don't think there's such a thing as substantive frolicking and merriment).

Thank you for the nice words, Mischka. They mean a lot.
 
Mischka said:
You know what, looks like I agree with Lance. Tunnel-vision is a problem around here.

Indeed.

Comparing my experience with lots of threads and posts on the BDSM Forum, The Playground and the GB, I find that the GB is by far and away the least receptive and least friendly of the three.

Obviously, it has many good points...but you're right...it is a narrow, mean-spirited place, a fact I credit Killer Muffin, Lavender, Ishmael et al with creating and fostering.

Lance
 
Lancecastor said:
Indeed.

Comparing my experience with lots of threads and posts on the BDSM Forum, The Playground and the GB, I find that the GB is by far and away the least receptive and least friendly of the three.

Obviously, it has many good points...but you're right...it is a narrow, mean-spirited place, a fact I credit Killer Muffin, Lavender, Ishmael et al with creating and fostering.

Lance
That is honestly a shame, Lance. I really quite like the place. I've made friends, I've laughed, I've helped people, and they've helped me.

I've looked in on the Playground, but it's not for me. My sense of humor is different, and I'm flirting-challenged. I've skimmed a few threads in the BDSM Forum, mainly when it opened, but again, not my bag. I'm 'nilla (man, I wish cym could see my say that), and the topics do not interest me.

There are many more people on the GB than lavender, KillerMuffin, and Ishmael. In fact, if you focus on the multitude of others, perhaps you'd change your perspective. Have you checked out SilverTung Devil? He is hilarious. Or how about Gaucho's Ten Commandments of Lit? Nora is a culinary master, and can help add pizazz to any meal you mention. HeavyStick and BBW can banter like few others. Angel is about as wry as they come. leXie is ridiculously brilliant. Pyper has traveled extensively in her time here, and has shared many wonderful stories (as well as an essay on her perfect ass). Oliver Klozoff writes some of the best commentary on the human psyche (being a med student and all). Todd has undergone massive changes in his life in the last year, and is changing from Lit's Resident Virgin to a Family Man in one fell swoop. This place is teeming with rich, varied life. Branch out and experience it.
 
Mischka said:
Desert Rose, you post on an impressive range of topics, and frequently add substantive comments (when the topic merits such; I don't think there's such a thing as substantive frolicking and merriment).

  1. Lance posts on the GB.
  2. Lance is a vocally prolific poster, with over 7,000 posts.
  3. Lance is a master at painting issues in black and white terms, and dismissing the comments and posts of anyone he deigns within "the Clique."
You know what, looks like I agree with Lance. Tunnel-vision is a problem around here.

One of the things I have observed here as of late is a tendency to fly off the handle at the slightest remark. Desert Rose took my remark about the BSDM forum posts being insubstantial and apparently took personal offense. Hence, the remarks about how she does post worthwhile things etc. There is a growing tendency on this board to take comments said offhand and react to them personally. I am not immune here, I have done it as well, so don't think I don't understand my own hypocrisy. I have observed that people are very quick to call someone an asshole, when its their attitudes that reflect the assholism and not necessarily the poster. What we see of one another here, is but the tip of the iceburg, and its my opinion that the level of judgmentalism has reached epic proportion. Ironically, both sides of this "clique" disagreement appear to be on the same side. Both are proponents of free speech and both can and have been dismissive of posts that do not fit within a certain structure. Both sides have been dead on with several remarks, and I have gotten a good laugh out of some of the more creative posts where they make fun of one another. Essentially, neither side has managed to agree to disagree yet. As an observer to the ongoing commentary, it seems to me, that with all the insults aside, fundamentally there is an agreement going on here. I suspect, then, these posters focus on one another because they like fighting with one another. So, I am of the opinion that we should leave them to it. :D However, I am reserving the right to drop in my opinion on the matter (like now) at any time. I am going to go join the rest of the rogue posters out there and hope that this calms down. I will say this, this board is not stagnant by any means.:D
 
Back
Top