On Reading: Imagination

anthrodisiac

Dorkaeopteryx
Joined
Oct 12, 2025
Posts
6,276
One of the cool things about writing is that each version of your story gets imagined slightly differently depending on the reader. It means there are almost as many versions of that story as there are people who read it, since nobody pictures the characters exactly the same, or hears their voice quite the same, or visualizes up the setting the same way.

So, as a reader, how does your imagination manifest the story? Do you have go-to images in your head of the MC based on your personal preferences? How vivid are these worlds to you? Are the characters and worlds sketches, or 4k images? Do you prefer when the writer gives you a lot of detail with which to build the story, or keep it more sparse?How much do you feel of the characters' emotions? How important even is it to you to imagine the story?

There are plenty of other angles to explore, so really, share whatever experience your imagination takes as a reader.

Edit: Swapped out some of the original language to keep this more focused on the imagination aspect, not my weird philosophical mumblings.
 
Last edited:
I think this is a mostly unconscious and reflexive "act" on the part of the reader. I think the only time it's "co" anything is when a really edgy author writes something really avant-garde which forces the reader to confront the experience of not having a reflexive reaction, to have to instead ponder and decide what the thing they're reading says, and to understand that it's equivocal and there's no right interpretation.
 
It's ironic that the thing I love most about writing and reading is something I can't actually do. I'm borderline aphantasic (I can only visualize in my dreams), so that means when I'm reading, I see nothing in my mind's eye. I don't really know how anybody or anything actually looks beyond a collection of words. It's primarily abstractions for me — concepts, rather than constructs.

It goes beyond that though. I'm also mostly incapable of empathy, so not only can I not see, hear, smell, or taste the characters, but I can't put myself in their shoes and feel what they're feeling. I can become very attached and care about them, because I get to see their thoughts and come to know them on a very intimate level. I can feel sympathy for them, share in their triumphs and defeats, but I lack the ability to actually feel what they feel.

It means that two of the biggest qualities that most people enjoy about reading are beyond me. I really struggle with understanding how I can feel anything at all when I read, when I have no internal construction and everything is abstraction. My best guess is that it's primarily because I get to be in these people's heads, and being able to understand who they are and what drives them makes me feel close to them. It's intimate, and so I care about them, because I can see what they're going through and how it affects them.
 
how do you, as a reader, go about building the blueprints the writer has given you?
I don't. It's automatic, unless they blueprint inadequately in the first place AND that inadequacy shows up as a cognitive dissonance AND I care enough to still be reading.

Do you have go-to images in your head of the MC based on your personal preferences?
I guess? See "automatic." I guess that's go-to? But I don't have consistent ones which come up over and over, if that's what you mean. Every mental image is at least as original and novel as the written one.

How vivid are these worlds to you?
Depends on the writing.

Are the characters and worlds sketches, or 4k images?
Depends on the writing.

Do you prefer when the writer gives you a lot of detail with which to build the story, or keep it more sparse?
Depends on the story, but to me generally less is more.

What aspects of a story do you most value getting information about to help you build this world?
Whatever aspects are important to the particular story. I don't particularly want to "build the world." I mostly just want to read, and not feel like I'm doing the author's job.

How much do you feel of the characters' emotions?
Depends on the situation in the story, on the writer's ability to evoke, and on the author's achievement of my investment.

How important even is it to you to build this world given to you?
See above. I'd rather not. I'm the reader, not the builder. If something that shouldn't be left blank is left blank, I'm not going to feel very forgiving about it. If something is left blank which doesn't matter to the story, I'm not going to fill it in any more than my reflex does automatically in mere milliseconds.

Do you think differently about this co-creation process now compared to before you started writing?
Probably less.
 
I'm borderline aphantasic (I can only visualize in my dreams), so that means when I'm reading, I see nothing in my mind's eye. I don't really know how anybody or anything actually looks beyond a collection of words. It's primarily abstractions for me — concepts, rather than constructs.
So, what does "building" mean to you? I can't tell if you're attaching that word to the non-aphantasic experience, and contrasting it against your own, or, if "building" is something you think all readers do, but just in different ways?
 
I don't think of it quite this way. I'm visual, and as I read I generally visualize the characters and places, but I don't have any systematic way of doing it. It depends on the story and how much the author tells me.

I don't necessarily have to fill in details that the author has left out when I read a story. I'm content to leave blank spaces and concentrate on what the author wants to tell me.
 
So, what does "building" mean to you? I can't tell if you're attaching that word to the non-aphantasic experience, and contrasting it against your own, or, if "building" is something you think all readers do, but just in different ways?
Basically some of the stuff you outlined in your prior post, the visualization you do (though certainly it's not limited to visuals). Doesn't have to be conscious, many people are still taking the words and imagining what that looks like on some level, conscious or not. For some people, it's an active process where they take the time to imagine what those worlds and characters look like, filling in blanks. For others, as you mentioned, it's something that simply happens; but I don't think that makes it any less a co-creative process when it isn't someone being more active about their choices for how they visualize the world. The reader is still the one who creates parts of the world in their head.

Maybe I'm projecting to some degree what I think it must be like to have a mind's eye. But I've spoken with people and watched documentaries and read articles about papers with this phenomena (also those who don't have internal monologues, which is wild to me), and I know that it works very differently for people. Some people it comes unbidden, others they have to take a second and imagine it, build it, if you would. Some are more vivid than others, people who barely get anything and people for whom it looks so real they could reach out and touch it. I imagine it's not too dissimilar when they're reading something. In either case, they're constructing some image based on words you provided, which is why I like the building metaphor for this — blueprint (the words) to construction (whatever images or movie or sounds or smells or touch the reader imagines).
 
It's ironic that the thing I love most about writing and reading is something I can't actually do. I'm borderline aphantasic (I can only visualize in my dreams), so that means when I'm reading, I see nothing in my mind's eye. I don't really know how anybody or anything actually looks beyond a collection of words. It's primarily abstractions for me — concepts, rather than constructs.
For me, it’s the opposite. I’m near hyperphantasic to the point that it can negatively impact my reading due to also having ADHD. I will often, unintentionally, get caught up in constructing characters and locations that I forget what I was reading in the first place and then have to start a paragraph (or two) over.

As a means to cope with this, I’ve learned to substitute the fictional locations for real places. Someone is describing a kitchen? I think of a kitchen I’ve been to that closest resembles what’s being described and now the characters are in that. I can tweak it if needed, but it’s better for me to do that than build from scratch. And I should mention all this mental construction takes place in a second or two, but a lot happens in those two seconds.

There have only been a handful of instances where I was able to picture something new without getting lost. Something about the way certain writers describe things end up clicking in all the right ways for me.
 
For me, it’s the opposite. I’m near hyperphantasic to the point that it can negatively impact my reading due to also having ADHD. I will often, unintentionally, get caught up in constructing characters and locations that I forget what I was reading in the first place and then have to start a paragraph (or two) over.

As a means to cope with this, I’ve learned to substitute the fictional locations for real places. Someone is describing a kitchen? I think of a kitchen I’ve been to that closest resembles what’s being described and now the characters are in that. I can tweak it if needed, but it’s better for me to do that than build from scratch. And I should mention all this mental construction takes place in a second or two, but a lot happens in those two seconds.

There have only been a handful of instances where I was able to picture something new without getting lost. Something about the way certain writers describe things end up clicking in all the right ways for me.
That's really interesting. I hadn't considered that it might actually be distracting if it's that visceral. So then do you prefer light descriptions over heavy descriptions?
 
I just write fun stories. You guys think way too deeply into this.
^
Kind of that.

I don't envision the reader at all when writing. If I'm writing well, I'm in-tune with the characters. To the point that I don't worry too much about word choices while writing, I send a lot more time now in editing trying to get the words character appropriate. Because, to me, that involves the reader the most.

But that doesn't mean I try to think like a reader. That I only do during editing, and even then I don't think they're creating something with me.

To me, it feels like the stories are my little creations, that I have no control over once I send them out into the world. Different readers will have different experiences, I can't imagine all their possible backgrounds. So it doesn't feel like there's a "co" component.

The engagement when I'm purely a reader is also hugely author specific. There are some authors who do dialogue so well, that I could almost just read that.

Others take me into their heads and I get a sense of "their" emotions (thinking 1P here), and I take a ride almost like in "Inside Out". When it gets into heavy descriptions about places or things, I gloss over...

:)
 
It's a tough thing to describe for me. It is more an automatic response. I begin to read, and images do form in my mind, but I liken it to a waking dream, and it is of such a fugual quality that it's more like trying to remember a dream an hour after you've had it. So, more like visual impressions? Of a sort anyways. I don't really place any value in any of it, it's just something that occurs, and can be good or not good depending, but it's not exactly critical to my reading experience.

Also, it's usually only visual, when it's an automatic response. I don't tend imagine smells, tastes don't really come up when mentioned (although I just tried it out and I can kind of recall food textures when biting into them and chewing, which is odd to say the least), or any of the other senses really, unless my subconcious randomly tries to emulate them, and once again, it is an impression, an approximation at distance.

Don't particularly care about level of detail, although a lot of detail tends to get tedious and then I get a little lost and stop caring as much. However, if that is the flow of the piece, then it is what it is.

Depends on the character, but that also has oxymoronic traits for me. Closely aligned but far, far away.

I have dabbled in some form of writing for quite some time, so I can't remember what me before then would have thought on the whole thing.

When I am writing though, I point blank ignore any other readers beyond myself. Just sort of settled on that mentality, and really the only way I can put the words out.
also those who don't have internal monologues, which is wild to me),
At the risk of some derailment, this sentence made me realize my inner monologues don't have a voice. Puzzling.
 
That's really interesting. I hadn't considered that it might actually be distracting if it's that visceral. So then do you prefer light descriptions over heavy descriptions?
No preference in the general sense. I like both. What I can handle is based on where my head is at. I’m not on any medication so some days my mind focuses great and others it’s a swarm of bees. On the really bad days when I still want to read, I re-read things. Way easier to picture things when I’ve already been down the road.
 
When I read ASOIAF, I just pictured the characters as they appeared in the show. It was easier to recall the actors' looks than the character descriptions in the text. So whenever I see an artist's rendition of the book-accurate characters it's always a huge surprise.
 
There are plenty of other angles to explore, so really, share your experience as a reader in the process of co-creating the story.
As I'm reading, I don't know that I get super granular with the worlds and characters that I construct in my mind. What I imagine tends to be somewhat abstract, though roughly shaped and guided by details provided by the author.

I have noticed that whenever a house or apartment is involved, I automatically imagine one that I spent a lot of time in in real life. It's funny to think that when I'm writing, I might be imagining a house that I'm familiar with, but the reader is imagining their own house. 😅
 
I'm similar to @SimonDoom and @Britva415 on this. For me it's an automatic process to "turn" the words into the vision of the story, there's no construction or method to be followed.

I suspect there's a subconscious element determined by how good the writer is with their wordsmanship, as to how well my mind responds to their tale. But do I have preconceived notions of characters, their physicality? Not at all. If the writer doesn't describe blonde, I'm not defaulting to blonde.

As for co-creation? No. The writer is either doing a good job or they're not, my mind type has got nothing to do with it.
 
Seems I may have missed the mark with my intention on this (shocker, that's like half of these threads I start). I was more interested in discussing the way readers imagine the story they read than getting into nuances around what constitutes writer-reader compacts and co-creation, which is more bias toward my own philosophy on the matter than I realized. I'm going to amend this just to focus on the imagination aspect of this.

Edit: I've modified it to focus more on the aspects of how imagination manifests in you as a reader.
 
Last edited:
Edit: I've modified it to focus more on the aspects of how imagination manifests in you as a reader.
Being primarily a visual thinker who also happens to write, I think the manifestation in my mind is most like a movie playing, sometimes with a soundtrack but not always. Like memory, but without the film or the camera (that makes no sense, I know...).

Unless the piece is so cerebral that I have to more actively engage in "thinking" about what's going on, to figure out what the fuck is happening - then there might be a "thought process", but I've never deconstructed what that might be.
 
Another of those topics asking me to think before I've even had my morning coffee...

A lot of the time, I'll form an image almost immediately. Particularly of a character's face. It's one reason why I hate it if a writer adds details later that should have been immediately obvious, because it means altering the image in my head, or else ignoring the new details. Strangely, though, when I'm reading the rest of the story, I usually picture the characters from behind, or without faces.

Scenes like a generic bedroom or kitchen are almost always the same place for me: not somewhere I'm overly familiar with, actually, just a friend's house where I stayed once more than thirty years ago. I can change the image if there's a description and I make the effort, but chances are it will go back to the default pretty quickly.

But even so, I still think of it as co-creation (as per the original thread title). The writer provides the recipe, I bake the cake. Or something like that. I feel more engaged with the characters and setting, and they're more memorable to me, if the images are my own. If the story provides too much detail, I won't internalise it and will mostly forget it, or only remember it as an external fact.

I'm listening to an audiobook about emotion in fiction. I've just started, but one thing that's stuck with me is that the author says "we don't make readers feel emotions, we *provoke* emotions." It's the same with imagination, I think: the writer provides the information to provoke an image in the reader's mind. What that image is depends on the reader.
 
But even so, I still think of it as co-creation (as per the original thread title). The writer provides the recipe, I bake the cake. Or something like that. I feel more engaged with the characters and setting, and they're more memorable to me, if the images are my own. If the story provides too much detail, I won't internalise it and will mostly forget it, or only remember it as an external fact.

I'm listening to an audiobook about emotion in fiction. I've just started, but one thing that's stuck with me is that the author says "we don't make readers feel emotions, we *provoke* emotions." It's the same with imagination, I think: the writer provides the information to provoke an image in the reader's mind. What that image is depends on the reader.
While I'm not shocked we have a similar philosophy about this, I am really glad it isn't just crazy ol' me who thinks of it this way 🥰
 
Back
Top