Oh Really?

superlittlegirl said:
I definitely see where you're coming from, modest mouse. Your discourse is superior; you argue well and I'm glad you're here.
Are you hitting on me? Buy me a drink and lets see where this goes.
That being said, dating, going out to a nightclub alone, or having a one-night-stand carry similar inherent risks. Hell, even some marriages and committed relationships have a violent component.
I'll agree that they have 'similar inherent risks'. But the frequency of risk, and therefore the potential for a serious consequence is quite different.

While no expert on prostitution, be it street-level or agency based, I would think that a prostitute is exposed to more risk in a given month than teh average club goer, dater, etc.

Now thats not to say that some people, who are not prostitutes, dont take risks that are far beyond what i would consider reasonable. I would agree that the riskiest of behaviours may be less risky than the ones taken by a prostitute.
I might posit that women who work in the sex industry are perhaps more vigilant about issues of personal safety than other women are. A sex worker can never afford to fool herself into thinking that the world is a safe place; unfortunately many women do.
Hmmmmm.

Women who work in prostitution ( I consider other sex industry jobs differently due to the different risk levels) are probably more aware of the risks they put themselves in than someone who frequently goes home with strangers, or puts themselves in situations in which they could be drugged, etc.

But awareness doesnt always mean the risks are reduced. While precautions can be taken the risks are still significant.
 
Re: Creating Myths

That point was not initially raised by the sex-work-tolerant side of the argument. It was raised in derision by someone who was trying to frame sex workers as brainless bimbos. The fact that the sex-work-tolerant camp is able to cite specific empirical evidence of personal aquaintances who are educated and also do or have done sex work does not equate a stance touting PhD uberwomen.

That's sneaky argumentation you're engaging in, there.

takingchances42 said:

But this bit about prostitutes in general as PhD uberwomen... give me a break. :rolleyes:

 
Well said, mouse. The remaining disagreements we have are minimal, and entirely subjective. I do not have a range of experience that will permit me to speak about the risks inherent to all prostitutes, and I know that the risk is there. I think we're moving toward something more tangible with this avenue of discussion.

[my post edited for redundancy]

modest mouse said:
Are you hitting on me? Buy me a drink and lets see where this goes.

I'll agree that they have 'similar inherent risks'. But the frequency of risk, and therefore the potential for a serious consequence is quite different.

While no expert on prostitution, be it street-level or agency based, I would think that a prostitute is exposed to more risk in a given month than teh average club goer, dater, etc.

Now thats not to say that some people, who are not prostitutes, dont take risks that are far beyond what i would consider reasonable. I would agree that the riskiest of behaviours may be less risky than the ones taken by a prostitute.

Hmmmmm.

Women who work in prostitution ( I consider other sex industry jobs differently due to the different risk levels) are probably more aware of the risks they put themselves in than someone who frequently goes home with strangers, or puts themselves in situations in which they could be drugged, etc.

But awareness doesnt always mean the risks are reduced. While precautions can be taken the risks are still significant.
 
Last edited:
Lasher said:
I think it's a brand.

Marks him as being from the Flaming Retarded Newbie Ranch.


Can I have one? (retarded newbie) my last one put me on ignore.
 
In response to this snip of modest mouse's post:
While no expert on prostitution, be it street-level or agency based, I would think that a prostitute is exposed to more risk in a given month than teh average club goer, dater, etc.

I would like to clarify that there is further delineation within the sex-work industry. Independent Escorts occupy a very unique niche of the market. They are able to make all decisions regarding client interactions. A woman who works for an agency may have a supportive backup network, but all too often, an agency works less for a woman than she does for them. Independent Escorting can be small business at its finest.
 
*catching up here*

It's ok to have "one night stands" with no exchange of cash. But if a person wants to enterprise a little they we involve morals.

Wow.
 
HeavyStick said:
*catching up here*

It's ok to have "one night stands" with no exchange of cash. But if a person wants to enterprise a little they we involve morals.

Wow.
lol another interesting perspective. :)
 
Seven pages of (mostly) total slop about the sex trade, started by someone who says he/she/it is in Toronto.

Looks like a standard troll thread to me, probably started by one of the Dirty Dozen to keep the fodder fires stoked.

Same as it ever was...

But, by way of review...prostitution is legal in Canada. Soliciting to buy or sell sex in public is illegal.

Prostitutes, lawyers, dentists, teachers, doctors, politicians, plumbers, pipe-fitters, store clerks, cab drivers....there are brainless boobs, geniuses and every kind of person in between practising every craft, occupation and profession, no matter where you might be.

A thread starting sweeping generalization, a hit and run thread, with the thread starter appearing only occasionally to get you all revved up again...I'm surprised at all those who don't see the sucker pattern emerging as usual.

Oy...

I'm back to the Christmas tree, a nice rum and Batman Forever on TBS....The Superstation.

Cheers!

Lance
 
Aww, Lance! It's all in good fun. I haven't had one of these in a long time. You wouldn't begrudge me this, would you?


Lancecastor said:
Seven pages of (mostly) total slop about the sex trade, started by someone who says he/she/it is in Toronto.

Looks like a standard troll thread to me, probably started by one of the Dirty Dozen to keep the fodder fires stoked.

Same as it ever was...

But, by way of review...prostitution is legal in Canada. Soliciting to buy or sell sex in public is illegal.

Prostitutes, lawyers, dentists, teachers, doctors, politicians, plumbers, pipe-fitters, store clerks, cab drivers....there are brainless boobs, geniuses and every kind of person in between practising every craft, occupation and profession, no matter where you might be.

A thread starting sweeping generalization, a hit and run thread, with the thread starter appearing only occasionally to get you all revved up again...I'm surprised at all those who don't see the sucker pattern emerging as usual.

Oy...

I'm back to the Christmas tree, a nice rum and Batman Forever on TBS....The Superstation.

Cheers!

Lance
 
Oh, wait! Oops!

I am the thread starter you were talking about, Lance! *giggle*

I am having fun.
 
HeavyStick said:
*catching up here*

It's ok to have "one night stands" with no exchange of cash. But if a person wants to enterprise a little they we involve morals.

Wow.

I'd rather not have "one night stands" without exchange of cash!

:devil: :p :kiss:
 
SLG,
There is lots of ground in the issue that isnt as polarized as some of the posts in this thread. I do think you and I are looking at the issue through our own lenses, but both with a realistic and somewhat pragmatic approach.

A different perspective doesnt mean a difference of opinion, as is shown. But allows us our own concerns.

As I attempted to admit, I'm at a loss for specifics or detailed arguments but I like to think I have a reasonable idea what i am tlaking about.

***

The undercurrent in this entire issue is criminalization.

It is the criminalization of an act that involves two consenting adults that assures the health risks, the dangers, etc. yet its these very same problems that is continually held up as teh reason for its illegal status.

No one will say that legalized prostitution would be free of risk or crime. But I think a more involved public policy rahter than the de-facto denial of criminalization would lead to a better situation for those inside and outside the business.

Thats not to say that I would change my stance ont eh risks if it were legal or somewhat safer... only that criminalization does little to improve anyone's situation.
 
I couldn't agree more. Criminalization is the real issue of stress for people who provide and consume sex in a commercial sense. There is even more of a risk to sex workers, because the illegality of it denies them the protection of the police or any support within the legal system in the event of violence against them. Criminalization is an oddly shaped solution to an only partially-understood phenomenon. I fail to see how it supports any aspect of this cause effectively.


modest mouse said:
SLG,
There is lots of ground in the issue that isnt as polarized as some of the posts in this thread. I do think you and I are looking at the issue through our own lenses, but both with a realistic and somewhat pragmatic approach.

A different perspective doesnt mean a difference of opinion, as is shown. But allows us our own concerns.

As I attempted to admit, I'm at a loss for specifics or detailed arguments but I like to think I have a reasonable idea what i am tlaking about.

***

The undercurrent in this entire issue is criminalization.

It is the criminalization of an act that involves two consenting adults that assures the health risks, the dangers, etc. yet its these very same problems that is continually held up as teh reason for its illegal status.

No one will say that legalized prostitution would be free of risk or crime. But I think a more involved public policy rahter than the de-facto denial of criminalization would lead to a better situation for those inside and outside the business.

Thats not to say that I would change my stance ont eh risks if it were legal or somewhat safer... only that criminalization does little to improve anyone's situation.
 
modest mouse said:


While no expert on prostitution, be it street-level or agency based, I would think that a prostitute is exposed to more risk in a given month than teh average club goer, dater, etc.

I don't agree with this.
 
perky_baby said:
I don't agree with this.

Ditto.

"Professional" women are more apt to be taking precautions, their clients, we would hope would be aware of the risks and taking precautions.

Women who are dating casually or are with multiple partners may not be using the same judgement. Unprotected sex happening "just this one time" happens far more often than any of the enlightened crowd might care to believe.

"Just this once" turns into "Well, it doesn't matter, nothing will happen", when in reality, if you sleep with a women without protection, you are sleeping with every man she has ever been with.

If my SO cheated, I would almost prefer it be with a prostitute, for some of these reasons. (Yes, a upper class, pricey babe...)

My point being, naivete and denial are at large in the dating scene. The risks are many and are often ignored.

All conjecture, based only on my experience and observation of friends.
 
Having read the last couple of post, I am struck by a numbers game.

"Professional" women are more apt to be taking precautions, their clients, we would hope would be aware of the risks and taking precautions.

But the fact that they are probably having more sex than the average clubbers leads to statistically more chances to be infected. Therefore with those chances increased so does the risk of transmission.
 
MissTaken said:
Ditto.

"Professional" women are more apt to be taking precautions, their clients, we would hope would be aware of the risks and taking precautions.

Women who are dating casually or are with multiple partners may not be using the same judgement. Unprotected sex happening "just this one time" happens far more often than any of the enlightened crowd might care to believe.

"Just this once" turns into "Well, it doesn't matter, nothing will happen", when in reality, if you sleep with a women without protection, you are sleeping with every man she has ever been with.

If my SO cheated, I would almost prefer it be with a prostitute, for some of these reasons. (Yes, a upper class, pricey babe...)

My point being, naivete and denial are at large in the dating scene. The risks are many and are often ignored.

All conjecture, based only on my experience and observation of friends.

I remember reading about the prostitution trade in some East African village, where 15 year old girls would go to bars, and charge $1 for sex with a condom, and $3 for sex without a condom (or something like that). AIDs was endemic there, so the girls were basically placing a $2 value on their lives (the men usually preferred the $3 option, with no condom).

That is likely a more accurate picture of the real world of prostitutes worldwide, than the tiny minority of "upper class, pricey babes" in developed countries.
 
bknight2602 said:
Having read the last couple of post, I am struck by a numbers game.



But the fact that they are probably having more sex than the average clubbers leads to statistically more chances to be infected. Therefore with those chances increased so does the risk of transmission.

the fact that probably?
 
takingchances42 said:
I remember reading about the prostitution trade in some East African village, where 15 year old girls would go to bars, and charge $1 for sex with a condom, and $3 for sex without a condom (or something like that). AIDs was endemic there, so the girls were basically placing a $2 value on their lives (the men usually preferred the $3 option, with no condom).

That is likely a more accurate picture of the real world of prostitutes worldwide, than the tiny minority of "upper class, pricey babes" in developed countries.

this totally has bearing on this conversation.
 
perky_baby said:
I don't agree with this.
Ok. I maintain that if you compared the average prostitute to the average 'clubgoer/frequent fucker, the risk exposure is higher in the prostitute. What I am saying is that the prostitute is more regularly exposed. I don't think the average clubgoer is out doing 'stuff' more frequently than the average prostitute.

MissTaken said:
"Professional" women are more apt to be taking precautions, their clients, we would hope would be aware of the risks and taking precautions.

Women who are dating casually or are with multiple partners may not be using the same judgement. Unprotected sex happening "just this one time" happens far more often than any of the enlightened crowd might care to believe.

"Just this once" turns into "Well, it doesn't matter, nothing will happen", when in reality, if you sleep with a women without protection, you are sleeping with every man she has ever been with.

If my SO cheated, I would almost prefer it be with a prostitute, for some of these reasons. (Yes, a upper class, pricey babe...)

My point being, naivete and denial are at large in the dating scene. The risks are many and are often ignored.

All conjecture, based only on my experience and observation of friends.

Your assumptions are naive and balanced tenuously on shaky ground.

YOu are making massive assumptions about the 'one night stand' populace as to frequency and to precautions. ITs wild assumptions that started thsi whole thread.

You are also casting prostitution on an umbrella too large. The 'upper class' girls you speek of are the exception, not the rule.

You are more than welcome to disagree with everything I have said but you have to offer up something more than this to refute my ideas.
 
modest mouse said:
Ok. I maintain that if you compared the average prostitute to the average 'clubgoer/frequent fucker, the risk exposure is higher in the prostitute. What I am saying is that the prostitute is more regularly exposed. I don't think the average clubgoer is out doing 'stuff' more frequently than the average prostitute.

I'm saying that the prostitute is more apt to use a condom, and thus the risks are similar.
 
modest mouse said:
Ok. I maintain that if you compared the average prostitute to the average 'clubgoer/frequent fucker, the risk exposure is higher in the prostitute. What I am saying is that the prostitute is more regularly exposed. I don't think the average clubgoer is out doing 'stuff' more frequently than the average prostitute.

I would tend to agree with this assertion, except for one thing.

We have no gauge for what constitutes average in either demographic.

I think the point is moot from both sides, because we have no way of getting numbers. We can postulate all we want about this, but we have no way to see real answers.

The solution lies with each fucker (or fuckee) taking full responsibility for protecting his or her genitals in the most effective way possible.
 
perky, I hear ya. Thanks for the clarification.

***

SLG, Yes, its educated guesses and reasonable assumptions, but as you say there isnt empirical evidence to toss around.

Personal responsibility is probably the most significant factor in the lowerign of inherent risk. This is again hindered by the oddball relationship of the law.
 
Back
Top