Oh Really?

Creating Myths

OK, I've met a number of prostitutes over the years. Most of them being strippers who also work bachelor parties while doing a lot more than stripping, but other kinds as well.

Generalizing is dangerous -- there are some sweet, nice, well educated people who make all kinds of choices. Getting a job where you can spend days with your kids, and support them, seems to be a common motivation (hey, I like talking to "working women", can be interesting).

But this bit about prostitutes in general as PhD uberwomen... give me a break. :rolleyes:

What a fantasy. Sure, there are some individuals out there like that. But most prostitutes do not have college degrees, do not come from upper or middle class families, have lived a hard life -- and show it. That is a fairly accurate _generalization_, FWIW... though there are of course many _exceptions_.
 
perky_baby said:


de Sade? don't diminish your debate by using your winks and quips as a tool. It's a sophomoric tactic.
ooooh ya put me in my place.
Prostitution is illegal because it "diminishes the value system of society". I didnt make the laws, dont shoot the messenger
 
modest mouse said:
Ok...

I am against the criminalization of prostitution.

But lets calrify a point. Any person that engages in prostitution, ie the payer or payee, is undertaking an act that puts them at serious risk for both fatal and non-fatal disease. This point is not up for debate. So I cannot see the efficacy in arguing that its the choice of a liberated women who likes the money and freedom. That argument hasnt flown since about 1988.

I agree with the fact about the health risk, but the risks are no different than if someone has sex without getting paid for it.

When it comes to a woman's body, their choice what to do with it as a liberation argument is always a valid argument.
 
perky_baby said:
and no mouse, you're not supposed to feel bad, but you're supposed to research why you feel that prostitution is wrong.

Is it just because it is illegal? Why was it made illegal? What's the bottom line. You choose not to like things for reasons, I assume you don't just go with the flow.

I dont think its wrong. Its a matter of personal choice. Two consenting adults, one who is paying, fuck. That doesnt influence my life so its all good.

There are frequent ties to crime that opens up a 'chicken or the egg' thing but that is moot for this discussion.

I dont understand the 'research' angle you are espousing.
 
Jim_Henson said:
Theres still one about?

Fuck, better find the I hate newbies thread just to round up the new set of usual suspects.

Seems someone forgot to close the gate on Xmas day, there's been a few floating about the last couple days.
 
yeah you'd better hurry. they're all scurrying around aimlessly at the news of your round-up.

:s(


Jim_Henson said:
Theres still one about?

Fuck, better find the I hate newbies thread just to round up the new set of usual suspects.
 
dont get me wrong, prostitution isnt morally wrong. I am simply curious as to why a woman would choose it over every other job out there. It seems incredibly risky.
 
perky_baby said:
I agree with the fact about the health risk, but the risks are no different than if someone has sex without getting paid for it.

Yes and no. I'm not sure I coul;d put faith in the thought that the average john is less disease-prone than the average fuck.

When it comes to a woman's body, their choice what to do with it as a liberation argument is always a valid argument.

Incorrect.

yes a woman can do whatever she wishes with her body. But i dont think putting oneself at such serious risk is al that liberating. I would have some thoughts as to self-worth if anyone was engaging in risky behaviour, sexual or otherwise.
 
Re: Creating Myths

takingchances42 said:
OK, I've met a number of prostitutes over the years. Most of them being strippers who also work bachelor parties while doing a lot more than stripping, but other kinds as well.

Generalizing is dangerous -- there are some sweet, nice, well educated people who make all kinds of choices. Getting a job where you can spend days with your kids, and support them, seems to be a common motivation (hey, I like talking to "working women", can be interesting).

But this bit about prostitutes in general as PhD uberwomen... give me a break. :rolleyes:

What a fantasy. Sure, there are some individuals out there like that. But most prostitutes do not have college degrees, do not come from upper or middle class families, have lived a hard life -- and show it. That is a fairly accurate _generalization_, FWIW... though there are of course many _exceptions_.

you're on target here. There are so many sides, and so many grey areas to all people. To show one extreme and not show the other is unconscionable. This shows all of the levels and I concur.
 
De Sade said:
dont get me wrong, prostitution isnt morally wrong. I am simply curious as to why a woman would choose it over every other job out there. It seems incredibly risky.
Your PM box is full, so unless you want me to post my reply on the forum, please empty out your PM box.
 
stillclear said:
yeah you'd better hurry. they're all scurrying around aimlessly at the news of your round-up.

:s(

No, they always scurry around aimlessly

Look at you.
 
modest mouse said:
Ok...

I am against the criminalization of prostitution.

But lets calrify a point. Any person that engages in prostitution, ie the payer or payee, is undertaking an act that puts them at serious risk for both fatal and non-fatal disease. This point is not up for debate. So I cannot see the efficacy in arguing that its the choice of a liberated women who likes the money and freedom. That argument hasnt flown since about 1988.


i agree with you there ... while i am very far from de sades opinion im not sure i agree with other people either

i don't think prostitution is a risk free almost romantic way for a woman to make money as some people might see it


like i said i've never met a prostitute but just from the STD stand point its risky and i don't think anything like the film pretty woman :)
 
Why is this debate only discussing female prostitutes?

There are male prostitutes as well of all different ilks and backgrounds.

Prostitution isn't a choice I would make for myself, but is someone else choses to, so be it. Perferably, they are making an informed decision, but yes, as sexy girl points out , there are those who enter prostitution as the result of force and coercion, whether by life circumstances or physical and mental abuse.

The second scenario is the most sad.
 
modest mouse said:
Yes and no. I'm not sure I coul;d put faith in the thought that the average john is less disease-prone than the average fuck.



Incorrect.

yes a woman can do whatever she wishes with her body. But i dont think putting oneself at such serious risk is al that liberating. I would have some thoughts as to self-worth if anyone was engaging in risky behaviour, sexual or otherwise.

is it more risky to have a health standard and testing to be a prostitute or just to fuck every next guy at the bar?

and no, I'm not saying all prostitutes are healthy. I know I'm not in a prostitue utopia.

I think there are all types of risky behavior, bungie jumping, using firearms... sex. I just don't think they're all morally judged, like prostitution is.
 
Miss T,

I dont see how the gender of the prostitute changes teh argument and therefore merits mentioning. The only point that would enter into it would be that in sexual relations it is statistically more difficult for the male to contract a STD due to simple biology. But that is a very insignificant point.

*******

The issue can be separated out like this:
Stripper/Prostitute

THink about how you perceive each, as a career, and as a person.

I've known plenty of women who have stripped full or part time. Got no issue with that as long as they remain in control, and not at the mercy of the 'lifestyle' The key being the degree of risk involved.

In the end its about a person being able to carve out a life for themselves. I think the risks inherent in prostituion inhibit one;s ability to create their own life.
 
De Sade said:
ooooh ya put me in my place.
Prostitution is illegal because it "diminishes the value system of society". I didnt make the laws, dont shoot the messenger

diminishes the value system of a society?

value system according to who's values?
 
Re: Re: My 2 cents

*giggle*

And I haven't even read to the end of the thread yet!


stillclear said:
i don't think prostitutes are thinking women... if they were, they wouldn't resort to sex to earn a living... the only thing they're thinking is money... not pride, not morals not anything... only money.

:s(
 
damn, I wish I didn't have to leave. I was enjoying this.

Night all.
 
perky_baby said:
is it more risky to have a health standard and testing to be a prostitute or just to fuck every next guy at the bar?

Well, Perkster, we both know that such ahealth standard does not exist. Which is part of the criminalization. The Euro model of legalization hasnt proven that succesful in limiting disease. It has lowered the spread but not nearly as much as I would have thought.

If you are comparing it to a person who fucks everythign in sight then its a different case. We can both agree that such a person is putting themselves at incredible risk.

and no, I'm not saying all prostitutes are healthy. I know I'm not in a prostitue utopia.

I know you;re not saying that. Its why Im engaged in this discussion. Its good to be in one with ya.

I think there are all types of risky behavior, bungie jumping, using firearms... sex. I just don't think they're all morally judged, like prostitution is.
Probably true.

I think I can honestly say that I dont judge prostitution on amoral level. I look at it from the point of intelligent decision making and it seems rather unintelligent to me (to either be a prostitute or to visit one). So on that level I view prostitutes or johns in a negative light.
 
Are you starting to use words like "facts?"

Bwahahaha!


De Sade said:
I guess crime stats are wrong? No, I didnt imply the ONLY reason is because a woman was molested. But the fact is, most women who sell sex were sexually abused by a family member or spouse.
 
I definitely see where you're coming from, modest mouse. Your discourse is superior; you argue well and I'm glad you're here.

That being said, dating, going out to a nightclub alone, or having a one-night-stand carry similar inherent risks. Hell, even some marriages and committed relationships have a violent component.

I might posit that women who work in the sex industry are perhaps more vigilant about issues of personal safety than other women are. A sex worker can never afford to fool herself into thinking that the world is a safe place; unfortunately many women do.


modest mouse said:
Ok...

I am against the criminalization of prostitution.

But lets calrify a point. Any person that engages in prostitution, ie the payer or payee, is undertaking an act that puts them at serious risk for both fatal and non-fatal disease. This point is not up for debate. So I cannot see the efficacy in arguing that its the choice of a liberated women who likes the money and freedom. That argument hasnt flown since about 1988.
 
superlittlegirl said:
quote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by stillclear
and plus, unthinking women are what prostitutes are for.

:s(
------------------------------------------------------------------------


Oh really?
ok just a thought ......if the post had said "most johns don't go to a hooker for a lively political debate" would that have been so objectionable?
 
Well, let's see. A woman could work three hours per week and still make three times as much as she would in an entry level job that would rob her of at least 40 hours of her week. She could decide when she wanted to work, decide who she wanted to work with, and decide when and who she didn't. She wouldn't even have to answer to anyone else, if she had an iota of good sense about self-promotion and some internet savvy. She could put the 37 hours she had left over into her education, organized or self-guided, and she could pursue arts, writing, or any number of other pastimes. She could travel whenever she wished, she could feel a sense of financial security, and she could call the shots with her life in general.

Yep, dunno why anyone would choose to pursue such a thing.



De Sade said:
dont get me wrong, prostitution isnt morally wrong. I am simply curious as to why a woman would choose it over every other job out there. It seems incredibly risky.
 
Wow go away for a little while and miss all the fun....The world according to me...It's mine, I can sell it, I can loan it, I can give it away....It's all up to me, she, her, he, him, them....If you're gonna use protect it.....That's all I have to say about that.........;)
 
Back
Top