Dixon Carter Lee
Headliner
- Joined
- Nov 22, 1999
- Posts
- 48,685
I've been down to Zuccotti Park a few times. What strikes you most about the movement, once you get past the fringe "crazies" (who aren't that crazy) who stand around with signs and funny costumes looking for someone to listen to their disparate causes (gay rights, fracking, Canadian pipelines) is that the movement isn't actually in the park (which is good, considering it isn't actually on Wall Street), it's in the smart phones and web cams and broadcast media trucks everywhere. The protest is digital. It's electronic.
And it works. The movement is putting the wind on the back of legislation and commercial change.
You're also struck by the organization. The lack of crime and drugs (though I know for a fact they exist -- but this is New York City -- they exist with or without the tents). The 24 hour theatre of the thing. It's really something. Put it on your tourist list along with The Statue of Liberty and The Book of Mormon. It's worth it. (Plus you can check out Freedom Tower's progress at the same time).
But I haven't signed off on it because it's so enthusiastically irresponsible for the here and now, for the health and safety of the neighborhood (despite it's "Neighborhood Pledges" and other efforts to respect its fellow citizens). Michael Moore and other celebs who give the movement their backing are playing with fire because, you know, they could start a fire, and no one is responsible, which means the celebs become culpable.
I suppose it's too much to ask that in the middle of a political revolution that everyone pick up their candy wrappers. I get that. And I want to see the movement continue. But I'd also like to see leaders emerge. (And they're there.) Not because "da people" aren't smart enough to bring effective collective voice, but because, in the end, someone will have to answer for the murders and rapes. Someone needs to man-up and take control and police the tents. Even Woodstock warned people about the bad LSD.
I can only speak about Occupy Wall Street. I believe the protest here is unlike the protest anywhere else. Zuccotti Park is tiny. It's not on Wall Street. It's not really designed to "be" in New York at all. It's a 24 hour digital web theatrical event slash protest that reverberates internationally (take that Tea Party). And I applaud it, and want to see it sustained. But I just can't endorse it completely because irresponsibility breeds parasites that, may, eventually, kill the host much more effectively than the establishment.
And it works. The movement is putting the wind on the back of legislation and commercial change.
You're also struck by the organization. The lack of crime and drugs (though I know for a fact they exist -- but this is New York City -- they exist with or without the tents). The 24 hour theatre of the thing. It's really something. Put it on your tourist list along with The Statue of Liberty and The Book of Mormon. It's worth it. (Plus you can check out Freedom Tower's progress at the same time).
But I haven't signed off on it because it's so enthusiastically irresponsible for the here and now, for the health and safety of the neighborhood (despite it's "Neighborhood Pledges" and other efforts to respect its fellow citizens). Michael Moore and other celebs who give the movement their backing are playing with fire because, you know, they could start a fire, and no one is responsible, which means the celebs become culpable.
I suppose it's too much to ask that in the middle of a political revolution that everyone pick up their candy wrappers. I get that. And I want to see the movement continue. But I'd also like to see leaders emerge. (And they're there.) Not because "da people" aren't smart enough to bring effective collective voice, but because, in the end, someone will have to answer for the murders and rapes. Someone needs to man-up and take control and police the tents. Even Woodstock warned people about the bad LSD.
I can only speak about Occupy Wall Street. I believe the protest here is unlike the protest anywhere else. Zuccotti Park is tiny. It's not on Wall Street. It's not really designed to "be" in New York at all. It's a 24 hour digital web theatrical event slash protest that reverberates internationally (take that Tea Party). And I applaud it, and want to see it sustained. But I just can't endorse it completely because irresponsibility breeds parasites that, may, eventually, kill the host much more effectively than the establishment.
