NC passes Admendment 1

So again, please define what a right is.

I'm enjoying watching you make Vette look dumb, but this is actually a pretty damned difficult thing to do. It's easy to find lists of purported rights, but it's challenging to define.

The wiki is an interesting discussion.

Rights are legal, social, or ethical principles of freedom or entitlement; that is, rights are the fundamental normative rules about what is allowed of people or owed to people, according to some legal system, social convention, or ethical theory.[1] Rights are of essential importance in such disciplines as law and ethics, especially theories of justice and deontology.

Rights are often considered fundamental to civilization, being regarded as established pillars of society and culture,[2] and the history of social conflicts can be found in the history of each right and its development. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "rights structure the form of governments, the content of laws, and the shape of morality as it is currently perceived."[1] The connection between rights and struggle cannot be overstated — rights are not as much granted or endowed as they are fought for and claimed, and the essence of struggles past and ancient are encoded in the spirit of current concepts of rights and their modern formulations.
 
I'm enjoying watching you make Vette look dumb, but this is actually a pretty damned difficult thing to do. It's easy to find lists of purported rights, but it's challenging to define.
.

I'm more than willing to admit that the difference between a right and a privelege are very murky. The distinction between the two, if it exists at all, is likely to be entirely arbitrary.

However Pergy, you're a moron. Just like me. The great and powerful Vette should be able to say something a little more substantive than rights don't require permission. Which is all he's offered and I want to know what human action cannot be outlawed. Aside from eating, (oh wait kosher), drinking and breathing I'm not certain these "rights" exist in any provable sense.
 
So, the founding fathers meant that you could "bear arms" in your own home, but not anywhere else, without a license?

Is that what you're attempting to portray?

No as I stated in a previous post theh founding fathers were wise enough to know they couldn't predict every eventuality so they left some things vague so later generations could make changes as needed.

In their day Firearms were used to hunt and for self defense. Their writings also indicate they wanted an armed populace to prevent tyranny.

One of the reasons Japan decided not to invade Hawaii after Pearl Harbor is the fear of an armed populace.

...that's supposed to look like Palin, and is a nod to her American flag / gun pictures.

So anyone who poses in front of the US flag with a gun is Palin? Sounds like the old bigoted expression "They all look alike to me". Glad not everyone is like that.

That comment is referring to myself, idiot..
So you can hate others as long as they don't hate on you. Figures. Probably couldn't handle it if someone was mean to you. Say anything you want about me, this is the last time I respond to you. Have fun flaming me.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Constitution was written by men who understood real oppression, who valued freedom, because in their world there was little to be had.
Are you talking about the slave owners or the slaves? Because the slaves who actually understood real oppression and valued freedom way better than the slave owners sure as fuck didn't write the Constitution.

Trips me out every time you invoke the Founding Fathers like they were altruistic demigods or some shit like that.
 
Sometimes I think I'd have more respect for people who oppose gay marriage if they'd stop with this ridiculous and hypocritical "sanctity of marriage" bullshit and just admit that they think homosexuality is profoundly wrong and gross and would like to use any legislative means available to prevent it from existing in their backyards.

I'd still think they were bigoted and ignorant and incorrect, but at least I'd consider them to be a little more honest and a little less stupid.
 
Sometimes I think I'd have more respect for people who oppose gay marriage if they'd stop with this ridiculous and hypocritical "sanctity of marriage" bullshit and just admit that they think homosexuality is profoundly wrong and gross and would like to use any legislative means available to prevent it from existing in their backyards.

I'd still think they were bigoted and ignorant and incorrect, but at least I'd consider them to be a little more honest and a little less stupid.


They think homosexuals can never be "sanctified". Or whatever.

Because they're bad.
 
I'm more than willing to admit that the difference between a right and a privelege are very murky. The distinction between the two, if it exists at all, is likely to be entirely arbitrary.

However Pergy, you're a moron. Just like me. The great and powerful Vette should be able to say something a little more substantive than rights don't require permission. Which is all he's offered and I want to know what human action cannot be outlawed. Aside from eating, (oh wait kosher), drinking and breathing I'm not certain these "rights" exist in any provable sense.



You are Born with your inalienable rights. They cease to be inalienable about the time your midwife covers you with a blanket (must not be naked). They die further when the intern jabs you with inoculations for the public good. And when your first pasteurized milk is put into your bottle . . . and so on.
 
You can for private sales, but you can't carry it in the vast majority of states legally without a license for it.
True to an extent (I think in most states it's a crime for a felon to buy even from an individual), but what if you can't find a person willing to sell to you in a private sale the government has placed a condition on otherwise buying a gun. Just like the government has placed conditions on who you can marry.
The difference here is that the conditions of buying a gun are, in theory, equally applied to all citizens, for example, must be 18, must not have a criminal background, etc., they aren't, "must be white heterosexual male".
Even though for a while marriage was like that, a white person couldn't marry a black person, but a white could marry a white and a black could marry a black, but now interracial marriage is ok, legally.
Now we have a homosexual can't marry a homosexual, but a homosexual can marry a heterosexual. Pretty similar case in most people's view.

if the spouse of a same sex couple is in the hospital, their partners are often denied the right to make medical decisions
An this is part of the problem of marriage being a "states rights" issue.
For example, Mary and Jane get legally married in MA. They decide to fly to visit friends in IA, but the weather is too bad to land there and the plane is diverted to NE.
They rent a car and have an accident leaving the airport. Jane is put in the ICU. Even though her mother is an angry homophobic bigot Mary calls her and tells her of Jane's condition. Jane's mom shows up and tells the hospital to not allow Mary anywhere near her daughter, which they have to do since Mary has no legal next of kin rights in NE. And since she has no rights where Jane is concerned, she can't even take her back to MA.

Well there's one thing for certain, a gay marriage will never contribute to any such statistics, or produce a generation of any kind. In the scope of the present set of circumstances, it's hard to see why it's a national priority without being overcome with political cynicism.:)
It's a national priority because there are a lot of adults who feel they have a right to control others' lives even when it has no effect on their own.
Counter to them are the rational adults who feel what they do with another consenting adult is no one else's business.

No as I stated in a previous post theh founding fathers were wise enough to know they couldn't predict every eventuality so they left some things vague so later generations could make changes as needed.
You're saying here that they intentionally didn't enumerate every single right and condition of them, yet because they didn't specifically talk about marriage it's not a right? Ummm...which is it?

Sometimes I think I'd have more respect for people who oppose gay marriage if they'd stop with this ridiculous and hypocritical "sanctity of marriage" bullshit and just admit that they think homosexuality is profoundly wrong and gross and would like to use any legislative means available to prevent it from existing in their backyards.
Same here. I can usually respect, to some degree anyway, an honest person. But not a hypocrite or liar or someone who makes straw arguments to divert from the fact they have no rational argument. "Because I said so" isn't a rational argument.

The United States and it's Constitution are unique among nations, please do not try and compare us or the principles of our founding documents to any other.
That statement shows one of two things, you believe our rights are granted by the US Constitution rather than them coming from God or being natural rights. Or else it's a complete non sequitur.
If you think they are granted by the Constitution, then yeah, what other countries do is pretty irrelevant.

But most people believe they are natural rights and the fact that other countries take them away illustrates quite clearly that our rights can be taken away, making the "you can't take away rights" argument complete nonsense.
The US is just as capable of denying and/or taking away rights as any other country and our history as a nation shows that. Our claim to fame however, is the ability, if you have enough money or good connections, to apply for redress all the way to the supreme court.
 
Last edited:
I'm more than willing to admit that the difference between a right and a privelege are very murky. The distinction between the two, if it exists at all, is likely to be entirely arbitrary.

However Pergy, you're a moron. Just like me. The great and powerful Vette should be able to say something a little more substantive than rights don't require permission. Which is all he's offered and I want to know what human action cannot be outlawed. Aside from eating, (oh wait kosher), drinking and breathing I'm not certain these "rights" exist in any provable sense.

I see his latest nonsense still doesn't answer the question. Though he does say that "as soon as the government regulates it, it's no longer a right," which to me says he doesn't believe in rights at all, since it's conceivable that the government could regulate anything at all. Then he flips again in the next post. How are we poor morons ever supposed to learn anything?
 
The importance of the Constitution is that it enumerates the powers of government, which are limited and defined, and states those powers that are not enumerated to the government are left to the states and to the people, which are many and indefinite.
Then you're ignoring the fact that the constitution enumerates only some of our rights, specifically states that is is, and states very clearly that doesn't mean we don't also have those non-enumerated rights.

You can make the case that it should be left up to states, which could be a valid argument, but no more valid than someone arguing that it shouldn't be because it is in fact a natural right that voters and some activist courts have decided to deny to or take away from a specific class of people.
 
I see his latest nonsense still doesn't answer the question. Though he does say that "as soon as the government regulates it, it's no longer a right," which to me says he doesn't believe in rights at all, since it's conceivable that the government could regulate anything at all. Then he flips again in the next post. How are we poor morons ever supposed to learn anything?

The focus on "license" is a red herring. Yes, license suggests a privilege. It is not determinative, though.

No right is unfettered. Subject to due process and various reasonableness tests, rights can be regulated.

Speech is subject to reasonable time, manner, and place regulation--thus the need for parade permits.

The state can regulate the way in which you possess your property, thus the need for building permits.

If you really want to chew on this issue, look at international human rights laws or South Africa's constitution. http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_Republic_of_South_Africa,_1996/Chapter_2
 
The focus on "license" is a red herring. Yes, license suggests a privilege. It is not determinative, though.

No right is unfettered. Subject to due process and various reasonableness tests, rights can be regulated.

Speech is subject to reasonable time, manner, and place regulation--thus the need for parade permits.

The state can regulate the way in which you possess your property, thus the need for building permits.

If you really want to chew on this issue, look at international human rights laws or South Africa's constitution. http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_Republic_of_South_Africa,_1996/Chapter_2

It can't be determinative. Vette's argument is bogus, of course, but it's because it's based on faith, the faith that we talked about yesterday.

I was looking at some international stuff last night, but it didn't lead me to SA. Thanks for the signpost. I'll chew on it later.
 
What a joke, he can't even chew out the truth of his own founding documents let alone those of South Africa. Are those the International Human Rights laws presided over by Libya and other dictators in the UN?

Dude, you can't find your way out of the First Amendment. You have no room to lecture anyone about the meaning of the constitution.
 
The importance of the Constitution is that it enumerates the powers of government, which are limited and defined
Yes, and one of those powers is to help ensure that the rights of the citizens are not denied to them, not even by the states.
 
In short yes, it does relegate your right to bear arms to a mere privilege. When the government acts unconstitutionally and it happens to be supported by the Court, there is no reason to suggest that a practical infringement of that right hasn't occurred.

If somebody accosts you on the street, takes your watch against your will and then pays you the market price price before leaving, does not change the fact that a theft just occurred.

Prior to 1934 this is how the Thompson sub machine gun was marketed to the general public, when anyone could buy one and the idea that a person's right to keep and bear arms "shall not be infringed.":

http://www.nfatoys.com/tsmg/images/cowboy.gif



How much freedom of speech do you have here these days if say you board an airplane with a copy of Mein Kamph in your luggage, are you going to attract the attention of the DHS? Will the FBI be interested in persons marketing the book, or buying the book? Despite the law of the land saying, "Congress shall make no law...or abridging the freedom of speech, or the press."




The above is a mish mash of mumbo jumbo.

Do you think convicted felons have a right to own a gun?
 
Are you talking about the slave owners or the slaves? Because the slaves who actually understood real oppression and valued freedom way better than the slave owners sure as fuck didn't write the Constitution.

Trips me out every time you invoke the Founding Fathers like they were altruistic demigods or some shit like that.

He prays to the gods of the free market, the founding fathers, and the glory hole.

Amen.
 
So tell me all about the South African Constitution and why it's superior to ours. Does it read like the Soviet Constitution?

i do not know why someone who has such a hard time with abstract ideas feels so compelled to dwell in them.

perg was pondering the source of rights.

that is a great ponder. philosophers have done it for centuries. our constitution and laws draw heavily from them.

so--i pointed out to perg other, more recent, articulations of rights. other places define fundamental rights differently. south africa's constitution is one of the most recent available.

i did not suggest it was superior or inferior. south africa, though, did just what our forefathers did. it considered the wisdom and experience of other places.
 
Back
Top