Musicians

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
How do you learn new songs?

I have my own process, not great but it works for me.

I don't have the 'ear' to tell whether the original artist is playing an A7dim, let alone whether it's being played on the 5th or 8th fret. So I pull up the tabs, then pull up the vid. on YouTube. Some of the tabs are just re-keyed to make it easier for the novice so some changes are often required to get it right. Then I just play along with the vid.

What's your plan?

Ishmael
 
If I'm learning to play music created by someone else, that's pretty much how I do it. I look at the tablature, then watch/listen to the music to uncode the strum pattern, then try to figure out how the instruments and vocals are layered. But I don't play many covers.

When I'm learning a new song I've written with a group of my musician friends, we have a few methods. One is just sitting down together and writing the lyrics and scratching out basic tabs, then building and layering the melody, find some bridges and just fill in any gaps. Then we write it all down, especially if (ahem) libation is involved, because we tend to forget the chords and we never, ever record ourselves. The second method is just pure jam style. Get together in the jam room, then someone plays something, someone else jumps in, then someone makes up some lyrics on the fly.

No matter how you learn, it's fun. The process.
 
If I'm learning to play music created by someone else, that's pretty much how I do it. I look at the tablature, then watch/listen to the music to uncode the strum pattern, then try to figure out how the instruments and vocals are layered. But I don't play many covers.

When I'm learning a new song I've written with a group of my musician friends, we have a few methods. One is just sitting down together and writing the lyrics and scratching out basic tabs, then building and layering the melody, find some bridges and just fill in any gaps. Then we write it all down, especially if (ahem) libation is involved, because we tend to forget the chords and we never, ever record ourselves. The second method is just pure jam style. Get together in the jam room, then someone plays something, someone else jumps in, then someone makes up some lyrics on the fly.

No matter how you learn, it's fun. The process.

I play a LOT of covers. So I'm more or less slaved to the method I use, which is that same you do it seems. (I used to buy the tab books, but most of them were off shit.)

re. new songs. I have a notebook or two filled with verse. Some melody, some chorus. I sometimes hallucinate that the NSA will end up with the books and their best code breakers will slowly go insane trying to decipher the crap contained therein. Some parts actually have some music to go with the words, mostly not. But I'll keep writing the crap down, it's just habit now.

Ishmael
 
I play a LOT of covers. So I'm more or less slaved to the method I use, which is that same you do it seems. (I used to buy the tab books, but most of them were off shit.)

re. new songs. I have a notebook or two filled with verse. Some melody, some chorus. I sometimes hallucinate that the NSA will end up with the books and their best code breakers will slowly go insane trying to decipher the crap contained therein. Some parts actually have some music to go with the words, mostly not. But I'll keep writing the crap down, it's just habit now.

Ishmael

I remember a decade or so ago when the interwebz was too young to have a massive tablature library online and you would *have* to buy the books to figure out the tabs, or know someone who could learn by ear to figure out the chords for you. I had a guitar teacher who would help me map the tabs, he was great. I always thought the books were a waste of money. I remember paying $25 for a Rolling Stones tab book. Fuck. What a waste of cash.

But now? Now we have access to everything. If the tabs aren't online, you can post in a music forum and someone will send them along via email. All that information is so readily available, which is good, but also terrible because it squashes some of the mystery of figuring that stuff out on your own.

I have about, well, 10 notebooks filled with verse. Half of them were written hastily and while under the influence of my favorite adult beverage, so mostly they're just not legible.
 
I remember a decade or so ago when the interwebz was too young to have a massive tablature library online and you would *have* to buy the books to figure out the tabs, or know someone who could learn by ear to figure out the chords for you. I had a guitar teacher who would help me map the tabs, he was great. I always thought the books were a waste of money. I remember paying $25 for a Rolling Stones tab book. Fuck. What a waste of cash.

But now? Now we have access to everything. If the tabs aren't online, you can post in a music forum and someone will send them along via email. All that information is so readily available, which is good, but also terrible because it squashes some of the mystery of figuring that stuff out on your own.

I have about, well, 10 notebooks filled with verse. Half of them were written hastily and while under the influence of my favorite adult beverage, so mostly they're just not legible.

Yeah, some teachers are worth their weight in gold. Mine showed me an alternate way of playing Carol Kings, "It's too late." I learned more from that change of progressions than he might of ever realized.

Tell me. (The Stones???? Are you kidding? Did the book indicate which tuning they were using at the time?)

I don't count the illegible, most of that crap is in a landfill somewhere. I really don't want to become an insane NSA cryptologist trying to decipher my own shit. If I can't figure it out by the second day, it never makes it from the 'stream of consciousness' note pad to the 'to be worked on' note pad.

Ishmael
 
Yeah, some teachers are worth their weight in gold. Mine showed me an alternate way of playing Carol Kings, "It's too late." I learned more from that change of progressions than he might of ever realized.

Tell me. (The Stones???? Are you kidding? Did the book indicate which tuning they were using at the time?)

I don't count the illegible, most of that crap is in a landfill somewhere. I really don't want to become an insane NSA cryptologist trying to decipher my own shit. If I can't figure it out by the second day, it never makes it from the 'stream of consciousness' note pad to the 'to be worked on' note pad.

Ishmael

I'll snap a pic of the book and send it to you. It's been a decade (?) since I even looked in it. It's up in my jam room in the pile with my favorite drum book, "Stick Control for the Snare Drummer."

All of my notebooks are partitioned into "crap" and "crap we may play someday." Or, "unoriginal crap we wrote when we were too drunk to know better."
 
I listen for the changes
decide what I want to play against it
then it becomes a matter of muscle memory
then what to tinker with to keep it from becoming boring
 
I'll snap a pic of the book and send it to you. It's been a decade (?) since I even looked in it. It's up in my jam room in the pile with my favorite drum book, "Stick Control for the Snare Drummer."

All of my notebooks are partitioned into "crap" and "crap we may play someday." Or, "unoriginal crap we wrote when we were too drunk to know better."

Am I going to have to send that pic to the NSA for deciphering? *chuckle*

Anything with "Stick Control" in the title is a book worthy of review. Or at least one that should sell well on certain internet forums.

I'm trying to re-organize based on subject. Perhaps doing it that way I may end up with a whole song.

I'm thinking that there are basically two classes of song writers. (No hard line there, just the way they lean for the most part.) Realists and abstractionists. Realists base their writing on life experience, abstractionists on how they think life should be. Overall I've learned more from the realists.

Ishmael
 
I love it when I reach the point of muscle memory where I can sit back and close my eyes and barely grip the guitar .. and still hit every chord dead-on perfect. Fluid is a good mode of playing. And being.
 
I listen for the changes
decide what I want to play against it
then it becomes a matter of muscle memory
then what to tinker with to keep it from becoming boring

Hmmm, I've done that with one song Bert. Billy Joe's "Downeaster Alexa." Just tried to play counterpoint to the accordion.

Ishmael
 
I love it when I reach the point of muscle memory where I can sit back and close my eyes and barely grip the guitar .. and still hit every chord dead-on perfect. Fluid is a good mode of playing. And being.

Practice, practice, practice.

Ishmael
 
Am I going to have to send that pic to the NSA for deciphering? *chuckle*

Anything with "Stick Control" in the title is a book worthy of review. Or at least one that should sell well on certain internet forums.

I'm trying to re-organize based on subject. Perhaps doing it that way I may end up with a whole song.

I'm thinking that there are basically two classes of song writers. (No hard line there, just the way they lean for the most part.) Realists and abstractionists. Realists base their writing on life experience, abstractionists on how they think life should be. Overall I've learned more from the realists.

Ishmael


Agreed on those two music writing pathologies, based on my swirling circles of musician friends. But I call them gleaners and dreamers.
 
I pick a song that I love, then look online at the simple version, so I can work against it. I play almost entirely melody instruments. Makes it easy. Fake book and shit. All I need to do is transpose.
 
Agreed on those two music writing pathologies, based on my swirling circles of musician friends. But I call them gleaners and dreamers.

Guess those nomikers come from being a 'Melodic Grunge Girlie." (I do like that description.)

My examples of the two, for the greater audience, are Paul Simon and John Lennon.

Ishmael
 
I pick a song that I love, then look online at the simple version, so I can work against it. I play almost entirely melody instruments. Makes it easy. Fake book and shit. All I need to do is transpose.

This is news Perg, never knew you played, an instrument that is. *snicker*

Ishmael
 
Hmmm, I've done that with one song Bert. Billy Joe's "Downeaster Alexa." Just tried to play counterpoint to the accordion.

Ishmael

we worked up a version of some kind of wonderful over labor day to keep the vocalist from quitting.
 
This is news Perg, never knew you played, an instrument that is. *snicker*

Ishmael

Don't *Ishsnicker* at me, fucker. I played piano for a couple years, switched to trumpet for maybe seven, then decided I needed an instrument I could play under a tree to myself, so flutes and stuff since then. And I can sing pretty damned well, too. I'm probably still best on the horn, but I prefer other outlets.
 
Guess those nomikers come from being a 'Melodic Grunge Girlie." (I do like that description.)

My examples of the two, for the greater audience, are Paul Simon and John Lennon.

Ishmael

That's spot on.
Melodic Grunge Girls could be its own genre. Case/point, etc.
This is news Perg, never knew you played, an instrument that is. *snicker*

Ishmael

I think Perg should stream vid of himself playing so we can join in on the jam. I vote for Honey to do the singing.
 
Don't *Ishsnicker* at me, fucker. I played piano for a couple years, switched to trumpet for maybe seven, then decided I needed an instrument I could play under a tree to myself, so flutes and stuff since then. And I can sing pretty damned well, too. I'm probably still best on the horn, but I prefer other outlets.

Word. If you can play brass, you're coveted in certain circles of musicians.
 
Don't *Ishsnicker* at me, fucker. I played piano for a couple years, switched to trumpet for maybe seven, then decided I needed an instrument I could play under a tree to myself, so flutes and stuff since then. And I can sing pretty damned well, too. I'm probably still best on the horn, but I prefer other outlets.

*Ishchuckle*

I stared on *cough* accordion, did trumpet for a while, then clarinet. Been on guitar for a while now.

Did you know that the accordion was one of those equal opportunity instruments? *nods* It was designed to accommodate pirates with only one finger on their left hand.

Ishmael
 
I think Perg should stream vid of himself playing so we can join in on the jam. I vote for Honey to do the singing.
I'm fucked. Honey and I once talked about doing a duet...and she held up her end, sent me a file of her singing the female part of "Landslide" by Fleetwood Mac....I pussied out, but later sang it with SheRem one night when she was hanging out at my place.
Word. If you can play brass, you're coveted in certain circles of musicians.

I can play trumpet, but the trombone positions are beyond me. I want to buy a valve trombone to fiddle with. But honestly, I'd rather play flute and fiddle right now.
 
I'm fucked. Honey and I once talked about doing a duet...and she held up her end, sent me a file of her singing the female part of "Landslide" by Fleetwood Mac....I pussied out, but later sang it with SheRem one night when she was hanging out at my place.


I can play trumpet, but the trombone positions are beyond me. I want to buy a valve trombone to fiddle with. But honestly, I'd rather play flute and fiddle right now.

I sooooooooooooooooooooo want to hear you sing a duet of Landslide with Honey. Really. Really, really. Or with Ish. So think about it. :D

Trombone, I found, way harder to play then trumpet, but I sucked at trumpet. I rocked the French horn, though. I gave up all brass and woodwinds when I discovered the guitar, though. I suck at everything, but I don't care. It's fun to play.
 
*Ishchuckle*

I stared on *cough* accordion, did trumpet for a while, then clarinet. Been on guitar for a while now.

Did you know that the accordion was one of those equal opportunity instruments? *nods* It was designed to accommodate pirates with only one finger on their left hand.

Ishmael
I had no idea. That's interesting stuff.
I second the lead choice. Perg's going to have to step up though.

Ishmael

You motherFUCKER. You know I'm going to do it, too. Where's Honey?
 
Back
Top