The man is so wretched, by the distortion of his postion, but he is so alive from the act of playing. The contradiction to me is enough to make this the most ironic painting Picasso ever did.
I, as a player, know that this is more of a lute stance, and I find that interesting. Looking at it this way envokes a sence of displacement and dispair to the forlorn man, who is aged and now possibly completely destitute and possbibly facing self induced dissolution. I think it is really emotional and dark.
I feel and can hear the player playing some long, dark Spanish melody, something of his sorrow of a lost love in youth or something equally romantic.
That painting has always spoken strongly to me as well.
I'm also a musician, and I think what it conjures up is the pain, struggle and darkness involved in honest self expression.
If any artist truly gets through to their innermost feelings, and manages to express them through their art, it will reflect not only their original intent, but the path and struggle involved in getting it out.
To me, this man shows the weariness from a long and difficult path of self-expression.