Justin or Kelly

[TonyG]

Who is your choice, if you even care, for the New American Idol and why?

 

[binkley]

Who?

 

[RawHumor]

Kelly's 3 times the singer that Justin is, but Justin knows how to work the crowd and the teeny bopper girls all love him.

Man, how bad did that winner of the UK contest suck?

That was just sad. I didn't know the Monkeys were coming back.

 

[pussy4u40]

Kelly is a better singer but Justin is the hearthrob. I vote for Kelly though.

 

[Jewelz]

Kelly's 3 times the singer that Justin is, but Justin knows how to work the crowd and the teeny bopper girls all love him.

Man, how bad did that winner of the UK contest suck?

That was just sad. I didn't know the Monkeys were coming back.

I ditto everything!!

 

[Bluesboy2]

Who is your choice, if you even care, for the New American Idol and why?

It will be whom ever the producers scripted way back when they started the show.

 

[TonyG]

That UK guy WAS really bad. I can not imagine who is buying his CD. 1.2 million sold in one week so far.

 

[brokenbrainwave]

I am proud to say I have yet to see a single episode of this show, survivor, or big brother.

 

[binkley]

I ditto everything!!

Another Rush Limbaugh fan.

 

[Mistress]

I ditto everything!!

I ditto her ditto

 

[medjay]

Neither. Everyone knows Tamyra was the best one. And the prettiest. Her getting voted off was a complete disgrace!

 

[RawHumor]

Neither. Everyone knows Tamyra was the best one. And the prettiest. Her getting voted off was a complete disgrace!

She IS a great singer, but she's more R&B. The voters might be looking for more of a POP star. I still think Kelly's voice is better than Tamyra's though.

My personal favorite was Nikki, but mostly because I liked her style (more rock than Celine-ish). I don't think her voice is as good as any of the other two girls or Justin, but I'd rather listen to her than any of those three, with the possible exception of Kelly.

 

[Jewelz]

Another Rush Limbaugh fan.

How bad will I be ambushed if I say "Not really"?

 

[Jewelz]

I ditto her ditto

I think I might like that. *wink*

 

[medjay]

She IS a great singer, but she's more R&B. The voters might be looking for more of a POP star.

Maybe so. But I'm willing to bet all the money in my pocket that in the long run, Tamyra will end up having a longer career than anyone else who appeared on that show. We'll be hearing from her again. *Fingers crossed*

 

[TonyG]

Bump for more votes.

 

[Tantanah]

I vote for Kelly. She is a way better singer than Justin.

 

[Devilish1]

Kelly's 3 times the singer that Justin is, but Justin knows how to work the crowd and the teeny bopper girls all love him.

Man, how bad did that winner of the UK contest suck?

That was just sad. I didn't know the Monkeys were coming back.

I agree with you Raw. Kelly just rocks and Justin IF he wins it will because he knows how to swoon the girls.

I thought the same thing about the UK winner, he didnt do a thing for me and neither did the song he sung. How Brady Bunch was that? LMAO

 

[HighSchoolJock]

Kelly's 3 times the singer that Justin is, but Justin knows how to work the crowd and the teeny bopper girls all love him.

Man, how bad did that winner of the UK contest suck?

That was just sad. I didn't know the Monkeys were coming back.

for your information the MONKEES came back in 1987 with the formation of the NEW MONKEES the single greatest collection of artists ever assembled

 

[perks]

kelly damnit, justin only has half the package. He's a heart throb, not an idol.

 

[WhatsHerName]

I have to admit that I was not once tempted to watch this show. I don't see the point in it...when the votes really didn't count.

 

[RawHumor]

I have to admit that I was not once tempted to watch this show. I don't see the point in it...when the votes really didn't count.

What do you mean that the votes didn't count?