"It Doesn't Affect You"

Ramone45

Literotica Guru
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Posts
5,896
It seems like such a specious argument. Legalizing gay mariage doesn't affect me, so I shouldn't care. But truthfully, if gay marriage was illegal, that wouldn't affect me either. The poor drug dealer who gets gunned down in Detroit doesn't affect me in the least, Why should I care about that?
 
It seems like such a specious argument. Legalizing gay mariage doesn't affect me, so I shouldn't care. But truthfully, if gay marriage was illegal, that wouldn't affect me either. The poor drug dealer who gets gunned down in Detroit doesn't affect me in the least, Why should I care about that?

Why should anyone care about you?
 
Can't any of you selfish dipshits explain why "it doesn't affect you" is a coherent position?
 
Nothing much was decided today. Marriage shouldn't be a federal issue, so killing DOMA was appropriate. Prop 8 split the court in a way that surprised many...Scalia and Roberts joined 3 liberals, but one liberal and Kennedy joined Thomas and Alito, so it looks to me like this game isn't over or may go a direction folks don't expect for it decides nothing in states where same-sex is illegal. So faggots gotta decide if 5 shots were fired, or six.
 
Nothing much was decided today. Marriage shouldn't be a federal issue, so killing DOMA was appropriate. Prop 8 split the court in a way that surprised many...Scalia and Roberts joined 3 liberals, but one liberal and Kennedy joined Thomas and Alito, so it looks to me like this game isn't over or may go a direction folks don't expect for it decides nothing in states where same-sex is illegal. So faggots gotta decide if 5 shots were fired, or six.


Oh the game is over. The winds of change are blowing incredibly strongly at the backs of marriage equality advocates while opponents are losing their vigor and well, dying off. The debate is over, we won. The only question now is how soon the rest of the states will commit to freedom.
 
Who's selfish again?

Those who think an issue should be decided on its immediate affect on them.
In what possible way would the extinction of the Polar Bear have any possible affect on me here in Phoenix, Arizona? Why should I care?
 
Oh the game is over. The winds of change are blowing incredibly strongly at the backs of marriage equality advocates while opponents are losing their vigor and well, dying off. The debate is over, we won. The only question now is how soon the rest of the states will commit to freedom.

Prop 8 changed nothing. Same-sex remains illegal in 38 states.
 
Can't any of you selfish dipshits explain why "it doesn't affect you" is a coherent position?

Sure, I'll field this one, but can you do me a favor and expend maybe an ounce of effort and critical reasoning before you post a dumb thread asking a dumb question (which, for the record, makes you look like a dumb person)? I think it will save all of us a lot of grief.

That line of reasoning is used in direct response to the argument that allowing gays to wed would erode the "sanctity of marriage," implying that gay marriage would have some magical, sparkly, gay impact on heterosexual couplings.

Disregarding the staggering divorce rates and rampant infidelity that exist within the institution of marriage already, "it doesn't affect you" is a perfectly reasonable and true response. Since that represents the null hypothesis, the burden of proof is on the people who claim they're being affected. So, your turn!

Very Truly Yours,
A Selfish Dipshit
 
Sure, I'll field this one, but can you do me a favor and expend maybe an ounce of effort and critical reasoning before you post a dumb thread asking a dumb question (which, for the record, makes you look like a dumb person)? I think it will save all of us a lot of grief.

That line of reasoning is used in direct response to the argument that allowing gays to wed would erode the "sanctity of marriage," implying that gay marriage would have some magical, sparkly, gay impact on heterosexual couplings.

Disregarding the staggering divorce rates and rampant infidelity that exist within the institution of marriage already, "it doesn't affect you" is a perfectly reasonable and true response. Since that represents the null hypothesis, the burden of proof is on the people who claim they're being affected. So, your turn!

Very Truly Yours,
A Selfish Dipshit

Wait a second!!! Marriage is meant for procreation... so I guess that means that heterosexual couples that can't or don't create children should be forced to divorce.
 
Prop 8 changed nothing. Same-sex remains illegal in 38 states.

And a few years ago it was illegal in 50 states.

Among America's many voter types, there are only five demographic groups left where opponents of equality still show up: less educated Caucasians (56%), the over-65 crowd (58%), Republicans (69%), evangelical Protestant Caucasians (73%), and Tea Partyists (nearly 100%). Those five are the only opponent hideouts left; every other demographic group measured in a major national poll now supports same-gender marriage.

http://www.policymic.com/articles/2...l-probably-legalize-gay-marriage-in-2013-2014
 
- New Jersey, Hawaii, Oregon, Colorado, New Mexico, and Nevada are all planning on putting marriage equality on the ballot next year.

- Illinois has two lawsuits in process to make it legal and their legislature is getting ready to pass a law legalizing it in case those don't work.

- New Jersey has lawsuits, a ballot coming, and a legislature that backs marriage equality so much that they may be able to override Christie's veto.
 
why make a thread if it never affected you then? lol

some way some how it did affect you because it made you create this topic.

:D
 
Sure, I'll field this one, but can you do me a favor and expend maybe an ounce of effort and critical reasoning before you post a dumb thread asking a dumb question (which, for the record, makes you look like a dumb person)? I think it will save all of us a lot of grief.

That line of reasoning is used in direct response to the argument that allowing gays to wed would erode the "sanctity of marriage," implying that gay marriage would have some magical, sparkly, gay impact on heterosexual couplings.

Disregarding the staggering divorce rates and rampant infidelity that exist within the institution of marriage already, "it doesn't affect you" is a perfectly reasonable and true response. Since that represents the null hypothesis, the burden of proof is on the people who claim they're being affected. So, your turn!

Very Truly Yours,
A Selfish Dipshit

Listen to the crazy pony! She's absolutely right!
 
So was prohibition. So was slavery. Sex with children usta be legal too. I guess what youre saying is youre hopeful the tide is coming in.

Holy crap, do you actually think there's a chance that this will swing the other way?

Slavery might swing the other way too and become legal again, right?
 
You know merc it's usually considered bad form to quote someone everybody has on ignore just so other people will see what he posted. We all know your far too inteligent to have honored that with a response otherwise but I assure you we know he's an idiot racist fuckwit.
 
You know merc it's usually considered bad form to quote someone everybody has on ignore just so other people will see what he posted. We all know your far too inteligent to have honored that with a response otherwise but I assure you we know he's an idiot racist fuckwit.


It's fun though.

You don't have BB on iggy, right? :)
 
Doesn't everybody? I do check in on him every other day or so. His sigline is usually worth that. :D
 
It seems like such a specious argument. Legalizing gay mariage doesn't affect me, so I shouldn't care. But truthfully, if gay marriage was illegal, that wouldn't affect me either. The poor drug dealer who gets gunned down in Detroit doesn't affect me in the least, Why should I care about that?

The drug dealer who gets gunned down in Detroit does affect where your taxes go.
 
- New Jersey, Hawaii, Oregon, Colorado, New Mexico, and Nevada are all planning on putting marriage equality on the ballot next year.

- Illinois has two lawsuits in process to make it legal and their legislature is getting ready to pass a law legalizing it in case those don't work.

- New Jersey has lawsuits, a ballot coming, and a legislature that backs marriage equality so much that they may be able to override Christie's veto.

I can see Nevada allowing it simply because they have a service industry economy.
 
Can't any of you selfish dipshits explain why "it doesn't affect you" is a coherent position?



Because the core premise of DOMA is that gay marriage devalues traditional marriage, a position that is outright bullshit. :cool:
 
Back
Top