Ishmael

It's the same old argument, Rhumb.

See, the thing is, you don't figure out how much to charge for your burger by how much you wanna make - you figure out how much the market will bear, and charge appropriately. If you can sell burgers for two bucks a piece, you do. But if the going rate is a buck and a half, that's all you can charge - that is, if you want to sell your burgers.

If you can sell your burgers for four bucks a piece, that's what you charge. You don't charge less just because you "only" want to make forty grand.

Similarly, if a buck and a half is the going rate, people aren't going to pay more just so you can make the profit you feel you're entitled to.
 
Sandia said:
It's the same old argument, Rhumb.

See, the thing is, you don't figure out how much to charge for your burger by how much you wanna make - you figure out how much the market will bear, and charge appropriately. If you can sell burgers for two bucks a piece, you do. But if the going rate is a buck and a half, that's all you can charge - that is, if you want to sell your burgers.

If you can sell your burgers for four bucks a piece, that's what you charge. You don't charge less just because you "only" want to make forty grand.

Similarly, if a buck and a half is the going rate, people aren't going to pay more just so you can make the profit you feel you're entitled to.

True as far as it goes.

First of all, all similar business's in similar locations are effected the same by taxes. Period.

You raise taxes, prices go up. Period. Why, all business have to absorb the overhead. There is a certain profit margin below which the business in no longer sustainable. So it fails.

I'll try another approach. Name one business that is without customers? Just one please? No company is it's own source of money. The money is always ALWAYS from an external source. Usually called cusotmers.

So, if the company makes no money (lacks customers) it will naturally not forward a portion of the money that the company didn't collect in the form of 'pass through' taxes.

Trace any companies revenues and you will find that the source of the money that the company is collecting are the consumers. Even in the instance of governement purchases which are paid for by the consumers that paid individual income taxes.

Companies act as bookkeepers and pass through tax collectors for the government. They never have, and never will pay taxes in the same manner that the individual does.

The fact that they fill out some paperwork has no bearing on the issue. It's just a convenient way for the government to collect money from the individual citizens while appearing to have not raised their taxes. Merely a shell game perpetrated on the terminally economically challenged.

Ishmael
 
Econ 101

Corporations can only shift a portion of their tax burden to their customers. The amount shifted depends on both the elasticity of the demand curve they face in the market and the freedom they have to set prices. Remember revenue is the product of price and volume, and the relationship between price and volume is inverse.
 
Re: Econ 101

Sam1 said:
Corporations can only shift a portion of their tax burden to their customers. The amount shifted depends on both the elasticity of the demand curve they face in the market and the freedom they have to set prices. Remember revenue is the product of price and volume, and the relationship between price and volume is inverse.

That's a business decision and all of the tax burden maybe shifted depending on the strategy and the market.

A business may decide to operate at reduced profit for a time inorder to gain a price advantage on competitors and to increase market share.

It is a matter of accounting and strategic business planning as to how much and when. Eventually the market levels out and it's all passed on again.

Ishmael
 
Re: taxes

cajunman said:
i made the mistake of keeping a record of all of my taxes between sales, hotel, gas, income, everything. the entire tax load i paid for last year was $0.65 for every $1.00 that i made including $.36 for federal in texas no state tax thank GOD but our gas tax is $.42 cents a gallon sales of 8.25% to 9% and hotel tax of up 22% IT MAKES ME SICK but i pay it all so i don't go to jail

get a bike and a sleeping bag!
 
Re: Re: Econ 101

Ishmael said:
Eventually the market levels out and it's all passed on again.

Ishmael

Markets never level out! Or if they do it is only in econ 101. that some portion is passed on the the customer is with out question.

How many investors does it take to change a light bulb?

none the market has already discounted the darkness.
 
Re: Econ 101

Sam1 said:
Corporations can only shift a portion of their tax burden to their customers. The amount shifted depends on both the elasticity of the demand curve they face in the market and the freedom they have to set prices. Remember revenue is the product of price and volume, and the relationship between price and volume is inverse.

Yes.

Unless there's no elasticity in the market some of the tax comes out of profits.
 
"See, the thing is, you don't figure out how much to charge for your burger by how much you wanna make - you figure out how much the market will bear, and charge appropriately. If you can sell burgers for two bucks a piece, you do. But if the going rate is a buck and a half, that's all you can charge - that is, if you want to sell your burgers. "


Bullshit.

Bullshit.

I market. I decide my income level, I decide how much I need per students and how many students I need, find a location that matches that discretionary income level, develop a curriculum to suit the location's lifestyle, and then I go get students... You sell burgers the same fawking way...

For example, Bruce Lee eventually only needed like three students because they were paying him a butload of cash per lesson. The kid down the street competing against me charges half the price I do and has trouble staying in business. People think they get what they pay for and treat your business accordingly...

Why do you think they are marketing the six-dollar burger?

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm????????????
 
Sandia said:
It's the same old argument, Rhumb.

See, the thing is, you don't figure out how much to charge for your burger by how much you wanna make - you figure out how much the market will bear, and charge appropriately. If you can sell burgers for two bucks a piece, you do. But if the going rate is a buck and a half, that's all you can charge - that is, if you want to sell your burgers.

If you can sell your burgers for four bucks a piece, that's what you charge. You don't charge less just because you "only" want to make forty grand.

Similarly, if a buck and a half is the going rate, people aren't going to pay more just so you can make the profit you feel you're entitled to.

Sorry, Sandia, but baseline price is always calculated on return on investment.

Mr. Smith's investment is his financial obligations plus his "sweat equity". When costs increase beyond the ability of the sales to provide that minimal rate of return, a good businessman closes the business.

Your argument that pricing is based on "what the market will bear" is false and naive. In the very rare circumstance where a product has a monopoly market with a high demand curve, you are correct. Barry Bond's home run baseballs are a good example. Mr. Smith will never have that option. He could price his burgers at $4.00, watch sales drop by 60%, see 40% of inventory go to waste and return on investment decline to were he gets $20,000 a year, pays $5000 in taxes and quits.

Hopefully he does that before Mickey D's opens across the street and he goes completely bankrupt!

Rhumb
 
Rhumb, I don't know if you're arguing with me or for me here.

The reason Mikkey D's doesn't charge six bucks a burger is they can't get away with it - folks won't buy their burgers at that price.

That's true of every service and commodity. If you can charge six bucks a burger, or a million per home run, or whatever, you do. You try to find the price that maximizes your income - what the market will bear.

Now, SIN, you're absolutely right - if you can't compete - whether because of taxes, or other expenses - you get out of the market altogether. On an individual level, people do the same thing as businesses do. They look for the best return on their labor or their capital. In other words, they try to make as much money as they can. If they can make more working for IBM than selling burgers, they'll likely work for IBM. If you can charge a hundred dollars a session to your students, you do. If your students start dropping out when you raise your prices, you better charge less, or you'll end up teaching to an empty classroom.

Now don't get me wrong. I'm not arguing the extreme position, here - that people will continue selling at a set price regardless of their taxes or other expenses. Nobody sells below cost, for example - at least not for long.

But if you're selling at what the market will bear, and your taxes go up... you pay the taxes. Just like any other sod who works for a living.

If Dell is selling computers in a competitive marketplace.. and their taxes go up.. Dell's shareholders are going to get a report showing profits have declined for the quarter.

Now Dell - or any company - will try to pass on as much of the tax as they can. But if it's a competitive market they're not necessarily going to be able to pass on all of it.
 
Bullshit.

I can walk into applebee's and buy a fawking $6.00 burger and their stock is solid.

MARKETING BAYBEE! That's the only reason one pays gwad knows what to see Barry hit home runs... MARKETING

McDonalds choose the kid's market, low cost and volumne. Only if I choose to compete on MacDonald's level do your rules come into play. It cost more to eat ans Wendy's and Dave croaked well-off...
 
SINthysist said:
Bullshit.

I can walk into applebee's and buy a fawking $6.00 burger and their stock is solid.

MARKETING BAYBEE! That's the only reason one pays gwad knows what to see Barry hit home runs... MARKETING

McDonalds choose the kid's market, low cost and volumne. Only if I choose to compete on MacDonald's level do your rules come into play. It cost more to eat ans Wendy's and Dave croaked well-off...

That's the nut of it bro. It is those concepts of business and economics that many fail to grasp. One of the reasons that you seldom see legal hacks as CEO's.

That may change now that some of the ambulance chasers have established multiple regional offices and are doing TV marketing over the entire region. They're making themselve the Mickey D's of the legal profession. But that probably isn't such a bad thing. Eventually others will catch on and the prices will go down. (And if they don't they are going to open themselves up to price fixing. I love it.)

Ishmael
 
The phone was ringing elsewise I would have cleaned up the spelling and added a few more fawks and gawds... :D
 
Back
Top