Intentional writing style

old_prof

Older than that
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Posts
4,076
@sijopunk has been trying for over a year to get me to be more aware and more intentional about how I write. I think I've proven a bad student.

I write what flows out of my subconscious. I have learned to revise much more effectively, but, for the most part, the voice is unchanged.

My awareness of this came to the fore twice recently. I'm reading Chuck Palahniuk's essays on writing (at @sijopunk 's bidding); he has one talking about spending months writing in another's style. I could not imagine doing that.

I heard Salisbury Hill come on the radio today. Allegedly, Pater Gabriel wrote that to sound like an old Genesis song (back when he wrote essentially all their songs). I'm a very different write than I was 18 months ago, but I could never imagine trying to write a story like I did 18 months ago.

My wife suggested that it's because my style hasn't changed, just my mastery of the craft has improved (not to claim that I am a master of the craft now by any stretch of the imagination). I'm not sure I have a style yet. Or maybe ever.

How many of you are aware of a style you write in (I know some are)? When did you realize your own style? I wonder if it's
1) something you have or don't have
2) something you gain in a sudden epiphany. Much of revising has worked that way for me. It doesn't work for me until it suddenly does.
3) something that grows organically over time and you gain in shades of gray.
 
I feel like it's a little bit like the way I talk, or the way I present myself as a person. Over the years there have been things I've noticed myself saying or doing, or noticed the way people have responded to something I've said or done, where I've thought Huh, maybe that's annoying, I should stop doing that. I don't think of my personality as something I've consciously cultivated on every level, but I've leaned into things that feel right and tried to shed things that don't. The result is people generally seem to like me,* so I think I've done ok so far.

I'm intentional with style when there's something specific I want to evoke, where maybe I'll try to veer toward darker or weirder or more high energy, depending on the needs of the story. I flatter myself that not all my stories sound exactly the same, whether or not it's true. But at its core, on the level that doesn't change from story to story or voice to voice, I think it starts at a subconscious level. It's just the way I am/write. Until with practice I notice things that seem to work or don't work and try to consciously tweak that approach as needed. Hopefully I get better over time (I think I do).

* similar to what I noted in the shit list thread, perhaps an illusion that I'm not eager to disabuse myself of.
 
How many of you are aware of a style you write in (I know some are)? When did you realize your own style?
I spent a lot of energy back when I was publishing, trying to identify my style. I've gathered a lot of insights since then. @ElectricBlue gave me two important concepts, he said (words to the effect) that my writing was "static," that I liked "to paint a tableau." An AH member who seems to have disappeared alluded to "formal."
I wonder if it's
1) something you have or don't have
I've only written in one style. So I guess I have it. I've not thought about it consciously before or while writing, only after the fact.
2) something you gain in a sudden epiphany. Much of revising has worked that way for me. It doesn't work for me until it suddenly does.
I was a young adult when The Story of O hit the streets. The opening scenes stuck with me vividly. I'm guessing that was an important influence.
3) something that grows organically over time and you gain in shades of gray.
Nope. It was or wasn't. I did spend a lot of time refining language, but that's not the same as style.
 
How many of you are aware of a style you write in (I know some are)? When did you realize your own style? I wonder if it's
1) something you have or don't have
2) something you gain in a sudden epiphany. Much of revising has worked that way for me. It doesn't work for me until it suddenly does.
3) something that grows organically over time and you gain in shades of gray.
I'm very aware of style, and I deliberately choose styles to suit the story.

Compare this from Jackie:
Once upon a time, a happier time long, long ago, there lived a farm lass called Jackie. Jackie was pretty, with curly hair and freckles on her face from spending long days in the sunshine, and tall and strong from working on her parents' farm.

All day she laboured, tending the beasts, ploughing, sowing and harvesting the crops, chopping timber in the wood, and everything else that needed to be done to maintain the farm.

One day her Ma came to her and said, "Jackie, lass, it's time you married. Have some children of your own, so they can help on the farm when your Da and I are old and weak."

Jackie, being a dutiful daughter and very fond of her Ma besides, considered this for a long moment. Then she replied, "Fuck that, Ma. I'm too young and pretty to have babies. I have brothers and sisters aplenty who can provide you with grandchildren to look after you."
With this from My Wife the Witch:
How do you know if your wife is a witch?

I don't mean one of those spiritual types with a tendency to go on about "the Goddess" and how every woman is a magical creature. My wife wears business suits and heels, and aside from a preference for dangly earrings she doesn't have any mystical jewellery to clank in her hair.

And I'm not saying she's a witch doctor, or voodoo priestess, with cards and black candles and creepy eyes that roll back into her head, and maybe a huge black rooster to stalk around after her.

The closest Alys has is Nick, who's black but a cat. He's big, and admittedly he follows her from room to room if he has the chance. But he'd never hop onto a broomstick if she put on a pointy hat and invited him to go flying around beneath the full moon. He's more the kind of cat to fall asleep on her lap to stop her from going.

Alys is too grounded to be mystical or mysterious. She works in advertising, she loves Thai food and, like I mentioned, she has a black cat called Nick. Officially he's "our" cat, but we all know he's hers. Unless I'm holding a tin opener or a brush, I might as well be part of the furniture for all he could care.

But Alys also has something about her that I can't explain. An aura, perhaps, and a way of turning every situation to her hand. Sometimes things come together for her in the most implausible of ways, and she just says, "It's magic."
And with this from Shadows of Betrayal:
Sunset fell on the Imperial City of Mezhan, on the Hard Coast between the sea and the desert. The sounding of the great gong in the Westgate Tower heralded the end of the day's business, when workers laid down their tools, shopkeepers ushered the last customers out into the street, and the massive gates in the city's walls were closed and barred.

Along the Prince's Avenue, in the parks and gardens that surrounded the mansions of the rich, rows of tall silverboughs shed the day's blooms. Silver petals fell in soft clouds to cover the ground and fill the air with their gentle perfume. One-day hummer moths appeared out of nowhere to descend on the fallen blossoms, insect and flower celebrating together their life and their death.

As the red disc disappeared below the desert dunes, glowstones shed their light in the richer quarters and torches sputtered into life elsewhere. Tidy rows marked the streets of the artisan districts, and tall clusters brought light to the docks and great blocks of warehouses. Flames flickered from sconces and brackets in the Thieves' Market, a collection of alleys and squares where the business of the night lived.

Here, shopfronts opened, musicians struck up in inns and taverns, streethawkers and harlots shouted their wares. Swaggering mercenaries brushed shoulders with shady scholars and love-sick poets. The dark air, cooler than under the desert's hot sun but still warm, grew heady with the scents of spices, perfumes and strange smokes. Wine and stronger drink flowed by the jug down thirsty throats, and the hubbub rose and fell steadily like the tide that beat against the city's seawalls.
And this from Into The Night:
The boss man's givin' you hell, all day, shoutin' at you across the ever-present hiss of the rain, glarin' and pointin' and you just wanna do your job, shitty as it is, loadin' them crates, the wonky ones the androids are too particular to load, and you just wanna do your hours and get your pay, is that too much to ask, do your job and get the bux, it's not like you're demandin' handouts or anythin', just wanna do your job in peace, without that fucker yellin' at you like you don't know your shitty job, because what are you, some shit for brains who don't know how to load crates, all you gotta do is pack 'em down, nice and snug, then use the Air-G lifter to put 'em on the belt, and then the belt and the androids and the boss man do all the thinkin', like which dock they go to and who gets bribed to pass 'em and who gets fucked up if the ship or train gets where it's supposed to be and the crate ain't on it...

And probably half a dozen more besides. Different styles for different effects, for different moods, for different kinds of stories. It's half the fun of writing to try all of them.
 
How many of you are aware of a style you write in (I know some are)? When did you realize your own style? I wonder if it's
1) something you have or don't have
2) something you gain in a sudden epiphany. Much of revising has worked that way for me. It doesn't work for me until it suddenly does.
3) something that grows organically over time and you gain in shades of gray.

Probably almost 2 decades ago I realized my writing style was staccato visceral minimalistic free verse poetry and micro fiction/flash fiction stories. I became aware of this because I put my thoughts on post-it notes and there's not room for novel length content.

Currently I am enjoying tinkering with existing poetry forms (fun word puzzles) as well as creating my own poetry form which I call the Cadelle
 
Last edited:
If there's a style for 'characters emote too much', then that's mine. My characters never just say something, they say it with a smile or grunt with a raised eyebrow or reply with a quizical expression. I write the way I see the characters in my mind so that the readers can too. Perhaps too much.
 
My style changes based on the narrator who tells my story, especially in 1P. I like that the narrator is also a character, and the style in which I write their thoughts helps the reader understand a little more about the kind of person they are.

When I (rarely) write in 3P, I find that my style conforms itself to the tone of the piece I'm writing. I tend to write SF or fantasy pieces much less formally than vampire/witch stories, and that's largely a subconscious choice on my part... though, once I've started, I do notice it consciously.

When I abandon 3P stories, nine times out of ten it's because I'm dissatisfied with the style choices I find myself making.
 
How many of you are aware of a style you write in (I know some are)? When did you realize your own style? I wonder if it's
1) something you have or don't have
2) something you gain in a sudden epiphany. Much of revising has worked that way for me. It doesn't work for me until it suddenly does.
3) something that grows organically over time and you gain in shades of gray.
Shocker, I'm like @StillStunned: The style and voice vary depending on the type of story, POV characters, vibe, genre, content, etc. Basically, whatever voice and style is what the story requires, I'll try to do that. It's probably more evident in my non-Anthy stories than it is here. I'm not sure if I have a default style; if I do, it's probably slightly clipped with a tendency for meanders mid-sentence — slightly stream of consciousness, if you would — as I think of something, then I come up with something else, then the sentence keeps going because I think to myself, "Ah, wait, it shouldn't end yet, there's still this to say and it fits better in this sentence than if I were to stick it in the next," and soon you have a long-winded piece of nonsense that, at some point, comes to an end.

I suspect that style shows up a little bit regardless of what I do, but I do try to style with an eye for what best fits the story. Horror has a different style than floaty fantasy has a different style to grounded erotic has a different style to whimsy. The fact that I often mix a lot of things together makes it interesting, and tends to result in a bit of a blend depending on which part of the story I'm in and what mood and vibe I want to instill.
 
It's difficult to assess one's own style objectively. I try, but I'm not sure how successfully. I think it helps deliberately to try different styles so you can analyze how styles can differ. One of my stories is in an exaggerated Hemingway style. One is written in a spoof of a hard-boiled detective style. Most of my stories adopt a fairly conventional style, but sometimes I like to try to get more flowery with descriptions. I think if you experiment with different styles you become more aware of what you naturally gravitate toward.
 
Back
Top