Intelligence Is Guessing Correctly

I'm going to "guess" that you didn't do a very good job of reading the link in your original post.

If I'm right, does that mean I just evolved luck??
 
Scientists have been searching for evidence of paranormal phenomena for more than a few years and come up dry; everything that appears to be evidence of such always evaporates under bright light.

Like the 'God' particle, you mean?
 
That pretty much marginalizes the President right into the dumpster for the dumb.

Yes sir!

I've long and often said that if you wanna seriously screw someone, make life easy for them.
 
If you are going to link to a scholarly article with a brain-dead ALL CAPS post, well we know what side of the iceberg you are on. Or are you afraid to enunciate?
 
If you are going to link to a scholarly article with a brain-dead ALL CAPS post, well we know what side of the iceberg you are on. Or are you afraid to enunciate?

Furthermore, "THE SMARTIES GUESS RIGHT" is really not a very good encapsulation of what Dr. Calvin is saying here, even if it does have the word "guessing" in it:

While we often use the term 'intelligence' to encompass both a broad range of abilities and the efficiency with which they're enacted, it also implies flexibility and creativity, an "ability to slip the bonds of instinct and generate novel solutions to problems" (Gould and Gould 1994, p. 70). Those three pillars of animal intelligence - association, imitation, and insight - are also impressive (Byrne 1994), as are the occasional symbolic (Deacon 1997) and reasoning (Gould & Gould, 1998) abilities. But Piaget (1929; 1952) said that intelligence is what you use when you don't know what to do, when neither innateness nor learning has prepared you for the particular situation.

Intelligence is improvisational. Still, most of the time, not much improvisation is necessary; the individual has encountered somewhat similar situations before, has a repertoire of actions, and simply starts one - and gropes, using feedback's progress reports to guide to the goal. No major planning is needed in most cases, and thus not much in the way of intellectual wherewithal. This suggests a focus on those few behaviors that require an elaborate multistage plan prepared during "get set." An example would be the ballistic movements (hammering, clubbing, throwing, kicking, spitting) where the speed of feedback is so inadequate (they're often over-and-done by the time that progress reports can start modifying the movement), where only near-perfect plans will succeed.

What the mind is often seeking during "get set", I suspect, is coherence - finding a conceptual combination of sensory input, memories, and movement plans that fit together particularly well - though, because of novelty, most will rate less than the "perfect ten" of exact, unambiguous fits. Similar to this is Barlow's (1987) suggestion that intelligence is all about making a guess that discovers some new underlying order. "Guessing well" neatly covers a lot of ground relevant to higher intellectual functions: finding the solution of a problem or the logic of an argument, happening upon an appropriate analogy, creating a pleasing harmony or witty reply, or guessing what's likely to happen next.

What he means by "guessing" has nothing at all to do with luck.
 
If you are going to link to a scholarly article with a brain-dead ALL CAPS post, well we know what side of the iceberg you are on. Or are you afraid to enunciate?

Yes, indeed.
 
If it were possible to evolve "towards better luck," which it isn't; no more than it is possible to evolve toward paranormal/psychic abilities, because they do not exist and are not physically possible.

I have read theories based on quantum entanglement that posit not only are they possible, but MUST exist (because of another theory - whose name escapes me...senior moment- that posits if something is possible it MUST occur).
 
Furthermore, "THE SMARTIES GUESS RIGHT" is really not a very good encapsulation of what Dr. Calvin is saying here, even if it does have the word "guessing" in it:



What he means by "guessing" has nothing at all to do with luck.

Guessing has everything to do with luck, cuz.....YOU DONT REALLY KNOW WHAT YOU HAVE NO EXPERIENCE WITH.
 
I have read theories based on quantum entanglement that posit not only are they possible, but MUST exist (because of another theory - whose name escapes me...senior moment- that posits if something is possible it MUST occur).

Regarding quantum entanglement, see here. See also quantum woo. Please. :(
 
Guessing has everything to do with luck, cuz.....YOU DONT REALLY KNOW WHAT YOU HAVE NO EXPERIENCE WITH.

And that's why you have to use your mind to speculate on the logical implications of what you can see. Which is a completely different thing from speculating as to whether the next toss of a coin will come down heads or tails. Both can be called "guessing," but they're not the same thing, and only the second has to do with "luck," and the second is not what Dr. Calvin is talking about.
 
And that's why you have to use your mind to speculate on the logical implications of what you can see. Which is a completely different thing from speculating as to whether the next toss of a coin will come down heads or tails. Both can be called "guessing," but they're not the same thing, and only the second has to do with "luck," and the second is not what Dr. Calvin is talking about.

I dont know, I defied a few court orders in my time, and didnt go to jail. I wasnt confident the judge would wink at my contempt, I guessed and I got lucky.
 
Great military commanders have always been able to take the right course of action with incomplete and inadequate information.

With unlimited hindsight, it is easy to criticise an action taken in the heat of battle, but it is sometimes difficult to understand HOW the commander guessed so nearly right given what was known at the time.

People set up re-fighting Trafalgar, Waterloo, the D-Day Landings in Normandy, some of the US naval battles in the Pacific - and can lose many times.

For example, what if the US forces had known in advance that the Japanese were going to attack Pearl Harbor and had been prepared for that attack? The Japanese strike force would have been slaughtered. The Japanese commander risked everything on a guess that the US forces would be unprepared.
 
Great military commanders have always been able to take the right course of action with incomplete and inadequate information.

With unlimited hindsight, it is easy to criticise an action taken in the heat of battle, but it is sometimes difficult to understand HOW the commander guessed so nearly right given what was known at the time.

People set up re-fighting Trafalgar, Waterloo, the D-Day Landings in Normandy, some of the US naval battles in the Pacific - and can lose many times.

For example, what if the US forces had known in advance that the Japanese were going to attack Pearl Harbor and had been prepared for that attack? The Japanese strike force would have been slaughtered. The Japanese commander risked everything on a guess that the US forces would be unprepared.

One of your Brit historians (Hart) interviewed the surviving German generals, and they knew where D-Day was going to happen, because bombing and guerilla strikes identified the locations. But they couldnt convince Hitler to let them position their forces correctly.

Stalin signalled his invasion intentions to Hitler, and Hitler attacked first. Hell! Even the Poles planned to attack Chechoslovakia, to grab some territory, but Hitler divined it and hit first.
 
I dont know, I defied a few court orders in my time, and didnt go to jail. I wasnt confident the judge would wink at my contempt, I guessed and I got lucky.

And what's that got to do with this?

(Serious question. Think very carefully before you answer. Reread post #40.)
 
Last edited:
Great military commanders have always been able to take the right course of action with incomplete and inadequate information.

With unlimited hindsight, it is easy to criticise an action taken in the heat of battle, but it is sometimes difficult to understand HOW the commander guessed so nearly right given what was known at the time.

People set up re-fighting Trafalgar, Waterloo, the D-Day Landings in Normandy, some of the US naval battles in the Pacific - and can lose many times.

For example, what if the US forces had known in advance that the Japanese were going to attack Pearl Harbor and had been prepared for that attack? The Japanese strike force would have been slaughtered. The Japanese commander risked everything on a guess that the US forces would be unprepared.

Not coincidentally, in later Pacific battles, it was the Americans' overwhelming advantage in intelligence that helped determine the outcome. The Japanese continued to rely much more on guesswork, and were undermined by their own egos. The Americans worked much harder to determine exactly where to attack, and when.
 
I have read theories based on quantum entanglement that posit not only are they possible, but MUST exist (because of another theory - whose name escapes me...senior moment- that posits if something is possible it MUST occur).

Of course and this theory is based totally on two words; those words being "random and infinity". The theory is not true if the event is specified and in fact it may be untrue in toto, Remember, it is a theory not a law. It is a weak premis at best but it is something to hang your PhD on
 
The problem science runs into withproving or disproving psychic abilities is that there is no tangible way to prove or disprove the experience occured. One can only take said psychics word about what they see or feel etc. There is always room for interpritation. Its not unlike trying to prove their is a good.

Until we can record things like dreams, daydreams, thoughts, etc, we wont have a scientific break through on proof of such phenomenon.

We still cant prove or disprove ghosts exist, though we are trying. Perhaps in a couple hundred years we wilk start to figure it out...

Just for what its worth, I am sure others will feel the need to tell me I am wrong. Lol
 
The problem science runs into withproving or disproving psychic abilities is that there is no tangible way to prove or disprove the experience occured. One can only take said psychics word about what they see or feel etc.

But, the claims are not limited to subjective experiences. "Psychics" variously claim to be able to see into the future, to read the thoughts of others, to manipulate material objects with their minds through no perceptible material means, and these claims are falsifiable. Even a claim to be able to perceive another person's "aura" is falsifiable -- just place the person behind an opaque partition just above head-height; the psychic should be able to pinpoint that person's position by the aura projecting a foot or two beyond the skin -- but it's been tried, and they never can.
 
Last edited:
But, the claims are not limited to subjective experiences. "Psychics" variously claim to be able to see into the future, to read the thoughts of others, to manipulate material objects with their minds through no perceptible material means, and these claims are falsifiable. Even a claim to be able to perceive another person's "aura" is falsifiable -- just place the person behind an opaque partition just above head-height; the psychic should be able to pinpoint that person's position by the aura projecting a foot or two beyond the skin -- but it's been tried, and they never can.

As it stands right now psychic abilities still fall under spiritual practices. We assume the future is already set in stone so to speak if we try to prove future events with prophecy. Once a prophecy is spoken the future that may have been has been manipulated. If one sees the future a.d never speaks it then it could be a true event, but if never spoken it cant be proven or disproven.

Such things are directly linked to thoughts, and communication which is influenced by personal perception and free will.

Indeed if one cant see auras through opaque sheilds, then it may lend itself to prove that auras do indeed exist, and is not just figment of the imagination. Its the first step towards science being able to test such things, yet there is a long way to go. Its not impossible that science will help bridge some of the understandings of how it all works, but as of right now its not likely it will prove or disprove anything as a whole.

Infact its possible those looking to prove such things false, may indeed be the ones to prove its probable. We just barely scratched the surface on such things.

I am all for skepticism, when dealing with such matters. Most who claim to have such abilities are frauds, and looking for money, but I have had enough personal experiences to not discount the possibilities either. I would love for science to make some serious break throughs, but I am not expecting them in my life time.

Its not a tangible thing that can be measured, and much like the start of the thread, inteligence is the ability to guess correctly, so is said psychic ability. There is no true way to measure either, and so there will be no real conclusions either way, just good guesses.

We would have to weed out the frauds from those who are not, which in itself would be a difficult task. Mainly because those most apt to have such a gift, don't advertise that they do. Purely because they dont wish to be tested, and would rather just live life as a regular person.

Lol Its not quite as simple as most would think. So for now its catagorized in belief and faith, which needs a whole different approach than lab experiments. Studies of the brain and dreaming and other things of that nature may also be the forerunners for understanding, its too broad really.

Humans once thought the world was flat, so that you could fall off the edge of it. Becareful not to limit the possibilities. It stifels potential.

I heard once we are all born geniuses, we are taught to be dumb. Well, society and enviroment influence intelligence potential. Imagine if that were to be proven.
 
Back
Top