Intelligence Is Guessing Correctly

The problem science runs into withproving or disproving psychic abilities is that there is no tangible way to prove or disprove the experience occured. One can only take said psychics word about what they see or feel etc. There is always room for interpritation. Its not unlike trying to prove their is a good.

Until we can record things like dreams, daydreams, thoughts, etc, we wont have a scientific break through on proof of such phenomenon.

We still cant prove or disprove ghosts exist, though we are trying. Perhaps in a couple hundred years we wilk start to figure it out...

Just for what its worth, I am sure others will feel the need to tell me I am wrong. Lol

You can say the same about LOVE or a headache.
 
One of your Brit historians (Hart) interviewed the surviving German generals, and they knew where D-Day was going to happen, because bombing and guerilla strikes identified the locations. But they couldnt convince Hitler to let them position their forces correctly.

Stalin signalled his invasion intentions to Hitler, and Hitler attacked first. Hell! Even the Poles planned to attack Chechoslovakia, to grab some territory, but Hitler divined it and hit first.

I think those generals were using hindsight.

The bombing before D-Day was deliberately split equally between Pas De Calais and Normandy, as were the resistance attacks. Both aimed to reduce the Germans ability to manoeuvre in either area, and to hinder transfer of armour from one to the other.

Hitler's contribution was:

1. Not allowing armour reserves to be committed without his personal authority and then having a drugged sleep, and

2. Continuing to believe, for days after it was obviously wrong, that Normandy was a diversion for Patton's attack against Pas De Calais. Patton was given command of a phantom army based in East Anglia and Kent, apparently with larger forces than those committed to Normandy.

By that time, allied air supremacy had made transfer of armour to Normandy extremely costly and difficult.

Even if the local generals had realised beforehand that Normandy was the target, all their intelligence pointed to Pas De Calais. They would have had considerable inertia in their political/military system to overcome to get Normandy considered seriously. Even Rommel thought that the bad weather made any invasion anywhere in Northern France unlikely.
 
They guessed correctly in that regard, but failed in their assessment of American logistical capability. So what they gained through initial tactics was lost in the long run to superior logistics and tactics. The old saying that amateurs talk tactics and experts talk logistics, is quite true.

Some of the Japanese were well aware that they would lose a protracted war because they didn't have the industrial capacity or the raw materials.

But they hoped that a pre-emptive strike might lead to a peace with territorial gains for them in East Asia. Their mistake was attacking before the declaration of war was delivered. That had not been their intention. They meant to declare war in Washington just BEFORE striking Pearl Harbor.

The result was American fury, and a desire for revenge, sweeping away the isolationist movement.

As the Japanese Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto (1884-1943) said after Pearl Harbor:

"I fear we have only awakened a sleeping giant, and his reaction will be terrible."
 
. . . How?

Look, do you understand the concept of Occam's razor?

And the concept of falsifiability?

And why these things are important?

I know *I* do, but I also understand the importance of keeping an open mind and thinking outside the box.

I don't know the truth. Yet. But I have questions; many, many questions.

Paraphrasing, 'any technology sufficiently advanced would seem as magic'...I think that can also be applied to natural events that we have no knowledge of. Yet.
 
. . . How?

Look, do you understand the concept of Occam's razor?

And the concept of falsifiability?

And why these things are important?


Lol how? If those who claim to be able to see auras consistantly cant see them with an opaque sheild the question becomes why not? It leads to asking more questions, which inturn may eventually get us to ask the right questions, to explore further imto the subject.

Note I said may lend istelf to prove, its not stated as it will or will not.
 
Lol how? If those who claim to be able to see auras consistantly cant see them with an opaque sheild the question becomes why not?

Because a person with normal eyesight can't see anything through an opaque shield. You do understand the experiment here, which has actually been done? (I think I read about it in The Skeptical Inquirer, or one of James Randi's books.) The psychic claims to be able to see an aura radiating a foot or so out from your body. Fine, then if you stand behind a screen, through which the aura-seer cannot see your actual body, then, if the screen is not more than a foot higher than your head, the aura-seer still should be able to see your aura, projecting over the top of the screen, and should be able to pinpoint your physical position from that; but no purported aura-seer who has been so tested can do it. The most parsimonious (i.e., requiring fewest assumptions) explanation for that, and therefore the one to be preferred by Occam's razor, is that the "psychic" cannot actually see any aura, but is only imagining, or hallucinating, or simply dishonestly inventing that ability.

You do have a sort of aura that can be captured by Kirlian photography, but it is only an electric coronal discharge -- and that aura is not, BTW, limited to living things, therefore it is not life force or psychic energy or chi or kundalini or whatever you name the concept.
 
Last edited:
Not coincidentally, in later Pacific battles, it was the Americans' overwhelming advantage in intelligence that helped determine the outcome. The Japanese continued to rely much more on guesswork, and were undermined by their own egos. The Americans worked much harder to determine exactly where to attack, and when.

So: Decisions made based on actual intelligence/information are more likely to yield desired outcomes than decisions based on guessing. No surprise.

Seems to me the only advantage of guesswork in a military setting is that General A cannot anticipate General B's decisions if General B makes decisions by rolling dice, or the intuitive equivalent of that. But that's a very limited advantage.
 
Back
Top