Infrastructure spending vs. welfare programs

It's no worse an idea than letting people starve in the streets or die of easily preventable conditions.
 
It's no worse an idea than letting people starve in the streets or die of easily preventable conditions.

Roads aren't capable of providing for themselves. Individuals are supposed to be able to. You don't see the fundamental difference?
 
I'm a social-ist, not a socialist. I support a social society, where the greater good is paramount rather than providing things to individuals they should provide for themselves. That is what sets me apart from both liberals and libertarians / economic conservatives who don't want any government spending at all.

I used to call it social patriotism, but there's really no good agreed upon name for the philosophy. That's what holds it back politically. :mad:
 
Provide the framework where people can succeed, and then don't prop them up with giveaways if they don't make the effort. :cool:
 
What holds it back is that it's a poor philosophy unfit for the real world.

Why shouldn't people provide their own roads anyway?
 
They are in the sense that vehicle fuel taxes should be paying for them 100%.

I'm not even sure that would be a particularly good plan. I don't own an 18 wheeler but I bet that they do a lot more damage to the road than the difference between the amount of gas they use vs your average car.
 
They are in the sense that vehicle fuel taxes should be paying for them 100%.

Fuel taxes and other taxes being paid by vehicle owners and drivers pay for the building and upkeep of roads and bridges and similar costs.

The infrastructure option should eliminate some of the need for welfare, because it will provide jobs for some of those out of work. Not everybody, but a sizeable fraction.
 
and those would be.........

Child birth just off the top of my head. Various infections, bad case of the flu. I'm sure there's more if I wanted to look it up. Not eating gets pretty damn fatal rather quickly too.
 
The problem with the Social Patriotism philosophy is that its unpopular with both liberals and conservatives as well as libertarians. Yet, its actually the most normal and sensible philosophy. It was pretty much the mainstream philosophy at one time. That's probably why it doesn't even have an agreed upon name. :(
 
The problem with the Social Patriotism philosophy:(

Is that it is anti-social and unpatriotic.

A philosophy that says to let people die cannot be regarded as social.

An fomenting a revolution is unpatriotic. Those folks aren't just going to lay down and die because you think they should.

BALANCE is needed.
 
Which do you feel should get priority?

At what level?

Local, or national?

We have done both nationally, to no avail.

President Obama would actually like to undo some infrastructure so that he can move people out of the suburbs and into the cities in order to spend more on them in "services."

I would move both to the states and let the citizens of each state decide their own priorities.
 
The way to think about ALL government spending is like this: EVERY GODDAMNED DIME POSSIBLE WILL GO TO CHELSEA CLINTON BEFORE A PENNY IS SPENT ON ROADS, SCHOOLS, MILK, and OBAMAPHONES.
 
Back
Top