oggbashan
Dying Truth seeker
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2002
- Posts
- 56,017
I am listening to a CD of German Brass Band music, the sort of music that is played in Bavarian Beer Gardens in summer.
Some of my German friends would be horrified, because that sort of music is associated with their equivalent of unreconstructed rednecks, male chauvinists and has overtones of Aryan racial purity. To me, it is just a pleasant change from other forms of music.
Some songs and marches are banned in modern Germany because they are associated with the Hitler regime. I can sing the Horst Wessell Leid in England. No one would understand it. If I sung it in Germany I would be arrested, even if I sung my late uncle's parody that made fun of SA and SS men. The tune is enough...
English fans singing 'Ten German Bombers' during the World Cup were insulting the host country.
What would be the reaction in Southern Lebanon if I played Hava Nagila?
There are hymn tunes that aren't appropriate for weddings. 'Fight the Good Fight' is probably an unwise choice.
What would be your suggestion for music in an inappropriate place?
'Nelly the Elephant' at a Republican convention? Or would 'The Internationale' be worse?
Any offers?
Og
Some of my German friends would be horrified, because that sort of music is associated with their equivalent of unreconstructed rednecks, male chauvinists and has overtones of Aryan racial purity. To me, it is just a pleasant change from other forms of music.
Some songs and marches are banned in modern Germany because they are associated with the Hitler regime. I can sing the Horst Wessell Leid in England. No one would understand it. If I sung it in Germany I would be arrested, even if I sung my late uncle's parody that made fun of SA and SS men. The tune is enough...
English fans singing 'Ten German Bombers' during the World Cup were insulting the host country.
What would be the reaction in Southern Lebanon if I played Hava Nagila?
There are hymn tunes that aren't appropriate for weddings. 'Fight the Good Fight' is probably an unwise choice.
What would be your suggestion for music in an inappropriate place?
'Nelly the Elephant' at a Republican convention? Or would 'The Internationale' be worse?
Any offers?
Og