Immigration aargument

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
Premise:

"No nation with any substantial social safety net can survive an unregulated immigration policy, be the immigrants legal or illegal." - Ishmael
 
Survive is an exaggeration. Replace with, for instance, "fare well". Sounds resonable otherwise. Know of any nation with unregulated immigration, or anyone advocating it?

Also, unregulated illegal immigration is an oxymoron.
 
Nope most places do what Mexico does on there southern border shoot you.
 
Premise:

"No nation with any substantial social safety net can survive an unregulated immigration policy, be the immigrants legal or illegal." - Ishmael

In an Australian context this is a moot point - the news tonight tells of yet another boat load of potentially illegal immigrants sinking with substantial loss of life.

The resources we put into attempting to regulate the flow of boat people is huge..and makes for political point scoring without any solution in sight.
 
Premise:

"No nation with any substantial social safety net can survive an unregulated immigration policy, be the immigrants legal or illegal." - Ishmael

As Liar already pointed out, all nations that fulfill your criteria already regulate immigration and no serious political party proposes an immigration free for all.
Illegal immigration is by definition unregulated, but most nations do their best to control that too.

Migration is part of human spirit and evolution. USA would not exist in its current form without it.
 
The best minds and biggest hearts do not see the parallels to Rome when people do not immigrate their labor and adapt to the culture that created the need for it, but choose, instead to immigrate their culture, then one that created the need to emigrate.
 
Furthermore, as they allow in this cheap labor for the jobs that their own citizens will not do (because they pay too little) they fail to see how they depress wages and limit the opportunities for those of lesser faculty, yet they are quick to bemoan the loss of the middle class as if one has absolutely nothing to do with the other.
 
The UK under the last Labour Government came close to unregulated immigration. It was unregulated for people from within the expanded EU.

The result was hundreds of thousands of immigrants who wanted to work, would work hard, and outperformed many UK resident unemployed job applicants.

The consequence was and is relatively high youth unemployment. As ecomomic conditions began to worsen in the UK and improve in the new EU countries, many of the recent immigrants returned to their country of origin.

The UK survived, and will survive, the freedom of people to cross borders within the EU to seek work.

What is difficult is assimilation of large numbers of immigrants in a small area.

That would be equally true for mass migration within the UK. Many years ago I was given a project to move 27,000 people, all employees of the company and their immediate families, to 'somewhere' outside London. Although I found two or three places that could provide the housing, the sites for building our facilities, the transport infrastructure - nowhere could provide the school places, the university places, the recreation facilities etc that such a large addition to an area's population would need. That would take decades and we wanted to move everyone within an 18 month timescale.

Eventually my study showed that the project was not financially viable. The cost of the move outweighed any possible financial benefits even taking the best scenario for savings.

Yet now, that number of people could appear within a district in months, unplanned, unexpected, and the authorities have to try to cope. The strain on local resources affects not just the newcomers, but the existing population as well. If the newcomers have a different culture that adds something to the difficulties but the main problem remains the sheer numbers.

Just imagine taking a town in say Utah and moving everyone to New England. Or the other way around. The existing locals and the newcomers would take a generation or two to adjust to the new situation and they would all be US citizens.
 
The best minds and biggest hearts do not see the parallels to Rome when people do not immigrate their labor and adapt to the culture that created the need for it, but choose, instead to immigrate their culture, then one that created the need to emigrate.

lol. Rome. :roll eyes thing:
 
In an Australian context this is a moot point - the news tonight tells of yet another boat load of potentially illegal immigrants sinking with substantial loss of life.

The resources we put into attempting to regulate the flow of boat people is huge..and makes for political point scoring without any solution in sight.

It's heartbreaking. Look, I've watched documentary after documentary, and I still wonder if these people are really weighing up the outcome of their actions.

Jump on a boat and hope for the best... Is Indonesia in that much shit? Do they really have to gamble the lives of their children? Or is there something I don't know?
 
There's a shitload I don't know, but after all the events and loss of life...

I have to question.
 
In an Australian context this is a moot point - the news tonight tells of yet another boat load of potentially illegal immigrants sinking with substantial loss of life.

The resources we put into attempting to regulate the flow of boat people is huge..and makes for political point scoring without any solution in sight.

Are the illegal immigrants trying to get into or out of Australia?
 
Back
Top