I changed the category for the second part of my story. Will that affect anything?

Sai_dias_29

Experienced
Joined
Dec 24, 2019
Posts
76
Same as the title. I originally published my Awakening story as Incest/Taboo because there was incest in the story. Kind of. However, when I asked for feedback on the story, most people suggested that I should categorize it as sci-fi/fantasy because it also features elements of those genres. More-so than Incest. But I'm curious, will changing the category affect anything?
 
I've just been experimenting with exactly that question - I'm publishing High Life across multiple categories and if anything, it's getting more readership than if I'd have just stuck to one. YMMV, especially if you're coming out of high-traffic categories like I/T or LW into the relative backwaters....
 
I've published several series that have crossed categories. While some here would advise against it, I actually find it beneficial. As @oneagainst said, I find it encourages readers of both categories to notice it and come and read the first chapter.

Sure, sci-fi fans that don't like I/T will shun you (and may even 1-bomb you) but I think that risk is low, personally.
 
Same as the title. I originally published my Awakening story as Incest/Taboo because there was incest in the story. Kind of. However, when I asked for feedback on the story, most people suggested that I should categorize it as sci-fi/fantasy because it also features elements of those genres. More-so than Incest. But I'm curious, will changing the category affect anything?
Do you mean that you have a series, and you have a different category for the later chapters? That is sometimes hard to avoid. If you change a stand-alone story, probably no one is going to notice, because after the first ten days or so, people will have moved on. I had to change one because I accidentally put it in the wrong category. It took six days (pretty fast for Lit) to change it, but by then it had mostly been bypassed by readers.

Don't pick a category merely because it seems popular, unless you have a clear choice to make. No matter how popular Incest/Taboo is, I have yet to have a story that would fit there.
 
Don't pick a category merely because it seems popular, unless you have a clear choice to make. No matter how popular Incest/Taboo is, I have yet to have a story that would fit there.
My story has both incest, super power, and body swapping elements within it. So I wasn't sure how to categorise it. The first part had incest. Kind of. It was a body swap incest, not a "real" incest, and the second part doesn't have that at all. It mainly focuses on the power and side stories. Currently, for now at least, the incest aspect is not there. So I wasn't sure if it'd make sense to put it as Incest/Taboo.
 
My story has both incest, super power, and body swapping elements within it. So I wasn't sure how to categorise it. The first part had incest. Kind of. It was a body swap incest, not a "real" incest, and the second part doesn't have that at all. It mainly focuses on the power and side stories. Currently, for now at least, the incest aspect is not there. So I wasn't sure if it'd make sense to put it as Incest/Taboo.
But you haven't submitted it yet?

Lit does have these suggestions about picking a category.

https://classic.literotica.com/s/love-your-readers-categories

If it's too close to call, then just pick something and list the other story elements in the tags you create.
 
If Sci-Fi part is dominant and incest part only minor, then maybe switching to that category is a reasonable thing to do. The downside is that the number of views you will get in Sci-Fi is considerably lower than in I/T. I don't think either choice is bad, just use plenty of tags to describe your content. Good luck ;)
 
Same as the title. I originally published my Awakening story as Incest/Taboo because there was incest in the story. Kind of. However, when I asked for feedback on the story, most people suggested that I should categorize it as sci-fi/fantasy because it also features elements of those genres. More-so than Incest. But I'm curious, will changing the category affect anything?
I think there are too many variables in readers passing through to know what the affect of this is. I've done it both ways and haven't seen any comparative pattern in readership.
 
I've published several series that have crossed categories. While some here would advise against it, I actually find it beneficial.
That's something I've often done, and haven't heard a lot of readership squawk about it. In my story "The Yearbook Girl," the girl doesn't even get laid until the third chapter, so that chapter becomes "First Time." Everything else is either Exhibitionism (the first chapter) or Erotic Couplings. The only reason Erotic Couplings is used for the second chapter is that the MCs get down to some hot mutual masterbation, even though they don't take it all the way.

If there's an abrupt change in categories, I sometimes add a cautionary note at the start, telling the reader that this will be different from the last installment, so if they have any hot buttons about gay sex or group sex, they can refrain from reading the story.
 
That's something I've often done, and haven't heard a lot of readership squawk about it. In my story "The Yearbook Girl," the girl doesn't even get laid until the third chapter, so that chapter becomes "First Time." Everything else is either Exhibitionism (the first chapter) or Erotic Couplings. The only reason Erotic Couplings is used for the second chapter is that the MCs get down to some hot mutual masterbation, even though they don't take it all the way.

If there's an abrupt change in categories, I sometimes add a cautionary note at the start, telling the reader that this will be different from the last installment, so if they have any hot buttons about gay sex or group sex, they can refrain from reading the story.
Right. I have a series where part 1 is non-con, parts 2-7 are lesbian, and part 8 is romance. So M/F. I was more concerned about the 'sudden' swop from lesbian to M/F then I was about the non-con to lesbian, even though you'd have to be a complete dullard to have read the series and not expect some inevitable M/F. I flagged it at the top of the story, and have only received positive comments.

I have another series that also goes from non-con to romance, and again, no objections (at least from a category perspective... plenty of objections for other reasons!)
 
I don't category swap within a story, because I'm not convinced smorgasbord stories really help you. You're trying to appeal to everyone, all at the same time, which rarely works very well.

It's better, I think, to write separate stories, and zero in on the particular category kink. I reckon you get happier readers that way. Give them what they want, not the unexpected.

Or, don't worry about readers and their squicks, and just get on and write good stories. That's the best strategy, I've found.
 
I don't category swap within a story, because I'm not convinced smorgasbord stories really help you. You're trying to appeal to everyone, all at the same time, which rarely works very well.

It's better, I think, to write separate stories, and zero in on the particular category kink. I reckon you get happier readers that way. Give them what they want, not the unexpected.

Or, don't worry about readers and their squicks, and just get on and write good stories. That's the best strategy, I've found.
It's not about aiming for a 'smorgasboard', or trying to appeal to readers of different categories, but more about (at least in my case) writing a series in which the various chapters cover different things and thus get assigned to the appropriate category at the time I hit 'publish'. To take the example above, if I'd posted the whole thing as one chapter (all 90k+ words of it...) it wouldn't have fit in any category. It's got non-con, lesbian, and M/F in it.

But it's a story about a girl that explores her bi-sexuality while slowly falling for the MMC; that's the story I've written, and the story I set out to write. I wanted to write that story, so I have.

I received a comment yesterday that said, 'I was captivated from the start. This is indeed possibly the best example of erotica I have had the pleasure of reading. A most worthy tale.' And you know what? That single comment totally makes up for all the effort, all the 1-bombs, and the question of whether it's in the right category(yies).

Also my partner liked it :)
 
I received a comment yesterday that said, 'I was captivated from the start. This is indeed possibly the best example of erotica I have had the pleasure of reading. A most worthy tale.' And you know what? That single comment totally makes up for all the effort, all the 1-bombs, and the question of whether it's in the right category(yies).
Lol. I've received similar comments many times. One hopes they're not all from the same person! :).

Along the same lines, my favourite comments are variations on, "This is not the usual stuff we see around here, very refreshing."
 
We're talking about creative writing, so there are no hard and fast rules. Many things can work.

But, generally speaking, I think if you switch categories from chapter to chapter you will lose readers. Why? Because Literotica readership is Balkanized. Many readers like one thing, but not another. Plus, some categories get many more readers than others. If you start with chapter 1 in Incest, and then shift to chapter 2 in Sci Fi, you are guaranteed to lose many of your readers, because many of the incest readers of chapter 1 won't be interested in sci fi, or they'll be pissed if they don't get more incest.
 
Perhaps the more important issue here isn't what category(ies) you put chapters of divergent genre in as much as how well stories with significantly divergent categories from chapter to chapter go over with readers at all.
 
Really the only thing I think you have to gain is attention from a different and possibly larger audience by crossing genres. Ultimately if there are topics you feel might not mesh will with audiences on the whole, a small disclaimer at the start of the story is always helpful, as well as the added tags. I understand your pain though, I feel that if a story touches base on many different genres its hard to pick one...
The good news is if you change your mind and want them grouped under one category, it's only an Edit submission away.
 
The good news is if you change your mind and want them grouped under one category, it's only an Edit submission away.
Well, not necessarily. Laurel reserves the right of category placement and exercises that right. You can't necessarily change the category--or even determine it to begin with.
 
Well, not necessarily. Laurel reserves the right of category placement and exercises that right. You can't necessarily change the category--or even determine it to begin with.
I've personally moved my work from one category to another with no issues, but I suppose it'll depend on the individual work... I really never pegged Laurel as a stickler for overly controlling the author's creative preferences, but hey... maybe others haven't been so successful.
 
I've had her change the category choice. I'm pretty sure what I posted is correct--that she retains the right to categorize it and exercises that right. And I think I was correct that you couldn't just guarantee a chosen change by sending an edit. It's her call and she exercises the right to make it--and sometimes does. There's no reason users shouldn't know that.
 
I've personally moved my work from one category to another with no issues, but I suppose it'll depend on the individual work... I really never pegged Laurel as a stickler for overly controlling the author's creative preferences, but hey... maybe others haven't been so successful.
She'll occasionally change a story to a category where she thinks it will run better, and she will also allow incest outside the I&T category (contrary to a common belief that all incest is ring-fenced), provided you explain your reasons. She'll put an incest warning at the top of the story. She's not a category fanatic, unlike some readers.
 
She'll occasionally change a story to a category where she thinks it will run better, and she will also allow incest outside the I&T category (contrary to a common belief that all incest is ring-fenced), provided you explain your reasons. She'll put an incest warning at the top of the story. She's not a category fanatic, unlike some readers.
Definitely good to know.
 
Back
Top