Todd-'o'-Vision
Super xVirgin Man
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2002
- Posts
- 5,609
What are your thoughts on it?
LP.org
Law forcing schools to share student data with Selective Service should be scrapped, Libertarians say
WASHINGTON, DC -- A new law that requires public schools to turn over student information to military recruiters should be scrapped, Libertarians say, because educators shouldn't have to cooperate in sending their students off to get killed in senseless foreign wars.
"Apparently the government believes the three R's should stand for reading, writing – and recruiting," said George Getz, Libertarian Party communications director. "Schools are supposed to be supplying an education to their students, not supplying their students to the armed forces."
A little-noticed amendment to the elementary and secondary education funding bill signed earlier this year by President Bush requires public high schools to turn over students' names, addresses, and telephone numbers to military recruiters. The measure, which has already sparked opposition in New York and other cities, is designed to help the Selective Service track down 18-year-old males who have neglected to register for the draft as required by federal law.
But Libertarians say the government has no business deputizing
school administrators to act as agents for the Selective Service.
"The fact that some students fail to comply with a federal regulation shouldn't obligate schools to violate the privacy of all students," Getz said. "The Selective Service should have no more right to demand student records without a warrant than does the IRS, the DEA, or any other government agency.
"Besides, teachers' first obligation should be to educate and protect their students, not make it easier for the government to launch another Vietnam-style draft."
The law was prompted by complaints by the Selective Service that compliance with draft registration has been falling, and has plunged to 49 percent in some urban areas like New York, Getz noted.
"Americans should think about why so many youths are refusing to register," he said. "Maybe they've learned that the draft has been used as a tool to wage senseless wars that the public rightly opposed, such as Vietnam and Korea. Maybe inner-city students are especially aware that while governments launch wars, minorities always seem to end up leading the charge into battle.
"And how can students fail to notice that presidents have a habit of sending Americans to fight in places totally unrelated to U.S. national security, like Bosnia, Haiti, Panama, Somalia, Lebanon, and Iraq?
"No wonder so many students are reluctant to register: They don't want to die defending someone else's country."
History shows that a draft has never been needed to defend the USA, Libertarians note.
"Anytime this nation was actually attacked, as it was at Pearl
Harbor and on September 11, Americans rushed to volunteer for military service," Getz said. "It's only when U.S. national security is not at stake that politicians turn to coercion and conscription.
"If the government wants to ensure that Americans will always be eager to defend their country, it doesn't have to turn teachers into informants for the Selective Service. All it has to do is adopt a truly defensive foreign policy of neutrality and non-intervention."