Human popsickles

I work in Chicago and I know for a fact there are places to go to keep warm get meals and sleep and if you call them they will even pick you up and take you there.
 
teddybear4play said:
It is necessary for the maligners of the capitalist system to malign and scapegoat the system itself, in order to avoid acknowledging that they're just really fuckin' stupid.

TB4p

As opposed to what? An alternative system which uses human resources like so many blips on a screen only to spit them out when their usefulness is over?

Capitalism only works for the capitalists...

Unfortunately most of us aren't rich enough to be one...

So we suffer...

ppman
 
p_p_man said:
As opposed to what? An alternative system which uses human resources like so many blips on a screen only to spit them out when their usefulness is over?
Wait, what system were you describing again?

p_p_man said:
Capitalism only works for the capitalists...

Unfortunately most of us aren't rich enough to be one...

So we suffer...
And socialism works for nobody.

Define "work." The socialist's view of capitalism is that you either get rich or get fucked. Well, it doesn't always work that way. A lot of people are perfectly happy with a decent job, and decent money, and a decent house, and a decent life. Nobody promised we'd all live like kings.

TB4p
 
p_p_man said:
As opposed to what? An alternative system which uses human resources like so many blips on a screen only to spit them out when their usefulness is over?

Capitalism only works for the capitalists...

Unfortunately most of us aren't rich enough to be one...

So we suffer...

ppman

You don't have to be rich to be a capitalist, all you've got to do is get a job, live within your means, and be productive. That doesn't sound too hard, does it?
Hell, if you show more than a little bit of smarts and ambition, you'll even get a promotion — without having to toe the communist party line.
Now, with all the concern expressed by the mush-leftists on this thread, I've gotta ask: What have you done for the homeless lately?
I don't pretend to be an expert on all things European, but I do know that a lot of people there are pissed because they don't get to keep very much of what they earn because of the high tax rates. Who is greedy here — the government for taking more and more for more and more social programs, or the people who actually work and produce something and want to keep more of the money they earned?
It sounds to me like those socialist countries are using people (and their earnings) like so many blips on a screen.
 
There have always been poverty-stricken, homeless, unfortunate, wretched people. Always have been, and always will be. "Systems" have squat to do with it. It's human nature.
 
phrodeau said:
There have always been poverty-stricken, homeless, unfortunate, wretched people. Always have been, and always will be. "Systems" have squat to do with it. It's human nature.


Well said.
Think it will sink in?
Nah.
 
Last refuge of reactionaries: "human nature"

phrodeau said:
There have always been poverty-stricken, homeless, unfortunate, wretched people. Always have been, and always will be. "Systems" have squat to do with it. It's human nature.

Thank you, phrodeau, for succintly stating the ultimate fall-back position of all reactionaries (all those who seek to turn the clock back, rather than moving forward). Their last intellectual refuge is to blame "human nature" for the faults of the archaic and outmoded system they defend. Never mind that this is merely blaming the victims on a philosophical scale, blaming everyone for the faults of a system designed by, and constructed for the benefit of, a tiny few (the rich). More fundamentally, it is a metaphysical concept, ultimately derived from the Christian concept of "original sin." It falsely posits a static, eternal, unchanging "essence" in humanity. In fact, human beings are almost infinitely variegated, and constantly changing and evolving, both individually and as a whole. There is no such thing as "human nature," merely human behavior, which is incredibly diverse. In a capitalist society, of course many people will be greedy and selfish: capitalism promotes and encourages greed and selfishness, even demands it. Even if you don't want to, you have to be somewhat materialistic just to survive in capitalist society. And in order to "get ahead," you have to be totally greedy, duplicitous, and amoral.

By contrast, in a socialist society, where values of cooperation, sharing, and community are emphasized and promoted-- values which most people find inherently congenial to begin with-- such traits will quickly become almost universal.
:heart:
 
Re: Last refuge of reactionaries: "human nature"

REDWAVE said:
By contrast, in a socialist society, where values of cooperation, sharing, and community are emphasized and promoted-- values which most people find inherently congenial to begin with-- such traits will quickly become almost universal.
:heart:

Oh absolutely. Look at the working examples we have had. Stalinist Russia. Maoist China. Khmer Rouge Cambodia. It almost makes me delirious with desire to have it on a world wide basis.
 
teddybear4play said:
The socialist's view of capitalism is that you either get rich or get fucked. Well, it doesn't always work that way. A lot of people are perfectly happy with a decent job, and decent money, and a decent house, and a decent life.
TB4p

Until you're out on your ear, your pension either vanished or vanishing and not much help from the State...

First to go is the furniture, then the house, then the wife...

At least Socialism will give you a helping hand whilst getting back on your feet.

I can never understand normal, hard working folk like you describe ever voting for the Right. They must follow the sounds of the drum or something...

ppman
 
That's the best you can do?

RosevilleCAguy said:
Oh absolutely. Look at the working examples we have had. Stalinist Russia. Maoist China. Khmer Rouge Cambodia. It almost makes me delirious with desire to have it on a world wide basis.

I've said many times I'm a Trotskyist, not a Stalinist, and I not only don't hold those societies up as models, but in fact call for workers and peasants in the remaining Stalinistic regimes to overthrow them, and establish genuine socialism. And I know you've read enough of me to know that. Still all you can do is trot out this lame bullshit about Stalinism. I'll say it again: Stalinism was a gross betrayal and perversion of genuine Communism, which is a doctrine of liberation of the working class world-wide. Stalin murdered all the original old Bolsheviks, the true Communists, except Kollontai. The rise of the Stalinist bureaucracy in the Soviet Union was due to deformations of Soviet society caused by the implacable antagonism and unrelenting warfare (both economic and of the shotting variety) of the capitalist nations, including the U.S.
 
Re: That's the best you can do?

Still waiting for an example of true, pure socialism that actually works.
 
Still waiting for an example of true, pure capitalism that really works.

Pre-1929 America, perchance?
 
Re: That's the best you can do?

REDWAVE said:
I've said many times I'm a Trotskyist, not a Stalinist, and I not only don't hold those societies up as models, but in fact call for workers and peasants in the remaining Stalinistic regimes to overthrow them, and establish genuine socialism. And I know you've read enough of me to know that. Still all you can do is trot out this lame bullshit about Stalinism. I'll say it again: Stalinism was a gross betrayal and perversion of genuine Communism, which is a doctrine of liberation of the working class world-wide. Stalin murdered all the original old Bolsheviks, the true Communists, except Kollontai. The rise of the Stalinist bureaucracy in the Soviet Union was due to deformations of Soviet society caused by the implacable antagonism and unrelenting warfare (both economic and of the shotting variety) of the capitalist nations, including the U.S.

Redwave,

The basic flaw with the whole revolutionary THEORY is that it has a remarkable proclivity to be hijacked by the Stalins of the world.

Is it possible that the unrelenting warfare in Russia was originally due to the fact that the Soviets essentially hijacked what was a pacifist revolution by the Russian People, plunging the country into a horrendous civil war?

how about the Soviet Invasion of Poland in 1920? No doubt induced by the reactionary west. Or maybe it was Stalin's fault....DOH....Lenin was still in power then....silly me.
 
P.C. and REDWAVE. I have a solution for you.


Its called ROSEVILLECAGUYISM. It's pure SOCIALISTCAPITALISM at its finest.

Just put me in power and I will show you how it works.


Trust me.


Really.
 
Re: Re: That's the best you can do?

RosevilleCAguy said:
Redwave,

The basic flaw with the whole revolutionary THEORY is that it has a remarkable proclivity to be hijacked by the Stalins of the world.

Is it possible that the unrelenting warfare in Russia was originally due to the fact that the Soviets essentially hijacked what was a pacifist revolution by the Russian People, plunging the country into a horrendous civil war?

how about the Soviet Invasion of Poland in 1920? No doubt induced by the reactionary west. Or maybe it was Stalin's fault....DOH....Lenin was still in power then....silly me.

Paragraph by paragraph:

(1) No. Stalin was able to usurp power and betray the revolution because of the weakness, isolation and backwardness of the early Soviet Union, which had just been devastated by WW1; the failure of the revolution in western Europe, especially Germany, where Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht were murdered by the German government (with the collusion of the SPD), in order to decapitate the revolutionary movement.

(2) That's a complete distortion of Russian revolutionary history. The Bolsheviks did not hijack the Revolution; they completed it. It was the Mensheviks and SR's who betrayed the February Revolution by handing power back to the capitalists and landlords, and by accepting high level positions (ministries) in the bourgeois Provisional Government. By contrast, Lenin called for "All power to the soviets!" (workers councils), even at a time when Mensheviks had a majority in the soviets. Also, the February Revolution was not "pacifist," but a chaotic, spontaneous overthrow of the Czar by masses of St. Petersburg workers. The Russian Civil War was caused by the machinations of fourteen capitalist countries, including the U.S., which intervened militarily, and furnished arms, money, and supplies to the counterrevolutionary Whites, in order to try to destroy the Soviet workers state. As Churchill so memorably put it, the goal of the entire capitalist world was "to strangle this infant in the cradle."


(3) The Soviet "invasion" of Poland in 1920, as you call it, was in fact an attempt to liberate the Poles from the fascistic dictatorship of Pilsudski, and to make direct contact with Germany, so the fledgling Soviet Union could give assistance to the revolutionary movement there.
 
Circular reasoning

The reactionaries who scream "Socialism has never worked!" conveniently fail to mention that whenever socialism has been attempted, the capitalists have gone to great lengths to attack and destroy it, and make sure it doesn't work. From the bloody suppression of the Paris Commune of 1871, to the unrelenting attacks upon the Soviet Union, Red China, North Vietnam, Cuba, etc., to the CIA machinations against Hugo Chavez going on today, this has always been true. Then, once they succeed in murdering socialism, they crow "See! I told you it wouldn't work!"
:p
 
Who attacked Jamestown colony?

Socialism didn't work in the pure format of the new world.

Even the fawking Indians had a no work no eat code...
 
Was that the Soviet Union that formed an alliance with Hitler?

Or the Soviet Union that relied on America to free it to resume it's tryranny?
 
SINthysist said:
How come EVERYONE wanted to keep liberating Poland?
so my father in law would have a reason to go back and never come by the house again....

sue me, I was being selfish. I wanted his Polish sausage back in his motherland
 
I don't believe the CIA is machinating against Chavez because Don hasn't been talking about it and he knows ALL the CIA sekrets...
 
brokenbrainwave said:
so my father in law would have a reason to go back and never come by the house again....

sue me, I was being selfish. I wanted his Polish sausage back in his motherland

Oh, it was personal then...

:D
 
SINthysist said:
Who attacked Jamestown colony?

Socialism didn't work in the pure format of the new world.

Even the fawking Indians had a no work no eat code...

That's got to be one of the most unjust, unproductive and evil systems of all.

And yet you hold it up as a shining example of how society should work.

Sorry SIN you can't work since you busted your leg by falling off the barn roof...

starve you bastard starve...

ppman
 
Back
Top