How do you define literate?

they're's literate, WH, and then theirs literate ;)


One of the interesting, more serious things I firmly believe is that there are many people who are completely at home with the spoken language in this country who for a variety of reasons come off looking much less literate when they are writing/typing. It is easy for a person who judges them on that basis to under-estimate their mental capacity, and virtually all who make that error similarly foul up determinations about worth, as well. They miss a lot.
 
When I was a freshman in college I was amazed to see how many people in English 101 could not put together a simple research paper.

They knew nothing about a thesis statement or a closing. They did not know how to include footnotes. Concepts like verbs and nouns seemed to stump them. They didn't know where to place commas or apostrophes. Run ons and sentence fragments were common. And these were high school graduates!

The thing that really shocked me was that I didn't encounter this sort of thing until I reached college which made me wonder what kind of schools these people were coming from. I always attended predominately black, inner-city educational facilities and that sort of ignorance was never tolerated there. My college professors though I was brilliant but compared to my high school classmates my english skills were only slightly above average.

A friend of mine has suggested that computers are to blame for much of the ignorance being displayed by our young people. Spellcheckers and grammar checkers prevent the average student from learning how to correctly compose a paper by himself. Like learning math while always using a calculator. Feasable?
 
medjay said:
When I was a freshman in college I was amazed to see how many people in English 101 could not put together a simple research paper.

But were they "literate" in the sense of being able to function in society?

Me, from an earlier post in this thread:

I do think I created more confusion than necessary by choosing the word "Literate" for this discussion, but I still can't think of a word that covers the aspects of "educated" that I wanted to include.

"Educated" carries implications of "higher education" to many people, and that's well above the ignorant/not ignorant line I'm looking for.

"Ignorant" in turn skews things towards discussions of "common sense" and how uncommon it is.

"Functional" includes skills and aptitudes that can't be taught or quantified, so that doesn't quite work either.

"Graduate" covers too much and not enough. I've known droputs who were "literate" (in the inaccurate sense I've been using the word) and known "graduates" who were both ignorant and uneducated.

The freshman you cite are not prepared for college, but if you met them on the street would you tag them as "ignorant" or "illiterate" or otherwise recognise their literary failings?
 
Weird Harold said:


But were they "literate" in the sense of being able to function in society?

The freshman you cite are not prepared for college, but if you met them on the street would you tag them as "ignorant" or "illiterate" or otherwise recognise their literary failings?

I'm sure they are quite able to function. I remember reading somewhere that the average American reads at a sixth grade level (correct me if I'm wrong on this). No it doesn't make them illiterate and if I did meet them on the street I would have no way to judge that.

It's just that encountering it at an institute of "higher learning" came as a shock to the system for me because reading and writing skills were stressed so seriously as I was growing up. I never imagined that people all over the country weren't receiving the same quality of education I was.
 
medjay said:


I'm sure they are quite able to function. I remember reading somewhere that the average American reads at a sixth grade level (correct me if I'm wrong on this). No it doesn't make them illiterate and if I did meet them on the street I would have no way to judge that.

It's just that encountering it at an institute of "higher learning" came as a shock to the system for me because reading and writing skills were stressed so seriously as I was growing up. I never imagined that people all over the country weren't receiving the same quality of education I was.

I don't know what the actual average reading level is, but I've been taught to write to a seventh grade level for a general audience -- That's the USAF's standard assumption of average reading level, but it's the only definitive standard I've had contact with.

"people all over the country weren't receiving the same quality of education I was." -- is the reason for discussing this question. Before a standardized test can be applied nation-wide to determine if students are reaching a minimum level of education or "literacy" then we have to define what a minimum education should cover.

I don't think there will ever be a way to truly homogenize education on a national basis, but there are certainly needs to be some effort to close the gaps.
 
I graduated from high school in the mid 60's and "literate" was inferred by the minimum graduation requirements.

English - an understanding of the elements of sentence structure and the ability to write understandably with the correct format, business letters, personal letters, and letters of application for employment. Also included was a half year of public speaking.

Math - the ability to add, subtract, multiply, divide and figure percentages. (these skills let one balance a checkbook and figure income taxes)

History - a passing grade on a test of the state and US constitution.

Science - one class of general science which encompassed rudimentary biology, chemistry, physics, and astronomy.

These were minimum requirements, and most students exceeded them.

After putting three kids through school, and after having taught (a long time ago) at the high school and junior college level, I find it difficult to fault this definition. These minimum skills will allow most adults to function in society, and to have enough understanding of the political and physical world to stay with the world as it changes.

There would be no problem with minimum competency tests if they were considered that, but the school systems in my area seem to be in competetion for the highest scores. Funding is partially based on the standardized test scores as are teachers' performance appraisals. The schools begin earlier each year to give teachers time to cram the test material into their students before the day of the test.

I would submit that "mimimum" should mean different things for different students. Some students will have achieved a great milestone when they pass one of the current standardized tests. Others will pass the same test without interrupting their thoughts from what they would rather be doing.

I have worked in industry for the last 28 years, and have seen a steady degredation in the writing and speaking skills of young professionals. All have degrees, but some of them are nearly functionally illiterate relative to the requirements of the job. Not only can they not spell, but they don't even set the spellchecker to prompt them for changes. They let it correct their errors as they type. In case you haven't tried it, if you type in "commonize", a word used frequently in industry for the action of making things common, Word will change it to "communize". Customers have gotten correspondence that states we are "communizing" their parts. Forget about correct usage of "their" and "there", "an" and "and" and other common grammatical and typographical errors. They don't understand syntax and often write in incomplete sentences.

I don't buy the excuse that computers are the cause of the problem. It is true that computers will gladly help you appear to be illiterate, but they only reflect their input. I got a business email the other day and the author used "ppl" instead of people. The computer did not cause this. I am also starting to see "lol" in internal business emails. Perhaps this is laziness, but to customers, it appears as unprofessional as using "was" instead of "were".

For many of them, the Vietnam war is something their father's talk about, and anything before that is pretty hazy. The Civil War and The Great Depression are things they see in movies. How can they hope to lead this country and business (the US in my case) if they don't understand the historical events that formed the present?

It is reasonable to expect an individual with a college diploma to have a greater command of his/her native language and of history than one without. This is not to say that a mortarboard is a magical crown that conveys greater intelligence upon it's wearer. There is a huge difference between literacy and intelligence. If society deems it necessary to evaluate the public school system with standardized testing, it should also require standardized "literacy" testing for college graduates that is commensurate with their years of education and the expectations of their future employers.

WH, this rant may be tangential to your original question, I felt most of the discussions were aimed at the public school systems when the question of literacy has a broader scope in today's world.
 
Originally posted by Problem Child
Ally and Harold are obviously very well educated, or at least naturally smart as hell.

My question is, why is this so tough?

What is so hard about coming up with basic minimum standards for learning and then writing a fair test to evaluate a students level of knowledge? . . .

I don't think the things people really need to know in order to have a basic understanding of how the world works really changes all that much. The only thing getting in the way of kids learning is the politics of teaching.
You know, the funny part of this whole discussion is that everything that is pointed out here as a potential improvement can be solved very simply. Give parents the choice as to where to educate their children. Give them school vouchers and make the public school system compete in a free marketplace and you'll se dramatic improvements in education gained from all sources, public and private.

Politicians are loath to actually solve the problem because too many of them are too accustomed to feeding at the public trough and will not do anything however beneficial if it threatens their perpetuation in office.
Originally posted by Mischka
I'm afraid it isn't that simple, PC. I volunteered at an elementary school for a year, teaching math to two fifth graders. . .
You're citing a case that is hardly the norm. These kinds of things occur but even if you take the phenomenal stretch and say it's 10%, that still doesn't explain the remaining 90%.
Originally posted by Mischka
Do you propose increasing the budget along with this suggestion? . . .
Funding is hardly the issue. Get rid of the layers of administration imposed by all the Federal bureaucracy and return to an efficient administrative system and your budget problem is non-existent.

I graduated from a high school with a student population of about 1,800 students and the entire admin staff was about 20-25. Add another 10-15 for the cafeteria and 30-50 people took care of the "running the school" functions. The teachers were responsible for teaching and testing.

And typically, the schools with the highest budgets (greatest dollar/student ratio) produce the poorest reasults further pointing to the invalidity of the claim that we don't spend enough money. We spend too much and too poorly manage what is spent so much of it is wasted.

I'll offer some thoughts, WH.
Originally posted by Weird Harold
Are Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry, and Logorithms, "basic math skills" or are they "advanced mathematics". Do we stop at the equivalent of a four function calculator, or is there more to "basic math skills" than Arithmetic?
Basic math skills involve arithmetic to the extent of multiplying and dividing multidigit numbers, being able to make change without a register or calculator and perform most aritmetic without a calculator. This includes know the precedence of operators in complex arithmetic problems involving add/subtract/multiply/divide combinations. Perhaps even some introductory algebra. I'd even consider including the ability to derive a square root with paper and pencil.

In response to your later post, I'd also include fractions, ratio and proportions, percentages and basic exponentiation in the basic math skills.

The other math (geometry, trig, logs) you note is definitely advanced math and should be standard fare for anyone bound for post secondary education. I would also include factorials and permutations and combinations in the advanced math realm.
Originally posted by Weird Harold
Is teaching "how to learn" as important as teaching mere facts? Can "how to learn" even be assessed quantitatively? Does it need to be?
The basis of learning at the outset is learning facts. In order to increase one's knowledge, however, it is imperative that one learn to think. If you teach someone how to think rationally and objectively in an organized manner, to apply reason, then you have adequately equipped them to learn.

If they lack the ability to think coherently, learning is going to be very difficult.
Originally posted by Weird Harold
Which is more basic to reading: Vocabulary or sentence structure?
I'd give vocabulary a bit of an edge here. If you know the meaning of the words, you can perhaps glean the meaning from the context if you've learned to think coherently. If you don't know what the words mean, you can't learn anything from all the reading in the world.
Originally posted by Weird Harold
What is more basic to writing: Penmanship or grammar?
Grammar absolutely! Penmanship is to communication what paint is to making your automobile run. Penmanship can be cured by a typewriter (word processor), voice recognition software, etc. Grammar can't for the most part though some software does take a stab at it. The greatest difficulty there is that the English language permits such complexity of structure that to create a program to analyze it effectively is extremely difficult. I use MS Word '97 with the grammar and spell check enabled to evaluate as I type. Most of the spelling suggestions I accept; most of the gramamr suggestions I reject because they're not valid in the context of my writing.
Originally posted by Siren
But isnt this an awful lot of words for some of the semi-literates to be able to read and grasp?

I mean it is about them that we are all talking about isnt it?

Carry on......... ;)
To borrow a quote from an old Navy acquaintance, "We're talking about them, not to them. There's no necessity for them to respond." :D

And if they're literate enough to contribute to the discussion, then it's probably not them about whom we discourse, now is it, dearie?
Originally posted by Weird Harold
. . . If the "story" that frames the problem deals with planning a debutante ball, many people who aren't rich and/or well read will get lost in the unfamiliar terms and lose track of the math problem. . . .
This is precisly why critical thinking skills are important. They can eliminate much of this "cultural bias" nonsense.
Originally posted by Weird Harold
. . . . Nit-pickers who oppose testing for whatever reason pick at every straw they can dream up and apply every PC silliness they can manufacture to obstruct any rational standard. . . .
Tests have an objective: screening for a particular result. The result is determined by the criteria set. Construct the best possible test to evaluate the requisite skills and/or knowledge of the applicants and ignore the idiot nitpickers who are not contributing to the solution but rather seek to be part of the problem they wish to perpetuate.
Originally posted by rambling man
Standardized testing also reduces teacher creativity because of pressure to teach to the test. . .
I ran into this idea of "teaching the test" in the Navy schools where I taught on two different tours. There were some instructors whose ability was such that they would literally teach "40 well known facts" to get their class to pass the test. Fortunately, these particular people were rare. Also they were not particularly well thought of nor did they serve their students well.

The fact is, there are learning objectives which identify the knowledge factors to be taught. Guess what? The questions on the tests check the students' knowledge of these objectives! So if you teach to the objectives, you teach the test, albeit not literally "the test".
 
ronde said:
I graduated from high school in the mid 60's and "literate" was inferred by the minimum graduation requirements.
...
WH, this rant may be tangential to your original question, I felt most of the discussions were aimed at the public school systems when the question of literacy has a broader scope in today's world.

Not really tangental at all. As a graduate from high school in 1968, I agree with almost everything you say.

This discussion was started as a way to narrow the discussion of "our schools have gone to hell" down to some specific points that need to be addressed. As such, it cna't help but be an indictment of "public schools" which are the largest percentage of "our educational system." Not all private and parochial schools can escape censure, but they do, in general, represent the top end of the educational system.
 
Unclebill said:
The fact is, there are learning objectives which identify the knowledge factors to be taught. Guess what? The questions on the tests check the students' knowledge of these objectives! So if you teach to the objectives, you teach the test, albeit not literally "the test".

All good thoughts UB. I would add one other comment about military tech schools -- They somehow seem to cram a whole year's worth of learning into a six-week course without any noticeable loss of long term learning.

Could the latest "cure" being suggested -- longer school days and longer school years -- be an indication that administration and required repitition be wasting too much of a teacher's time?
 
Originally posted by Weird Harold
All good thoughts UB. I would add one other comment about military tech schools -- They somehow seem to cram a whole year's worth of learning into a six-week course without any noticeable loss of long term learning.
One of my students told me I taught in six weeks everything about basic electricity he had covered in his first semester of college.

The military only has a guy for 4-6 years. They can't afford to waste 3-4 of that teaching him a system to have him then soon leave the service. Just not cost effective.

I taught a pretty complex radar system and the entire course was 28 weeks. We covered a lot of material and covered it very fast. I was amazed that we achieved the retention we did.
Originally posted by Weird Harold
Could the latest "cure" being suggested -- longer school days and longer school years -- be an indication that administration and required repitition be wasting too much of a teacher's time?
I think the problem is too much time is wasted o the "social indoctrination" and "social engineering" crap and administration. Teachers' admin should be kept to a minimum. Taking attendance, grading tests and homework and assigning grades and supplemental evaluations if necessary should be the limits of what they are required administratively.

Get the useless shit off their backs and they could actually teach the core curriculum material the students need, like reading, speling arithmetic, grammar, etc. And if there's a discipline problem, eject the cause of the problem to eliminate the disruption for those who wish to learn.
 
This is one of the more interesting, informed, and intelligent discussions I've seen on the GB in awhile. Thanks, WH, for kicking it off and bringing it back.

There are too many response-worthy posts here for me to review, so I'll just toss out a couple of general considerations that I do not think have been raised yet.

First of all, "literacy" is the state or quality of being literate--i.e., having the ability to read and write. Consequently, knowledge of math, science, geography, and so forth are, strictly speaking, irrelevant to the question of literacy.

While it is true that some scholars and pundits have been tossing around terms like "cultural literacy" and "media literacy" in the last 20 years, and while I have used them myself on occasion, they are bastard terms that do more harm than good, in my opinion. Why? Because the state or quality of being "cultured" has no necessary relation to the state or quality of being "literate"; because the ability to use electronic communication technologies effectively is quite different from the ability to read and write effectively.

At any rate, I believe that the goal of public education back in the 18th and 19th centuries was to help foster the Jeffersonian ideal of an informed citizenry. Give the people the information they need to make a decision, and trust them to be able to render a prudent decision. In order to contribute to the democratic enterprise, citizens needed to know how to read and write, and, more importantly, to listen to and give speeches, since the newspapers and the pulpits and the platforms were the main arenas for the dissemination of information and the exchange of ideas. By the end of the 19th century, the importance of speech had declined while the importance of the printed word had increased.

One of the reasons it is so difficult to set or measure a standard of literacy today is owing to the influence of so-called mass communication. How necessary is it, really, for an "informed citizen" to be able to read the newspaper? We assume, as a matter of course (as some of you have done in this thread), that any moderately educated person in this country ought to be able to read an English-language newspaper. Why? Newspapers are mainly outlets for advertising, not news or information--a simple content analysis will show you that. If literacy skills are declining--a presumption of which I am highly skeptical--perhaps it is because they are becoming less important in the ordinary, day-to-day lives of many citizens.

The effects of the newer and converging communication technologies are only now being felt, and because they are so new, we cannot grasp what they will do to us, in terms of shaping what knowledge and skills we'll need to live--not in a literate world, but in a post-literate world.
 
I'm breaking my new rule by responding before I finish the thread, but, godammit, this is a long thread, and I want to respond to this:


KillerMuffin said:
The minimum standard for education? I think we're all making this far too difficult.

A person ought to be able to read well enough in the predominant language to understand the content, if not all of the ramifications, in the newspaper.

A person ought to be able to do enough math that if their calculator broke when you're standing in their line at the cash register, you don't have to figure out your own change.

A person ought to know enough about society and government to recognize the importance of participating in that society and government as well recognizing that there is cultural differences.

A person ought to know enough about auto mechanics to pump their own gas, check their own oil, put on the spare tire, and recognize when the car should be maintained.

A person ought to know enough about science to realize that chemicals should be treated with respect, stuff falls when you drop it for a reason, and that when you're sick, you go to the doctor.

We call them MINIMUM standards for a reason. Some people DO NOT care to be educated. They'd rather subsist down at the bottom of the socio-economic food chain. Someone has to manage McDonalds and swab the deck.

None of the minimum standards to get by in today's society should have anything to do with cultural bias. How can you culturally bias math and basic reading? English is English. Addition and subtraction is addition and subtraction. When it comes to MINIMUM standards of education for a person to subsist in this world, you're talking about a cultural bias already. These people are from all cultures and share one thing in common, poverty.

If you want to raise the standards, to give them a stronger education and a better future, then you can get into cultural biases. This is where things like history and creativity come into play. Face it, the minimum standard does not equate with the ideal minimum standard.

I don't go to the doctor when I'm sick: I hate doctors. They don't do shit for you, anyway. Also, I have to say: I don't recognize the importance of participating in government; in fact, I view voting as basically an otherwise irrelevant ritual designed to fool the masses into thinking they have more of a say in government than they do.

Do I fail your classes? Do you hold me back until I learn these things?

Also: managing a McDonald's is no easy thing, and my understanding is a manager can make a decent living doing what he does. About as good as teachers I believe. And you know, don't you, that Bill Gates was a college drop-out?

If I'd ever had to take a class on changing tires, or pumping gas, I doubt I'd have made it through school myself.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
First of all, "literacy" is the state or quality of being literate--i.e., having the ability to read and write. Consequently, knowledge of math, science, geography, and so forth are, strictly speaking, irrelevant to the question of literacy.

At any rate, I believe that the goal of public education back in the 18th and 19th centuries was to help foster the Jeffersonian ideal of an informed citizenry. ...

How necessary is it, really, for an "informed citizen" to be able to read the newspaper? ... Why? Newspapers are mainly outlets for advertising, not news or information--a simple content analysis will show you that. ...

knowledge and skills we'll need to live--not in a literate world, but in a post-literate world.

First, as I've explained several times in this thread, I meant the term "literate" in it's bastartdized form as a synonym for "adequately educated" rather than it's literal definition. It's more a question of "what is the minimum schools should teach."

You make a very good point about the probable goal of 18th &19th century schooling. That was still a strong element of educational philosophy in the first two-thirds of the 20th century. I'm not quite sure when it got lost -- if it even has. It definitely has gotten submerged in the philosophy of "producing productive members of society."

"Why newspapers?" you ask.

Because newspapers are more than advertising bundles. They're still the one place where you can get more than "sound bites." Newspapers are still the one place where editorial comments are usually clearly labeled as editorial comments, and detailed follow-up information on a story can usually be found.

Granted, there is a lot of advertising in newspapers, but that doesn't negate the value of newspapers -- or their online equivalents like MSNBC, BBC.COM, YAHOO News, and other modern multi-media news sources.

It's been my experience that online "newspapers" require the same levels of "literacy," in the tradional sense, is about the same as it is for printed newspapers.

The level of advertising in print (and other media) presents another "literacy" problem -- fraud detection. Without "literacy" in it's tradional sense, weeding out the scams and cons from the honest advertising is difficult. A bit of non-traditional "literacy" -- as in logic training or economics -- doesn't hurt in detecting logical fallacies and outright lies in advertising.

Personally, I hope we never reach your "post-literate" ideal. It strikes me as being a world rules by con-men, shysters, and advertising flacks instead of informed citizens. We're far to close to that vision alrady unless education -- AKA literacy -- improves.
 
Weird Harold said:
. . . Personally, I hope we never reach your "post-literate" ideal. It strikes me as being a world rules by con-men, shysters, and advertising flacks instead of informed citizens. We're far to close to that vision alrady unless education -- AKA literacy -- improves.

Well, it will happen--is happening already--although I certainly share some of your trepidation about it. Of course, 2500 years ago or so, some of those old Greek philosophers were expressing similar fears about literacy, fearing what this new-fangled reading and writing nonsense might do to people, fearing the development of a new caste of con-men, shysters, and hacks who couldn't be interrogated, whom you couldn't look in the eye to judge their character, and so forth. (You must be an unscrupulous bastard to hide behind the mask of text, after all.)

I do still think the newspaper is passé--sort of like the appendix in our anatomy: a vestigial organ of democracy that no longer serves a useful function (except to advertisers).

And I guess I'd regard the term "online equivalent" as an oxymoron. Once you have to plug it in, as McLuhan once suggested, everything has changed. I can (although I don't) read newspapers; their "online equivalents" just give me a headache. It's rather like equating being at a performance of, say, Hamlet, and reading the text of the play. Is that the "printed equivalent" of the performance? Hardly.

One of the consequences of the new communication age we're in, as people like McLuhan, Ong, Baudrillard, et al. have shown, is that the old discursive/knowledge boundaries are collapsing. The distinctions that used to be held and reinforced between, say, editorial comment and advertising have become much fuzzier now. ABC news is mainly an infotainment program--news as entertainment--and it could be argued that the entire show is nothing more (or less) than an advertisement for itself. (And I'm not just picking on ABC here, of course.) Television used to be structured on a relatively clear separation of the programming content from the advertising, but MTV changed all that. Here, for the first time, you had a network that broadcast nothing but ads--the music videos--under the guise of "programming content," with more traditional sorts of ads thrown in for good measure.

It would be nice--even noble, I guess--to entrench ourselves and defend the bastions of the old literacy. But I think what we ought to prepare ourselves (our students, our citizens) for is to take control of the new media, and to train them in the skills necessary to be critical audiences and producers of discourse in the new condition of post-literacy. Certainly, the "old" literacy skills constitute a part of that, but if we stop there--teaching Johnny and Jane to read and write--then we've failed them.
 
Ok, I've finally caught up. And thank you WH for starting this conversation.

Literacy/education/minimum standards...

I'd argue there's three levels of "literacy."

Reading, writing, and arithmetic, which ought to be learned in grade school; basic civic knowlege, which ought to be learned no later than Jr. High, and logic.

The three R's are pretty self-explanatory. Basic civic knowlege means things like "what does the Supreme Court do?" "What is the shape of the Earth?" "When was (in the case of the US) the Civil War fought?"

By "logic" I mean the kinds of things that are generally taught in college, or in college level H.S. courses. "Why was the Civil War fought?" "What is 'cultural relativity?'" "How does it relate to a debate over education and literacy standards?"

"Logic" has to do with how to think, not what to think.

It's the difference between a teacher who says: "here's what's going to be on the test: memorize it," and one who encourages students to find answers themselves; to debate those answers, and to think of education as a continuing process, not an end result.

There is one other kind of education: technical training.

Technical training - or job training - is important and valuable; how else can you learn to do a job?

But it is not what teachers should be doing in college, unless it's a technical college, I guess.

To be a good worker is not the same as to be educated. In fact it may often be the two are in conflict.
 
Weird Harold said:


Not really tangental at all. As a graduate from high school in 1968, I agree with almost everything you say.

This discussion was started as a way to narrow the discussion of "our schools have gone to hell" down to some specific points that need to be addressed. As such, it cna't help but be an indictment of "public schools" which are the largest percentage of "our educational system." Not all private and parochial schools can escape censure, but they do, in general, represent the top end of the educational system.

Just a couple of quick thoughts that I hope haven't been covered already, didn't read all the responses . . . my wife's a teacher, the school get's more requests from parents for her class than any other (go baby.)

The face of public education is changing, albeit slowly and much more markedly in certain areas. Every child is ready to advance at their own pace and one of the most frustrating challenges for the educators who care is finding a median where the brighter kids are well prepared for the next grade level but not so far ahead they lose their ambition when they get stuck there.

The schools have 12 years of educational steps to move children through and those kids are cognitively and emotionally all over the place. My wife's elementary school has a very progressive administrator who set's the tone for the school and I firmly believe that makes all the difference. We had a charter school open in my home town a few years ago to cheers and lots of political back-patting, it thus far has failed miserably. The scores coming out of that school were among the lowest in the county and suddenly the public system didn't look so bad. I'm not saying private education is a bad thing, the school failed because of it's administration, I'm just pointing out you can't throw a blanket over the lot and declare that private is inherently better.

If you want your kids to get a good education, take responsibility for the things that are in your lap. Talk to everyone you can before the school year starts and lobby diligently to pair your kid with a good instructor then get involved. Approach education in a way that your children see it's value. Help your kids with their homework but make them responsible for it. Go to the conferences and find out what's really going on and leave all the "not my kid" crap at the door.

One last thing, I am a product of the public educational system as are most of you. Is there anyone here that doesn't believe they could have excelled in that environment if they really wanted to? I know, as bad as the Florida schools were purported to be in the seventies, I could have walked with an education that would have allowed me to compete with most anyone if I would have applied myself, and if someone had been involved enough to kick me in the pants. It's no different today, the schools have evolved just as society has. The technological forum available to most everyone has made it even harder to find an excuse not to rise to whatever level you are capable of. Take responsibility, or your kids will just find someone else to blame too.
 
Sandia said:
Ok, I've finally caught up. And thank you WH for starting this conversation.

Literacy/education/minimum standards...

I'd argue there's three levels of "literacy."

Reading, writing, and arithmetic, which ought to be learned in grade school; basic civic knowlege, which ought to be learned no later than Jr. High, and logic.

...

"Logic" has to do with how to think, not what to think.

It's the difference between a teacher who says: "here's what's going to be on the test: memorize it," and one who encourages students to find answers themselves; to debate those answers, and to think of education as a continuing process, not an end result.

...

To be a good worker is not the same as to be educated. In fact it may often be the two are in conflict.

I think your concept of "logic" applies much earlier than college level courses. In fact I think that if you wait until that level to start teaching it, you're doomed to failure.

Teaching students "how to find answers" should start in pre-school or before -- with parents who care about education. Failing parental encouragement of a child's natural curiosity to think about why as wellas what, then pre-school and elementary teachers should try to instill that mind-set as soon as possible while children's minds are still malleable enough to incorporate it as "the natural order" of learning.

The "modern" workplace can't function without workers who are at least technically literate enough to deal with computers on some level. Even counter workers at McD's need to be able to read orders from the monitors and clear the orders when completed.

As much as "old-line" capitalists would prefer mindless drones as workers, I can think of very few jobs that don't require some degree of literacy in this day and age.
 
That's the last time I'll be reading a whole thread from start to finish. My coffee's gone cold ...
 
Ally C said:
That's the last time I'll be reading a whole thread from start to finish. My coffee's gone cold ...

I'm at least glad this thread was interesting enough that you forgot to sip at your coffee while reading it. :p
 
KillerMuffin[/i][b] A person ought to know enough about science to realize that chemicals should be treated with respect said:

Math tests are easy to bias culturally as well. Any good math assessment test includes "story problems." If the "story" that frames the problem deals with planning a debutante ball, many people who aren't rich and/or well read will get lost in the unfamiliar terms and lose track of the math problem. By the same token, a problem dealing with how many Keys of Coke are required to make a batch of crack, is going to distract those who had no trouble with planning a ball.

Wouldn't the fact that they were so caught up in the details show that they were, in fact, lacking in problem solving skills? Any word problem is only a math problem. If you lack the ability to pick out the pertinent information, and apply it in the manner required to solve the problem, then that shows a lack of 'literacy'. Doesn't it?

This is a great thread, I wish it wasn't almost 1am, so I'd have a shot at answering coherently.

I have a rather high IQ, an excellent vocabulary, and my reading/comprehension skills were measured at high school level when I was in first grade. I read Sherlock Holmes in second grade after getting special permission to check it out from the library, because it was considered too advanced.

I'm a history junkie, and my brain is filled with completely random facts and information. I function quite well in almost any social situation, from talking to the farmers and migrant workers at the diner in the morning, to conversing with retired Generals at parties and balls.

I also failed college algebra 3 times. I can apply geometry to my life, building barns and stalls, remodeling my house, etc... but I probably couldn't take a standardized test, because on paper, the problems make no sense to me.

According to the basic standards that we're postulating, I'm illiterate.
 
pagancowgirl said:
Originally posted by Weird Harold

Math tests are easy to bias culturally as well. Any good math assessment test includes "story problems." ...By the same token, a problem dealing with how many Keys of Coke are required to make a batch of crack, is going to distract those who had no trouble with planning a ball.



Wouldn't the fact that they were so caught up in the details show that they were, in fact, lacking in problem solving skills? Any word problem is only a math problem. If you lack the ability to pick out the pertinent information, and apply it in the manner required to solve the problem, then that shows a lack of 'literacy'. Doesn't it?

To some extent, that's true, the actual mathematics involved is independent of the story presenting the problem. However, the "story" part of the problem can alter the testee's perception of the "relevance" of the problem, and affect their willingness to sift diligantly for the pertinent details.

The story used to frame a math problem can have a subconscious effect on whether it's perceived as "worth solving" that transcends the testing context. The "What kind of stupid question is this," factor can intrude on the rational thought processes required to solve the problem.

It takes a very astute or dedicated student to keep the test ahead of the subconscious reaction.
 
Sandia said:


Also: managing a McDonald's is no easy thing, and my understanding is a manager can make a decent living doing what he does. About as good as teachers I believe. And you know, don't you, that Bill Gates was a college drop-out?


I'm also breaking my rule of not reading the whole thread. I've skimmed.. but haven't read it all the way.

Managing a McDonalds... isn't easy. It is one of the reasons I'm not with my ex husband today. I couldn't compete with the attention his job required.

My ex... we will call him J.. worked at McDonalds starting at the age of 16. He worked his way up.. to now being the supervisor (getting ready to purchase) 5 local McDonalds.

I married him when he was what was called a Shift Manager. At that time.. it was a shit job. It was the "lowest" management position at McDonalds. He made (in 1986) $4.25 an hour. We made it.. paid our bills, bought a "new" used car.. and paid our rent on time. Even raised a child.

When we divorced 7 years later.. he had worked his way up to Store Manager. He was in charge of 2 stores at that time. He was working long hours.. paid salary... and was getting over $30,000 a year.

Now.. 8 years later.. He is Supervisor. Meaning he is the person right under the owner. He is responsible for all 5 stores.. I don't know his exact salary.. but I'm sure its well over the $30,000 he was making when we divorced.

My oldest son has worked for McDonalds for a year now. He is making almost $8.00 an hour. Not shabby for a 15 year old. He has enough cash in the bank right now to buy a nice car and has a great start on his college fund.
 
Back
Top