Hi

I really don't see the dynamic you described in your first paragraph. I think people were all like "wtf?" I didn't see people scrambling to have more outrage than the poster before them.

You're free to think that my posts on the subject are "posturing" or "an exploitation, for self-aggrandizement, of the Shock! and Horror! of something that is too actually important for all that." You're wrong and it's rather ironic that you will give the benefit of the doubt to someone who is proud of being a racist rather than someone being honest about how they feel about that racism.

I don't post here to please or impress anyone. I never have and I never will. Being honest is far too important a principle to me to do that. As for your taking offense to it, well, that's up to you. Believe what you want and get as offended as you want, that really doesn't matter to me.

I think your position reeks of overcompensation far more than mine does.
Zip, I replied longer above, but you seem to have taken my criticism personally. It was the aggregate I was commenting on. You don't seem to be able to move past some perception of personal critique to see the issue a little more broadly. If you would, this conversation might be a little more constructive.
 
Of course you can't: that's the crux of our disagreement. You see that OP differently from me. That doesn't mean I am excusing anything. It simply means that the responses, in the aggregate, triggered a couple of buttons in me--the Rabid, Humorless Self-Righteousness Button and the button that finds actual racism so insidious and so deeply worthy of serious condemnation and critical thought, that the willy-nilly application of that charge is cynical and destructive (in my eyes).

But let me ask you a question: you said you didn't mind if someone called you a kike, since that word had no power to hurt you. (I'm Jewish too, by the way.) If someone did call you that, would you instruct them never to say it, because regardless of how you feel about it, it deeply hurts others? Because hearing it used about anyone wounds your soul and lessens all of us, regardless of who the target is? Or would you say, "You can call me that all you want, it doesn't mean anything to me"?

If it's the latter, you should ask yourself if you're not being a little opportunistic in this thread, just because it's someone who makes an easy target. I think most of the pilers on were, as I've made clear.

You should also ask yourself how that latter response is so different from Ginny saying, "You can call me a racist all you want, it doesn't mean anything to me."

We're all racist on some level. We're all least tolerant in others of those characteristics we most dislike about ourselves. Self-righteousness, in my eyes, is almost always over-compensation. In this entire thread, so far I'm the only one who has used anything approaching the phrase, "we all have racist thoughts." Everyone's right to the binary opposition: It's RACISM! Therefore Condemnation Script #3 must be executed, and we have God and everything good on our side.

That's too simple.

Because I know that, I was willing to read the OP slightly differently. I still do. I can see how you're reading it.

Have you made the same effort on my behalf?

Well, speaking as one of the "aggregate", (I assume this means the rest of us) :little avery:

Your post #179 was one of the best posts I've ever seen on any thread
on the GB. Exception, like Zip said to the last paragraph... However, are you sure what you you mean to say in the bolded is that we are all judgemental on some level? We all pass judgement on people day in and day out? That I would agree with. I'm sorry but racist and judgemental are not the same things to me and don't carry the same weight...

Maybe you're philosophizing way over my head but I'm not seeing any of the rabidness or self-righteousness you're labeling the rest of us (the aggregate) with. In fact the comments about EVERYONE being racist to some degree are the only ones I'm seeing as being on higher moral ground...

She put it out there, on a open forum. No matter her state of mind. And no matter who it was intended to rile...

I'm not sure how you would try to pschoanalyze my reason for posting here. I can tell you that the word offends me, and deeply.
 
Well, speaking as one of the "aggregate", (I assume this means the rest of us) :little avery:

Your post #179 was one of the best posts I've ever seen on any thread
on the GB. Exception, like Zip said to the last paragraph... However, are you sure what you you mean to say in the bolded is that we are all judgemental on some level? We all pass judgement on people day in and day out? That I would agree with. I'm sorry but racist and judgemental are not the same things to me and don't carry the same weight...

Maybe you're philosophizing way over my head but I'm not seeing any of the rabidness or self-righteousness you're labeling the rest of us (the aggregate) with. In fact the comments about EVERYONE being racist to some degree are the only ones I'm seeing as being on higher moral ground...

She put it out there, on a open forum. No matter her state of mind. And no matter who it was intended to rile...

I'm not sure how you would try to pschoanalyze my reason for posting here. I can tell you that the word offends me, and deeply.
OK, to step back:

First, I hate to be a dummy, but what is avery? Perg used it too.

Second, this issue (racism in America) is one I spend a lot of time bumping against, for reasons I can discuss in PM.

Third--actually, now that I think about it, possibly related to the previous comment--as a person I tend to be extremely suspicious of the 'herd.' We tend to valorize co-opinions to an extent that, in my view, often marginalizes the really interesting elements around us in damaging ways.

My own perception of the thread--by the time I got to it--was that there was a lot of herding going on. No one person, perhaps, was consciously 'following,' but I do think the aggregate, and the fact that the OP made a handy and frequent target, was providing some cover-fire for the too-obvious (to my ears, shrill) scolding that Racism Is Bad. It's an obvious and unnuanced position, and I was finding it tiresome by the time I posted. (I may, of course, have brought enough of my own stuff to the table that it didn't take much to get me to that point.)

Do I approve of the OP? Of course not. But it came after a year of Rory hounding her like the moral mafia. To be honest, half the time I find him so insufferable that I want to use the word just to tweak him. So whether I approve of it or not, I do understand it.

That doesn't excuse it or sanction it. But it puts it in a concept-space that--again, to me--makes all the resultant outrage seem knee-jerk and foolish: of course it was wrong. She was doing it because it was wrong. That was the point. There was some nuance to be perceived there, if one was inclined to look.

Was it immature and potentially broadly hurtful? Yes. Did any of the people who responded really think their response was going to change her? No. That's why it comes across to me as posturing on the part of the scolders. It's being said--de facto or intentionally--for others to see, not for the OP.

As for the we-are-all-racist part. This needs a longer discussion, but: bio-evolutionarily speaking, we're natural categorizers. We process visual information incredibly quickly, and have any of a host of mnemonics we use to help that along. We understand, for example, that a baobab tree is a tree, the first time we see one, even though we've only ever seen oaks and pines to that point.

"Race" is a bogus scientific 'concept' that is essentially a series of mnemonics. Whatever purpose they originally served, they now hold a big box of cultural freight along with them. I simply don't believe a grown-up who says they have never had a generalized race-related thought, even if they abandoned it as foolish a second later. You cannot be of a culture and not tie concepts to words in the short-hand of the realm, and some elements of racism--actually, arguably all--are, at their core, some form of cultural shorthand.

But let's table that for another thread at this point, OK? This one deserves to die a natural death.
 
Last edited:
OK, to step back:

First, I hate to be a dummy, but what is avery? Perg used it too.

Second, this issue (racism in America) is one I spend a lot of time bumping against, for reasons I can discuss in PM.

Third--actually, now that I think about it, possibly related to the previous comment--as a person I tend to be extremely suspicious of the 'herd.' We tend to valorize co-opinions to an extent that, in my view, often marginalizes the really interesting elements around us in damaging ways.

My own perception of the thread--by the time I got to it--was that there was a lot of herding going on. No one person, perhaps, was consciously 'following,' but I do think the aggregate, and the fact that the OP made a handy and frequent target, was providing some cover-fire for the too-obvious (to my ears, shrill) scolding that Racism Is Bad. It's an obvious and unnuanced position, and I was finding it tiresome by the time I posted. (I may, of course, have brought enough of my own stuff to the table that it didn't take much to get me to that point.)

Do I approve of the OP? Of course not. But it came after a year of Rory hounding her like the moral mafia. To be honest, half the time I find him so insufferable that I want to use the word just to tweak him. So whether I approve of it or not, I do understand it.

That doesn't excuse it or sanction it. But it puts it in a concept-space that--again, to me--makes all the resultant outrage seem knee-jerk and foolish: of course it was wrong. She was doing it because it was wrong. That was the point. There was some nuance to be perceived there, if one was inclined to look.

Was it immature and potentially broadly hurtful? Yes. Did any of the people who responded really think their response was going to change her? No. That's why it comes across to me as posturing on the part of the scolders. It's being said--de facto or intentionally--for others to see, not for the OP.

As for the we-are-all-racist part. This needs a longer discussion, but: bio-evolutionarily speaking, we're natural categorizers. We process visual information incredibly quickly, and have any of a host of mnemonics we use to help that along. We understand, for example, that a baobab tree is a tree, the first time we see one, even though we've only ever seen oaks and pines to that point.

"Race" is a bogus scientific 'concept' that is essentially a series of mnemonics. Whatever purpose they originally served, they now hold a big box of cultural freight along with them. I simply don't believe a grown-up who says they have never had a generalized race-related thought, even if they abandoned it as foolish a second later. You cannot be of a culture and not tie concepts to words in the short-hand of the realm, and some elements of racism--actually, all--are, at their core, some form of cultural shorthand.

But let's table that for another thread at this point, OK? This one deserves to die a natural death.

I hesitated bumping it at all if not for the fact it was still active when I sat down this evening. I agree it should just be tabled, for the moment, anyway...

For the last sake of argument though, I get when you say that the word race is only a way of categorgizing humans. We are a bunch of namers and until our brains have evolved enough to use other means to convey messages we have no choice. So, maybe your idea that we are all racist has some validity when posed that way but the GB is not an anthropology class...

And yes, it probably would have been better if no one had responded as it wont change her mind anyway. But that's not why the forum exists either. It exists for discussion and no one in their right mind can argue on the side of racial prejudice. It may have looked to you as knee-jerk but I didn't see it that way...

I don't know why you are more sensitive (not meant in a bad way) to the issue of racism any more than the rest of us, I'm assuming it has to do with your type of work, but feel free to PM if you wish. I'm interested...

Oh and an :avery: is Lit's own special emoticon. Goes back about 6-7 years. It's only the sarcasm symbol (though I've never thought it conveyed sarcasm, just rolly eyes) that a poster named Avery always used. Actually she ONLY ever used it. Never posted a word, of 1000s of posts, only the emoticon. Though she had a really hot pic thread :) She was actually not a bad chick, just strange like that...

Anyway, last post by me anyway, in the thread. It should just die off...
 
Interesting all the hand wringing over the OP when for years and years BB posted literally thousands of blatantly racist threads. Not to mention all the other alts that would come and go posting the same if not worse nonsense.
 
Hey Ginny, it's been awhile, it's nice to see again...:kiss:

You were my first friend on lit, and I'll never forgot that.

I'm sure you've noticed that some of your old threads were picked up by others, most notably by Crea(m), and mabe Meanie.

I hope you are well, and I'd like to see you back posting. I've missed you.

Take care, Sweetie.........:rose::kiss:
 
Back
Top