Hi

Fuck, I hate doing this.

I've given you a fair amount of shit in the past but, I have to admit, you have done a great deal to redeem yourself in my eyes over the last few weeks.

This was worth every moment of bittersweet self realization. :D

Ok, in reality this really wouldn't and doesn't change a thing or add up to a heck of a lot with regards to my personal journey, but it sure was nice to read.

Thanks, Sean. I appreciate it. I really, honestly do.

I don't imagine we'll ever entirely agree on each other's opinions, views or posting styles entirely, but I have said before that I can respect your intelligence, and therefore I find myself pleased with this post. Of course, it is also mildly entertaining for me to watch someone quite so stubborn feel as though he had to go back on his initial opinions, and hate it as much as you do, but in a cute sort of "awww lemme pinch your cheeks" sort of way, not a "haha, I got you!" sort of way.:D

In all seriousness, I gather this post was difficult for you to make openly, and I respect your open honesty and your choice to post it. You didn't have to say anything in public, or at all, but you chose to say it anyways. Perhaps you're redeeming yourself a wee bit in my eyes along the way also. :)
 
THe article is interesting indeed. I don't think what I'm saying falls under the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis at all (which I don't believe in). I'm not saying that language determines what we can and can't believe or conceive of, I'm saying that we infuse words with power. They have meaning based on societal or group agreement, but the power they have is given to them by us.

I'll use myself as an example. I'm Jewish. If some noob here called me a Kike, it wouldn't upset me at all as I couldn't care less what he called me. Some other Jewish person might take offense to that word based on how much power they give it. It's the same word. I just refuse to give the word any power.

Like I said, a sort of arguable extension. The feminists were great for that shit back i the 60's and 70's; if you refer to women as "girls" or "broads" you devalue them and that eventually becomes your reality, your perception.

S-W is gaining a lot of currency among skeptical linguists lately. I never believed it either, but I think we may have to revise our positions as time passes.

I agree on the calling you a kike. I wonder, though, if who says it and with what intent might change your ability to refuse to give it power.
 
Like I said, a sort of arguable extension. The feminists were great for that shit back i the 60's and 70's; if you refer to women as "girls" or "broads" you devalue them and that eventually becomes your reality, your perception.

S-W is gaining a lot of currency among skeptical linguists lately. I never believed it either, but I think we may have to revise our positions as time passes.

I agree on the calling you a kike. I wonder, though, if who says it and with what intent might change your ability to refuse to give it power.
The word 'nigger' is an atrocity, a single-word evocation of centuries of dehumanization and abuse in this country. It's freighted with more implications than almost any other word I can think of. It means I see you as less than a person, as less than me, as someone I might justify doing violence to, as someone I might intend to do violence to, and as a walking minstrel-simple caricature of a people that never existed except in the rationalizing minds of their dehumanizers and tormenters.

I can't think of a single other English-language word that carries all that weight. Not 'cunt,' not 'kike,' not any of the other racial slurs we're so inventive at producing.

Possibly 'fag,' in every way except the long history behind 'nigger.'

It's a word I think twice about even typing here because I know that, for example, Zumi doesn't even like to see it talked about as a word, and I like and respect him, so I don't want to hurt him.

It's a word I actively pray that my four-year-old son and 2-year-old daughter never have to hear, so they never have to ask me about it, so I don't have to explain how truly dark and awful we humans can occasionally be to each other, and so he never has to look at a black person as anything but a person, even for good reasons.

It's a word that has existed silently at the end of a good 70% of the criticisms around Obama, whether the criticizers knows it or would cop to it or not. It's a word that--again, silently--dictates how many black people can be cast in starring roles in Hollywood movies if the studio wants a wide release. It's a word that silently dictates that white pop stars are pop stars, while black ones who do the same music are R&B stars. It's a word that means a black doctor or professor or neuroscientist will be chased by the presumption of affirmative action regardless of his level of intelligence or achievement.

It's a word whose power to injure hurts all of us because of its power to injure, like a verbal nuclear bomb, and whose continued after-effects hurt my soul, especially as most of my endeavors tend to be in fields that frankly would not exist without the object of that injury.

It's a far more complicated term than we can do justice to here, and even more complicated than has yet to be done justice to in critical, political or social circles.

Having said all that, I still say: the OP was just a drive-by mooning, intended for a single person who has made the mooner his pet project for a year, and the posturing that followed in the thread offended me more than the original moon.

FWIW.
 
The word 'nigger' is an atrocity, a single-word evocation of centuries of dehumanization and abuse in this country. It's freighted with more implications than almost any other word I can think of. It means I see you as less than a person, as less than me, as someone I might justify doing violence to, as someone I might intend to do violence to, and as a walking minstrel-simple caricature of a people that never existed except in the rationalizing minds of their dehumanizers and tormenters.

I can't think of a single other English-language word that carries all that weight. Not 'cunt,' not 'kike,' not any of the other racial slurs we're so inventive at producing.

Possibly 'fag,' in every way except the long history behind 'nigger.'

It's a word I think twice about even typing here because I know that, for example, Zumi doesn't even like to see it talked about as a word, and I like and respect him, so I don't want to hurt him.

It's a word I actively pray that my four-year-old son and 2-year-old daughter never have to hear, so they never have to ask me about it, so I don't have to explain how truly dark and awful we humans can occasionally be to each other, and so he never has to look at a black person as anything but a person, even for good reasons.

It's a word that has existed silently at the end of a good 70% of the criticisms around Obama, whether the criticizers knows it or would cop to it or not. It's a word that--again, silently--dictates how many black people can be cast in starring roles in Hollywood movies if the studio wants a wide release. It's a word that silently dictates that white pop stars are pop stars, while black ones who do the same music are R&B stars. It's a word that means a black doctor or professor or neuroscientist will be chased by the presumption of affirmative action regardless of his level of intelligence or achievement.

It's a word whose power to injure hurts all of us because of its power to injure, like a verbal nuclear bomb, and whose continued after-effects hurt my soul, especially as most of my endeavors tend to be in fields that frankly would not exist without the object of that injury.

It's a far more complicated term than we can do justice to here, and even more complicated than has yet to be done justice to in critical, political or social circles.

Having said all that, I still say: the OP was just a drive-by mooning, intended for a single person who has made the mooner his pet project for a year, and the posturing that followed in the thread offended me more than the original moon.

FWIW.

This is a great post, Sonny. You've done a wonderful job-better than I could have-of articulating why I dislike and refuse (mostly, as noted) to use the word. Why I flinch when I see it or hear it.
 
Oh, and as an aside, I was once vacationing on a lake in Maine with some straight friends and their kids, as well as some gay friends. The straight and gay contingents had never met, though everyone was as cool and liberal as can be. One day, two of the gay men took two of the young kids out in a canoe. As they were returning, the other two gay men, sitting on the dock, jokingly asked the canoe ones "They were okay with their kids going out with you guys? Two gay men? Two fags?"

Everyone chuckled, and I said, "Two fags...straight people can't use that word." One of them snickered and said, "No, you can't; it's like the "N" word."
 
I grew up in Clover, South Carolina. That word was and is used on a regular basis. It is used by both black and white with no consideration of racism from either ethnicity.

Ginny is a racist cunt, those that use nigger to trigger other responses are racist, and those that argue against it, but are passive aggressive in their racism are just as suspect.

Fuck each of you, and your sorry bullshit.

The ONLY thing good about ginny is that she speaks her mind so you flat out know she is a racist. No guess work involved.
 
The word 'nigger' is an atrocity, a single-word evocation of centuries of dehumanization and abuse in this country. It's freighted with more implications than almost any other word I can think of. It means I see you as less than a person, as less than me, as someone I might justify doing violence to, as someone I might intend to do violence to, and as a walking minstrel-simple caricature of a people that never existed except in the rationalizing minds of their dehumanizers and tormenters.

I can't think of a single other English-language word that carries all that weight. Not 'cunt,' not 'kike,' not any of the other racial slurs we're so inventive at producing.

Possibly 'fag,' in every way except the long history behind 'nigger.'

It's a word I think twice about even typing here because I know that, for example, Zumi doesn't even like to see it talked about as a word, and I like and respect him, so I don't want to hurt him.

It's a word I actively pray that my four-year-old son and 2-year-old daughter never have to hear, so they never have to ask me about it, so I don't have to explain how truly dark and awful we humans can occasionally be to each other, and so he never has to look at a black person as anything but a person, even for good reasons.

It's a word that has existed silently at the end of a good 70% of the criticisms around Obama, whether the criticizers knows it or would cop to it or not. It's a word that--again, silently--dictates how many black people can be cast in starring roles in Hollywood movies if the studio wants a wide release. It's a word that silently dictates that white pop stars are pop stars, while black ones who do the same music are R&B stars. It's a word that means a black doctor or professor or neuroscientist will be chased by the presumption of affirmative action regardless of his level of intelligence or achievement.

It's a word whose power to injure hurts all of us because of its power to injure, like a verbal nuclear bomb, and whose continued after-effects hurt my soul, especially as most of my endeavors tend to be in fields that frankly would not exist without the object of that injury.

It's a far more complicated term than we can do justice to here, and even more complicated than has yet to be done justice to in critical, political or social circles.

Having said all that, I still say: the OP was just a drive-by mooning, intended for a single person who has made the mooner his pet project for a year, and the posturing that followed in the thread offended me more than the original moon.

FWIW.
All of that ^^^ is why I think it is the deal breaker for some. For me? Everything you just said above is why I wouldn't want to hang out with someone who thought it was no big deal to use that word. Had this been Ginny's only offense; the incredibly poor taste of this thread, I could perhaps get past it, because I don't have to hang out with her, and because I know what it's like to make impulsive mistakes of character based on a defensive feeling. I know people sometimes say things they don't mean, or secretly wish they could take back. I could convince myself she wished she could take it back. But the other post? Where she freely admitted she is a racist, made no apology for it, and then cemented it with stating she was speaking the truth? That I cannot abide by. I cannot convince myself that was simply something she said in anger and wished she could take back.

That being said, I couldn't care less who hangs out with Ginny, or anyone else. Everyone is free to make their own informed choices. I can't guarantee I'll still view someone who looks past an obvious deal breaking (in my eyes) evil in another person and declares their friendship for said person, but you'll never catch me trying to dictate who should and should not be friends.

I can see the point you and Bronze are trying to make, and I think you made it better than he did. His first sarcastic post didn't amuse me, even though I could see where he was going with it. I think also some folks are more tolerant and willing or able to set things aside than others. For me? I've lived on the streets and seen the worst sides of people. I've been through terrors no woman or person for that matter should go through. I've seen what true desperation does to a human being, I've seen what real hate looks like. Perhaps my deal breakers may seem silly to someone else, but in my case at least, I have no desire whatsoever to involve myself in any way with those types of people ever again. I've done my time. I am an adult, free to make my own choices. I choose not to hang out with racists, for starters. I also choose not to hang out with people I catch lying to me, rapists, gay bashers or thieves, among others.

Thanks for this post. It was incredibly insightful and offered an interesting look into a more serious side of you.
 
Last edited:
All of that ^^^ is why I think it is the deal breaker for some. For me? Everything you just said above is why I wouldn't want to hang out with someone who thought it was no big deal to use that word. Had this been Ginny's only offense; the incredibly poor taste of this thread, I could perhaps get past it, because I don't have to hang out with her, and because I know what it's like to make impulsive mistakes of character based on a defensive feeling. I know people sometimes say things they don't mean, or secretly wish they could take back. I could convince myself she wished she could take it back. But the other post? Where she freely admitted she is a racist, made no apology for it, and then cemented it with stating she was speaking the truth? That I cannot abide by. I cannot convince myself that was simply something she said in anger and wished she could take back.

That being said, I couldn't care less who hangs out with Ginny, or anyone else. Everyone is free to make their own informed choices. I can't guarantee I'll still view someone who looks past an obvious deal breaking (in my eyes) evil in another person and declares their friendship for said person, but you'll never catch me trying to dictate who should and should not be friends.

I can see the point you and Bronze are trying to make, and I think you made it better than he did. His first sarcastic post didn't amuse me, even though I could see where he was going with it. I think also some folks are more tolerant and willing or able to set things aside than others. For me? I've lived on the streets and seen the worst sides of people. I've been through terrors no woman or person for that matter should go through. I've seen what true desperation does to a human being, I've seen what real hate looks like. Perhaps my deal breakers may seem silly to someone else, but in my case at leas, I have no desire whatsoever to involve myself in any way with those types of people ever again. I've done my time. I am an adult, free to make my own choices. I choose not to hang out with racists, for starters. I also choose not to hang out with people I catch lying to me, rapists, gay bashers or thieves, among others.

Thanks for this post. It was incredibly insightful and offered an interesting look into a more serious side of you.

On a side note, December made a sweet av for me back in the day. She was a bitter bitch back in the day, but seems much more mellow now. I hope that change was a good thing.
 
I've spoken out against the Rory Crusade on multiple occasions. Personally I think he's an obsessive idiot. Have you ever seen me go out and start threads about who is or isn't a racist or who is and isn't associating with them? You haven't because I haven't.

Since we agree her comments on NO were racist and we agree that her apology was a non-apology, then that inherently makes her a racist. Therefore, how can you be so sure she was just tweaking Rory? And even if she was just "tweaking Rory" was he the only one affected? When you throw remarks out there in a public forum like this, you can't limit the damage of them to just the intended target. It's like thinking you're using a sniper rifle and using a hand grenade instead.

I really couldn't care less if it comes across as the unracist olympics. To be honest, this thread was all over the place until Bronzeage's comment. My comments about Ginny weren't over the top or designed to stoke the flames. It was just calling it like I see it which I always will do on here. I don't throw out the "racist" title for every perceived infraction of my personal definition, but racism can be both overt or subtle. When someone who I know is a racist types "nigger, nigger, nigger" then I think it's fair to comment on it. That wasn't a verbal tic or a slight breaze. That was pretty clear to me.


I wouldn't go so far as to call Rory an idiot, but I think his decision to continue to call folks' attention to Ginny's posts of a few months back qualifies as trolling and I've told hm so.

Having said that, most of this thread isn't about what Ginny said a while back, it's about what she said in the first post. It's silly to say that comments on it later in the same thread are piling on or off topic. And while I don't want to endorse a witch hunt, it's ridiculous for people to go 180 degrees the other way and act like they're striking a blow for free speech by refusing to say there's anything wrong with her post--or even dumber, accusing her critics of being the ones who really deserve condemnation.

Of course, one reason this thread has gone this long where run-of-the-mill bigot threads die on the vine is that a lot of people here have been posting with Ginny for going on 10 years, and are wondering what the hell could have happened.
 
All of that ^^^ is why I think it is the deal breaker for some. For me? Everything you just said above is why I wouldn't want to hang out with someone who thought it was no big deal to use that word. Had this been Ginny's only offense; the incredibly poor taste of this thread, I could perhaps get past it, because I don't have to hang out with her, and because I know what it's like to make impulsive mistakes of character based on a defensive feeling. I know people sometimes say things they don't mean, or secretly wish they could take back. I could convince myself she wished she could take it back. But the other post? Where she freely admitted she is a racist, made no apology for it, and then cemented it with stating she was speaking the truth? That I cannot abide by. I cannot convince myself that was simply something she said in anger and wished she could take back.

That being said, I couldn't care less who hangs out with Ginny, or anyone else. Everyone is free to make their own informed choices. I can't guarantee I'll still view someone who looks past an obvious deal breaking (in my eyes) evil in another person and declares their friendship for said person, but you'll never catch me trying to dictate who should and should not be friends.

I can see the point you and Bronze are trying to make, and I think you made it better than he did. His first sarcastic post didn't amuse me, even though I could see where he was going with it. I think also some folks are more tolerant and willing or able to set things aside than others. For me? I've lived on the streets and seen the worst sides of people. I've been through terrors no woman or person for that matter should go through. I've seen what true desperation does to a human being, I've seen what real hate looks like. Perhaps my deal breakers may seem silly to someone else, but in my case at least, I have no desire whatsoever to involve myself in any way with those types of people ever again. I've done my time. I am an adult, free to make my own choices. I choose not to hang out with racists, for starters. I also choose not to hang out with people I catch lying to me, rapists, gay bashers or thieves, among others.

Thanks for this post. It was incredibly insightful and offered an interesting look into a more serious side of you.
Thank you. I'm not being glib when I say this, but the piling-on of "I'm offended!" "I'm even more offended! And shocked!" "I'm offended, shocked, and disappointed!" etc. is literally more offensive to me than whatever the initial comment was. It's an exploitation, for self-aggrandizement, of the Shock! and Horror! of something that is too actually important for all that. It rings false in the aggregate, and stinks of overcompensation. I'd rather let the original offense speak for itself then get into a Morality Olympics over it.

I don't know where my cut-off is in terms of racist comments. We're all natural categorizers. Anyone who claims they've never had a racist thought is lying. So I need more information about the person. I need context.

I've told this story before, but: One night, my father was drunk. He was expounding on some subject, and said something like, "The only people worse than the Irish are the niggers"--words to that effect, I actually forget, suddenly, what they were.

I wasn't brought up hearing that kind of language from him, had never observed a single interaction that would have suggested he felt anything of the sort (to the contrary, in fact), and he spent the rest of his life never saying anything that came close to that or behaving in any way that would have suggested it. As dismayed as I was--and it hit me hard--I finally had to take in the whole picture of him and slice that comment off. It didn't match his behavior, the values he brought me up to have, or any of a million other elements of his character. I attributed it to drunken bravado, in the safety of a Queens apartment.

I'm willing to give others the same full-picture benefit of the doubt. I won't condone dehumanizing behavior. But I will allow my Ivy League uncle-professor to say, "I hate to say it, but when it comes to learning students' names, a lot of the Asian girls really do look the same." I look at his three adopted kids, all of color, the political and moral positions he takes, and I slice that comment off.

There are plenty of others for whom it's easier to dump the body than excise a slice. But excision is not the sin we make it out to be here.
 
Thank you. I'm not being glib when I say this, but the piling-on of "I'm offended!" "I'm even more offended! And shocked!" "I'm offended, shocked, and disappointed!" etc. is literally more offensive to me than whatever the initial comment was. It's an exploitation, for self-aggrandizement, of the Shock! and Horror! of something that is too actually important for all that. It rings false in the aggregate, and stinks of overcompensation. I'd rather let the original offense speak for itself then get into a Morality Olympics over it.

I don't know where my cut-off is in terms of racist comments. We're all natural categorizers. Anyone who claims they've never had a racist thought is lying. So I need more information about the person. I need context.

I've told this story before, but: One night, my father was drunk. He was expounding on some subject, and said something like, "The only people worse than the Irish are the niggers"--words to that effect, I actually forget, suddenly, what they were.

I wasn't brought up hearing that kind of language from him, had never observed a single interaction that would have suggested he felt anything of the sort (to the contrary, in fact), and he spent the rest of his life never saying anything that came close to that or behaving in any way that would have suggested it. As dismayed as I was--and it hit me hard--I finally had to take in the whole picture of him and slice that comment off. It didn't match his behavior, the values he brought me up to have, or any of a million other elements of his character. I attributed it to drunken bravado, in the safety of a Queens apartment.

I'm willing to give others the same full-picture benefit of the doubt. I won't condone dehumanizing behavior. But I will allow my Ivy League uncle-professor to say, "I hate to say it, but when it comes to learning students' names, a lot of the Asian girls really do look the same." I look at his three adopted kids, all of color, the political and moral positions he takes, and I slice that comment off.

There are plenty of others for whom it's easier to dump the body than excise a slice. But excision is not the sin we make it out to be here.

I like this side of you. I like your dorky side, too.

I think both points of view are valid, they have to be, considering we're all entitled to our own beliefs and opinions. I can see what you are saying, but I think some other factors are in play here as well. For instance, with your father, you spent a lifetime with him, in RL. You were privy to his body language, the tones in his voice, and all the communication between you and him in between. I can understand slicing that comment off, I would have as well, even though it would have left a sour taste in my mouth at the time.

The difference here is that it is a text based world. We are not privy to the intricate workings of the whole person that is Ginny outside of here. We know what she puts out there. Before any of this started, what she had put out there for us to see was all beautiful, sexy, imaginative, fun and amazing. Granted she put pieces of herself out there for us to snatch up and hold on to, but she didn't, couldn't, put all of herself out there.

I believe a lot of the outrage noted in this thread is because of this. While it is highly likely that Ginny has all kinds of fantastic qualities in RL, we are not privy to those qualities. If we are only given a portion of all that a person is here in this text based world, then we only have that potion to go on. If a person sullies a smaller piece of that already mere portion, do you not think it is much easier for people to become shocked or upset?

I'm not sure I worded any of that very well. It's 1:30am and I am on another break from making Valentines day cards for the kids in my daughter's class. I don't imagine I'll be done for another few hours, I am tired, my fingers are gluey and I think I'm starting to lose mental focus.

The point I was trying to make, is that it would be much easier to "slice" a few comments off if we knew Ginny in a more broad sense. If we knew her in RL. If we could understand and see her mannerisms, her body language. If we could hear her voice and know without a doubt that she was capable of empathy, compassion, remorse. I guess perhaps a few people may know her like that, but I don't. Based on the little that I do know of Ginny, I don't think I can simply slice off her admittance to being a racist and making no apology for it.

I do see what you mean, I just don't think it applies here in this text based mini-universe we spend so much of our time inhabiting digitally.

I hope I managed to spit out what I was trying to say properly. I think I should get the cards finished and hit the hay.
 
I like this side of you. I like your dorky side, too.

I think both points of view are valid, they have to be, considering we're all entitled to our own beliefs and opinions. I can see what you are saying, but I think some other factors are in play here as well. For instance, with your father, you spent a lifetime with him, in RL. You were privy to his body language, the tones in his voice, and all the communication between you and him in between. I can understand slicing that comment off, I would have as well, even though it would have left a sour taste in my mouth at the time.

The difference here is that it is a text based world. We are not privy to the intricate workings of the whole person that is Ginny outside of here. We know what she puts out there. Before any of this started, what she had put out there for us to see was all beautiful, sexy, imaginative, fun and amazing. Granted she put pieces of herself out there for us to snatch up and hold on to, but she didn't, couldn't, put all of herself out there.

I believe a lot of the outrage noted in this thread is because of this. While it is highly likely that Ginny has all kinds of fantastic qualities in RL, we are not privy to those qualities. If we are only given a portion of all that a person is here in this text based world, then we only have that potion to go on. If a person sullies a smaller piece of that already mere portion, do you not think it is much easier for people to become shocked or upset?

I'm not sure I worded any of that very well. It's 1:30am and I am on another break from making Valentines day cards for the kids in my daughter's class. I don't imagine I'll be done for another few hours, I am tired, my fingers are gluey and I think I'm starting to lose mental focus.

The point I was trying to make, is that it would be much easier to "slice" a few comments off if we knew Ginny in a more broad sense. If we knew her in RL. If we could understand and see her mannerisms, her body language. If we could hear her voice and know without a doubt that she was capable of empathy, compassion, remorse. I guess perhaps a few people may know her like that, but I don't. Based on the little that I do know of Ginny, I don't think I can simply slice off her admittance to being a racist and making no apology for it.

I do see what you mean, I just don't think it applies here in this text based mini-universe we spend so much of our time inhabiting digitally.

I hope I managed to spit out what I was trying to say properly. I think I should get the cards finished and hit the hay.
Thank for another thoughtful reply. Yes, I do understand the distinction you're making. I suppose the only difference in our positions is that I am making it in 'both' directions: while I can't know everything I would need to know to excise a racist comment, I also can't know everything I need to know to condemn one either.

There are a a few clearly racist posters here; mostly alts. There are others who say racist things just to provoke. At least to my eye, they're always obvious. There are others who say things that sound racist, but may or may not be; more information is needed. And there are others yet who have never said a racist word online, yet who secretly think all black men are criminals, all jews are cheap, and all Muslims are terrorists.

Of all those types, the latter scares me the most.

Good luck on the V-Day cards. Thanks again for the thoughtful reply.
 
I wouldn't go so far as to call Rory an idiot, but I think his decision to continue to call folks' attention to Ginny's posts of a few months back qualifies as trolling and I've told hm so.

Having said that, most of this thread isn't about what Ginny said a while back, it's about what she said in the first post. It's silly to say that comments on it later in the same thread are piling on or off topic. And while I don't want to endorse a witch hunt, it's ridiculous for people to go 180 degrees the other way and act like they're striking a blow for free speech by refusing to say there's anything wrong with her post--or even dumber, accusing her critics of being the ones who really deserve condemnation.

Of course, one reason this thread has gone this long where run-of-the-mill bigot threads die on the vine is that a lot of people here have been posting with Ginny for going on 10 years, and are wondering what the hell could have happened.

He devotes the same level of attention to Alts as well which is why I characterized him the way I did. I stand by that.

Other than that I agree with your post completely.
 
The word 'nigger' is an atrocity, a single-word evocation of centuries of dehumanization and abuse in this country. It's freighted with more implications than almost any other word I can think of. It means I see you as less than a person, as less than me, as someone I might justify doing violence to, as someone I might intend to do violence to, and as a walking minstrel-simple caricature of a people that never existed except in the rationalizing minds of their dehumanizers and tormenters.

I can't think of a single other English-language word that carries all that weight. Not 'cunt,' not 'kike,' not any of the other racial slurs we're so inventive at producing.

Possibly 'fag,' in every way except the long history behind 'nigger.'

It's a word I think twice about even typing here because I know that, for example, Zumi doesn't even like to see it talked about as a word, and I like and respect him, so I don't want to hurt him.

It's a word I actively pray that my four-year-old son and 2-year-old daughter never have to hear, so they never have to ask me about it, so I don't have to explain how truly dark and awful we humans can occasionally be to each other, and so he never has to look at a black person as anything but a person, even for good reasons.

It's a word that has existed silently at the end of a good 70% of the criticisms around Obama, whether the criticizers knows it or would cop to it or not. It's a word that--again, silently--dictates how many black people can be cast in starring roles in Hollywood movies if the studio wants a wide release. It's a word that silently dictates that white pop stars are pop stars, while black ones who do the same music are R&B stars. It's a word that means a black doctor or professor or neuroscientist will be chased by the presumption of affirmative action regardless of his level of intelligence or achievement.

It's a word whose power to injure hurts all of us because of its power to injure, like a verbal nuclear bomb, and whose continued after-effects hurt my soul, especially as most of my endeavors tend to be in fields that frankly would not exist without the object of that injury.

It's a far more complicated term than we can do justice to here, and even more complicated than has yet to be done justice to in critical, political or social circles.

Having said all that, I still say: the OP was just a drive-by mooning, intended for a single person who has made the mooner his pet project for a year, and the posturing that followed in the thread offended me more than the original moon.

FWIW.

I strongly object to this word as it is used to reduce women to their genitalia and we've had enough of that shit.
 
I strongly object to this word as it is used to reduce women to their genitalia and we've had enough of that shit.
But 'kike' was OK?

I wasn't dismissing the term--quite the opposite. I was using it as an example of a deeply offensive term, to give some context for how extreme a word we're all talking about here.
 
I grew up in Clover, South Carolina. That word was and is used on a regular basis. It is used by both black and white with no consideration of racism from either ethnicity.

Ginny is a racist cunt, those that use nigger to trigger other responses are racist, and those that argue against it, but are passive aggressive in their racism are just as suspect.

Fuck each of you, and your sorry bullshit.

The ONLY thing good about ginny is that she speaks her mind so you flat out know she is a racist. No guess work involved.

Interesting view.

http://forum.literotica.com/showthread.php?t=445767
 
Interesting. I could swear I remember Ginny as the other half of Tortoise, a bright, sexually hungry and intensely pleasing female with good ideas, morals, values and a healthy porn streak a mile wide. I could swear I remember Ginny being well liked by all, envied by many and an upstanding poster/citizen in general.

How is it that I don't have any recollection of Ginny being a miserable, drunken fucking racist?

I've been telling people for years that Ginny is a mindless, vapid cunt. No one believed me. How I cried.
 
Like I said, a sort of arguable extension. The feminists were great for that shit back i the 60's and 70's; if you refer to women as "girls" or "broads" you devalue them and that eventually becomes your reality, your perception.

S-W is gaining a lot of currency among skeptical linguists lately. I never believed it either, but I think we may have to revise our positions as time passes.

I agree on the calling you a kike. I wonder, though, if who says it and with what intent might change your ability to refuse to give it power.

I don't think the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis was about changing a perception, but rather, whether or not you could even have the thought based on the word not being a part of the language. I don't think it's a logical extension.

If someone calls me a Kike, they are actually insulting themselves by using the word. It might change my perception of the person using it but it wouldn't hurt my feelings at all.
 
The word 'nigger' is an atrocity, a single-word evocation of centuries of dehumanization and abuse in this country. It's freighted with more implications than almost any other word I can think of. It means I see you as less than a person, as less than me, as someone I might justify doing violence to, as someone I might intend to do violence to, and as a walking minstrel-simple caricature of a people that never existed except in the rationalizing minds of their dehumanizers and tormenters.

I can't think of a single other English-language word that carries all that weight. Not 'cunt,' not 'kike,' not any of the other racial slurs we're so inventive at producing.

Possibly 'fag,' in every way except the long history behind 'nigger.'

It's a word I think twice about even typing here because I know that, for example, Zumi doesn't even like to see it talked about as a word, and I like and respect him, so I don't want to hurt him.

It's a word I actively pray that my four-year-old son and 2-year-old daughter never have to hear, so they never have to ask me about it, so I don't have to explain how truly dark and awful we humans can occasionally be to each other, and so he never has to look at a black person as anything but a person, even for good reasons.

It's a word that has existed silently at the end of a good 70% of the criticisms around Obama, whether the criticizers knows it or would cop to it or not. It's a word that--again, silently--dictates how many black people can be cast in starring roles in Hollywood movies if the studio wants a wide release. It's a word that silently dictates that white pop stars are pop stars, while black ones who do the same music are R&B stars. It's a word that means a black doctor or professor or neuroscientist will be chased by the presumption of affirmative action regardless of his level of intelligence or achievement.

It's a word whose power to injure hurts all of us because of its power to injure, like a verbal nuclear bomb, and whose continued after-effects hurt my soul, especially as most of my endeavors tend to be in fields that frankly would not exist without the object of that injury.

It's a far more complicated term than we can do justice to here, and even more complicated than has yet to be done justice to in critical, political or social circles.

Having said all that, I still say: the OP was just a drive-by mooning, intended for a single person who has made the mooner his pet project for a year, and the posturing that followed in the thread offended me more than the original moon.FWIW.

I honestly can't believe that the bolded section follows the rest of that post. It's "an atrocity" but you can excuse the use of it as a drive-by mooning? I really don't see the logic that leads you to be so sure of the intent (especially from someone who is proud of being a racist) and dismissive of the consequences of that use.
 
Thank you. I'm not being glib when I say this, but the piling-on of "I'm offended!" "I'm even more offended! And shocked!" "I'm offended, shocked, and disappointed!" etc. is literally more offensive to me than whatever the initial comment was. It's an exploitation, for self-aggrandizement, of the Shock! and Horror! of something that is too actually important for all that. It rings false in the aggregate, and stinks of overcompensation. I'd rather let the original offense speak for itself then get into a Morality Olympics over it.

I don't know where my cut-off is in terms of racist comments. We're all natural categorizers. Anyone who claims they've never had a racist thought is lying. So I need more information about the person. I need context.

I've told this story before, but: One night, my father was drunk. He was expounding on some subject, and said something like, "The only people worse than the Irish are the niggers"--words to that effect, I actually forget, suddenly, what they were.

I wasn't brought up hearing that kind of language from him, had never observed a single interaction that would have suggested he felt anything of the sort (to the contrary, in fact), and he spent the rest of his life never saying anything that came close to that or behaving in any way that would have suggested it. As dismayed as I was--and it hit me hard--I finally had to take in the whole picture of him and slice that comment off. It didn't match his behavior, the values he brought me up to have, or any of a million other elements of his character. I attributed it to drunken bravado, in the safety of a Queens apartment.

I'm willing to give others the same full-picture benefit of the doubt. I won't condone dehumanizing behavior. But I will allow my Ivy League uncle-professor to say, "I hate to say it, but when it comes to learning students' names, a lot of the Asian girls really do look the same." I look at his three adopted kids, all of color, the political and moral positions he takes, and I slice that comment off.

There are plenty of others for whom it's easier to dump the body than excise a slice. But excision is not the sin we make it out to be here.

I really don't see the dynamic you described in your first paragraph. I think people were all like "wtf?" I didn't see people scrambling to have more outrage than the poster before them.

You're free to think that my posts on the subject are "posturing" or "an exploitation, for self-aggrandizement, of the Shock! and Horror! of something that is too actually important for all that." You're wrong and it's rather ironic that you will give the benefit of the doubt to someone who is proud of being a racist rather than someone being honest about how they feel about that racism.

I don't post here to please or impress anyone. I never have and I never will. Being honest is far too important a principle to me to do that. As for your taking offense to it, well, that's up to you. Believe what you want and get as offended as you want, that really doesn't matter to me.

I think your position reeks of overcompensation far more than mine does.
 
I honestly can't believe that the bolded section follows the rest of that post. It's "an atrocity" but you can excuse the use of it as a drive-by mooning? I really don't see the logic that leads you to be so sure of the intent (especially from someone who is proud of being a racist) and dismissive of the consequences of that use.
Of course you can't: that's the crux of our disagreement. You see that OP differently from me. That doesn't mean I am excusing anything. It simply means that the responses, in the aggregate, triggered a couple of buttons in me--the Rabid, Humorless Self-Righteousness Button and the button that finds actual racism so insidious and so deeply worthy of serious condemnation and critical thought, that the willy-nilly application of that charge is cynical and destructive (in my eyes).

But let me ask you a question: you said you didn't mind if someone called you a kike, since that word had no power to hurt you. (I'm Jewish too, by the way.) If someone did call you that, would you instruct them never to say it, because regardless of how you feel about it, it deeply hurts others? Because hearing it used about anyone wounds your soul and lessens all of us, regardless of who the target is? Or would you say, "You can call me that all you want, it doesn't mean anything to me"?

If it's the latter, you should ask yourself if you're not being a little opportunistic in this thread, just because it's someone who makes an easy target. I think most of the pilers on were, as I've made clear.

You should also ask yourself how that latter response is so different from Ginny saying, "You can call me a racist all you want, it doesn't mean anything to me."

We're all racist on some level. We're all least tolerant in others of those characteristics we most dislike about ourselves. Self-righteousness, in my eyes, is almost always over-compensation. In this entire thread, so far I'm the only one who has used anything approaching the phrase, "we all have racist thoughts." Everyone has stuck to the binary opposition: It's RACISM! Therefore Condemnation Script #3 must be executed, and we have God and everything good on our side.

That's too simple.

Because I know that, I was willing to read the OP slightly differently. I still do.

I can see how you're reading it. Have you made the same effort on my behalf?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top