Hi

You position on racism/pedo might have a little validity if pedophilia were a result of social conditions and was in previous generations accepted as the social norm and written into law. There was a time when racism was decreed by law. Those laws have been changed, but I was unaware racism was actually a crime. As far as I know, it's strictly optional.

It does seem Ginny metamorphosised in one post from fun based poster to racist. Have stranger things ever been observed? I think not.

Unless of course humans are the sum of their parts and not the small window we see in posts. That is the problem with judging people. We never know if we have an accurate body of evidence. Just when we think its complete, George Wallace apologizes for his life's work. Tricky one, that George. Do we judge him for the man who stood for segregation or the man he lived to be.

I admit to a good deal of self righteousness, but it is only the result of being so fucking righteous.

Okay, the pedophelia comparison doesn't work for you. Obviously you can't see past how they are different to see how they can be viewed as the same in the context I provided. That's besides the point. My bad. Here's my question "When does "a bunch of people having the same opinion turn into group think?" This thread had taken a lot of twists and turns prior to your sarcastic post about "bad, bad Ginny." As Dolf said, more people were like "wtf?" Why is it group think that a bunch of disapprove of her use of that language. Again as Dolf pointed out, no one engaged in Rory type behavior to ostracize her. Some condemned her choice of language but no one said "don't be friends with her" or "don't be friends with anyone who talks to her."

Just because stranger things have happened doesn't mean it's not worth commenting on.

I never said Ginny was a horrible person without any redeeming qualities. I am saying that being a racist is a deal breaker for me. I didn't say anyone else had to use that as their standard. People judge situations, ideas and people all the time. It isn't always a bad thing. Judgement can keep us alive or kill us depending on the danger of the circumstances. Wasn't your comment about "bad, bad Ginny" a judgement of everyone who criticized her in this thread?
 
Bronze may disown me as a friend after I type this, but most people in the deep south, at least of a 'certain age,' have grown up fairly comfortable with the word 'nigger'--whether or not they would ever use it to describe anyone, and whether or not they've ever had a racist thought in their life. Which they have, because we all have.

I understand that. But it's more than just being comfortable using the term. In their mind they truly believed blacks to be sub-human, unentitled to basic human considerations. And then passing that poison on to future generations...
 
Yes, she apologises for her temper immediately afterwards. She doesn't try to take back the portion of her post that is in bold above. Basically, her apology says "Hey, sorry about my bad temper, by the way, I'm still a racist, and I freely admit it." She didn't apologise for being racist in the first place, nor for bringing it here to a public forum. She apologised merely for allowing her temper to get so far out of control that she spit out the worst part of herself for all to see. She wasn't sorry she hates black people, she was sorry she let the rest of us know it. She even goes so far as to say she apologises "but speaks the truth."

A few posts later she goes on about Obama wearing faggy dress shoes. A lesser offense, but still a minor offense in my eyes, since the word faggot really fucking bothers me.

As far as Sonny, Bronze ect go, you are entitled to your opinion, as am I. In my opinion her original post above is what upset me. This thread I find in very poor taste, but it didn't upset me as much. My opinion is that I feel saddened by reading these posts from Ginny. Why do I feel saddened? It has nothing to do with jumping on a bandwagon for me, I could be the only one who felt this way and I assure you I would still feel this way. I am saddened because I can't bring myself to think of someone who openly admits to being a racist with that much hatred backing it up as a person with a beautiful mind worthy of my admiration. I agree there are many facets of Ginny that are still amazing and beautiful, but for me, her boldly stating she is a racist, and then backing it up by saying she spoke the truth will always tarnish her beauty. I am entitled to have that opinion, and I am entitled to lament the loss of my ability to further view Ginny in such high regard.

Eloquently put and this perfectly describes my feelings on the matter especially the last line.
 
I guess not. I'd rather be called a name, no matter how venomous and culturally powerful, than be physically or sexually abused.

I agree that either of those is cause for alarm, but I think you have to consider that not every swastika leads to violence; sometimes, I daresay most of the time, it really is just a dipshitty act of vandalism. In the same way, not everyone who yells "nigger" out the car window as they drive by is capable of violence.

Let me say that I realize, having grown up white and middle class, that I lack perspective that you have. Please don't take my questions as disagreeing with or challenging your experience. I'm genuinely interested in your perspective.

Another question for you: What's your take on the use of the word by black folks to refer to other black folks? Is it okay for rappers to use the word? It seems to me there's two ways to see it: 1) The Lenny Bruce thing about desensitizing it, taking it back, changing its power and 2) The continued hearing of it keeps it alive and in the present for people when maybe it should be consigned to the same historical garbage can as such words as "redskin." What's your take?

Rappers are just that rappers. Some I would approve others I would not. It would be like asking if you approve of writers using the word. Mark Twain I would approve. David Duke I would not. I don't approve of the word in general but the context is important.
 
Again as Dolf pointed out, no one engaged in Rory type behavior to ostracize her. Some condemned her choice of language but no one said "don't be friends with her" or "don't be friends with anyone who talks to her."
well there are very few posters who do engage in that kind of behaviour, who set themselves up as the morality police and think they have the right to dictate who anyone talks to, who troll anyone who'll give so much as a polite greeting to those on their diss lists.
they hardly make a mob and they certainly don't lead the rest of us.
 
Rappers are just that rappers. Some I would approve others I would not. It would be like asking if you approve of writers using the word. Mark Twain I would approve. David Duke I would not. I don't approve of the word in general but the context is important.

That's an excellent response, actually. I hadn't really thought about it in terms of Twain and Duke.

I've been fascinated by the power of the word for a long time. I keep meaning to read Randall Kennedy's book about it. It's an almost unique cultural-linguistic phenomenon, and so wrapped up in our cultural history.

(Book.)
 
You may have had a point about the context, aside from that fact that you don't have a point. Here is why:



Yes, she apologises for her temper immediately afterwards. She doesn't try to take back the portion of her post that is in bold above. Basically, her apology says "Hey, sorry about my bad temper, by the way, I'm still a racist, and I freely admit it." She didn't apologise for being racist in the first place, nor for bringing it here to a public forum. She apologised merely for allowing her temper to get so far out of control that she spit out the worst part of herself for all to see. She wasn't sorry she hates black people, she was sorry she let the rest of us know it. She even goes so far as to say she apologises "but speaks the truth."

A few posts later she goes on about Obama wearing faggy dress shoes. A lesser offense, but still a minor offense in my eyes, since the word faggot really fucking bothers me.

As far as Sonny, Bronze ect go, you are entitled to your opinion, as am I. In my opinion her original post above is what upset me. This thread I find in very poor taste, but it didn't upset me as much. My opinion is that I feel saddened by reading these posts from Ginny. Why do I feel saddened? It has nothing to do with jumping on a bandwagon for me, I could be the only one who felt this way and I assure you I would still feel this way. I am saddened because I can't bring myself to think of someone who openly admits to being a racist with that much hatred backing it up as a person with a beautiful mind worthy of my admiration. I agree there are many facets of Ginny that are still amazing and beautiful, but for me, her boldly stating she is a racist, and then backing it up by saying she spoke the truth will always tarnish her beauty. I am entitled to have that opinion, and I am entitled to lament the loss of my ability to further view Ginny in such high regard.
Fuck, I hate doing this.

I've given you a fair amount of shit in the past but, I have to admit, you have done a great deal to redeem yourself in my eyes over the last few weeks.
 
Okay, the pedophelia comparison doesn't work for you. Obviously you can't see past how they are different to see how they can be viewed as the same in the context I provided. That's besides the point. My bad. Here's my question "When does "a bunch of people having the same opinion turn into group think?" This thread had taken a lot of twists and turns prior to your sarcastic post about "bad, bad Ginny." As Dolf said, more people were like "wtf?" Why is it group think that a bunch of disapprove of her use of that language. Again as Dolf pointed out, no one engaged in Rory type behavior to ostracize her. Some condemned her choice of language but no one said "don't be friends with her" or "don't be friends with anyone who talks to her."

Just because stranger things have happened doesn't mean it's not worth commenting on.

I never said Ginny was a horrible person without any redeeming qualities. I am saying that being a racist is a deal breaker for me. I didn't say anyone else had to use that as their standard. People judge situations, ideas and people all the time. It isn't always a bad thing. Judgement can keep us alive or kill us depending on the danger of the circumstances. Wasn't your comment about "bad, bad Ginny" a judgement of everyone who criticized her in this thread?

A group is a group, but different groups are different. I reject the context you used. Deal with it, or don't. I won't think less of you for it.

Group think is anything you think it is. The term is always used in the negative. It is a judgment bestowed on those we believe are wrong. Socially sanctioned racism was groupthink. It was accepted as normal and proper.

Yes, my "bad, bad, Ginny" comment was not a judgment on everyone, just some. I have a lot of friends. Some are good and some are bad. None of them are perfect. I can defend my friends as needed, without defending their actions.

I have seen some reprehensible acts committed by people on this board. Since it did not involve racism or pedophilia, they were given a pass by their friends. It was either ignored or excused. The most common excuse was, "it's personal business and not my place to say." Everybody goes on, happily posting, day after day.

If one's friends can't stand by you and deal with your problems personally, what is the point of having friends? If life was just a popularity contest, cheerleaders would lead the world.
 
That's an excellent response, actually. I hadn't really thought about it in terms of Twain and Duke.

I've been fascinated by the power of the word for a long time. I keep meaning to read Randall Kennedy's book about it. It's an almost unique cultural-linguistic phenomenon, and so wrapped up in our cultural history.

(Book.)

What I think a lot of people miss around here is that the casual use of the word is not a series of isolated incidents but a atmosphere of racism.

If you have young children you view these incidents differently just as any parents would when news there is some creepy guy in a van asking children if they want candy. If you have no children you can say it's awful and change channel. If you have small children that news is not as easily dismissed and requires action on your part to protect your loved ones.
 
In their mind they truly believed blacks to be sub-human, unentitled to basic human considerations. And then passing that poison on to future generations...

I thank you for including the word "blacks" there...

..."fetuses" probably would've just started another barrage.

Thank God "blacks" today are considered human at least, huh?

Hopefully, one day, the age-old human race haters will too give way enough that the unborn will be accorded their God-given individual right to life...
 
What I think a lot of people miss around here is that the casual use of the word is not a series of isolated incidents but a atmosphere of racism.

If you have young children you view these incidents differently just as any parents would when news there is some creepy guy in a van asking children if they want candy. If you have no children you can say it's awful and change channel. If you have small children that news is not as easily dismissed and requires action on your part to protect your loved ones.

I see what you mean. It's reminiscent of some of the points made by feminists, actually, in large part based on the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. Well, an arguable extension of it, anyway. That's more or less the reason I barely ever use the word. I don't like it, and while I think I can use it without racism, I don't want to create an environment where other people thinks it's okay used as an epithet.

Maybe I should explain: The only times I ever use it are 1) obviously, when discussing the word itself, 2) when--and this is extremely rare--I happen to be quoting something like song lyrics, and 3) to refer playfully to a white friend of mine when no one else is around, as a way of irritating him. Though I haven't done that for years, as he stopped reacting and it wasn't fun any more.
 
A group is a group, but different groups are different. I reject the context you used. Deal with it, or don't. I won't think less of you for it.

Group think is anything you think it is. The term is always used in the negative. It is a judgment bestowed on those we believe are wrong. Socially sanctioned racism was groupthink. It was accepted as normal and proper.

Yes, my "bad, bad, Ginny" comment was not a judgment on everyone, just some. I have a lot of friends. Some are good and some are bad. None of them are perfect. I can defend my friends as needed, without defending their actions.

I have seen some reprehensible acts committed by people on this board. Since it did not involve racism or pedophilia, they were given a pass by their friends. It was either ignored or excused. The most common excuse was, "it's personal business and not my place to say." Everybody goes on, happily posting, day after day.

If one's friends can't stand by you and deal with your problems personally, what is the point of having friends? If life was just a popularity contest, cheerleaders would lead the world.

Obviously, group think has different meanings for each of us. Unfortunately, either you don't want to define what it means for you or you can't. No biggie.

I've seen bad things done on this board that didn't have to do with either racism or pedophelia. I've also commented on what I thought about them in the same way. The best example is the comments RDS has made about A_J's daughter. Perhaps others didn't comment on them because they had the same attitudes towards "friends" that you have.

Personally, my friends tend to have the same values as I do for the most part. My best friend is a very vocal supporter of the Palestinians. He's free to have different opinions and we've had plenty of heated discussions on the topic, but we've never had a fight. I've walked away from some friendships and I've strengthened others as I've seen their values and beliefs in action.

I had one friend who thought it was okay to hit a woman. It didn't matter to me how much fun I have had with him over the years, we had different core values regarding violence towards women. I couldn't get past that. Again, I'm perfectly comfortable with my decision. That doesn't make it a popularity contest at all, just a different set of criteria for whom I choose to call friends.
 
I thank you for including the word "blacks" there...

..."fetuses" probably would've just started another barrage.

Thank God "blacks" today are considered human at least, huh?

Hopefully, one day, the age-old human race haters will too give way enough that the unborn will be accorded their God-given individual right to life...

No one can even look your posts in the eyer anymore without laughing. I had you pegged weeks ago. Now, tell us who you were. I mean after Michael...
 
No one can even look your posts in the eyer anymore without laughing. I had you pegged weeks ago. Now, tell us who you were. I mean after Michael...

You really need to thank God the only thing you truly have "pegged" is the empty space between your ears...

...why don't you go ahead, airy, and tell "us" who I was..."I mean after Michael"...

Remember your first PM to me, Image?

You should've kept believing yourself...

Weak, wary women who don't have the courage to stand for truth are not attractive to me in any way, Image...

Sorry.
 
Obviously, group think has different meanings for each of us. Unfortunately, either you don't want to define what it means for you or you can't. No biggie.

I've seen bad things done on this board that didn't have to do with either racism or pedophelia. I've also commented on what I thought about them in the same way. The best example is the comments RDS has made about A_J's daughter. Perhaps others didn't comment on them because they had the same attitudes towards "friends" that you have.

Personally, my friends tend to have the same values as I do for the most part. My best friend is a very vocal supporter of the Palestinians. He's free to have different opinions and we've had plenty of heated discussions on the topic, but we've never had a fight. I've walked away from some friendships and I've strengthened others as I've seen their values and beliefs in action.



I had one friend who thought it was okay to hit a woman. It didn't matter to me how much fun I have had with him over the years, we had different core values regarding violence towards women. I couldn't get past that. Again, I'm perfectly comfortable with my decision. That doesn't make it a popularity contest at all, just a different set of criteria for whom I choose to call friends.

I had a friend like that, too. I went over to his house and stood in the doorway while his girlfriend packed her stuff and left him. It was an uncomfortable decision, at least for while. He threatened to kick my ass and I said, "You'll never have a better chance. Go for it." By the time he made up his mind, she was ready to leave.

In my last personal battle with real life racism, I did not fare as well. Given the chance to do it over, I would do the same thing again. As I am a middle aged white man, living in a southern state, the opportunities are often available. If you want details, send me a pm. There is no way to tell the story without seeming self righteous.

Groupthink is the phenomena of a large number of people accepting an idea as correct and proper. The chief characteristic of groupthink is group members assume all in the group agree.

Close enough? Have you ever seen it used in a positive sense? The modern idea that racism is bad is now shared by a large group of people, but I have never seen that called "groupthink."

I have commented on how easily charges of pedophilia are inserted into political arguments. It comes from the "if you can't convince a man your argument is sound, call him a pedophile" school of debate.

It is so common now, it's hard to remember who made the charge, or when. You may have noticed I refrain from name calling in posts. It serves no purpose.

I have traded posts with our resident pedophile in his several usernames. I do not believe there was anything ambiguous about my position.
 
I had a friend like that, too. I went over to his house and stood in the doorway while his girlfriend packed her stuff and left him. It was an uncomfortable decision, at least for while. He threatened to kick my ass and I said, "You'll never have a better chance. Go for it." By the time he made up his mind, she was ready to leave.

In my last personal battle with real life racism, I did not fare as well. Given the chance to do it over, I would do the same thing again. As I am a middle aged white man, living in a southern state, the opportunities are often available. If you want details, send me a pm. There is no way to tell the story without seeming self righteous.

Groupthink is the phenomena of a large number of people accepting an idea as correct and proper. The chief characteristic of groupthink is group members assume all in the group agree.

Close enough? Have you ever seen it used in a positive sense? The modern idea that racism is bad is now shared by a large group of people, but I have never seen that called "groupthink."

I have commented on how easily charges of pedophilia are inserted into political arguments. It comes from the "if you can't convince a man your argument is sound, call him a pedophile" school of debate.

It is so common now, it's hard to remember who made the charge, or when. You may have noticed I refrain from name calling in posts. It serves no purpose.

I have traded posts with our resident pedophile in his several usernames. I do not believe there was anything ambiguous about my position.

I didn't question your real life commitment to fighting racism. I just commented that it sounded rather self-righteous which is what those who chose to comment on what Ginny posted were accused of.

As far as engaging in group think or a mob mentality goes, I thought that was the main point of your initial post. If I was wrong I'm happy to admit it. But to use the wife beating analogy, if someone posted that they did it and were proud of it and a bunch of posters disagreed, would they be guilty of group think or would they just all have the same opinion? I view that accusation sort of the way I view posters who use the word "sheeple." It's a cheap way of deriding someone else's opinion.

For the record, I didn't use the pedophilia argument to minimize anyone else's opinion, I did it to try and draw a comparison about the "group think" accusation. And while I was the one who used the phrase, I thought you certainly implied that concept in your post. Again, if I was wrong I am happy to admit it. I would also point out that I haven't called you any names either.

I don't follow who or what was accused of anything on these boards unless I pretty much stumble acorss it. Nor do I tell anyone else who they can or can't post with. I thought this thread would have some good porn in it when I read the title. My mistake.
 
You really need to thank God the only thing you truly have "pegged" is the empty space between your ears...

...why don't you go ahead, airy, and tell "us" who I was..."I mean after Michael"...

Remember your first PM to me, Image?You should've kept believing yourself...

Weak, wary women who don't have the courage to stand for truth are not attractive to me in any way, Image...

Sorry.

You're going to have to refresh my memory :rolleyes: Post it if you still have it. (translated as: You're full of crap, I never would have PM'd you as who you portray yourself currently)
 
That's an excellent response, actually. I hadn't really thought about it in terms of Twain and Duke.

I've been fascinated by the power of the word for a long time. I keep meaning to read Randall Kennedy's book about it. It's an almost unique cultural-linguistic phenomenon, and so wrapped up in our cultural history.

(Book.)

There's two important concepts here, the power that words have and the context (or intent) with which they are spoken. Words only have as much power as we give them, especially with regard to being hurt by them. As far as the comment Ginny made, it didn't hurt or offend me personally. That doesn't mean that the context with which it was were used were offensive. Her intent in using them was clear. In other words, they definitely seemed more Duke-ish than Twain-esque.
 
No one can even look your posts in the eyer anymore without laughing. I had you pegged weeks ago. Now, tell us who you were. I mean after Michael...

His style is the same with all his alts... I just wonder wonder why he feels the need.
 
You're going to have to refresh my memory :rolleyes: Post it if you still have it. (translated as: You're full of crap, I never would have PM'd you as who you portray yourself currently)

I've never "portray"ed myself any different on this board, Image...

...the way behind you is totally clear - you can commence backtracking at your leisure.

But, before you go...how "full of crap" are you?

Edit:

Just posted the link to the PM...but it seems that leaves my CP open to others...let me get back to you...
 
Last edited:
I've never "portray"ed myself any different on this board, Image...

...the way behind you is totally clear - you can commence backtracking at your leisure.

But, before you go...how "full of crap" are you?

Edit:

Just posted the link to the PM...but it seems that leaves my CP open to others...let me get back to you...

Please do, I'll wait...

Did anyone else see it? Come on, it was up for 3 minutes...
 
I've never "portray"ed myself any different on this board, Image...

...the way behind you is totally clear - you can commence backtracking at your leisure.

But, before you go...how "full of crap" are you?

Edit:

Just posted the link to the PM...but it seems that leaves my CP open to others...let me get back to you...

Only the lowest of slimeballs post PM's.
 
Please do, I'll wait...

Did anyone else see it? Come on, it was up for 3 minutes...

A link to a pm sends you to the log-on page, unless it is your pm box and you are logged on. It does not give anyone access to someones control panel.
 
Back
Top