Here's a question

Leeloo777

Really Experienced
Joined
Jul 2, 2011
Posts
166
I'm going to phrase this as delicately as I possibly can.

The issue of pedophilia is a sensitive one, and rightly so. However, do you think there can be varying degrees of such a thing?

IE: I think there is a world of difference between an 18-year-old having sex with his/her 17-year-old bf/gf versus a 40-year-old man/woman(pervert) doing the same with a 4,5,6,7etc-year-old child.

Would you prosecute the 18-year-old to the full extent as you would the 40-year old?

At what point can you draw the line? Or can you? Since the legal age of consent differs from country to country, how can you determine where the cut-off is, or where to apply leniency?

Very technically speaking, a human achieves "maturity" when they go through puberty. For girls, this can be rather early. Still, I'm of the opinion that a 13,14, 15-year-old is still way too young to even be thinking of having sex. Hell, I think 16 is still too young to be allowed to drive.

Is the issue really age or mental/physical maturity? Not to mention that teenagers' hormones are generally going crazy. Is it really prudent or realistic to assume that they must abstain until they hit that 18-year mark?

If so, then why aren't teen fathers (or teen mothers for that matter) being charged with a crime? In my high school, there was a daycare center on campus so teen mothers could leave their children there while they went to attend class. No one seemed to think this was odd in the least.

Also, how would you legally handle two underage teens who were proven to be active?

Note: I'm only curious. There is no intent to offend.
 
I'm going to phrase this as delicately as I possibly can.

The issue of pedophilia is a sensitive one, and rightly so. However, do you think there can be varying degrees of such a thing?

IE: I think there is a world of difference between an 18-year-old having sex with his/her 17-year-old bf/gf versus a 40-year-old man/woman(pervert) doing the same with a 4,5,6,7etc-year-old child.

Would you prosecute the 18-year-old to the full extent as you would the 40-year old?

At what point can you draw the line? Or can you? Since the legal age of consent differs from country to country, how can you determine where the cut-off is, or where to apply leniency?

Very technically speaking, a human achieves "maturity" when they go through puberty. For girls, this can be rather early. Still, I'm of the opinion that a 13,14, 15-year-old is still way too young to even be thinking of having sex. Hell, I think 16 is still too young to be allowed to drive.

Is the issue really age or mental/physical maturity? Not to mention that teenagers' hormones are generally going crazy. Is it really prudent or realistic to assume that they must abstain until they hit that 18-year mark?

If so, then why aren't teen fathers (or teen mothers for that matter) being charged with a crime? In my high school, there was a daycare center on campus so teen mothers could leave their children there while they went to attend class. No one seemed to think this was odd in the least.

Also, how would you legally handle two underage teens who were proven to be active?

Note: I'm only curious. There is no intent to offend.

Why are you wondering so generally...

...when there are both federal and state statues already in place that specifically address your concerns?
 
Why are you wondering so generally...

...when there are both federal and state statues already in place that specifically address your concerns?

Because I'm interested in the opinions of others.

EDIT: And because I have a young daughter. This is an issue I'm likely going to have to deal with when she gets older and more independent.
 
Last edited:
Because I'm interested in the opinions of others.

EDIT: And because I have a young daughter. This is an issue I'm likely going to have to deal with when she gets older and more independent.

So...

...which do you think will be more beneficial to your curiosity and your daughter's development: the laws of the land or "the opinions of others"?
 
So...

...which do you think will be more beneficial to your curiosity and your daughter's development: the laws of the land or "the opinions of others"?

The laws of the land must be obeyed regardless of opinion. Even so, it can still be brought up for discussion.
 
The laws of the land must be obeyed regardless of opinion. Even so, it can still be brought up for discussion.

Not true: obeying - in any way - is a natural choice...

...while being trained to obey is the world's way of keeping the natural chaos of the universe on some sort of manageable level, so that man can have some illusion that s/he is in charge of human destiny (when nature states that just one mighty sunflare, eg, can wipe that destiny crap of man's instantly off of his face).

But, anyway: are you more interested in "the opinions of others"...

...or the laws that specifically address the concerns you raised in the OP, and are precisely applicable to the state you and your daughter live in?
 
Not true: obeying - in any way - is a natural choice...

...while being trained to obey is the world's way of keeping the natural chaos of the universe on some sort of manageable level, so that man can have some illusion that s/he is in charge of human destiny (when nature states that just one mighty sunflare, eg, can wipe that destiny crap of man's instantly off of his face).

But, anyway: are you more interested in "the opinions of others"...

...or the laws that specifically address the concerns you raised in the OP, and are precisely applicable to the state you and your daughter live in?

Alright, I'll give you that.

I'm both interested and concerned. Laws can be changed and revised. Some are plausible, while others are completely bizzare.

Should I tote the importance of abstaining or should I be a mother who provides birth-control? Parents cannot be everywhere all the time. Especially single ones. Public opinion can be harsh... especially against parents concerning the behaviors of their kids.

Say she brought home a 30-year-old when she turns 18? I think that'd be inappropriate, even though the law states that she is a legal adult.
 
i don't think she's a jackass; I think she's just curious.

There have been cases where 18 year old boys still in high school have been charged with the statutory rape of their 16 year old girlfriends when the parents find out that consensual sex or other acts codified by law (i.e., oral sex) have been going on. And personally I think that's bullshit.
 
Alright, I'll give you that.

I'm both interested and concerned. Laws can be changed and revised. Some are plausible, while others are completely bizzare.

Should I tote the importance of abstaining or should I be a mother who provides birth-control? Parents cannot be everywhere all the time. Especially single ones. Public opinion can be harsh... especially against parents concerning the behaviors of their kids.

Say she brought home a 30-year-old when she turns 18? I think that'd be inappropriate, even though the law states that she is a legal adult.

How old are you?
 
I was just reading about age of consent reform. Apparently many Countries have implemented close-in-age exemptions. You'll have to look for your state to figure out if they've passed such a law.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_consent_reform

In "the hat" sex between 15/16 years olds and partners up to 5 years older are exempt. Which seems rather liberal. I'd rather see it at 4 years older. However it frees up to the courts to deal with less superfluous cases so that's good.
 
i don't think she's a jackass; I think she's just curious.

There have been cases where 18 year old boys still in high school have been charged with the statutory rape of their 16 year old girlfriends when the parents find out that consensual sex or other acts codified by law (i.e., oral sex) have been going on. And personally I think that's bullshit.
Me too.
 
i don't think she's a jackass; I think she's just curious.

There have been cases where 18 year old boys still in high school have been charged with the statutory rape of their 16 year old girlfriends when the parents find out that consensual sex or other acts codified by law (i.e., oral sex) have been going on. And personally I think that's bullshit.



not in this state. 16 is legal.

and it wouldn't be pedophilia even if it wasn't. words have meanings.
 
not in this state. 16 is legal.

and it wouldn't be pedophilia even if it wasn't. words have meanings.

The meaning of pedophilia is "sexual attraction towards children". If you're below the age of majority, guess what? Legally you are considered a child.

Yes, the age of consent varies by state. But regardless of that, the act can still be defined as pedophilia if the person is below the age of majority.

Regardless of the age of consent in a state - and it can be two 16 year olds, or a 16 year old with a 15 year old, and so on - the person convicted becomes a registered sex offender. The only people on that registry are convicted pedophiles.

So yes, they are considered as such under the law.
 
Last edited:
i don't think she's a jackass; I think she's just curious.

There have been cases where 18 year old boys still in high school have been charged with the statutory rape of their 16 year old girlfriends when the parents find out that consensual sex or other acts codified by law (i.e., oral sex) have been going on. And personally I think that's bullshit.

Thank you. And yes, in some cases it's treated as a double-standard. Sometimes it's alright, other times it isn't. I don't think it's right to prosecute an 18-year-old either.

I was just reading about age of consent reform. Apparently many Countries have implemented close-in-age exemptions. You'll have to look for your state to figure out if they've passed such a law.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_consent_reform

In "the hat" sex between 15/16 years olds and partners up to 5 years older are exempt. Which seems rather liberal. I'd rather see it at 4 years older. However it frees up to the courts to deal with less superfluous cases so that's good.

I read a study and I believe it stated that humans don't reach their mental maturity, as far as decision-making capabilities, until their mid-twenties. Don't quote me, I may be remembering incorrectly.

As far as relationships go, I also prefer young people to date closer to their age. Something about an "Of-age" teen and a much older adult is off to me. Still, law dictates that it would be alright. But as a parent, this terrifies me. That older man could still be preying on a much younger girl.

The age laws in this state are strangely divided anyhow; at 16, you are allowed to drive a vehicle - which can be disastrous. Given the mentality of many teens. At 18, you can move out on your own and vote for the leaders of the country, yet you're not considered adult enough to drink until you're 21.
 
Regardless of the age of consent in a state - and it can be two 16 year olds, or a 16 year old with a 15 year old, and so on - the person convicted becomes a registered sex offender. The only people on that registry are convicted pedophiles.

So yes, they are considered as such under the law.

that is one the stupidest things i have ever read here. you can get on the sex offender list in some states for taking a piss on the side of the highway.
 
Because I'm interested in the opinions of others.

EDIT: And because I have a young daughter. This is an issue I'm likely going to have to deal with when she gets older and more independent.
As a mother to 2 daughters, I feel for you. The only advice I can give you is in 2 parts.

1. ALWAYS ALWAYS be open with your daughter. Do not pretend sex does not exist..and do not pretend she will not sneak and do it anyway(you may end up a grandmother way too early). Be open! Talk to her. Make her sit and listen.

I was very fortunate...both my girls were just scared enough of me they did not want to face my disappointment. Both girls left high school not sexually active. I kept them busy, cheerleading(I went to every game), gymnastics, they both worked, both high GPA's. BE open! I pushed the fact that high school was brutal enough without mixing sex into the equation. To please wait til they were 18 and in college.

Yes Yes I know the trolls on here will blast me, but this worked for me. Oldest is out of college and successful. Still no babies...and my youngest is in college with a 3.9 GPA...she is on the right road.

2. Do not ever assume she wont. Id rather my daughters were on the pill and sneaking then not on the pill and sneaking. I was fortunate. Both my girls had to go on them for medical issues...so I knew I was pretty safe from an unplanned baby.

18 bringing home a 30 yr old man? no. I(and her dad) would die.
an 18 yr old getting in trouble for having sex with his/her 16 yr old SO? no.
 
I was just reading about age of consent reform. Apparently many Countries have implemented close-in-age exemptions. You'll have to look for your state to figure out if they've passed such a law.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_consent_reform

In "the hat" sex between 15/16 years olds and partners up to 5 years older are exempt. Which seems rather liberal. I'd rather see it at 4 years older. However it frees up to the courts to deal with less superfluous cases so that's good.

That's a good start.

Thank you. And yes, in some cases it's treated as a double-standard. Sometimes it's alright, other times it isn't. I don't think it's right to prosecute an 18-year-old either.



I read a study and I believe it stated that humans don't reach their mental maturity, as far as decision-making capabilities, until their mid-twenties. Don't quote me, I may be remembering incorrectly.

As far as relationships go, I also prefer young people to date closer to their age. Something about an "Of-age" teen and a much older adult is off to me. Still, law dictates that it would be alright. But as a parent, this terrifies me. That older man could still be preying on a much younger girl.

The age laws in this state are strangely divided anyhow; at 16, you are allowed to drive a vehicle - which can be disastrous. Given the mentality of many teens. At 18, you can move out on your own and vote for the leaders of the country, yet you're not considered adult enough to drink until you're 21.

You're correct on that with some modification. Women****** are approx. 3 years mentally more mature than males from puberty up to that age. Women****** will reach risk assessment maturity in their early to mid 20's, men in their mid to late 20's. But that only speaks to brain maturity, not raging hormones.

Ishmael
 
Thank you. And yes, in some cases it's treated as a double-standard. Sometimes it's alright, other times it isn't. I don't think it's right to prosecute an 18-year-old either.



I read a study and I believe it stated that humans don't reach their mental maturity, as far as decision-making capabilities, until their mid-twenties. Don't quote me, I may be remembering incorrectly.

As far as relationships go, I also prefer young people to date closer to their age. Something about an "Of-age" teen and a much older adult is off to me. Still, law dictates that it would be alright. But as a parent, this terrifies me. That older man could still be preying on a much younger girl.

The age laws in this state are strangely divided anyhow; at 16, you are allowed to drive a vehicle - which can be disastrous. Given the mentality of many teens. At 18, you can move out on your own and vote for the leaders of the country, yet you're not considered adult enough to drink until you're 21.

No, I've read about the mid-twenties thing as well. It also seems to me that I've read about the whole age of consent thing being turned on its ass because some parent has a hissy fit that their precious girl has had sex at 16 with her 17/18 year old boyfriend. Then the poor guy is automatically registered as a sex offender.

If I ever had a son, I think I'd tell him not to date until he was in college - and then demand ID. I'm serious. I wouldn't prosecute an 18 year old guy for sleeping with my 16 year old (or even my 15 year old, if they're in high school and I know the kid) even if I'd really want to jerk a knot in both of them for doing it. At some point you relinquish control and hope you've taught your kids well enough that they know what they should and shouldn't be doing. But I'd be terrified of my 17, 18, or even my 16 year old son sleeping with his younger girlfriend, because if the parents got pissed off, my son's life could essentially be over.
 
that is one the stupidest things i have ever read here. you can get on the sex offender list in some states for taking a piss on the side of the highway.

Which is also unreasonable. When you have to go, you have to go. It doesn't mean you get your jollies because someone might see your genitals.

As a mother to 2 daughters, I feel for you. The only advice I can give you is in 2 parts.

1. ALWAYS ALWAYS be open with your daughter. Do not pretend sex does not exist..and do not pretend she will not sneak and do it anyway(you may end up a grandmother way too early). Be open! Talk to her. Make her sit and listen.

I was very fortunate...both my girls were just scared enough of me they did not want to face my disappointment. Both girls left high school not sexually active. I kept them busy, cheerleading(I went to every game), gymnastics, they both worked, both high GPA's. BE open! I pushed the fact that high school was brutal enough without mixing sex into the equation. To please wait til they were 18 and in college.

Yes Yes I know the trolls on here will blast me, but this worked for me. Oldest is out of college and successful. Still no babies...and my youngest is in college with a 3.9 GPA...she is on the right road.

2. Do not ever assume she wont. Id rather my daughters were on the pill and sneaking then not on the pill and sneaking. I was fortunate. Both my girls had to go on them for medical issues...so I knew I was pretty safe from an unplanned baby.

18 bringing home a 30 yr old man? no. I(and her dad) would die.
an 18 yr old getting in trouble for having sex with his/her 16 yr old SO? no.

Thank you. My mother was of the same mindset and as a result, I wasn't a teen mother, and I did not get into trouble with drugs or the law.

She's only five now, so who knows what the norm will be when she turns 18.
 
Which is also unreasonable. When you have to go, you have to go. It doesn't mean you get your jollies because someone might see your genitals.



Thank you. My mother was of the same mindset and as a result, I wasn't a teen mother, and I did not get into trouble with drugs or the law.

She's only five now, so who knows what the norm will be when she turns 18.
You are quite welcome. My mother wasn't of this mindset..and the crap I done. I was lucky I wasn't either killed, locked up or a teen mom.
My girls couldn't get away with anything...I had already been there and done that..and I let them know it. Needless to say they walked the straight and narrow.
Just be open...and never assume she wont. That is the best advice I can give any mother.
 
that is one the stupidest things i have ever read here. you can get on the sex offender list in some states for taking a piss on the side of the highway.

How, exactly, is that 'one of the stupidest things' you've ever read here? The situation you point out has nothing to do with my example or with the legal definition of pedophilia.
 
18 bringing home a 30 yr old man? no. I(and her dad) would die.

To be honest, I used to be very open minded about the whole age gap thing.

But one of my closest friends is in a relationship with a 19 year old.
They started dating the week after she turned 18.
There's a 20 something age gap.

And frankly, he might be kind, gentle, considerate etc etc...but they have nothing in common and the way he dresses her and paws over her in public is pretty freaking pathetic actually.

I keep trying to encourage her to find her own identity, stand up for herself, have some semblance of a backbone...but she has the personality of soggy beige clay.

So no...I have to retract my earlier opinion that age doesn't matter. It does. A lot.

He's just lucky that she's over 18 and therefore legally an adult, because her parents are rightly dissapproving of the whole thing.
 
Back
Top