God

Tryharder, you're trying so hard. And I appreciate that. So I'll do more than toss off bon mots. If you truly want to debate at this level you have to understand the rhetoric involved. I don't want you to look foolish. The example I gave above is a simplification of Russell's Teapot. Here you go.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot

This is why I don't have to prove God doesn't exist. If you really don't understand this point after here on, then we're done.
 
Prove it.

(Sweetie, you're showing your ignorance here. No one has to prove a negative. And no one who hasn't made a claim has to prove anything. It's rhetoric 101. Let me give you an example. If I claim "There's a raccoon living on Alpha Centauri" I don't then get to say to you "Prove there isn't." Do you understand?)

That's stupid. Raccoons live on Epsilon Eridani. Yaks live on Alpha Centauri.
 
Prove it.

(Sweetie, you're showing your ignorance here. No one has to prove a negative. And no one who hasn't made a claim has to prove anything. It's rhetoric 101. Let me give you an example. If I claim "There's a raccoon living on Alpha Centauri" I don't then get to say to you "Prove there isn't." Do you understand?)

(Darling, it is not I that am showing my ignorance here. You have made a claim that there is no God. It's common sense 101 that you too must prove it. It is not impossible to prove a negative. If I say there are no pennies in my right pocket, all I need to do is take all the objects out of the pocket, and in finding no pennies I have proved the claim. You are in denial that you have made a claim. Do you understand? )
 
Tryharder, you're trying so hard. And I appreciate that. So I'll do more than toss off bon mots. If you truly want to debate at this level you have to understand the rhetoric involved. I don't want you to look foolish. The example I gave above is a simplification of Russell's Teapot. Here you go.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot

This is why I don't have to prove God doesn't exist. If you really don't understand this point after here on, then we're done.

I didn't realize there were levels on this discussion. Your the upper level huh?
Me, I don't want to have the party line of rhetoric. I want to share my experience, strength and hope just as others do without being called a moron or being told to shut the fuck up. It sounds like Bertrand Russell was just a guy that couldn't make a case for what he believed so he just said that it doesn't make sense for him to have to. Whoopie!!!!!

I do understand the point you are making but I disagree with it, and I'm not going anywhere.
 
Let me make a prophecy about how this argument will end. Eventually TryHarder will run out of cut and paste content from HowToArgueWithAnAtheist.com and will be left with "I can believe whatever I want and you can't stop me!" and never return to the thread.

Bet me, motherfuckers.

I'm still here.
 
(Darling, it is not I that am showing my ignorance here. You have made a claim that there is no God. It's common sense 101 that you too must prove it. It is not impossible to prove a negative. If I say there are no pennies in my right pocket, all I need to do is take all the objects out of the pocket, and in finding no pennies I have proved the claim. You are in denial that you have made a claim. Do you understand? )
OK, we have searched the entire visible universe, billions of light-years in every direction, and never found anybody's hand out there.

There's also no firmament, trove of hailstones, or grapes of wrath out there.
 
OK, we have searched the entire visible universe, billions of light-years in every direction, and never found anybody's hand out there.

There's also no firmament, trove of hailstones, or grapes of wrath out there.

I believe in the Trinity. God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit as one God. When Jesus went back up to heaven, after he had reappeared, he sent his holy spirit to be with those who believed in him that remained. I guess I could use a line in a famous hymn to answer "You ask me how I know He lives? He lives within my heart."
 
I believe in the Trinity. God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit as one God. When Jesus went back up to heaven, after he had reappeared, he sent his holy spirit to be with those who believed in him that remained. I guess I could use a line in a famous hymn to answer "You ask me how I know He lives? He lives within my heart."

So, this spirit thing. How do you know this is what happened? Can you prove it? And remember, the onus is not with me to disprove it, it is on you to prove it. You are making the claim.
 
So, this spirit thing. How do you know this is what happened? Can you prove it? And remember, the onus is not with me to disprove it, it is on you to prove it. You are making the claim.

Fair warning I cannot prove it. It is a personal experience. I am sharing it because someone asked me a question. I am also not asking anyone here to believe the way that I do.

I was at the end of my rope when I asked God to take over and guide my life. There is no way to explain the presence I felt unless you have lived it. The peace.
 
God exists because people believe in him/her, his strength and power comes from those believers/worshipers/followers of his faith. Those that do not believe then to them god does not exist. So the question about proving yes or no has a simple answer of : Yes and No he is real...

over the many thousands of years on earth many many gods and Demi gods have had power of people simply because many people worshipped and followed, as the people stopped so did the gods stop to exist. Such as Zeus, because he is only known as a fictional god from movies he has stopped being a god yet if
Millions of people started to believe in him again he will be reborn.

this is the wise and powerful thoughts of a girl called Debbie worship me and I wil bring you peace to your world earthlings!!!
 
Fair warning I cannot prove it. It is a personal experience. I am sharing it because someone asked me a question. I am also not asking anyone here to believe the way that I do.

I was at the end of my rope when I asked God to take over and guide my life. There is no way to explain the presence I felt unless you have lived it. The peace.
A shot of dimethyltryptamine will do the same thing.
 
Tryharder62,
I am going to try hard to make this my last post on this thread because I think your belief in God and the Bible is rock solid. And as a result, nothing I say will sway you otherwise.

Now, notice above I have bolded think, so listen up. If I say "I think something is.....", then no one can argue the contrary. The thought that I think is mine and mine alone. So, if you say "I think there is a God" then I can't argue against that. I can say that "I think there isn't a God" and leave it at that. But when you say "God is real or I know God exists" I'm right in asking for proof. Your example of the pennies in your pocket was not a logical example of proving a negative. All you did there was confirm your statement that you had no pennies in your pocket.

Think about this: If I claimed I was a brain surgeon and applied for a job as such, I would be expected to provide evidence of my claim to being a brain surgeon. I wouldn't counter a request for evidence of my qualifications by saying "no, you prove I'm not a brain surgeon."

What irritates me is when you claim to have studied and weighed up the evidence/proofs contained in the Bible vs current scientific knowledge and you've come down in favour of the Bible. There. is. no. evidence. And be clear here that what I am saying is that there is no evidence in the Bible of the existence of a God. And not that there is no God. I would walk on by if your posts had said something like "I think God exists. I have faith in this."

You might just call it semantics, but it occurred to me that you may not fully understand why I have argued the toss with you on these religious threads.
 
Last edited:
Tryharder62,
I am going to try hard to make this my last post on this thread because I think your belief in God and the Bible is rock solid. And as a result, nothing I say will sway you otherwise.

Now, notice above I have bolded think, so listen up. If I say "I think something is.....", then no one can argue the contrary. The thought that I think is mine and mine alone. So, if you say "I think there is a God" then I can't argue against that. I can say that "I think there isn't a God" and leave it at that. But when you say "God is real or I know God exists" I'm right in asking for proof. Your example of the pennies in your pocket was not a logical example of proving a negative. All you did there was confirm your statement that you had no pennies in your pocket.

Think about this: If I claimed I was a brain surgeon and applied for a job as such, I would be expected to provide evidence of my claim to being a brain surgeon. I wouldn't counter a request for evidence of my qualifications by saying "no, you prove I'm not a brain surgeon."

What irritates me is when you claim to have studied and weighed up the evidence/proofs contained in the Bible vs current scientific knowledge and you've come down in favour of the Bible. There. is. no. evidence. And be clear here that what I am saying is that there is no evidence in the Bible of the existence of a God. And not that there is no God. I would walk on by if your posts had said something like "I think God exists. I have faith in this."

You might just call it semantics, but it occurred to me that you may not fully understand why I have argued the toss with you on these religious threads.

Thank you Fair warning. I think you are great. Nothing will change my mind about that.

Seriously, I do listen very carefully to what you say. I realize that it is difficult for natural man to believe in something that he cannot see or feel (1 Corintians 2:14) The Bible is not a textbook that attempts to prove the existence of God - The Bible opens with a positive statement that God does exist. "In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth."

All along I have said that I have looked at a lot of the arguments and have made the choice to believe in God. I thought about it - I made a choice. I know that it irritates you that I have looked at the evidence of the bible and current scientific knowledge and came down on the side of the bible. There is nothing I can do about that, our opinions just differ.

Thank you for making the attempt to clarify, but the truth is I think we are clear but that we disagree. I'm not going anywhere, so if you change your mind and want to talk, I am here. I have a bet to win from Dixon Carter Lee.:D
 
(Darling, it is not I that am showing my ignorance here. You have made a claim that there is no God. It's common sense 101 that you too must prove it. It is not impossible to prove a negative. If I say there are no pennies in my right pocket, all I need to do is take all the objects out of the pocket, and in finding no pennies I have proved the claim. You are in denial that you have made a claim. Do you understand? )

But you're not claiming there are no pennies in your pocket, you're claiming that there ARE pennies in your pocket. If there are, to prove it, all you need to do is take them out and show everyone.

Otherwise, I'll just call it what it is; a bluff.
 
(Darling, it is not I that am showing my ignorance here. You have made a claim that there is no God. It's common sense 101 that you too must prove it. It is not impossible to prove a negative. If I say there are no pennies in my right pocket, all I need to do is take all the objects out of the pocket, and in finding no pennies I have proved the claim. You are in denial that you have made a claim. Do you understand? )

Celestial teapot.
 
Spirit in the sky, a mighty wind, the breath of life, it's all the same stuff - air.

Phrodeau, I am not going to convince you, because you do have to have faith. That is what I have chosen to believe in and put my faith in. I respect your right not to choose it. :heart:
 
Back
Top