God

Dixon Carter Lee- Thank you for your response. It was very well put. The problem I have is with the hostility you exhibit to those who don't believe like you do. (It can be noted that you said I was douchey) I also get frustrated with people who bring up the so called "evils" Christians do like atheists have never done anything wrong. We are all human.

People like Stalin who was propagating athiesm - large numbers were persecuted and killed for practicing religion and for being interferences in the atheistic - communistic expansion. Mao Zedong whose Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution that is believed to have caused 40 to 70 million deaths. I don't take a broad stroke and say that everyone who is atheist is a mass murderer. I just wish people could judge me for who I am not because of their preconceived notions of the belief I choose to have.

Paragraph One: You're welcome. And please recognize that when you blithely say this and that about God as if it's a given he exists and everyone knows that you are royally pissing off the godless for taking us for granted and treating our convictions so dismissively. As I said above, every once in a while it's just fine that you get a taste of that kind of arrogance right back atcha.

Paragraph Two. Stalin was in no way propagating atheism. He was controlling dissent. And we'll have a discussion about the Culture of Celebrity as it Applies to Stalinist and Marxist Quasi-Theocratic States another time.

Thank you for asking actual questions.
 
Last edited:
So you are saying that it doesn't matter if the war was started for a religious reason or not it is still the believers fault. Then you say that "everyone" involved in war believes they have right on their side and that "their" God is watching over them. I think everyone is a pretty broad statement which would include you and your God.

I'll admit I wanted the Nazi's to lose. I am also all for Macarther praying for peace and enlisting someone who is willing to help.

As to your earlier post with eyer about hope being hope that our faith is right. I don't need hope that my faith is right. I have hope in Christ. I am 100% positive that I have made the right choice for me. I am also not arrogant enough to put anybody else down who chooses to believe different.

I can only show you the evidence of my life. Tell you the story of the peace that came into my life when I stopped trying to be god and gave control to a higher power I call Jesus Christ. I can tell you of experiences of feeling an immense presense when I had to make the terrible decision to stop treatment on my father - my best friend when he was at the end of his battle with cancer. I was not alone. Those things don't get far when people disagree with you. It is only my job to share it and let you take what you like and leave the rest.

I obviously didn't make my post clear enough.
During war, and I mean pretty much all wars, the most horrendous acts of violence have been carried out in the name of some particular brand of God.
 
Paragraph One: You're welcome. And please recognize that when you blithely say this and that about God as if it's a given he exists and everyone knows that you are royally pissing off the godless for taking us for granted and treating our convictions so dismissively. As I said above, every once in a while it's just fine that you get a taste of that kind of arrogance right back atcha.

Paragraph Two. Stalin was in no way propagating atheism. He was controlling dissent. And we'll have a discussion about the Culture of Celebrity as it Applies to Stalinist and Marxist Quasi-Theocratic States another time.

Thank you for asking actual questions.

Wooo! When have I ever carelessly said that God exists as if it is a given. I simply answered the question of this thread with my opinion which happens to differ from yours. Neither have I treated your convictions dismissively. I have listened with interest to your arguements and weighed them carefully. I think you are taking out your anger on all Christians on me. So, I do not like being told it is alright if you hurt me.

Although raised in the Georgian Orthodox faith, Stalin was an athiest. Stalin followed the position adopted by Lenin that religion was an opiate that needed to be removed in order to construct the ideal communist society. His goverment promoted atheism with special athiestic education in schools, antireligious propanda and the antireligious work of public instititutions. (Society of the Godless) There were also discriminatory laws and terror campaigns against relgious believers. By the mid 1930's it was very dangerous to be publically assoiciated with religion which is what I am afraid will soon happen again. Over 100,000 people were killed during the purge of 1937-1938. Yes they did dissent from Stalin's belief that there was no god. I guess it doesn't matter to some people that they were killed.

I have no problem with you being an athiest. I just choose to believe.

Your welcome.
 
I obviously didn't make my post clear enough.
During war, and I mean pretty much all wars, the most horrendous acts of violence have been carried out in the name of some particular brand of God.

See my post above. Stalin and Mao Zedong did may horrendous acts of violence toward people because they did not believe a particular brand of God. NO GOD . Every group has extremists.
 
Have any of you heard of a Goddess...we often just hear of a God....perhaps pagans and native americans had a less complicated approach to spirits and how our lives are effected by them.....
 
I don't think arguments about the acts of 'believers' or 'non believers' (for example, atheists) can be decisive.

But the facts about behavior do suggest that there is no necessary *improvement* of behavior
among either 'the religious' or, in particular 'the Christians'. I'm pretty sure the majority of those in
US prisons are Christian, as well as a majority of murderers executed. Further these executions themselves, for example in Texas or Florida (said to be highly Christian, indeed 'born again in Christ', demographically), show something about the alleged improvement in humane treatment of fellow humans, in these situations.
 
See my post above. Stalin and Mao Zedong did may horrendous acts of violence toward people because they did not believe a particular brand of God. NO GOD . Every group has extremists.

The point you are missing is that there is no causal relationship between the atheist position on God and acts of violence and socially disruptive behaviour. Atheists for the most part are not unifed, they don't act out their lack of belief en masse. Atheism is a choice, acted upon individually, to live life without theism. No war was ever waged in order to further a system that is based on a lack of belief. No, not ever.

I have never attempted to have others conform to my lack of belief. I go about the business of living my life without the expectation or hope that anyone else will follow my lead. My life is lived without deference to the religious laws laid down in the Bible. For example: I don't think it is wrong that a doctor helps terminate an often desperate woman's pregancy but I do think it is murder when someone kills a doctor because they helped a woman procure an abortion.


On the other hand there are countless examples I could give you where I have had to defer to a religious event or protocol. Christmas, Easter and so forth. Hey, I don't make a fuss, I eat the Easter Eggs and graciously accept the presents - but, I hope you understand the subtle point I make.

I need to correct you a little on Stalin. Stalin was a secular minded religious opportunist. When Stalin's star was on the rise it was at a time when whoever ruled the Church ruled Russia. He crushed the church, not in the name of atheism, but as a way to empower himself. When his power base was firmly establised he gave his blessing (excuse the pun!) to the Russian Othodox Church.

As for wars based on religion here's a clever little list I found. The only difference between the opposing sides were religion:

•Albigensian Crusade, 1208-49
•Algeria, 1992-
•Baha'is, 1848-54
•Bosnia, 1992-95
•Boxer Rebellion, 1899-1901
•Christian Romans, 30-313 CE
•Croatia, 1991-92
•English Civil War, 1642-46
•Holocaust, 1938-45
•Huguenot Wars, 1562-1598
•India, 1992-2002
•India: Suttee & Thugs
•Indo-Pakistani Partition, 1947
•Iran, Islamic Republic, 1979-
•Iraq, Shiites, 1991-92
•Jews, 1348
•Jonestown, 1978
•Lebanon 1860 / 1975-92
•Molucca Is., 1999-
•Mongolia, 1937-39
•Northern Ireland, 1974-98
•Russian pogroms 1905-06 / 1917-22
•St. Bartholemew Massacre, 1572
•Shang China, ca. 1300-1050 BCE
•Shimabara Revolt, Japan 1637-38
•Sikh uprising, India, 1984-91
•Spanish Inquisition, 1478-1834
•Taiping Rebellion, 1850-64
•Thirty Years War, 1618-48
•Tudor England
•Vietnam, 1800s
•Witch Hunts, 1400-1800
•Xhosa, 1857
•Arab Outbreak, 7th Century CE
•Arab-Israeli Wars, 1948-
•Al Qaeda, 1993-
•Crusades, 1095-1291
•Dutch Revolt, 1566-1609
•Nigeria, 1990s, 2000s
 
Last edited:
The point you are missing is that there is no causal relationship between the atheist position on God and acts of violence and socially disruptive behaviour. Atheists for the most part are not unifed, they don't act out their lack of belief en masse. Atheism is a choice, acted upon individually, to live life without theism. No war was ever waged in order to further a system that is based on a lack of belief. No, not ever.

I have never attempted to have others conform to my lack of belief. I go about the business of living my life without the expectation or hope that anyone else will follow my lead. My life is lived without deference to the religious laws laid down in the Bible. For example: I don't think it is wrong that a doctor helps terminate an often desperate woman's pregancy but I do think it is murder when someone kills a doctor because they helped a woman procure an abortion.


On the other hand there are countless examples I could give you where I have had to defer to a religious event or protocol. Christmas, Easter and so forth. Hey, I don't make a fuss, I eat the Easter Eggs and graciously accept the presents - but, I hope you understand the subtle point I make.

I need to correct you a little on Stalin. Stalin was a secular minded religious opportunist. When Stalin's star was on the rise it was at a time when whoever ruled the Church ruled Russia. He crushed the church, not in the name of atheism, but as a way to empower himself. When his power base was firmly establised he gave his blessing (excuse the pun!) to the Russian Othodox Church.

As for wars based on religion here's a clever little list I found. The only difference between the opposing sides were religion:

•Albigensian Crusade, 1208-49
•Algeria, 1992-
•Baha'is, 1848-54
•Bosnia, 1992-95
•Boxer Rebellion, 1899-1901
•Christian Romans, 30-313 CE
•Croatia, 1991-92
•English Civil War, 1642-46
•Holocaust, 1938-45
•Huguenot Wars, 1562-1598
•India, 1992-2002
•India: Suttee & Thugs
•Indo-Pakistani Partition, 1947
•Iran, Islamic Republic, 1979-
•Iraq, Shiites, 1991-92
•Jews, 1348
•Jonestown, 1978
•Lebanon 1860 / 1975-92
•Molucca Is., 1999-
•Mongolia, 1937-39
•Northern Ireland, 1974-98
•Russian pogroms 1905-06 / 1917-22
•St. Bartholemew Massacre, 1572
•Shang China, ca. 1300-1050 BCE
•Shimabara Revolt, Japan 1637-38
•Sikh uprising, India, 1984-91
•Spanish Inquisition, 1478-1834
•Taiping Rebellion, 1850-64
•Thirty Years War, 1618-48
•Tudor England
•Vietnam, 1800s
•Witch Hunts, 1400-1800
•Xhosa, 1857
•Arab Outbreak, 7th Century CE
•Arab-Israeli Wars, 1948-
•Al Qaeda, 1993-
•Crusades, 1095-1291
•Dutch Revolt, 1566-1609
•Nigeria, 1990s, 2000s


History simply does not support the hypothesis that religion is the major cause of conflict. I never said that some wars weren't caused by religion. The wars of the ancient world were rarely, if ever, based on religion. These wars were for territorial conquest to control boarders, secure trade routes, or respond to an internal challenge to political authority. In fact, the ancient conquerors whether Egyptian, Babylonnian, Persian, Greek or Roman openly welcomed the religious beliefs of those they conquered and often added the new gods to their own pantheon.

Medieval and Renaissance wars were also typically about control and wealth as city-states vied for power, often with the support, but rarely instigation of the Church. And the Mongol Asian rampage, which is thought to have killed nearly 30 million people, had no religious component whatsoever.

Most modern wars, including the Napoleonic Campaign, the American Revolution, the French Revolution, the American Cival War, World War 1, the Russian reviolution, World war 2 and the conflicts in Korea and Vietnam were not religious in nature or cause. While religious groups have been specifially targeted (most noteably in World War 2) to claim that religion is the cause is to blame the victim and to misunderstand the perpetrators motives, which were nationalistic and ethnic, not religious.

You said Athiem is a choice acted on individually. Stalin made that choice. You can't misinterprete his statement "You know they are fooling us...there is no God. All this talk about God is nonsense."

Similarly, the vast numbers of genocides (those killed in ethnic cleanses, purges, etc. that are not connected to declared war) are not based on religion. It is estimated that over 160 million civilians were killed in genocides in the 20th century alone.

The fact is People kill People. Religion only gets singled out because it is socially acceptable to do so.
 
Last edited:
History simply does not support the hypothesis that religion is the major cause of conflict. I never said that some wars weren't caused by religion. The wars of the ancient world were rarely, if ever, based on religion. These wars were for territorial conquest to control boarders, secure trade routes, or respond to an internal challenge to political authority. In fact, the ancient conquerors whether Egyptian, Babylonnian, Persian, Greek or Roman openly welcomed the religious beliefs of those they conquered and often added the new gods to their own pantheon.

Medieval and Renaissance wars were also typically about control and wealth as city-states vied for power, often with the support, but rarely instigation of the Church. And the Mongol Asian rampage, which is thought to have killed nearly 30 million people, had no religious component whatsoever.

Most modern wars, including the Napoleonic Campaign, the American Revolution, the French Revolution, the American Cival War, World War 1, the Russian reviolution, World war 2 and the conflicts in Korea and Vietnam were not religious in nature or cause. While religious groups have been specifially targeted (most noteably in World War 2) to claim that religion is the cause is to blame the victim and to misunderstand the perpetrators motives, which were nationalistic and ethnic, not religious.

You said Athiem is a choice acted on individually. Stalin made that choice. You can't misinterprete his statement "You know they are fooling us...there is no God. All this talk about God is nonsense."

Similarly, the vast numbers of genocides (those killed in ethnic cleanses, purges, etc. that are not connected to declared war) are not based on religion. It is estimated that over 160 million civilians were killed in genocides in the 20th century alone.

The fact is People kill People. Religion only gets singled out because it is socially acceptable to do so.

You continue to miss the point. When a war erupts, regardless of what the core reason was, the combatants, almost always, believe that they are right and that, as a result their God supports the conflict.

I'm sure at some stage Stalin did say "...there is no God". But he didn't rely on other atheists to take up his fight. He saw an opportunity and took it. He did what he did to further his political power base.

Most of your post above is c&p'd from Rabbi Alan Lurie who also said:
"Of course the Hebrew Bible chronicles many wars -- most notably Moses' conflicts in the desert and Joshua's conquest of the nations of Canaan -- and we may see these as examples of religiously sanctioned violence. Here, though, we must recognize that archeological evidence points to the conclusion that these conquests never occurred, or at least not as dramatically as described in the Bible. As one who reads the Bible for spiritual truths, not historical facts, I am, of course, quite happy that no such slaughters occurred. The ancient Rabbis also understood these stories not as celebrated victories, but as warnings about the dangers of warfare."

Religion doesn't get singled out because it's socially acceptable. Religion gets singled out because so many prissy God botherers assume that without God, religion and faith, athesists somehow live lesser lives than those with faith. Trust me, I am missing out on nothing. The good that I do is done without duress - I fear no hell or eternal torment. I live a good life - I have two wonderful children who were raised without God but understand what goodness and kindness are.

Btw, do you also support Rabbi Luries belief that not all archeological evidence supports the notion that the Bible should always be taken in a literal sense?
 
Last edited:
Richard Feynman, an atheist, once said that the core problem for atheists is an answer to the question, WHY IS THERE SOMETHING INSTEAD OF NOTHING. The universe is cluttered with stuff and natural laws.
 
Richard Feynman, an atheist, once said that the core problem for atheists is an answer to the question, WHY IS THERE SOMETHING INSTEAD OF NOTHING. The universe is cluttered with stuff and natural laws.

Wtf is a natural law as opposed to one that is not natural?
 
You continue to miss the point. When a war erupts, regardless of what the core reason was, the combatants, almost always, believe that they are right and that, as a result their God supports the conflict.

I'm sure at some stage Stalin did say "...there is no God". But he didn't rely on other atheists to take up his fight. He saw an opportunity and took it. He did what he did to further his political power base.

Most of your post above is c&p'd from Rabbi Alan Lurie who also said:
"Of course the Hebrew Bible chronicles many wars -- most notably Moses' conflicts in the desert and Joshua's conquest of the nations of Canaan -- and we may see these as examples of religiously sanctioned violence. Here, though, we must recognize that archeological evidence points to the conclusion that these conquests never occurred, or at least not as dramatically as described in the Bible. As one who reads the Bible for spiritual truths, not historical facts, I am, of course, quite happy that no such slaughters occurred. The ancient Rabbis also understood these stories not as celebrated victories, but as warnings about the dangers of warfare."

Religion doesn't get singled out because it's socially acceptable. Religion gets singled out because so many prissy God botherers assume that without God, religion and faith, athesists somehow live lesser lives than those with faith. Trust me, I am missing out on nothing. The good that I do is done without duress - I fear no hell or eternal torment. I live a good life - I have two wonderful children who were raised without God but understand what goodness and kindness are.

Btw, do you also support Rabbi Luries belief that not all archeological evidence supports the notion that the Bible should always be taken in a literal sense?

What you are really saying is that no matter what the real reason wars are started blame the - "prissy God Botherers". Does the fact that Stalin carried out his athiestic beliefs without enlisting other athiests somehow make it O.K?

Listen, I do not assume that athiests somehow live lesser lives than those with faith. I am glad you are missing out on nothing. The good I do is without duress-I do it because I care. I live a good life-I have two wonderful children who are raised with God but understand what goodness and kindess are. Why is it so hard to let me just let me live my life too?

No, as you know, I do not support Ravvi Luries belief that not all archeological evidence supports the notion that the Bible should be taken literally. I just have the ability to look at each piece of information and decide for myself if the data used to make that claim is true or false.
 
What you are really saying is that no matter what the real reason wars are started blame the - "prissy God Botherers". Does the fact that Stalin carried out his athiestic beliefs without enlisting other athiests somehow make it O.K?

Listen, I do not assume that athiests somehow live lesser lives than those with faith. I am glad you are missing out on nothing. The good I do is without duress-I do it because I care. I live a good life-I have two wonderful children who are raised with God but understand what goodness and kindess are. Why is it so hard to let me just let me live my life too?

No, as you know, I do not support Ravvi Luries belief that not all archeological evidence supports the notion that the Bible should be taken literally. I just have the ability to look at each piece of information and decide for myself if the data used to make that claim is true or false.


Can I ask you something in complete seriousness...

What parts of the bible can you take as truth?

I mean, as a road map for success or whatever, that's fine, as a group of parables and tall tales, meant to inspire good in someone, I guess it's nice, but as literal truth?

Do you believe that jesus was born of a virgin?

Do you believe that jesus died and came back to life?

Again, these things can be taken figuratively I suppose, but to believe them as things that actually happened... That crosses over into cult-ish territory.
 
Can I ask you something in complete seriousness...

What parts of the bible can you take as truth?

I mean, as a road map for success or whatever, that's fine, as a group of parables and tall tales, meant to inspire good in someone, I guess it's nice, but as literal truth?

Do you believe that jesus was born of a virgin?

Do you believe that jesus died and came back to life?

Again, these things can be taken figuratively I suppose, but to believe them as things that actually happened... That crosses over into cult-ish territory.

I really appreciate that you asked me with seriousness and not hate. I believe that you can take the whole bible as truth. I do believe Jesus was born of a virgin and that Jesus died and came back to life.
 
What you are really saying is that no matter what the real reason wars are started blame the - "prissy God Botherers". Does the fact that Stalin carried out his athiestic beliefs without enlisting other athiests somehow make it O.K?

Listen, I do not assume that athiests somehow live lesser lives than those with faith. I am glad you are missing out on nothing. The good I do is without duress-I do it because I care. I live a good life-I have two wonderful children who are raised with God but understand what goodness and kindess are. Why is it so hard to let me just let me live my life too?

No, as you know, I do not support Ravvi Luries belief that not all archeological evidence supports the notion that the Bible should be taken literally. I just have the ability to look at each piece of information and decide for myself if the data used to make that claim is true or false.

First paragragh - No, it doesn't make it ok. My point is, and continues to be that being an atheist is incidental to whatever else someone does. Atheists have never waged wars to further their lack of belief.

Second paragraph - Without going back and nit picking your posts, I recall you have mentioned, even asked, how does an atheist know virtue or have hope? I, along with countless millions of others don't need religion to know virtue, have hope, act ethically or show compassion and kindness. I don't live the way I do because I believe that God is going to reward me and swoop down to take me to heaven when I die. I live as I do because I am a member of the human race and it is part of being human. I have no trouble with you living your life the way you see fit. I do have a problem with you trying to pass off faith as some kind of end result to pseudo-scientific study of the bible. Faith is what it is. That's why it's called faith. It is the first step you take when confronted with something for which no proof exists.

My point about Rabbi Lurie was that you selectively C & P'd his article. Once again, the pick n' mix approach.
 
I really appreciate that you asked me with seriousness and not hate. I believe that you can take the whole bible as truth. I do believe Jesus was born of a virgin and that Jesus died and came back to life.

I don't have any hate...

People are free to believe in any mythos that they want; and if a grown adult wants to believe in the easter bunny, santa claus, and the tooth fairy, that's certainly their right. I will have a bit of pity, and want to pat them on the head, and wish them the best.

But to be honest, if you actually think that the bible is literal truth, there's not really any difference. If you want to believe in a zombie savior, arisen from the dead, to absolve us of our sins, by all means, carry on. As long as you realize that it's in no way, shape, or form; rational.

Do whatever you need to do to get yourself through the day.

Some people drink themselves to excess, some people whore themselves out (my personal preference), some throw themselves into a cause, and some lose themselves in fantasy worlds... like religion.
 
Here is an account of the sun and moon holding their positions in the Earth's sky.
Joshua 10:12 On the day the Lord gave the Amorites over to Israel, Joshua said to the Lord in the presence of Israel:
“Sun, stand still over Gibeon, and you, moon, over the Valley of Aijalon.”

Joshua 10:13 So the sun stood still, and the moon stopped, till the nation avenged itself on its enemies, as it is written in the Book of Jashar.
The sun stopped in the middle of the sky and delayed going down about a full day.

Joshua 10:14 There has never been a day like it before or since, a day when the Lord listened to a human being. Surely the Lord was fighting for Israel!

And here, the sun is made to move in reverse.

2 Kings 20:8 Hezekiah had asked Isaiah, “What will be the sign that the Lord will heal me and that I will go up to the temple of the Lord on the third day from now?”

2 Kings 20:9 Isaiah answered, “This is the Lord’s sign to you that the Lord will do what he has promised: Shall the shadow go forward ten steps, or shall it go back ten steps?”

2 Kings 20:10 “It is a simple matter for the shadow to go forward ten steps,” said Hezekiah. “Rather, have it go back ten steps.”

2 Kings 20:11 Then the prophet Isaiah called on the Lord, and the Lord made the shadow go back the ten steps it had gone down on the stairway of Ahaz.
And it was during the crucifixion of Jesus that the sun got dark.
Luke 23:44 And it was about the sixth hour, and there was a darkness over all the earth until the ninth hour.

Luke 23:45 And the sun was darkened, and the veil of the temple was rent in the midst.
Some think that this might have been an eclipse, but it would have been impossible for an eclipse to happen so soon after Passover, which is celebrated when the moon is full.
 
Wtf is a natural law as opposed to one that is not natural?

Spitting on the sidewalk is not a natural law. Spit on a sidewalk and prolly nuthin happens to you. Piss on an electric fence and God dont cut you no slack.
 
I don't have any hate...

People are free to believe in any mythos that they want; and if a grown adult wants to believe in the easter bunny, santa claus, and the tooth fairy, that's certainly their right. I will have a bit of pity, and want to pat them on the head, and wish them the best.

But to be honest, if you actually think that the bible is literal truth, there's not really any difference. If you want to believe in a zombie savior, arisen from the dead, to absolve us of our sins, by all means, carry on. As long as you realize that it's in no way, shape, or form; rational.

Do whatever you need to do to get yourself through the day.

Some people drink themselves to excess, some people whore themselves out (my personal preference), some throw themselves into a cause, and some lose themselves in fantasy worlds... like religion.

You left out belief in Obama.
 
Back
Top