God

I'd read it with you. It's a really great book even if you choose not to believe. As for going to church... I like to go and listen to my pastor and think more about things, learn . I will have to admit sometimes I just go for donut fellowship.

"c'mon let's go eat some donuts"

*steals a cop car* than *drives with her to dunkin donuts*

hahah
 
"c'mon let's go eat some donuts"

*steals a cop car* than *drives with her to dunkin donuts*

hahah

See I know ways to simplify your life. The donut fellowship is at church and it is free. They even bring the donuts in from dunkin donuts. Then a lot of people sit around and eat them, drink coffee and talk. No cost, no prison sentence. It's a good alternative.
 
God didn't say, "Isaac is your only legitimate son". He said, "Isaac is your only son."

Issac was the son God promised Abraham and Sarah. He was the only one who would be the father of a great nation, according to the promise. Ishmeal was a child conceived through disobedience to God with a concubine outside God's will. He was not recognized by God as the heir to Abraham's blessing.
 
Three tests can be applied to the bible to see if it exhibits characteristics of a divine book that is without error. 1. External evidence 2. Internal evidence 3. Bible prophecy.

External evidence from both archeology and non-Christian writers confirms that the Bible - Both the Old and New Testaments - is a trustwrothy historical document. Archeologist Joseph Free has said that "Archeology has confirmed countless passages which has had been rejected by critics as unhistorical or contrary to known facts." Renowned Jewish Archeologist Nelson Gluek confidently said that "It may be stated categorically that no archeological discovery has ever controverted a biblical reference."

Examples: Some scolars said that Moses couldn't have written the first five books of the Bible because writing was largely unknown in his day. Then, archeology proved otherwise by the discovery of many other written codes of the periods: the code of Hammurabi, he Lipit-Ishtar code and the laws of Eshnunna.

Another example: Critics used to say that the biblical description of the Hittite Empire was wrong because the Hittite Empire (they thought) didn't even exist? Then archeologists discovered the Hittite Capital in 1906 and discovered that the Hittite's were actually a very vast and prominent civilization. Archeological and linguistic evidence is increaslingly pointing to the 6th century B.C date for the book of Daniel, in spite of many critics who attempt to late-date Daniel and make it a prophecy after the detailed events it predicts.

For the New Testament, Dr. G.R Habernas points out that within 110 years of Christ's crucifixion, approximately eighteen non-Christian sources mention more that "One hundred facts, beliefs, and teachings from the life of Christ and Early Christendom." These Items mention almost every major detail Of Jesus' life, including miracles, the Resurection, and His claims to diety." Sir William Ramsey, one of the greatest archeologists to ever live, demonstrated that Luke made no mistakes in refereces to 32 countries, 54 cities and 9 islands.


The internal evidents test reveals the bibles amazing consistency. The Bible was written by over 40 authors, in 3 languages, on 3 continents, over a span of 1500 years and covers hundreds of controversial subjects, Yet, the authors all spoke with agreement. From Genesis to Revelation, there is one unfolding story--God's redemption of mankind.

Finally prophecy. See Josh McDowells book evidence that demands a verdict. There are hundreds of specific prophecies in the bible that have been literally fullfilled, In some cases centuries after the completion of the Bible. Some prophecies fullfilled by Jesus are Micah 5:2, which revealed where He was born; Isaiah 53 detailing his suffering, work at the cross and ressurection. Psalm 22 is a striking prophecy of his crucifiction.

Lastly. How can we know whether or not the Bible we have today is the same as what was written? The discovery of the Dead Sea Scroll, which date from 200 B.C to AD 68 included a copy of every Old Testament book except for one. Comparison with the texts of a thousand years later shows little or no vatiation and change beetween them.

:DHad to go pick up my kids:D
__________________
The real trouble with reality is that there is no background music.
What if the hokey pokey is what it's all about?

I'm going to ignore all the mistakes above regarding history and repeat the meme I've been harping on from the beginning...No one gives a shit about the history. We're talking about evidence for a Supreme Being here. Getting the number of cats in Constantinople correct means dick as far as that's concerned.

As for the Bible's consistency as a storybook telling the tale of man's redemption -- Jesus Christ IT WAS PUT TOGETHER THAT WAY IN THE THIRD CENTURY. Sorry to yell, but, Jesus, if you aren't familiar with the Nicene Council you should fold your tent and go home now.

Now -- as for the whole "The Bible's gotten a bunch of prophecies right" thing. Yeah. No. It hasn't. And the reason why I can say that is the same reason I'll give you for why the book you're referencing (Evidence That Demands A Verdict) has been tossed in the "Crap" pile since 1972 -- "Compiling Supportive Evidence" is not the same thing as "Compiling Evidence". The poor critical thinking surrounding your "proof" that prophesies have come true, and for the "Evidence" in McDowell's book is of the "Find the parts that I like and ignore everything else" variety.

In other words, just like your decades old Entropy argument, your prophecy evidence and the conclusions reached in "Evidence That Demands A Verdict" are poor science, and have been labeled so for a very, very long time.

So, your statement "The Bible is True" falls apart. When it gets historical facts right (which is far, far less than you realize -- find ONE mention of Hebrew slaves in Egyptian history, for example) it really doesn't matter, because it doesn't speak to God's divinity. When it's examined as a centuries long created book with a single theme, that's because it was put together from a few books chosen out of thousands to make it seem that way by the Nicene Council. And when you look at the veracity of its prophecies your only "evidence" is terrible critical thinking and awful scholarship, as described by decades historians, scientists and anthropologists.

Anyway -- nothing above actually speaks directly to the divinity, or existence, or God.

So, now that the big bad man-created and man-interpreted Bible is out of the way let's get back to your original claim. You say that there is a supreme being that created the universe and is aware of us and has rules for us. That's an astonishing thing to say. Astonishing claims are usually accompanied by an astonishing amount of evidence. Where's your evidence that God exists?

Prove it.
 
Issac was the son God promised Abraham and Sarah. He was the only one who would be the father of a great nation, according to the promise. Ishmeal was a child conceived through disobedience to God with a concubine outside God's will. He was not recognized by God as the heir to Abraham's blessing.

Prove it.

Where's the historical evidence that anyone named "Abraham" ever existed. (By the way, most Christian theologians, and many Jewish Theologians, consider Moses, Noah and Abraham to be fictional characters.)
 
Sorry, I was raised in church, three times a week, christian high school...the works. Once I realized I had the option of not believing in a fairy tale. Quite freeing. The only downside is, I have opinions regarding people who believe in gods. I feel bad for their ignorance. Keep on believing in a god. I will keep living in reality. If you realized how ridiculous the "god is real" talk was, you'd cringe. Its like an adult who still believes in santa or the tooth fairy.

We will fuck one day.

Oh yes, we will fuck one day.
 
Let me make a prophecy about how this argument will end. Eventually TryHarder will run out of cut and paste content from HowToArgueWithAnAtheist.com and will be left with "I can believe whatever I want and you can't stop me!" and never return to the thread.

Bet me, motherfuckers.
 
Issac was the son God promised Abraham and Sarah. He was the only one who would be the father of a great nation, according to the promise. Ishmeal was a child conceived through disobedience to God with a concubine outside God's will. He was not recognized by God as the heir to Abraham's blessing.
That is irrelevant. We are counting male offspring.

Gen 22:1 And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham, and said unto him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, [here] I [am].
Gen 22:2 And he said, Take now thy son, thine only [son] Isaac, whom thou lovest, and get thee into the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt offering upon one of the mountains which I will tell thee of.

The Hebrew word in verse 2 is "yachiyd". It is a quantity. It has nothing to do with being legitimate or chosen.

http://www.blueletterbible.org/lang/lexicon/lexicon.cfm?Strongs=H3173&t=KJV
 
That is irrelevant. We are counting male offspring.

Gen 22:1 And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham, and said unto him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, [here] I [am].
Gen 22:2 And he said, Take now thy son, thine only [son] Isaac, whom thou lovest, and get thee into the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt offering upon one of the mountains which I will tell thee of.

The Hebrew word in verse 2 is "yachiyd". It is a quantity. It has nothing to do with being legitimate or chosen.

http://www.blueletterbible.org/lang/lexicon/lexicon.cfm?Strongs=H3173&t=KJV

Nice.

But this is a little like arguing over who can win in a fight, the Tooth Fairy or Jack Frost. (Two characters in an upcoming feature film, by the way. I kid you fucking not.)
 
The "prove it" bit is a gas! It's also as old as the Roman Legions and lions and circus bread. The analytics are hackneyed at this point - on all sides. All dance around the unquantifiables of faith and the inertia thereof. Whether one has faith and what it may compel one to do has been making history since history has been humanly made.

Dixon was a God here. He's published and tenured and once was entitled. But, here isn't always here. With time it's somewhere else. Ozymandius...

So? Prove it? To whom?

A God? A cunning traveler? One without your faith? To what end? Must your words evangelize, or may they serve just as powerfully as a testament?

If there is a God? Must one mortal prove such a thing? The slippery trick is in the semantics woven by an avowed wordmaker...

The dance and attending stupidities are entertaining, nonetheless.

Keep your faith, baby. You've absolutely nothing to prove to any huckster.
 
The "prove it" bit is a gas! It's also as old as the Roman Legions and lions and circus bread. The analytics are hackneyed at this point - on all sides. All dance around the unquantifiables of faith and the inertia thereof. Whether one has faith and what it may compel one to do has been making history since history has been humanly made.

Dixon was a God here. He's published and tenured and once was entitled. But, here isn't always here. With time it's somewhere else. Ozymandius...

So? Prove it? To whom?

A God? A cunning traveler? One without your faith? To what end? Must your words evangelize, or may they serve just as powerfully as a testament?

If there is a God? Must one mortal prove such a thing? The slippery trick is in the semantics woven by an avowed wordmaker...

The dance and attending stupidities are entertaining, nonetheless.

Keep your faith, baby. You've absolutely nothing to prove to any huckster.

Yeah. The concept that "things that are true" relies on semantics is horseshit. Although that's a very nice way to try and frame the whole thing under the whole "Believe what you want!" motif, which is how I JUST predicted this argument would eventually end. After I win it. Again.
 
Let's also not pretend that proof isn't just as important to the faithful as it is to the skeptic. Because it is. Maybe even more so...

The faithful, those who accept irrational ideas despite the lack of evidence, and purely for emotional and fearful reasons, will wax poetic on the noble state of non-evidentiary belief. "I don't need proof!"

They speak crap. They crave evidence. Deep down we are investigatory creatures. We are pattern seekers. Our brains, our evolutionary make up forces us towards critical thinking and symbol recognition. We NEED evidence.

Religious faith does, too. Put on a TV special about the Shroud of Turin and how many faithful won't tune in because they don't "need" the evidence? Documentaries about the historical Jesus and photos of Noah's "Ark" on a mountain in Turkey are hugely popular amongst the faithful. The Dead Sea Scrolls and other early AD century texts are poured over for a scrap of historical testimony that jibes with Roman record keeping. And look at the book TryHarder just referenced above. It is an astonishingly detailed (and badly compiled) look at EVIDENCE for Christian veracity. The faithful, like the rest of humanity, move desperately towards Proof. They need it. They crave it. They'll say it's not necessary, but put a splinter of Christ's cross in front of them and they'll post the photos all over Facebook with uppper case captioned "AMENS!" and "AH-HAHS!", thrilled, finally, to the core that some mother-fucking PROOF has been unearthed.

Don't tell me the faithful don't want proof. They cream over it.
 
Let me make a prophecy about how this argument will end. Eventually TryHarder will run out of cut and paste content from HowToArgueWithAnAtheist.com and will be left with "I can believe whatever I want and you can't stop me!" and never return to the thread.

Bet me, motherfuckers.

I'll take that bet, your stuck with me honey. What do I win? The thing is and I don't think people read what I said earlier. I cannot prove that God exists. Either can anyone prove that he doesn't. That arguement will never be answered this side of heaven. All each of us can do is look at the information available today and choose for ourselves. What I have never understood is the amount of hostility some non-believers give the believer just for having a different opinion.

I will make a quote just so Dixon Carter Lee can be happy. "The athiest can appeal to nothing absolute, nothing objectively true for all people. It is just mere opinion enforced by might. The Christian appeals to a standard outside himself or herself in which truth and qualitative values can be made sense of."
 
That is irrelevant. We are counting male offspring.

Gen 22:1 And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham, and said unto him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, [here] I [am].
Gen 22:2 And he said, Take now thy son, thine only [son] Isaac, whom thou lovest, and get thee into the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt offering upon one of the mountains which I will tell thee of.

The Hebrew word in verse 2 is "yachiyd". It is a quantity. It has nothing to do with being legitimate or chosen.

http://www.blueletterbible.org/lang/lexicon/lexicon.cfm?Strongs=H3173&t=KJV

I do think that he does it because he is the only son God made the promise about. The only son that was born without disobedience. Some people say Ishmeal was born of Abram and Isaac was born to Abraham. Abraham was a new man and Isaac was his only son. I am not so sure about that.
 
I do think that he does it because he is the only son God made the promise about. The only son that was born without disobedience. Some people say Ishmeal was born of Abram and Isaac was born to Abraham. Abraham was a new man and Isaac was his only son. I am not so sure about that.
Well, my point is that in order to make the Bible consistent with itself, you have to do some semantic backflips. Even more effort is needed to get the Bible to agree with history. And it's these tiny disagreements that cause the bloodiest schisms among Bible adherents.

I don't know if the authors of the Bible deliberately set it up so that people would bicker, fight and start wars over its contents. But it seems pretty obvious that today's religious leaders are all too happy to keep the Bible exactly the way it is. And to me, that is reprehensible.
 
Well, my point is that in order to make the Bible consistent with itself, you have to do some semantic backflips. Even more effort is needed to get the Bible to agree with history. And it's these tiny disagreements that cause the bloodiest schisms among Bible adherents.

I don't know if the authors of the Bible deliberately set it up so that people would bicker, fight and start wars over its contents. But it seems pretty obvious that today's religious leaders are all too happy to keep the Bible exactly the way it is. And to me, that is reprehensible.


I don't think I was doing any semantic backflips - I think I was just disagreeing with you. If you were a religious leader and a believer, which I know you have stated you are not, how would you change the bible?
 
I don't think I was doing any semantic backflips - I think I was just disagreeing with you. If you were a religious leader and a believer, which I know you have stated you are not, how would you change the bible?
If I was a believer of what? If I believed in the Bible, I wouldn't want to change anything in it.
 
So, your statement "The Bible is True" falls apart. When it gets historical facts right (which is far, far less than you realize -- find ONE mention of Hebrew slaves in Egyptian history, for example) it really doesn't matter, because it doesn't speak to God's divinity. When it's examined as a centuries long created book with a single theme, that's because it was put together from a few books chosen out of thousands to make it seem that way by the Nicene Council. And when you look at the veracity of its prophecies your only "evidence" is terrible critical thinking and awful scholarship, as described by decades historians, scientists and anthropologists.
Exactly, and we won't even mention how English monarchy had their slash at making the Bible a better read.

They just don't get it - that the Bible is constructed to appear as a coherent narrative.
 
Back
Top