Feedback which do you prefer?

[Kain__Thornn]

No, not the choice between "It suck." or "You are the best writer on Lit." although they are both nice (and both real feeds) but the choice of style versus content.

Which gives you most pleasure? Feedback that says:
"Your writing is crisp and concise and draws the reader in to your world"
or the kind that virtually ignores your writing and asks about the characters:
"Why didn't she go with Wendy? What was wrong with her?"

Feedback on the writing or feedback on the story?

I like when someone says;

"Great story, but I'd do *** different" or "The third paragraph was long, maybe a break should have gone ***"

 

[Erotos]

As an avid reader I try to give more feedback than just, "it was hot" or alternatively, "that was the best story I have read on Literotica". To me it cheapens the work that the author has undertaken in getting the piece published on the site. So at the very least I feel it is necessary to show some knowledge of the story I am commenting on, as well as a little bit of praise or constructive criticism.

 

[NoJo]

I like the feedback messages that have links to pictures