Feedback to someone else's story?

[InsatiableMe]

So, I was going through my mail today and noticed I had some feedback mails. Excited, I opened the first one right away! And to my surprise...the person told me they did not like a certain story that "I" wrote. No problem, right? Well, there is a slight problem. I didn't write the story they mentioned. (It's a current V-Day Contest story for those interested.)

The mail went on to say that "in all fairness" to me they went ahead and read another story by me. This time it was one by me. lol They said they enjoyed that story much better and that it was "more suited for Lit". The reader said he/she didn't quite understand how one author could write two very different stories. lol

Has this ever happened to anyone else?

 

[wildsweetone]

What a nice 'fair' reader. I think you have a gem there IM. Probably one in a million.

 

[A7inchPhildo]

Sounds like someone was a bit confused. No never happened but I would be sure to make the same mistake with a response. Naturally just for fun.