Evolution vs God

Hey Try! You know I like you - I think you're sweet and genuine and fun. After the last creationism thread, though I certainly respect your right to your own beliefs, I thought it was best to avoid discussing religion with you. We're just never going to be on the same page, but I appreciate that you are always honest and respectful. I keep seeing this thread getting bumped, though, and I just have a few things that I'd really like to add.

Richard Dawkins is not "worried." Nobody who accepts the theory of evolution is worried. Not only because the logic and "evidence" in question hold about as much water as a pair of fishnet stockings, but because what is there to be worried about? That we'll find new evidence that will alter our idea of the development of terrestrial life? I'm not scared of that. That would be awesome. When I say that a belief in creationism is one of the wrongest things that an adult person can think (seriously, no offense intended! I promise! :D), I'm not trying to "prove" evolution; I'm just trying to find the truth. There are interesting theories about extinction and speciation that don't align perfectly with the Darwinian model. Cool. They don't have to. They just have to be supported by the evidence.

There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. And we're looking! And it's exciting! The pieces of the puzzle that we DO have are pretty straightforward and quite convincing. When you say things like "show me X" and "I'm just asking questions," it's incredibly exasperating, because you're ignoring the MOUNTAIN of science that's already there, and why are you even asking questions in the first place? What do you have to prove? Why should you have to prove the word of God? Isn't the point that you don't have to? Isn't that what faith is? Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? This is one in a loooong series of contentions with evolution, not one of which has been held up so far. Here's a big old list of them from a pro-creation website ("no new species" makes the list).

It's like if I tell you that the planet Kepler-62f is 1200 lightyears away. Now, I'm fairly certain the Bible didn't cover that, because it is a document written by people who were constrained by the scientific knowledge of their time and culture, but let's say you ask me how I know that's how far away it is. I can point you in the direction of trigonometric parallax and Hubble's Law and absolute/apparent magnitude and a zillion other things that astronomers have dedicated their lives to understanding. Would you question them because we don't have a tape measurer that's over a quadrillion km long?

Anyway. There's science, and there's creationism. If faith doesn't require proof, why are these guys trying so hard?

I really appreciate your articulate and respectful response. I know that people don't agree with me on the board but I do get pms. I have really tried to go out of my way not to discuss my faith. But truly it is me that loses out. I have learned a lot from people who want to share their knowledge instead of ridule. It is much appreciated.

There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. I can concure with this but in my mind it is not logical that this is spoken of as truth when in fact we don't really know. The pieces are still missing.

Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? I am not personally beating down science. I just can't agree at this point that because they found certain things that you can jump to the conclusions they draw as a whole. If those missing pieces are found then I will be the first one to say I am wrong.

I think your example is a great one. I also respect the people who have dedicated their life to science and figuring out our world. I also can equally hold those in high esteem who dedicate their lives to a different calling. I happen to like the fact that we are all different.

What would really be fantastic is if in the continued study of this both sides we could meet on common ground.

(I was also tired of talking about whether I could see my butthole or not.;))

Thanks Phelia:rose:
 
Quoted for awesomeness. Thank you for conveying the humility before nature any good scientist should express. For the scientist, joy is not found in the certainty of faith in any one article, but in the revelation of discovery.

Did you say faith? Hmmmm
 
Two stories: One is that a series of resourceful, elegant, imagination-boggling adaptations kept occurring against all odds and enemies to keep moving to toward more and more life, resulting in an almost inconceivable array of creatures and creations, a seemingly endless capacity for beauty, and a still-unfolding suggestion of infinite possibility. The other is that some invisible thing made stuff appear one week and it's been the same way ever since.

And I should find the second one more inspirational and wondrous than the first one why?
 
I know this thread derailed (evolved?) long ago, but on the off chance you're still here, look what it took me 30 seconds on Google to find.

http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2009/11/speciation-in-action/
But they are still finches!

Your article said: That question “is rarely if ever asked,” as speciation isn’t something that scientists have been fortunate enough to watch at the precise moment of divergence, except in bacteria and other simple creatures. But after at least three generations of reproductive isolation, the Grants felt comfortable in designating the new lineage as an incipient species.

No exact rule exists for deciding when a group of animals constitutes a separate species.

I guess the new bench mark is that it must be true if Peter and Rosemary Grant say so. Even if they can't show you how they know that.

The birds adapted. They didn't change into a different species.

I know people who have studied creationism for 36 years too. Just because they say God exists they can't show you direct evidence. They feel comfortable in saying that it is so - it must be true. Would that work for you?

No
 
Last edited:
Two stories: One is that a series of resourceful, elegant, imagination-boggling adaptations kept occurring against all odds and enemies to keep moving to toward more and more life, resulting in an almost inconceivable array of creatures and creations, a seemingly endless capacity for beauty, and a still-unfolding suggestion of infinite possibility. The other is that some invisible thing made stuff appear one week and it's been the same way ever since.

And I should find the second one more inspirational and wondrous than the first one why?

I guess for you, you shouldn't.
 
Two stories: One is that a series of resourceful, elegant, imagination-boggling adaptations kept occurring against all odds and enemies to keep moving to toward more and more life, resulting in an almost inconceivable array of creatures and creations, a seemingly endless capacity for beauty, and a still-unfolding suggestion of infinite possibility. The other is that some invisible thing made stuff appear one week and it's been the same way ever since.

And I should find the second one more inspirational and wondrous than the first one why?

Why did you stop using your Antoninus name?
 
I really appreciate your articulate and respectful response. I know that people don't agree with me on the board but I do get pms. I have really tried to go out of my way not to discuss my faith. But truly it is me that loses out. I have learned a lot from people who want to share their knowledge instead of ridule. It is much appreciated.

There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. I can concure with this but in my mind it is not logical that this is spoken of as truth when in fact we don't really know. The pieces are still missing.

Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? I am not personally beating down science. I just can't agree at this point that because they found certain things that you can jump to the conclusions they draw as a whole. If those missing pieces are found then I will be the first one to say I am wrong.

I think your example is a great one. I also respect the people who have dedicated their life to science and figuring out our world. I also can equally hold those in high esteem who dedicate their lives to a different calling. I happen to like the fact that we are all different.

What would really be fantastic is if in the continued study of this both sides we could meet on common ground.

(I was also tired of talking about whether I could see my butthole or not.;))

Thanks Phelia:rose:

I like that we're different, too, but I don't think we're so different. We all must have a few things in common. Like 99.9% of the nucleotide bases carried within the human genome, for example :D

Anyway, thank you for your response :rose: and I wouldn't worry so much about the whole separate species thing. Do what I do and think of birds as tiny, armless dinosaurs. It makes life one thousand percent more exciting.
 
But they are still finches!
Did you expect it to turn into a ferret or something? It's a bird. Of the finch variety.
There are four subfamilies of finches, breaking down into about 50 classes under that, and in total containing several hundreds of different varieties that are all considered separate spieces.

Your article said: That question “is rarely if ever asked,” as speciation isn’t something that scientists have been fortunate enough to watch at the precise moment of divergence, except in bacteria and other simple creatures. But after at least three generations of reproductive isolation, the Grants felt comfortable in designating the new lineage as an incipient species.

No exact rule exists for deciding when a group of animals constitutes a separate species.
So how can you say with such certainty that they're not a separate spieces? Is it not a separate species by your arbitrary definition?

I guess the new bench mark is that it must be true if Peter and Rosemary Grant say so. Even if they can't show you how they know that.
I guess their definition must be false because you say so. Even if you can't show me how you know that. They list their observations. Isolated gene pool - does not mate with local similar finches. Distinct communication mode - different songs than other finches. Different physical features - unusual size.

Wanna list yours?

The birds adapted. They didn't change into a different species.
Adaptation IS change. All "new spieces" are, is accumulated iterations of an isolated population.

What else are your goalposts for speciation, and what it is based on?

I know people who have studied creationism for 36 years too. Just because they say God exists they can't show you direct evidence. They feel comfortable in saying that it is so - it must be true. Would that work for you?

No
I'm sorry, you may notlike it, but the Grants DID show evidence, as reported. There is no set benchmark for speciation, because that's not how science works. New observations change both the analysis and the analytical tool.

What is the Cretationists' criteria? Does it evolve with new observaions?
 
Also, species must be the word in the English language that annoys me the most, on a spelling level.
 
There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. I can concure with this but in my mind it is not logical that this is spoken of as truth when in fact we don't really know. The pieces are still missing.

It is true we don’t yet know, and may never know, ALL of the facts. However, it is also true that every new discovery we have made all point towards one conclusion; that evolution is how things came to be as they are today.

Just because some pieces of a jigsaw are missing doesn’t mean we cannot make out what the image is. For anyone to insist that every single piece of a jigsaw has to be in place before we can identify the image is ridiculous.

And you don't get to make a demand that all the pieces have to be in place before it’s considered probable. This is like me saying I don't believe in gravity until someone puts gravitons in a bottle for me to see under a microscope, and until they do, I'll go around telling people that it's OK to walk off of cliffs.

And then to compound things insist on a competing hypothesis of which there is no evidence at all.

Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? I am not personally beating down science. I just can't agree at this point that because they found certain things that you can jump to the conclusions they draw as a whole. If those missing pieces are found then I will be the first one to say I am wrong.

Self-evidently no you wouldn’t.

We have a balance of evidence between 2 competing hypothesis on the one side we have literally 100’s of thousands of pieces of material evidence and DNA evidence that shows we share genes with every other living organism. Be that a chimp, a fly or a blade of grass, all indicating a common ancestry.
Darwin knew nothing of DNA and yet it confirms what he wrote. There can be no more conclusive piece of evidence than that.

And yet you champion a hypothesis of which you can provide no evidence whatsoever passed what is written in a series of compiled writings by faceless writers of which we know little or nothing about. They could have been mad, misguided, dishonest we just don’t know. None of it is testable and none of it is predictive we are just told we have to believe it and that’s it.
The balance of evidence is overwhelming on the side of evolution and non-existent on the side of creation.

To deny that balance of evidence is a sign of personal intellectual dishonesty.

The other thing that theists fail to grasp is that it isn’t a case of Evolution v’s god. Even if at some point evolution is proven wrong it does NOT by default mean the Abrahamic god exists. There could be another, yet undiscovered, explanation that is correct and both evolution and the Abrahamic version of events are wrong. What is required is evidence of the Abrahamic version of events. At the moment it is non-existent.

What would really be fantastic is if in the continued study of this both sides we could meet on common ground.

There can be no common ground if the only way to keep your narrative intact is to deny competing facts and provide no evidence of your own.

What is needed is a re-write of the Abrahamic narrative to fit the evidence that we have. And as that is the case then the only conclusion that can be made is that Abrahamic narrative is not the word of god.

Whilst we should keep an open mind on a spiritual entity the Abrahamic version of it isn’t it.

Woof!
 
The bible is wrong from its very first sentence-- "In the beginning". The notion of a beginning clearly implies that time existed before the creation (myth) It did not; and that is not a theory; it has been proved by physicists.

Through knowing how fast the universe is expanding we can calculate backwards to the exact time 13.2 billion years ago the big bang occurred. There was no time 'before' the big bang because neither time nor anything else - existed including the concept of any prime mover (The one TH calls God)

The first creative event was the big bang which had no cause - everything since flowed from that.
 
We are all more alike than unalike. We're variations on a basic theme.

I can totally go with that.

(((QUOTE=Bad_Doggie;47057318]So what you are saying is you want some “solid proof” directly in the palm of your hand.))))

Don't you want the same from creationism. I think it is generally accepted, through documetation more abundant than those that say that Julius Ceasar existed, that Jesus existed. What is in question is whether he was a diety or not. The truth is we all weren't there at the beginning. One group follows its evidence to conclude conservation of mass. Another group follows its evidence to a presence that has always been and will always be. Is that so far apart?

I just don't see how one group can say ignore the missing pieces but another group can't. JUST FOR ME, the missing pieces of creationism are filled by evidence I can't substantiate to others of the change in my heart and life. Personally I would need to see the missing pieces of evolution before I would change the evidence of a life literally saved.

I like that we're different, too, but I don't think we're so different. We all must have a few things in common. Like 99.9% of the nucleotide bases carried within the human genome, for example :D

Anyway, thank you for your response :rose: and I wouldn't worry so much about the whole separate species thing. Do what I do and think of birds as tiny, armless dinosaurs. It makes life one thousand percent more exciting.

I looked back at phrodeau's picture of the similarites between species and I think I need to imagine frogs as huge lions. That would be so cool.:cool:

To be honest, isn't speciation at the very heart of Darwin's Theory of evolution?? I can totally see the science behind natural selection and adaptation. Maybe I need to be specific and say I don't believe in speciation.

Wonderful thought provoking posts. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
(((QUOTE=Bad_Doggie;47057318]So what you are saying is you want some “solid proof” directly in the palm of your hand.))))
Don't you want the same from creationism.

I would find it a novel experience if any evidence of creation was presented at all, anywhere.

But, that was not my point; my point was that you are asking others here to provide you with evidence of evolution that you personally could find in any one of the 10’s of thousands of museums worldwide.

I think it is generally accepted, through documetation more abundant than those that say that Julius Ceasar existed, that Jesus existed.

So what?

There’s more documentation that fairies, leprechauns and UFO’s exist than Mr Brown who lives next door. However, the former I’m deeply sceptical exist and the later I’m fairly certain exists. How about you?

What is in question is whether he was a diety or not. The truth is we all weren't there at the beginning.

By any and all accounts neither was Jesus, he came along much later in an attempt to re-brand the cruel, vile, vain vengeful god of the Old Testament.

The only question is what brought god’s psychotic episode during the days of the old testament to an end?

One group follows its evidence to conclude conservation of mass.

With-in a simplified (closed) system this can be demonstrated to you and predicted to be true, yesterday, today and tomorrow.
Another group follows its evidence to a presence that has always been and will always be.

What evidence?

At this point I don’t think you have a notion what evidence actually is.

Tell me, what’s the difference between your invisible, incorporeal, being and no being at all?

If there’s no way to test the contention, no experiment that would validate or disprove it; what does it mean to say that this being exists at all? The inability to invalidate this hypothesis is not at all the same thing as you proving it true. Claims that cannot be tested, assertions immune to disproof are worthless.

With regard to god and creation it comes down to believing, in the absence of any evidence, on the say-so of some faceless individuals whose characters we know nothing about.

This being the case the only thing this can tell us is the state of the theist’s mind.

Is that so far apart?

It’s a universe apart and I’m stunned if you can’t see that.

I just don't see how one group can say ignore the missing pieces but another group can't.

Who says that science says “ignore the missing pieces?”

It says “the pieces are out there get looking,” and relentlessly over hundreds of years it has found piece by piece reducing our ignorance and bestowing the gifts we see around us, even the thing you are typing on this second. Do you deny that also?

JUST FOR ME, the missing pieces of creationism are filled by evidence I can't substantiate to others of the change in my heart and life. Personally I would need to see the missing pieces of evolution before I would change the evidence of a life literally saved.

This is a personal emotional experience and isn’t evidence of anything except your state of mind; again worthless to all but you.

There are no missing pieces of creationism; there’s simply no piece at all.

Woof!
 
Back
Top