Erotica vs. Porn

SpecialK

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 14, 1999
Posts
792
Do you think there is a difference?

When I mean 'porn', I mean specifically literary porn. (If that isn't an oxymoron.)

I'm curious to get everyone else's views on this.

To me, there is a difference. I consider myself a writer of erotica, not porn.

Porn stories are the jack-off stories. The ones that cut right to the chase. The plot is minimal and typical. (Heck, think of most porn movies here.) It centers on a physical reaction.

Erotica, conversely, is more subtle. It stimulates your mind just as much as it does your body. Erotica slowly teases you and builds up the emotions and eroticism through more unique and complex plots. Erotica is mental and emotional stimulation first, then the physical.

What do the rest of you think?

The reason I ask, a friend of mine who knows I write erotic stories, doesn't see a difference between pornography and the stories I write. He (yes, interestingly enough, he is male) has yet to read a story but he lumps it together with porn. He doesn't hold much esteem for porn either. He thinks all porn is perverted and has no purpose in a loving relationship.

He doesn't see how anyone who isn't a creepy pervert would have any use for erotica/porn. The concept that erotica can enhance a loving relationship is completely ludicrous to him. Incidentally, he is single. Yet he does not seem like the type of person who would have these views.

So.... share. Erotica vs porn? Or are they the same thing?

K
 
Quickies, but not in erotica

Where there is obviously a lot of overlap between erotica and porn, I think that erotica is more refined; has more of what would be defined as literary. Depending on the circumstances, I think that 'quickies' have their place in real time sex. The same thing in a short story is a waste. To be truly erotic, a story must have some character development and the mood has to be set in order for the reader to appreciate the sex that takes place.
 
i have been told that the difference between the two is the that in erotica the woman and man are on an equal level and porn puts the woman on a lower level (degrading).

It's a relative issue though. Some things women find to be degrading, I don't, so I'm sure there are several definitions out there.
 
i think erotica and porn do the same think but different people read them. i prefer erotica 'cause i get more involved if there's poetry in the writing but i still read it to get aroused. other people mainly guys read porn for the same reason but they don't like flowery writing. i'm a busy girl so i've still not read the stories here. are they more erotic or porn? *jenny*
 
All erotica is pornography but not all pornography is erotica.

In his introduction to 'Battlefield Earth' Mr. Hubbard spent several pages explaining the difference between true Science Fiction (his work) and Sci-Fi (Star Wars, Star Trek) yet, Libraries, book stores and entertainers draw no line between them.

Science Fiction is a genre; pornography is a genre as well. Could you so any of your 'erotica' (a subjective term) to a fifteen year old? No? Then it is pornography.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ :cool: ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
don't believe everything l ron hubbard says dude. he invented scientology and thats pretty creepy if you ask me. ursulla le guin wrote good science fiction. hubbard wrote trash. *jenny*
 
To me there is smut, there is porn, and there is erotica. These are my own very personal definitions and I use them only to label stories for myself or in casual conversation with my friends.

Erotica is a story that is sexually charged, but the story is about the relationship between the characters, not the sex between the characters. The sex may or may not be necessary, but the relationship is. It's people, not sex. Character development, plot development, good writing are all intrinsic.

Porn is a story about the sex, not the relationship. Sex is the main focus and everything written goes to that end. There may be character development and a plot, but the point of the story is sex, not the relationship between the characters.

Smut is a story that is sex only. No development, no plot, just straight sex. It's usually raunchy and/or poorly written.

I like erotica, I enjoy porn, but I usually don't read smut.
 
*Jennifer-In-Flares* said:
don't believe everything l ron hubbard says dude. he invented scientology and thats pretty creepy if you ask me. ursulla le guin wrote good science fiction. hubbard wrote trash. *jenny*



DiD you just call my neverkins a "DUDE"?????

That my dear, is trash!

SHE is no such thing.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~!!~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I have a copy of "1999s Best Erotica" on my coffee table
if it was "1999s Best Porn" I might have kept in in my toy box.
 
Adoratrice:
"DiD you just call my neverkins a "DUDE"?????"


YOUR neverkins? MY neverkins... Wait..
Okay, your neverkins.

What's wrong with Scientology, Jenny?
 
Never said:
YOUR neverkins? MY neverkins... Wait..
Okay, your neverkins.

What's wrong with Scientology, Jenny?
[/B]

ok i'm sorry if you're a scientologist and this offends you babe but i think scientology is a false religion just created to make money. they get people when they're confused and feeling low and vulnerable and i think that's sad. l ron hubbard was just a salesman and a pretty bad science fiction writer. :( but i liked all that other stuff you said and sorry for calling you dude lol. :D *jenny*
 
ROFLMAO!!!!! That link is hilarious!!!

P.S. My email is still the same, Indy... SpecialKay@canada.com Try again. :) I like getting mail from you. :)

K
 
*Jennifer-In-Flares* said:
ok i'm sorry if you're a scientologist and this offends you babe but i think scientology is a false religion just created to make money. they get people when they're confused and feeling low and vulnerable and i think that's sad. l ron hubbard was just a salesman and a pretty bad science fiction writer. :( but i liked all that other stuff you said and sorry for calling you dude lol. :D *jenny*

ok i just read it again and i hope it doesn't sound harsh but i have a girlfriend who got into all that and i dont like the way it changed her. *jenny*
 
Back
Top