Django Unchained

His opinion is based almost entirely on a Tarantino quote that he clearly doesn't understand and takes to the extreme that was obviously not meant. Whoever wrote that is a moron.

The Tarantino quote the writer mentioned is a precursor to a breakdown of a movie and its director that is virtually dead-on. I already knew the backstory about that, he didn't. So it helped with his assessment over the movie itself and it fits. It has nothing to do with whether you personally consider the movie good or bad, this is the real talk about the whys and the structure and the mechanics of it. I enjoyed the film, but I've known what Tarantino was about for a long, long time. What's happening with the way some people are taking it, not surprising to me.

I've read about six opinion pieces on Django since it came out, this one breaks it down the best. Not ignorant in the slightest.

By the way, that quote — I totally agree with Tarantino about actualizing his vision, but it does not absolve him of criticism over his culture appropriations and revisions and being taken to task for reaping the benefits of them. That's what dude broke down. Again, real talk, no ignorance.
 
Ya'll take shit too seriously. It's a Tarantino movie.
Also, Blob and Sonny are both right so there.
About the only thing he got right is that there were things called slaves and a movie called Roots.
 
About the only thing he got right is that there were things called slaves and a movie called Roots.

So, the depictions of antebellum life in Hollywood are accurate?

Mr. Bluebird's on my shoulder...
 
Keep in mind, though, that what Tarantino did was make his version of a spaghetti western with slavery as a motif. Fact, verity and reality are used as decoration and style. Despite the many things wrong with the movie, I'm glad I saw it. It's pure entertainment and there's a lot of good, needed discussion that happened because of it.

This is the best opinion about the movie I've read so far (there are spoilers in it, so I won't post the whole thing for those who haven't seen the movie yet):

Whiteness Unchained: When a National Shame Becomes Camp

I dunno. I think her/His white guilt is strong.

he/She did not get the (pre)-KKK scene, in which white people just looked stupid, among other things.

For example, in the last couple of paragraphs she says the black guy only gets his revenge after the good white guy offs the bad white guy, which in his/her mind is racism. What s/he doesn't note is the good white guy can't abide the bad white guys sadism against blacks so he acts and dies. On the other hand, Django is more interested in saving his wife so is tip-toeing around until he is forced into action. Stuff like that.

Oh, and she/it says this is a movie that stars white people with Black people in supporting roles. Did she not see the film's hero Jamie Foxx in about every scene finally kicking slavery's ass in a cool Little Joe jacket? ETA: And an LJ cowboy hat!

Just like Tarantino killed Hitler he is saying slavery was really bad in his Tarantino way.
 
Last edited:
About the only thing he got right is that there were things called slaves and a movie called Roots.

No, treatment of slaves ran from evil to civil. He was right that many owners did not beat their slaves (or at least not without what would have then been considered a valid reason) and looked at them as very expensive property that had to be taken care of. There was no universal way of treating them. Plantation owners and overseers were both good and bad.
 
The Tarantino quote the writer mentioned is a precursor to a breakdown of a movie and its director that is virtually dead-on. I already knew the backstory about that, he didn't. So it helped with his assessment over the movie itself and it fits. It has nothing to do with whether you personally consider the movie good or bad, this is the real talk about the whys and the structure and the mechanics of it. I enjoyed the film, but I've known what Tarantino was about for a long, long time. What's happening with the way some people are taking it, not surprising to me.

I've read about six opinion pieces on Django since it came out, this one breaks it down the best. Not ignorant in the slightest.

By the way, that quote — I totally agree with Tarantino about actualizing his vision, but it does not absolve him of criticism over his culture appropriations and revisions and being taken to task for reaping the benefits of them. That's what dude broke down. Again, real talk, no ignorance.

Dude doesn't understand a Tarantino movie and a simple quote clearly went way the fuck over his head.
 
I dunno. I think her/His white guilt is strong.

he/She did not get the (pre)-KKK scene, in which white people just looked stupid, among other things.

For example, in the last couple of paragraphs she says the black guy only gets his revenge after the good white guy offs the bad white guy, which in his/her mind is racism. What s/he doesn't note is the good white guy can't abide the bad white guys sadism against blacks so he acts and dies. On the other hand, Django is more interested in saving his wife so is tip-toeing around until he is forced into action. Stuff like that.

Oh, and she/it says this is a movie that stars white people with Black people in supporting roles. Did she not see the film's hero Jamie Foxx in about every scene finally kicking slavery's ass in a cool Little Joe jacket? ETA: And an LJ cowboy hat!

Just like Tarantino killed Hitler he is saying slavery was really bad in his Tarantino way.
I'm in the camp that says the only thing Tarantino ever says in any of his movies is "have fun." He makes pulp inspired by pulp.
There is a moderately popular horror writer named Brian Keene who is quite clearly inspired by Lovecraft. He doesn't try to hide it at all and in fact simply allows the Lovecraft to flow over everything he writes. His stuff has little depth and more often than not you don't really care about most of the characters but it's all fun as hell.
That's Tarantino. He's not trying to make Citizen Kane, he's trying to make Fistful of Dollars or Cleopatra Jones or the zillion of chopsocky movies Kill Bill was born of.
 
"I think we all think the bags was a nice idea. But, not pointing any fingers, they could of been done better. So, how `bout no bags this time, but next time, we do the bags right, and then go full regalia."

"Wait a minute! I didn't say no bags!"

I personally felt that scene was a little forced and out of place. Like he was trying too hard. It was funny but it didn't feel like it belonged.
 
One of the things that struck me as interesting about Pulp Fiction was "dead nigger storage". Jules didn't react at all to that. He treated it like it was just a normal statement. Seems like Tarantino was trying to make a point there.
 
A question for the guardians:

Does Tarantino get a pass? He says nigger a lot. He also never tells a story with a straight face. Is that OK?
 
One of the things that struck me as interesting about Pulp Fiction was "dead nigger storage". Jules didn't react at all to that. He treated it like it was just a normal statement. Seems like Tarantino was trying to make a point there.

It was the way all the characters talked. Eric Stoltz talked that way, too. "Am I a nigger? Is this Englewood?"
In the Tarantino universe that's just how people talk and nobody thinks much of it. I don't think there's some deep meaning to it though. I could be wrong. I often am.

"Is there a sign outside my house that says 'dead nigger storage?"
"No, man..."
"Know why? Cuz storing dead niggers aint my business."

Hilarious scene. The whole Bonnie Incident story was great.
 
A question for the guardians:

Does Tarantino get a pass? He says nigger a lot. He also never tells a story with a straight face. Is that OK?

Why would it not be ok to tell a story without a straight face? You want a more serious film then go see something else. People know what they get with him. Did you think Animal House lacked drama?

I think it's curious that he gets some flack for his use of the word nigger but actors both black and white line up and practically beg to be in his movies. They don't seem to have a problem with it and you'd think an actor would be somewhat sensitive to taking on a role that might draw comparisons to a drunk Mel Gibson.
 
I'm in the camp that says the only thing Tarantino ever says in any of his movies is "have fun." He makes pulp inspired by pulp.
There is a moderately popular horror writer named Brian Keene who is quite clearly inspired by Lovecraft. He doesn't try to hide it at all and in fact simply allows the Lovecraft to flow over everything he writes. His stuff has little depth and more often than not you don't really care about most of the characters but it's all fun as hell.
That's Tarantino. He's not trying to make Citizen Kane, he's trying to make Fistful of Dollars or Cleopatra Jones or the zillion of chopsocky movies Kill Bill was born of.

Great fun, yeah, and pulp from pulp and putting his spin on the past. But I think he wants to make more than fun violent movies. I think he wants to push some boundaries, be outrageous, smart, relevant and make movies that make people take notice and talk about things and that will be remembered...some meaningful stuff. But yeah, he's not Kurosawa.

I'll have to think about caring about his characters...I was bummed when Dr. Schultz was killed off...could be because he reminds me of a friend, I suppose.
 
Why would it not be ok to tell a story without a straight face? You want a more serious film then go see something else. People know what they get with him. Did you think Animal House lacked drama?

I think it's curious that he gets some flack for his use of the word nigger but actors both black and white line up and practically beg to be in his movies. They don't seem to have a problem with it and you'd think an actor would be somewhat sensitive to taking on a role that might draw comparisons to a drunk Mel Gibson.

Pretty much as I thought. Thanks.

Tarantino flosses with nigger. He's flummoxed by another word.
 
Personally, I enjoyed the movie. The scene with the KKK killed me, I was literally rolling around giggling as quietly as possible. And the tooth bouncing violently around, all noisy spring, on top of the carriage? Yeah, I really loved it.
 
Pretty much as I thought. Thanks.

Tarantino flosses with nigger. He's flummoxed by another word.

It's a word that jumps out and gets noticed. That doesn't mean it's the only word being used. Go watch Inglourious Basterds.
 
...
I think it's curious that he gets some flack for his use of the word nigger but actors both black and white line up and practically beg to be in his movies. They don't seem to have a problem with it and you'd think an actor would be somewhat sensitive to taking on a role that might draw comparisons to a drunk Mel Gibson.

I read De Caprio called Tarantino and asked to be cast in the role he played.
 
I read De Caprio called Tarantino and asked to be cast in the role he played.

One thing Tarantino will never have a problem with is casting. He has his pick of the entire entertainment industry. Minus Spike Lee of course but I think we all know that's for the best.
 
I dunno. I think her/His white guilt is strong.

he/She did not get the (pre)-KKK scene, in which white people just looked stupid, among other things.

For example, in the last couple of paragraphs she says the black guy only gets his revenge after the good white guy offs the bad white guy, which in his/her mind is racism. What s/he doesn't note is the good white guy can't abide the bad white guys sadism against blacks so he acts and dies. On the other hand, Django is more interested in saving his wife so is tip-toeing around until he is forced into action. Stuff like that.

I think that's exactly what the writer is saying. It's the white guy that stands up for what is right in the film, contrasted with the black character's more self interested actions. For most of the film the focus is on Waltz' character "rescuing" Foxx, mentoring him, etc.

Oh, and she/it says this is a movie that stars white people with Black people in supporting roles. Did she not see the film's hero Jamie Foxx in about every scene finally kicking slavery's ass in a cool Little Joe jacket? ETA: And an LJ cowboy hat!

Just like Tarantino killed Hitler he is saying slavery was really bad in his Tarantino way.

But up to that point, Foxx was pretty much a supporting character. He really didn't do or say much until the very end.

I'm not saying the movie wasn't entertaining nor that Tarantino ever meant anything deeper or considers the racial ramifications of his work to be offensive in any way. But that he didn't intentionally shape his work to be somewhat white-centric doesn't mean that it wasn't -- that may be the point of the article. I haven't thought deeply enough about it to comment past that, I think it raises interesting points for discussion though.
 
No, treatment of slaves ran from evil to civil. He was right that many owners did not beat their slaves (or at least not without what would have then been considered a valid reason) and looked at them as very expensive property that had to be taken care of. There was no universal way of treating them. Plantation owners and overseers were both good and bad.
Very different statement from the one he made. For backtracking I shall now withhold laughter from your otherwise funny "liar liar" post.
 
Back
Top