Django Unchained

I saw Django last night and thought it was one of his best. I laughed throughout the movie but was feeling self conscious since it seems I was the only one in the theater getting the jokes. Samuel L as always was great!

As entertainment it is pure awesomeness. As art it's somewhat less so but then so are most of his movies.
 
I really enjoyed it.

At the same time, I was horrified. I had always known slavery was awful - obviously, just on principle, the idea of owning another human being is reprehensible. But -- the way the slaves were treated was something I'd never been exposed to before. It wasn't something I'd actually imagined was possible. People treated their slaves worse than they treated their livestock. That's something that's incredibly hard for me to fathom.

Of course, I suppose people didn't really carry the same sort of bilious hatred towards their cows and horses that they did towards blacks.
 
As entertainment it is pure awesomeness. As art it's somewhat less so but then so are most of his movies.

No one but Quentin can get away with having his civil war era slaves talk shit with words like motherfucker and bitch or having Samuel L Jackson appear as Stepin Fetchit in one scene and Johnny Cochran the next.
 
I really enjoyed it.

At the same time, I was horrified. I had always known slavery was awful - obviously, just on principle, the idea of owning another human being is reprehensible. But -- the way the slaves were treated was something I'd never been exposed to before. It wasn't something I'd actually imagined was possible. People treated their slaves worse than they treated their livestock. That's something that's incredibly hard for me to fathom.

Of course, I suppose people didn't really carry the same sort of bilious hatred towards their cows and horses that they did towards blacks.

I don't think this movie is really your best source to learn about slavery.
 
I don't think this movie is really your best source to learn about slavery.


oh, no doubt. i know a lot of it was exaggerated. but slaves being whipped, slaves being raped, slaves being punished in various creative ways...i think a lot of that probably did happen. slaves being killed in horrible, torturous ways when they enraged their masters enough...that probably did happen.

if a horse stopped working, it got shot. it didn't get raped first. but then horses weren't hated the way blacks were.
 
oh, no doubt. i know a lot of it was exaggerated. but slaves being whipped, slaves being raped, slaves being punished in various creative ways...i think a lot of that probably did happen. slaves being killed in horrible, torturous ways when they enraged their masters enough...that probably did happen.

if a horse stopped working, it got shot. it didn't get raped first. but then horses weren't hated the way blacks were.

I've got polaroids and some very nice memories that say you're wrong.
 
I really enjoyed it.

At the same time, I was horrified. I had always known slavery was awful - obviously, just on principle, the idea of owning another human being is reprehensible. But -- the way the slaves were treated was something I'd never been exposed to before. It wasn't something I'd actually imagined was possible. People treated their slaves worse than they treated their livestock. That's something that's incredibly hard for me to fathom.

Of course, I suppose people didn't really carry the same sort of bilious hatred towards their cows and horses that they did towards blacks.

Keep in mind, though, that what Tarantino did was make his version of a spaghetti western with slavery as a motif. Fact, verity and reality are used as decoration and style. Despite the many things wrong with the movie, I'm glad I saw it. It's pure entertainment and there's a lot of good, needed discussion that happened because of it.

This is the best opinion about the movie I've read so far (there are spoilers in it, so I won't post the whole thing for those who haven't seen the movie yet):

Whiteness Unchained: When a National Shame Becomes Camp
 
Keep in mind, though, that what Tarantino did was make his version of a spaghetti western with slavery as a motif. Fact, verity and reality are used as decoration and style. Despite the many things wrong with the movie, I'm glad I saw it. It's pure entertainment and there's a lot of good, needed discussion that happened because of it.

This is the best opinion about the movie I've read so far (there are spoilers in it, so I won't post the whole thing for those who haven't seen the movie yet):

Whiteness Unchained: When a National Shame Becomes Camp

Yeah, I'm not making any arguments about the movies merits or lack thereof, just a general comment on the fact that I was woefully ignorant of how terrible slavery actually was. I never learnt anything about slavery other than the fact that it existed, and to see visual depictions (albeit grossly exaggerated) of it was a shock to me.

Interesting article though.
 
Keep in mind, though, that what Tarantino did was make his version of a spaghetti western with slavery as a motif. Fact, verity and reality are used as decoration and style. Despite the many things wrong with the movie, I'm glad I saw it. It's pure entertainment and there's a lot of good, needed discussion that happened because of it.

This is the best opinion about the movie I've read so far (there are spoilers in it, so I won't post the whole thing for those who haven't seen the movie yet):

Whiteness Unchained: When a National Shame Becomes Camp
I haven't seen it, but am definitely uncomfortable with the 'white guy showing black people being beaten for larfs (or otherwise)' vibe I get from it.

I'll probably still go. But all things considered, I'll take Blazing Saddles any day.
 
I like that Quentin has the balls and skill as a film maker to mix comedy so close to the savagery of a man being torn apart by dogs. I went from laughing to being horrified back to laughing in just a matter of seconds.
 
oh, no doubt. i know a lot of it was exaggerated. but slaves being whipped, slaves being raped, slaves being punished in various creative ways...i think a lot of that probably did happen. slaves being killed in horrible, torturous ways when they enraged their masters enough...that probably did happen.

if a horse stopped working, it got shot. it didn't get raped first. but then horses weren't hated the way blacks were.

That's not really accurate, at least not in regards to American slavery. While that sort of sadism absolutely happened, it was not anywhere near the norm. First, blacks generally weren't hated in the way we think of it today. They were often viewed simply as property. It would be today like someone hating a cow or a sheep. Also, the stories you hear about slaves pulling plows and being worked in the same manner as draft animals are almost universally false. Before the Civil War, a strong slave cost about $1,000, which was a tremendous sum in that day. No sensible person would force a $1,000 slave to do what a $50 workhorse could do.

While slavery was a brutal system that led to terrible abuses of human rights, most of what you see in Hollywood films is pure fiction. If you want something accurate, watch the television miniseries "Roots" based on the book of the same name by Alex Haley. Although Haley's genealogical data is questionable at best, the depictions of antebellum life are pretty accurate. Alternately, if you don't mind some Victorian-era prose, try the autobiography of Frederick Douglass. He was born a slave, so he had the ability to articulate it better than anyone else.
 
Was a great ride. Who else but Tarantino can make carnage funny?
 
I think people will have varied reactions to this movie based on their own awareness, knowledge of history and familiarity with Tarantino’s films. In the last movie anti-semetism was the foil, in this one it's racism and racists getting skewered.

It's a comedy. It wasn't meant to be Lincoln.
 
Yeah, I'm not making any arguments about the movies merits or lack thereof, just a general comment on the fact that I was woefully ignorant of how terrible slavery actually was. I never learnt anything about slavery other than the fact that it existed, and to see visual depictions (albeit grossly exaggerated) of it was a shock to me.

Interesting article though.
I don't know how far back into the slave chain the movie goes, but yes, it was horrific. Grown men and women living free as the descendants of kings and pharoahs in West Africa (and throughout the coast states), tracked like animals, packed into ships on which many of them died, chained up like dogs and sold as property.

Because this particular property represented a threat to its owners, they were ritually humiliated and beaten into submission, laughingly dehumanized, and disposed of without hesitation when necessary.

Owners feared revolts, so they broke up families, forbad talking/singing/playing music/congregating, and reward only physical prowess and fealty.

If one was weak or injured, he was painted as lazy. If one showed dignity, he was painted as arrogant and uppity.

Those characterizations have dogged our country's black population ever since, in sometimes overt, often perniciously subtle ways. They have certainly made our president's job harder.

A true accounting of slavery is almost too difficult to read. But ANYONE who wants to understand 2013 America, needs to start there. It's all still in the cocktail. Less visible, watered down a bit, but all still there.
 
I haven't seen it, but am definitely uncomfortable with the 'white guy showing black people being beaten for larfs (or otherwise)' vibe I get from it.

I'll probably still go. But all things considered, I'll take Blazing Saddles any day.

Yeah, the Blazing Saddles connection was made by many heads in their reviews and articles. That movie is better comedy, this one is pure bombast.

He's always been about "black cool," and this movie gave him the perfect carte blanche to freely indulge in the n-word — his ultimate barometer of "black cool" — as fetish within the context he craved. It only works as long as you understand Tarantino and what Tarantino's about, because this movie is totally Tarantino. And only he could do this in the way he did it. That's why it's working. We're used to him channeling this sort of thing.

When you do finally see it, you'll see what's entertaining about it...and then you'll see what's infuriating about it, because there's so many ways it could've been much more than it was, even using slavery as a black humor background (pun intended.)
 
Yeah, the Blazing Saddles connection was made by many heads in their reviews and articles. That movie is better comedy, this one is pure bombast.

He's always been about "black cool," and this movie gave him the perfect carte blanche to freely indulge in the n-word — his ultimate barometer of "black cool" — as fetish within the context he craved. It only works as long as you understand Tarantino and what Tarantino's about, because this movie is totally Tarantino. And only he could do this in the way he did it. That's why it's working. We're used to him channeling this sort of thing.

When you do finally see it, you'll see what's entertaining about it...and then you'll see what's infuriating about it, because there's so many ways it could've been much more than it was, even using slavery as a black humor background (pun intended.)
I'm going to guess/hope you have the idiot Blobfish on ignore. You may want to view his post #36, as a reminder of all that is good and beautiful in people.
 
I'm going to guess/hope you have the idiot Blobfish on ignore. You may want to view his post #36, as a reminder of all that is good and beautiful in people.

Oh sorry, did I forget to mention that people only dislike Obama because he's black? Thanks for covering for me.
 
I really enjoyed it.

At the same time, I was horrified. I had always known slavery was awful - obviously, just on principle, the idea of owning another human being is reprehensible. But -- the way the slaves were treated was something I'd never been exposed to before. It wasn't something I'd actually imagined was possible. People treated their slaves worse than they treated their livestock. That's something that's incredibly hard for me to fathom.

Of course, I suppose people didn't really carry the same sort of bilious hatred towards their cows and horses that they did towards blacks.

You do realise it was just a movie, right?
 
Keep in mind, though, that what Tarantino did was make his version of a spaghetti western with slavery as a motif. Fact, verity and reality are used as decoration and style. Despite the many things wrong with the movie, I'm glad I saw it. It's pure entertainment and there's a lot of good, needed discussion that happened because of it.

This is the best opinion about the movie I've read so far (there are spoilers in it, so I won't post the whole thing for those who haven't seen the movie yet):

Whiteness Unchained: When a National Shame Becomes Camp

You think that was a good opinion? It's ignorant.
 
Ya'll take shit too seriously. It's a Tarantino movie.
Also, Blob and Sonny are both right so there.
 
Back
Top