Compulsory reading list?

knot_sweet

mmmm rope...
Joined
Feb 12, 2012
Posts
1,210
For a long time, I was dead against a 'compulsory reading list' in the education system.

I figured as long as kids were reading, what did it matter the choice of subject, right?

Wrong.

Some of my younger friends were discussing that infernal show 'Big Brother', yet much to my disgust had never heard of George Orwell's classic dystopian novel 1984.

So it got me thinking...should there be some books better not forgotten?

I can think of at least one or two, that whilst not considered classic literature, should be part of a high school reading list.

"Blind Faith" by Ben Elton would be my first recommendation.

What's yours??
 
Why make them read? Google, Wiki, Bing and the whole internet mean that you can learn something in moments from your phone and forget it moments later when no longer need the information.

Soon we'll have an app called "conversationalist" which will use the mic and earbud to googlewiki appropriate responses for nearly eveything the mic picks up.

You'll be able to choose any setting between Mike Yates and Einstein and it will provide conversation points at that level. Wow your audience, be the life of the party, appear educated and well read. . . Topic is 1984? You've got the book in your ear. $2.99 at app store, turn on one click shopping, no ads.
 
Why make them read? Google, Wiki, Bing and the whole internet mean that you can learn something in moments from your phone and forget it moments later when no longer need the information.

Soon we'll have an app called "conversationalist" which will use the mic and earbud to googlewiki appropriate responses for nearly eveything the mic picks up.

You'll be able to choose any setting between Mike Yates and Einstein and it will provide conversation points at that level. Wow your audience, be the life of the party, appear educated and well read. . . Topic is 1984? You've got the book in your ear. $2.99 at app store, turn on one click shopping, no ads.

The only problem I have w/that 1st paragraph is the learning is subjective. People these days tend to think they're 'instant experts' because the information is at their finger tips. Practical application is an entirely different story though. And you're right, the info no longer sticks w/people.

I value reading above all else in education and the learning process. It's not reading alone that educates a person; it's how they apply the knowledge given to them through reading.
 
My list includes books no sane pedagogue would touch with a barge pole.

Like...A FIVE DAY COURSE IN THINKING by Edward de Bono, MD, PhD.

THE BEST AND THE BRIGHTEST by David Halberstam

DAY OF RECKONING by David Halberstam

BLOOD MERIDIAN by Cormac McCarthy

NEW DEALERS WAR by Thomas Fleming
 
My list includes books no sane pedagogue would touch with a barge pole.

Like...A FIVE DAY COURSE IN THINKING by Edward de Bono, MD, PhD.

THE BEST AND THE BRIGHTEST by David Halberstam

DAY OF RECKONING by David Halberstam

BLOOD MERIDIAN by Cormac McCarthy

NEW DEALERS WAR by Thomas Fleming



Halberstam's 1986 book about the rise of the Japanese automobile industry and the concomitant dysfunctional decline of the U.S. automobile industry is titled The Reckoning.



 
Once you weren't deemed educated until you could translate latin texts about the punic wars or compose verses extempore in that dead language. Now we've dumbed the requirements for literacy down to reading young-adult lit like 1984, Catcher in the Rye and The Great Gatsby. Youths today are useless except as a conduit for facebook and twitter information.
 
My youngest, who's off to college mind you, says she doesn't need to read, that's what google is for.
 

Halberstam's 1986 book about the rise of the Japanese automobile industry and the concomitant dysfunctional decline of the U.S. automobile industry is titled The Reckoning.

Interesting quasi-followup just came out, Bob Lutz's Icons and Idiots. More anecdotal than analysis, it's an insider look at the Red Poling years at Ford, specifically how Poling's austerity program returned Ford to profitablity by weakening the quality in the product line and basically crippling the company's future.
 
Why Geography Matters by Harm de Blij is a must read for anyone who deems to speak geopolitically...

...as much as Madison's Notes are an absolutely required read for anyone who wishes to discuss the Constitution.

Blij has now revised his cornerstone, adding the subtitle:

More Than Ever.
 
For a long time, I was dead against a 'compulsory reading list' in the education system.

I figured as long as kids were reading, what did it matter the choice of subject, right?

Wrong.

Some of my younger friends were discussing that infernal show 'Big Brother', yet much to my disgust had never heard of George Orwell's classic dystopian novel 1984.

The best argument in favor of a compulsory reading list is that it gives everyone a common frame of reference.
 
Why Geography Matters by Harm de Blij is a must read for anyone who deems to speak geopolitically...

...as much as Madison's Notes are an absolutely required read for anyone who wishes to discuss the Constitution.

Blij has now revised his cornerstone, adding the subtitle:

More Than Ever.




War is god's way of teaching geography to Americans.
-Ambrose Bierce
The Devil's Dictionary​


 
Last edited:
The best argument in favor of a compulsory reading list is that it gives everyone a common frame of reference.

I don't see any reason why that same logic can't be used to force the five of us who refuse to watch American Idol and Twilight to watch it. Despite the incredible headaches it would cause it would definitely be quicker and less painful (for the majority not me) to sit through four movies and a couple of hours of singing than it would be to get them through a similar amount of reading.
 
"Quadripedentae putrem sonitu,
Quatit ungula campum."
Horace, The Punic Wars.

...And that's just off the top of my head. So there.

Human beings are mostly pretty stupid anyway, that's why and how you can con them into becoming educated in the first place. All you have to do is show them something they already think they want.

Here are two/three examples:

"The Pleasures and Pains of Opium," by Thomas De Quincy

"How to Make A Million Bucks In Thirty Minutes Just By Drinking Coffee," I wrote that but it's not for sale anywhere.

"The Princess Masquerade Ball"@thefairytalepalace (By Some Twit)

I get the point of the OP though, are there some things that SHOULD be required reading...? Hell yeah!

Okay, it isn't going to happen in schools, but I'm not a pessimist about things like the internet and Google; I think at some point a few young people will make the leap from superficial titles and names and dates, to the actual source texts and all of a sudden you will get what the promise of this era is supposed to be, MORE knowledgeable and broader informed people, not less well-read people. People should use BOTH the internet, AND actual book texts, and then we will progress significantly.
 
Some of my younger friends were discussing that infernal show 'Big Brother', yet much to my disgust had never heard of George Orwell's classic dystopian novel 1984.
BB is cool beans, but not knowing it's based on Orwell's idea of 24-hour surveillance ought to be a capital offense.
 
Why make them read? Google, Wiki, Bing and the whole internet mean that you can learn something in moments from your phone and forget it moments later when no longer need the information.

Soon we'll have an app called "conversationalist" which will use the mic and earbud to googlewiki appropriate responses for nearly eveything the mic picks up.

You'll be able to choose any setting between Mike Yates and Einstein and it will provide conversation points at that level. Wow your audience, be the life of the party, appear educated and well read. . . Topic is 1984? You've got the book in your ear. $2.99 at app store, turn on one click shopping, no ads.
That's trying to make a horse drink.
 
Once you weren't deemed educated until you could translate latin texts about the punic wars or compose verses extempore in that dead language. Now we've dumbed the requirements for literacy down to reading young-adult lit like 1984, Catcher in the Rye and The Great Gatsby. Youths today are useless except as a conduit for facebook and twitter information.

"in pictura est puella romana"

First line from my first Latin textbook when I was at school. Engraved on my brain in letters of fire. I can still do the amo, amas bollocks if I have to. Not a lot of call for it these days.
 
The best argument in favor of a compulsory reading list is that it gives everyone a common frame of reference.
"I was in Europe when the Constitution was planned... On receiving it, I wrote to Mr. Madison, urging the want of provision for the freedom of religion, freedom of the press, trial by jury, habeas corpus, the substitution of militia for a standing army, and an express reservation to the States of all rights not specifically granted to the Union. He accordingly moved in the first session of Congress for these amendments, which were agreed to and ratified by the States as they now stand. This is all the hand I had in what related to the Constitution.

"Our predecessors made it doubtful how far even these were of any value; for the very law which endangered your personal safety, as well as that which restrained the freedom of the press, were gross violations of them.

"However, it is still certain that though written constitutions may be violated in moments of passion or delusion, yet they furnish a text to which those who are watchful may again rally and recall the people; they fix too for the people the principles of their political creed."

— Thomas Jefferson, letter to Dr. Joseph Priestly, June 1802
 
Once you weren't deemed educated until you could translate latin texts about the punic wars or compose verses extempore in that dead language. Now we've dumbed the requirements for literacy down to reading young-adult lit like 1984, Catcher in the Rye and The Great Gatsby. Youths today are useless except as a conduit for facebook and twitter information.

My last school (in England), not my last school, had graffiti in Latin in the toilets. The toilets reserved for the seniors also had obscene poetry in Classical Greek mainly about the staff's sexual preferences. But at the time Latin was compulsory for any student considering Oxford or Cambridge Universities.

But there are still some few UK state schools that offer Latin and Classical Greek, as options, not as the compulsory subjects they could be in my time.

I worry about the limited requirements of the English examinations at age 16 in England. Even the highest grade requires far less than my contemporaries were expected to have read. As for the level for University entrance? Any current student having read the minimum number of books now required for a good pass - would have failed miserably in the 1950s and early 1960s.

But there are still students who read widely, and read the classics of English Literature. What they read is much broader than in my day which assumed that all 'good' writers stopped writing in 1918, and that writers in English from other countries weren't worth considering.
 
Back
Top