Common Core

4est_4est_Gump

Run Forrest! RUN!
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Posts
89,007
Glen Beck and others have been talking about it. It is supposed to be some subversive tool to teach our children to be liberally flexible and give them all a common belief system that prepares them for college entrance. I thought in many ways that it is in Mike Yates territory when I hear it said that the answers are not as important as learning a process to get the answers. I mean, right is right and wrong is wrong, but my kid's Algebra text is giving me some grave concerns about a purely subjective education.

Last week, she was having problems with two questions on her homework and could not get the right answers according to the answers in the book. She texted her classmates and they were all getting the same answers, one of them collectively wrong and I figured out why. When I asked her if the teacher went over the two questions to show how to get the book's answer, she told me that he never goes over the homework, that turning it in is a 100%.

Last night's questionable question:

There are 300 coins in a jar. There are w pennies, x nickels, y dimes and z quarters. If you draw one coin from the jar what is P(the amount is less than $1.00)?

Let's see how many of you get the 'right' answer according to the book.

I think this must be purposeful in order to facilitate the student letting go with any obsession to get the correct answer and to focus on the process.

Maybe it is just me. Maybe it says more about the people writing the new texts...
 
Last edited:
Some of you might remember how I went on last year about the English text being not much more than a vehicle to teach the fear of man-made climate change...



But this is math. There can only be a right answer! :eek:
 
'The road to Hell is paved with good intentions' is the correct answer.
 
In Common Core there is no right answer, from what I've heard.

The amount is less that $1, and a Shiny Squirrel.


Oh look!!! A Mopar!!!

http://www.coronet440.com/images/big_DSC02901.jpg


Oh look mores . . . tits!!!!

http://www.boobieblog.com/JanaDefi.jpg

'The road to Hell is paved with good intentions' is the correct answer.


There may be no right answers in a subjective education...

They hate Mopar but love tits on display.

We cannot speak of hell.

Strict separation.

;) ;)
 
The truth is mean, Son. Life is not fair.


You were told what to do, and you took the Frank Sinatra approach instead.


Get lots of coffins ready.
 
Another farce in the Satyricon involves the nonchalant ignorance of Trimalchio and his guests. The wannabes equate influence and money with status and learning and so pontificate about current events, with made-up mythologies and half-educated references to history. When Trimalchio and his banqueters begin to sermonize on literature, almost everything that follows turns out to be wrong — as Petronius reminds us how high learning has become as inane a commodity as food or sex, and only sort of half consumed, rather like the 2008 campaign of faux Greek columns and Vero possumus, which were supposed to convey gravitas.

Likewise, in our version, what does a $200,000 Ivy League education or a graduate degree really get you any more? In the sophisticated world of our political and highly credentialed elites, there are 57 states. Atlantic Coast cities are said to lie along the Gulf of Mexico; after all, they are down there somewhere in the South. The Malvinas become the Maldives — Ma- with an s at the end seems close enough. Corps-men serve in the military (as zombies?). Medgar Evans was a civil-rights icon, but you know whom we mean. President Roosevelt addressed the nation on television after the stock-market crash in 1929 — well, he would have, had he been president then and if only Americans had had televisions in their homes. And how are we to know that what we read from celebrity authors is not just made up or plagiarized, whether a Maureen Dowd column or a Doris Kearns Goodwin book?

The famously nouveau-riche Trimalchio’s guests drop the names of the rich and powerful, mostly to remind one another that they are now among the plutocracy that is replacing the old bankrupt aristocracy. We too are seeing something like that metamorphosis. It is hard to guess on any given summer weekend which populist progressive family — the Obamas, the Clintons, the Kerrys, the Gores — will be ensconced on what particular Hamptons, Nantucket, or Martha’s Vineyard beach, rubbing shoulders with just the sort of Silicon Valley or Wall Street new zillionaires who during work hours are supposed to be the evil “1 percent” and “fat cats” who need to be forced to pay their “fair share.”

Al Gore, like Trimalchio, does not mutter a word without revealing his ignorance — or hypocrisy. Over the last 15 years, the planet has not heated up, and the science of global warming is not established, which is why the nomenclature had to change from global warming to climate change to climate chaos in order to account for too much bothersome wet, snowy, and cold weather. The reconciler, who became a near-billionaire both hyping global warming and selling medieval-style indulgences as antidotes, now claims those who disagree with him are comparable to fascists and racists. All this comes from a wheeler-dealer who made big money damning fossil fuels only to sell a failing cable station to an anti-Semitic, anti-American fascistic enterprise, fueled by the millions garnered from the vast export of oil and gas from the Arabian peninsula. And to complete Gore’s Trimalchian man-of-the-people profile, he rushed the sale in hopes of beating the new, higher capital-gains taxes that he had been urging for lesser folk — sort of like progressive John Kerry buying and berthing his grand new yacht in Rhode Island to avoid the high excise and sales taxes in his home state of Massachusetts.
Victor Davis Hanson, An American Satyricon
http://www.nationalreview.com/node/356805/print
 
Last night's questionable question:

There are 300 coins in a jar. There are w pennies, x nickels, y dimes and z quarters. If you draw one coin from the jar what is P(the amount is less than $1.00)?

Let's see how many of you get the 'right' answer according to the book.

I think this must be purposeful in order to facilitate the student letting go with any obsession to get the correct answer and to focus on the process.

Maybe it is just me. Maybe it says more about the people writing the new texts...

The answer to your question is, of course, Jesus.
Just as it is with any other good homeskool text.

However, if this is a Libertarian homeskool textbook, then the answer is "whatever you want it to be (usually 91 cents)" As you've mentioned before quite often: one dollar, one quarter and one nickel sums up to 91 cents.

I hope this helps your "daughter".
 
Two points to consider, Chief:

1. You're presumably paying good money for homeskooling your pretend child. If you find out that your "daughter"'s teacher is not checking her homework, it'd be prudent for you as a "parent" to find out why.

2. Questions that you cannot answer are not by definition "questionable questions". As we've seen here in the past decade on the General Board, there are substantial gaping holes in your knowledge. Most of it is "willful ignorance" but some of it is "natural ignorance".
 
Glen Beck and others have been talking about it. It is supposed to be some subversive tool to teach our children to be liberally flexible and give them all a common belief system that prepares them for college entrance. I thought in many ways that it is in Mike Yates territory when I hear it said that the answers are not as important as learning a process to get the answers. I mean, right is right and wrong is wrong, but my kid's Algebra text is giving me some grave concerns about a purely subjective education.

Last week, she was having problems with two questions on her homework and could not get the right answers according to the answers in the book. She texted her classmates and they were all getting the same answers, one of them collectively wrong and I figured out why. When I asked her if the teacher went over the two questions to show how to get the book's answer, she told me that he never goes over the homework, that turning it in is a 100%.

Last night's questionable question:

There are 300 coins in a jar. There are w pennies, x nickels, y dimes and z quarters. If you draw one coin from the jar what is P(the amount is less than $1.00)?

Let's see how many of you get the 'right' answer according to the book.

I think this must be purposeful in order to facilitate the student letting go with any obsession to get the correct answer and to focus on the process.

Maybe it is just me. Maybe it says more about the people writing the new texts...

I honestly cannot answer this question.

What grade is your daughter in?
 
I honestly cannot answer this question.

What grade is your daughter in?

That does not matter.

The answer is a matter of common sense. You do possess at least some street smarts. Right?

Even you know the odds of drawing a $2 coin from the jar...

It takes ZERO Algebra to solve this problem.
 
But this is math. There can only be a right answer! :eek:

True, but if you don't learn how to work the mechanics of it (the process of working the problem, order of ops. etc) you will NEVER get the right answer.

If you do learn the mechanics of it, you can put WHATEVER numbers you want in and ALWAYS get a right answer.

And that's horrible your kid's teacher doesn't go over the lesson that will enable them to complete their HW. I have only ever had that at a U and even then they were totally open for questions.
 
There are 300 coins made up of pennies/nickels/dimes/quarters but how do you know how many of each coin there are in that jar of 300? And if you draw a single coin from the jar, what is the average of 1/5/10/25 cents in a stack of 300?

I don't understand the mechanics or order of operations of this.
 
Last night's questionable question:

There are 300 coins in a jar. There are w pennies, x nickels, y dimes and z quarters. If you draw one coin from the jar what is P(the amount is less than $1.00)?

Let's see how many of you get the 'right' answer according to the book.

If "P" is supposed to be the monetary value of all the coins in the jar, and the given monetary value is less than $1.00 after withdrawing one, then there simply cannot be 300 coins in the jar. Even if there were zero nickles, dimes and quarters that would leave you with 300 pennies which, the last time I checked, is $3. Withdrawing one gets us to $2.99.

Unless we're in some South American country where a "centavos" is substantially less than 1/100th of a "peso."

Of far greater concern is why the teacher would give a top score to every single student who simply completed the homework.

As I understand common core standards, the primary objective is to separate process from result and ensure that the student has a CORRECT understanding of each. In algebra, for example, this would present the situation of actually having two correct answers for every problem. The first question is whether the student constructed or chose the correct algebraic formula to produce the correct quantitative answer through the standard operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication and division.

The second question is whether the student performed those operations correctly according to the dictates of the formula he chose.

In the "old days," any wrong answer would be totally wrong. But it is not difficult to see that a student arriving at a wrong quantitative answer by virtue of having chosen the wrong formula and completed all the operations correctly according to the formula he chose is "less wrong" by half than a student who chose the wrong formula AND performed its operations incorrectly.

If this type of in depth investigation into a student's abilities is at the core of common core standards, then that effort is to be commended. Giving the same score to every student for simply turning in a homework assignment, however, does not begin that degree of investigation. It suggests no instructional effort of the teacher's part whatsoever, and thus represents a procedural failure of its own sort.

I also don't see how a "common sense" problem like the one posed in the homework assignment addresses a student's ability to construct a proper formula where, in this case, no specific formula appears to be required.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top