Circumcision

Is male circumcision gential mutilation?

  • Yes

    Votes: 30 49.2%
  • No

    Votes: 30 49.2%
  • Other (explain)

    Votes: 1 1.6%

  • Total voters
    61
And to address those offended by my comments (probably the "fucked up in the head" part)..

all I meant by that is people have become brainwashed into thinking a routine circumcision is normal, healthy, and the right thing to do. If you're offended by my remark, then that probably means you're one of those people.

I'm not attacking your parenting skills, and I'm sure you love your child(ren). All I'm saying is society needs it's head examined.

it's like those tribes that modify their bodies by stretching their necks, ear lobes, heads, etc. Most people outside the tribe would probably think it's crazy to do that. If someone in the United States started putting rings around their kid's neck (in order to stretch it out), they'd probably get hauled off to jail.
 
For teens, it IS all about looks & fitting in. My son went through a period of looking like Carrottop, wild red hair and all. I am still not sure what that was all about, but he had fun & was a bit more individual than most. I am sure that when you were in school, you were totally your own person, didn't follow the trends & were totally happy. For many of us, it wasn't that easy. I was the geeky brainy girl in school & it sucked. I wish you luck when you have children, raising kids is a tough job & we all go about it a bit differently. This is one of those times where people need to agree to disagree. It would just be nice if it could be done in a rational manner.
 
Angel said:
I don't think it is mutilation - my personal opinion is that it is a body modification that is not needed.

Now I'm curious. What would be a body modification that is needed?
 
I chose no circumcision for my son. Uncircumcised is becoming more of the norm here on the west coast and particularly in urban settings. Insurance companies no longer will pay for it as it is unnecessary. The American Academy of Pediatrics no longer recommends them.

I love playing with foreskin. That is a benefit to me. One of my fetishes. I had a lover once whose circumcision didn't go as well as normal and he had a loop of skin, like it had been pierced, and I could slip my little finger into it. He liked it and so did I.

I don't think the locker room story holds anymore because there will be boys who are and boys who aren't . My husband is cut and my son just thinks he has "more" and is not in the least concerned about not looking like his dad. It is especially true when we tell him his dad had his cut off!
 
Last edited:
Ours was the first generation to adopt circumcision as a hygenic decision, thanks in part to Dr. Spock and other baby doctors out there. At the time of our births, the medical community believed that circumcision prevented cancer, was cleaner, and was a better choice. Now, if you ask any medical provider, they are most likely to be on the fence about this subject. While the prevailing opinions are 50-50, I have already made the decision that should I bear any boy children, the procedure will not be done. As to whether it is mutilation or not...there are men who have had it done who have no regrets...there are men who haven't and are perfectly happy about it. However, all of these beliefs are pre-empted should one's religious beliefs call for male circumcision.
 
Circumsized or not, it doesn't bother me. I've been with men of both types, and although it is different, I can't say that I prefer one to the other. Now, if I had a son I honestly don't know what I would do. It would be a careful decision made between the boy's father and I.
 
interesting reactions.


marxist, i'm wondering why you think it's a stupid thing to discuss. there are quite a few men involved in this discussion. on the first page there were 3 women and 10 men who posted.

i don't understand what it's like to have a penis. that's why i wanted to hear people's opinons.

i wonder why you reacted so strongly though. i'm sorry you were dissapointed in me.
 
Maybe he wants more men to have a micropenis like he does, hence the cutting?
 
Apparently I'm the only "Other"

Well... I chose other because I believe that the procedure both is and isn't mutilation.

My husband is circumsized, and thats great - that's the way is parents wanted him to be - to look like his dad.

My 3 boys ARE NOT circumsized... I'm personally against it as a parent - FOR MY CHILDREN.

So I'm neither for or against, I love my husband's cock, and have been with uncircumsized men as well... both are great... I love em all! But I'm leaving the decision to my boys if they want to be circumsized - they can do it when they are older. I've heard too many guys whining about the fact that they wish their parents hadn't cut them as babies.

And for the health aspect... all of my boys have been fine... they have been taught how to clean themselves properly and the whole nine yards... so, I'm happy with my choice.

Just my opinion...

Baby
 
There is an alternative. Cleaning an uncircumsized (sp?) penis is difficult for some men because the little strip of tissue between the bottom of the head and the foreskin inhibits "skinning back" for cleaning. It is a simple and painless (I read) procedure for the doc to clip it during your lunch hour. Nothing is removed. Solves the pain and cleaning problem. An uncircumsized friend accidently had this clipped while his Girl was sucking him. He says that it was the best thing that happened to him in a long time. Ask your doctor if you are having problems. Circumsizing an adult is quite painful and the pain lasts for days. I was in a navy hospital with two twin brothers who had both been "trimmrd". at age 22. They were in pain for days. After they started feeling better it became a joke. They had pills to prevent an erection and, as a joke, they would scramble frantically for their pills when a nurse would approach. The nurses were in the next wing of the hospital and would tease by doing a partial strip as if forgetting to close the blinds. Very funny.
 
seXieleXie said:
interesting reactions.


marxist, i'm wondering why you think it's a stupid thing to discuss. there are quite a few men involved in this discussion. on the first page there were 3 women and 10 men who posted.

i don't understand what it's like to have a penis. that's why i wanted to hear people's opinons.

i wonder why you reacted so strongly though. i'm sorry you were dissapointed in me.

That wasn't my count, but I think I have my page preferences set to display differently.

I guess what I reacted so strongly to was the murky waters of female circumcision (often confused with clitoris removal or mutilation) being mentioned in the same breath of a standard Western practice that is only harmful to the eyes of people watching.
 
How can you be so sure that it's not harmful at all, Marx?

This isn't about your beautiful, cut cock.
 
Rubyfruit said:
How can you be so sure that it's not harmful at all, Marx?

This isn't about your beautiful, cut cock.

You can't prove a negative, sweetheart.

Besides, if you had a cock you'd understand that the foreskin (even us cut boys still have a piece) is about as sensitive as the loose skin between your thumb and forefinger, cut or uncut.

Personally, I just don't like the idea of trying to teach a young boy how to deal with smegma when you can barely teach them to poop consistently and wipe.
 
Actually, the foreskin stays attached for many years in uncut boys. It's supposed to be that way and naturally will fold back when the time is right.
 
As far as we know, the first people to practise circumcision were those in the arid lands of the Middle East. The prevalence of sand and the challenge of cleanliness probably had a lot to do with it.

The practice became a religious ritual because medicine and religion have always been closely tied. Along with law, these were the only branches of higher learning.

Circumcision means a lot of different things across the various cultures that subscribe to it. Its importance depends on the meaning given to it. The original justification is mainly irrelevant today.
 
When we told my mother of our decision not to circumcise our son and the reasons for it, she became quite defensive. She was very upset, arguing that babies didn't even feel it, and it was no big deal, etc. She kept telling us of the reasons she had my brother circumcised, many of which are outdated. But my brother is almost 40 years old - things were different in this country when he was born. (my father also shared with us that he is uncut - because when he was born, 1930, it wasn't widely practiced) Today, however, at least half of male infants are no longer routinely circumcised.

I don't believe it is a type of mutilation, but it certainly is unnecessary surgery. My 4-year-old son had to have two surgeries before he was two months old. ALL surgeries are a big deal - I wouldn't put a baby through anything just to make a parent feel more comfortable.

And as for the argument that the boy will feel different in the locker room? Not anymore. Because by the time he is of age, half the boys in the locker room will be uncut.
 
I love my dick the way it is, I could never imagine it differently. I like having a pointy head. If I ever have monster, I mean kids, I'll get them circumcised
 
All the guys I've been with have been cut, except for one, and that was such a hasty encounter I did not have the opportunity to examine his equipment properly. Roughly 3/4 of the guys I was with that were cut were from the Middle East.

Remember that story in the Bible when the Lord supposedly caused the sun to stand still in the sky? All the guys had just been circumcized just before they had to go out and fight. No doubt it would have seemed like the sun stood still in the sky, even if it didn't.

I had my son done for the usual reason--to look more "regular" in the locker room. He suffered with adhesions in the first year of his life; the first time he had them treated, the doctor put in a local anesthetic which probably hurt just as much, if not more so, than the unsticking process. The second time was with a different doctor, who unstuck him without benefit of an anesthetic when he was howling his head off (my son, not the doctor) for having to be there at all. This doctor said that in the event that the kid was ever operated on for a hernia or something, he might ought to be recircumcized. However, last time I looked (he's now 13, and going through the modest phase) that did not appear to be necessary.

If I had it to do all over again, I'd probably leave him as God made him.
 
Last edited:
circumcision

I don't think it's mutilation - that's damn harsh I think. I had my sons circumcised and there was no sharp knife involved. They used a plastic ring that they sized to cut off the blood supply to the foreskin and it came off. There wasn't any blood and the boys didn't experience any discomfort (ie, crying, fussing, etc.) They don't harbor any ill feelings about my making that desicion for them. I do wish, however, that I had let them make the decision for themselves, as I now think it's a personal choice.
 
Marxist said:


You can't prove a negative, sweetheart.

Besides, if you had a cock you'd understand that the foreskin (even us cut boys still have a piece) is about as sensitive as the loose skin between your thumb and forefinger, cut or uncut.

And you were doing so well until I read the thumb and forefinger bit, you should know better than to generalise Marxist.

Frankly my foreskin is a damn site more sensitive than the skin between my thumb and forefinger.
 
OUTSIDER said:


Frankly my foreskin is a damn site more sensitive than the skin between my thumb and forefinger.

I can atest to the sensitivity of a man's foreskin from a woman's perspective.:)
 
OUTSIDER said:


And you were doing so well until I read the thumb and forefinger bit, you should know better than to generalise Marxist.

Frankly my foreskin is a damn site more sensitive than the skin between my thumb and forefinger.

You're just begging to be called "special." There ya go chief.
 
Back
Top