Childhood Obesity

WriterDom

Good to the last drop
Joined
Jun 25, 2000
Posts
20,077
In some states they are weighing kids and putting it on their report cards. To me that is humiliation. Both the kid and the parents already know he or she is overweight.
 
Sounds like child abuse, both the weighing and the parents who oversee the diet and exercise or lack of.
 
Just got to love government entities trying to make parents feel more like a failure and children with medical problems more neurotic. Way to send more kids into anorexia and bulimia....
 
Weight on your report card.

What's next, dick size on your resume?
 
Weight on your report card.

What's next, dick size on your resume?

Yours isn't? :D

Seriously, this is yet another un-needed government intrusion. Used to be we told the government what to do. That's changed, and that's a problem.
 
In some states they are weighing kids and putting it on their report cards. To me that is humiliation. Both the kid and the parents already know he or she is overweight.

You assume a lot.

A lot of parents don't know or care where their children are, let alone what they weigh and if it's bad, who their friends are, or how to make pasta on a stove. I know it's depressing to always have to assume worse when you're thinking about tailoring things to the public, but the levels of dysfunction that have to be addressed are amazing.

I'm not in favor of this because I think it's pointless to weigh kids and then feed them chips and fishsticks and quarter water and call it food. Which the school is doing.
 
Last edited:
We all had bad eating habits as kids but our activity level was so high we burned it off There were only a couple of heavy kids to a class. My mother would let me eat ice cream for breakfast. Food then was more often fried than not. Still I weighed 135 at 18.
 
God Almighty, that's horrible.

I mean, when I was in high school, I thought PE class was humiliating enough, and I was in shape. I was just one of those tall, muscled, built-like-a-brick-shithouse types (then) in a class full of tiny, wiry types. I could never run the mile in the amount of time allotted, but then they couldn't do sprints like I could, either.

I think between the horrid school lunches and the way they try to get kids to "exercise," which is also terrible, maybe the schools ought to look at themselves and say, "Hey, maybe we're doing it wrong!"

Like that's going to happen. :rolleyes:
 
how about instead of humiliating and psychologically scarring kids by weighing them, the schools bring back P.E. instead. P.E. programs are going the way of the dinosaur...Daddy's son has never heard of phys ed, and he's attended both private and public schools.

back when i was a little chap, i hated P.E. with a passion, but at least it forced you to move your butt and be active. does anyone else remember the Presidential Physical Fitness Test every year? do they even still do that anymore?
 
how about instead of humiliating and psychologically scarring kids by weighing them, the schools bring back P.E. instead. P.E. programs are going the way of the dinosaur...Daddy's son has never heard of phys ed, and he's attended both private and public schools.

My brain just broke.
 
What kills me about things like this is that they have these kids. They know these kids are overweight. But then, instead of, say, using gym to give them actual workouts (biking, lifting weights, stairmaster, stretching) they make them play basketball, or do track and field things.
That
doesn't
help.
In fact, its downright pointless anyhow. Gym shouldn't be about playing games. It should be about learning how to take care of your body and stay fit.
In practice, most of the time gym is more about putting the weaker kids down.
 
We only had 9th grade PE. I think the main purpose was letting the coaching staff get a look at the freshman class.
 
What kills me about things like this is that they have these kids. They know these kids are overweight. But then, instead of, say, using gym to give them actual workouts (biking, lifting weights, stairmaster, stretching) they make them play basketball, or do track and field things.
That
doesn't
help.
In fact, its downright pointless anyhow. Gym shouldn't be about playing games. It should be about learning how to take care of your body and stay fit.
In practice, most of the time gym is more about putting the weaker kids down.

Have you ever worked out? Did you think it was fun? Do you think a kid will think its fun?

They have kids play games as a way to get them to exercise and still have fun.
 
Have you ever worked out? Did you think it was fun? Do you think a kid will think its fun?

They have kids play games as a way to get them to exercise and still have fun.

It's still not fun. It's only fun if you get to play games you actually like as opposed to mindless games of kickball or something equally dull for months on end. Does anybody even LIKE kickball? (Hell, it requires the same number of people and facilities as softball; let's play that instead.) Or dodgeball, OMG. A stupider game I can't possibly imagine.
 
It's still not fun. It's only fun if you get to play games you actually like as opposed to mindless games of kickball or something equally dull for months on end. Does anybody even LIKE kickball? (Hell, it requires the same number of people and facilities as softball; let's play that instead.) Or dodgeball, OMG. A stupider game I can't possibly imagine.


completely.
I'm also not suggesting that its fun.
I didn't particularly like many of my classes.
If they can make it useful AND fun, great, but right now its useless and for many kids not fun at all.
If its going to be miserable, at least make it worthwhile.
Gym <> recess
 
It's still not fun. It's only fun if you get to play games you actually like as opposed to mindless games of kickball or something equally dull for months on end. Does anybody even LIKE kickball? (Hell, it requires the same number of people and facilities as softball; let's play that instead.) Or dodgeball, OMG. A stupider game I can't possibly imagine.

actually i used to love kickball, it was one of the very few sports we were forced to play in school that i didn't dread. why? because kicking, unlike softball/basketball/tennis/football/etc. does not require hand-eye coordination, nor balance, two things which i very much lack. i can kick a ball, kick it hard, and remain standing upright while doing it as opposed to falling on my bum. hence, i loved kickball. it is a sport built for geeks, lol.
 
actually i used to love kickball, it was one of the very few sports we were forced to play in school that i didn't dread. why? because kicking, unlike softball/basketball/tennis/football/etc. does not require hand-eye coordination, nor balance, two things which i very much lack. i can kick a ball, kick it hard, and remain standing upright while doing it as opposed to falling on my bum. hence, i loved kickball. it is a sport built for geeks, lol.

I'm probably just biased because I blew my left knee up playing kickball. I had problems with that thing off and on for years and years.
 
It's still not fun. It's only fun if you get to play games you actually like as opposed to mindless games of kickball or something equally dull for months on end. Does anybody even LIKE kickball? (Hell, it requires the same number of people and facilities as softball; let's play that instead.) Or dodgeball, OMG. A stupider game I can't possibly imagine.

They're never going to make EVERY kid happy. But having the kids do 30 minutes on a stair master and they will be begging to play kickball.

Plus it all depends on where you grow up and if your school has the funding/programs in place to make PE fun. When I was in PE we played football, softball, basketball, dodgeball, kickball, indoor floor hockey, went to the weight room, and more.
 
Dodgeball was great. Plastering a ball into the face of a kid and not getting in trouble. Kill or be killed. We're becoming too soft when schools outlaw it.

Yeah working out in theory would be good but most of the kids would hate it. Especially the ones who really need it.
 
why is everyone concerned about whether the kids are happy?
its
school
 
Back
Top