Cheerleader/athlete blackmails voyeur

[Brandnewbuddy]

So I primarily thought of this as a F/F story but this could work as a M\F story.

Another story I like to read is about two people engaging in some exploration, especially when they normally wouldn’t cross paths.

So for this one, our Voyeur is the POV. She is watching the secondary lead (a cheerleader or athlete) shower (either while taking a shower herself or peeping in on her) and gets so caught up in watching her that she doesn’t notice that she’s been caught until our cheerleader or athlete is locking eyes with her.

Afterwards our lead tries to slip out but gets cornered. Cheerleader makes a proposition: lead comes back with her to her home and lets cheerleader “Play” with her for the evening. The only rules are that lead must tell the truth and can’t do anything without Cheerleader’s permission. If lead does that, they‘lol be free to go, if they don’t, their voyeurism will be exposed.

They get home and cheerleader explains: while she has had sex, her boyfriend can never desire more than anything vanilla, he also can’t say why he finds her sexy other than he likes her ass or tits, any attempt to start a real conversation goes nowhere. Her friends also always say she’s a “sexy bitch” but they won’t say why they say that. They also will tease and flirt but aren’t really interested in her.

…but our naughty little lead is a captive audience and is clearly Very attracted to the cheerleader and they aren’t subtle about it. So for tonight our lead is going to help cheerleade find out what makes other people think she’s sexy while also finding out what makes her feel sexy. All our lead has to do is tell the truth, no matter how embarrassing, while the cheerleader lap dances, teases, and seduces them.

I think it would be fun to have a story where someone has to actually voice and explain why they find someone sexy and for it to come from someone inexperienced so their explanations come with a lot of embarrassment. Additionally since they’re inexperienced they wear their heart on their sleeves. Cheerleader might need to hear their exact words but the intent behind them is clearly on their faces and in their hearts that are pumping so hard the cheerleader can practically hear it while she straddles them.

On the flip side, I could see lead learning more about themself over the course of the night now that they’re forced to actually voice their attraction.

Like I said, the original idea was for a F/F story so the exploration would be sexuality and preference but guy could be fun too with cheerleader tapping his cock to check and see if her finds something sexy whenever he can’t put something into words.

 

[alohadave]

How about if the cheerleader is a secret exhibitionist but feels pressured to be prim and proper due to her social status.

She catches the person peeping and sees an opportunity to express her kink and not have anyone know. The cheerleader blackmails the peeper so it doesn't get out but she's still able to be watched without losing her social standing.

The peeper is happy to not be outed as a pervert and ostracized.

 

[Rob_Royale]

Blackmail can be fun.
Okay cheerleader spots the geek peeping. She's upset at first but quickly realizes that the geek is in the same college classes. So she blackmails that geek to do homework, write papers, tutor her etc. All the while sexual tension is building. The geeks not bad looking, and the cheerleader is just off a bad relationship. She needs someone's face between her thighs and the geek is so enamored with her they would do anything. A dom/sub relationship begins. It could turn romantic in a cute John Hughes kind of way, or swing into the BDSM world. It would work in any type of coupling as in college there are male cheerleaders. Lots of wiggle room in this idea. Two gay men, two gay women, male/female whatever.

 

[CuttingEdge]

I wrote a story along these lines...

It starts out with a grandmother going through her old yearbook with her granddaughter right before the homecoming game.

In the 1960's the grandmother was a cheerleader at a game her team won, but had no idea an agreement between the two teams was; the losing team got to have their way with one of the winning teams girls. The grandmother... young then, came out of the locker room after everyone had left to celebrate their win down main street. She was then taken by the rival, losing football team, staked to the fifty yard line and gangbanged.

The story ends with the granddaughter leaving for the game, the grandmother never warning her about the long established losing team gets the girl arrangement. She doesn't say anything because she loved being gang-banged so much, she secretly hopes her granddaughter gets the same treatment.

 

[alohadave]

I started working on this, I think I have a handle on how it can progress

How about if the cheerleader is a secret exhibitionist but feels pressured to be prim and proper due to her social status.

She catches the person peeping and sees an opportunity to express her kink and not have anyone know. The cheerleader blackmails the peeper so it doesn't get out but she's still able to be watched without losing her social standing.

The peeper is happy to not be outed as a pervert and ostracized.

I started on this, and I changed it up a little. The voyeur catches the cheerleader in the shower and blackmails her, holding her reputation hostage.

The voyeur will be directing the cheerleader to show herself in various situations.

Should have lots of opportunity for flashing and embarrassing the cheerleader.