Can I reply to comments on my stories?

Joined
Mar 12, 2025
Posts
35
So, I get comments on my stories. Not a lot, but sometimes there will be a question. Like "when's the next part coming?" There is no reply button in the comments. Some of the users comment anonymously. Is there a way to respond to them? If I post a comment of my own, do people who commented on that story get notified?
 
I post comments as a response occasionally. I have sent direct feedback to those with names as well. But Mr Anyonymous remains hidden. I have a few who I know are are the same guy because of what he says. He's read my series avidly. Why he doesn't go ahead and make up a username, I have no idea.
 
I would love a way to reply directly to comments and have them be nested underneath the original one. I don't reply to each individual comment because I think it looks tacky and artificially inflates your comment count, but there are plenty of other authors who do that, so it's certainly an option. I personally wait until there have been enough comments to add one of my own that addresses them all at once. Anonymous commenters can see that if they ever check the story again, but as alohadave said, there's no way of notifying them.

If a commenter has a Lit account, I have reached out before via the Feedback portal to avoid cluttering up the comments with my responses.
 
If they are a registered member, I often send a PM thank you and response, but as others have said, Anon generally gets left out unless they say something something really insightful or really ridiculous as to draw a direct reply in the comments. Even then, they probably won’t see it, but others who read their insight or their inanity may.

Like Nynah, I don’t like replying to each individual comment within the comments section itself because the original commenter likely won’t see the response anyway and it artificially inflates the comment count and may turn some readers (like me) off.
 
I often send private messages to named commentators, thanking them, and including the text of my public reply if I've replied publicly. I try and be a little restrained with the number of times I comment on my own stories, although not always successfully. If there's something really objectionable in what a commentator has said quite often other readers will jump in, but I think that it can sometime be helpful if the author acknowledges fair criticism or explains their intent.
 
I really wish we could directly reply to comments. Once in a while I get a nice comment from someone(most of the time anonymously) and I wanna say Yo thanks. But the simplicity of this site is part of it's charm. Also I could see that feature backfiring cause there would be random stories with a thousand comments from two people arguing.
 
I reply (post a comment myself) if someone asks a direct question about the content of that story, because I presume others will have the same confusion.

But "where is part II?" is not a question I'd bother replying to.
 
Back
Top