Buffy the Vampire Slayer fantasies

PanicByNumbers

Experienced
Joined
Nov 23, 2008
Posts
87
bottom boy started a thread about what one thinks about when one masturbates and I just let out with a few scenarios. I'm copy and pasting what I wrote, but I still have a few more situations to describe. Just been thinking of these for a long time and I finally have an excuse to kinda express them.

Me: 26/M/Straight

Don't know why, but I'm almost always fantasizing about most of the women from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV show, not movie). Mostly Faith, Willow (I'm her childhood best friend/true love, Xander doesn't exist in my fantasy) and Cordelia. I like to imagine I'm dating Cordelia. But the other girls make frequent appearances. Oz and Spike are my best friends and the only other guys. One of my favorite fantasies is Willow and I end up fucking/making love (I have no idea who got who into bed) with me on top slowly grinding into her while she writhes to meet me. While we're busy Tara walks in and stops short noticing me and her girlfriend together in bed. Tara stares at us for a minute before she just seems to shrug and starts to strip before joining in.

Another is I'm helping Buffy train (I'm a scrawny nerd, she'd kick my ass) for a while before she makes a pass at me and we end up cuddling naked and sated under a blanket on the floor. Buffy and I wake up when we hear an very loud "AH-HEM!" Opening my eyes, I see a pair of perfectly pedicured feet in a pair of open-toed valley girl heels. Looking up, Buffy and I follow a very nice pair of legs up to Cordelia's (my girlfriend) annoyed and sarcastic expression. Haven't quite figured out what she's wearing. Buffy's embarrassed more about the fact Cordelia's there than the fact she slept with me. Cordelia's annoyed more with the fact I didn't wait for her than the fact I slept with Buffy.

Another one is Buffy and Faith (who are a couple in my dreams) ask me to babysit Dawn while they go on patrol. Dawn has a head-over-heels crush on me and barely waits for the door to close before she's hitting on me. She's in pajamas and tries everything from sitting and squirming in my lap to flat out becoming the dirtiest talking girl in the world before she eventually turns on some music and alternate between dirty dancing with me to giving me a lap dance. Dawn ends up standing bent over with me fucking her ass (literally anal) screaming in ecstasy when Buffy and Faith walk in. Faith smiles and enjoys the show while Buffy shoots Dawn jealous looks. After I pop in Dawn's ass Faith applaudes us and takes Dawn to her bed and Buffy takes me to her and Faith's room so she can "thank me" for babysitting Dawn. She promptly jumps me and fucks me senseless, including demanding I pound her ass like I pounded her little sister's.

And now the rest....

Buffy and I go scouting for vampires. "Scouting" in this case means Buffy and I get in a fixed up t-bird and park in a secluded spot where vampires might be hunting. We hang out for a few minutes before Buffy suggests we need to look more vulnerable for the vamps. I ask how and Buffy recomends we act like a couple. We start petting and making out and her hands spend most of their time on the bulge in my pants. After she tells me to make it look real she says to play with her as much as I want. I'm not sure who wants her top off more, her or me. We get into it and she pauses and looks around. "No vamps." she says "They may not be fooled yet. I've really got to make it seem like we're on a date." or something like that. She tells me to keep my eyes open while she unzips my fly. I barely open my mouth to ask why, but she's already face down and moaning loudly around my cock while bobbing her head in my lap. After a while she lifts her head up and wipes her mouth while looking around again. "Still no vamps. Maybe if we both keep our eyes open for them at the same time." Buffy reaches under her mini-skirt and peels off her thong before straddling her topless self on me and engulfing my dick in her pussy. I buck into her and she bounces on me screaming until we both cum. when we get our breath back Buffy peels herself off of me and puts her top back on. I say "I guess there aren't any vampires around here." Buffy just throws me a confused look and asks "What vampires?" I look back at her and she says "Ohhh...right! Those vampires!" chuckling nervously to herself "Guess not. Maybe we should look somewhere else." Before we drive off.

I also fantasize about having Buffy naked and on her knees while I face fuck her with Dawn spying on us as her sister hungrily blows me.

Cordelia being extremely submissive with me is also a turn on. Something about the high and mighty "Queen C" stripping naked infront of me and the rest of the girls and then meekly dropping to her knees before she gives me a gentle, loving blowjob while everyone watches.

The next one is Oz and I hang out with Willow in her and Tara's apartment. Oz is dating Veruca and I'm still with Cordelia. Willow ends up sitting between Oz and I and somehow the conversation starts of who Willow would be with if she wasn't with Tara. Willow says she doesn't know, I say she'd stay with Tara and Oz says she'd want to be with me. Willow admits she'd like that but also says Oz was a nice boyfriend. I say Willow would be amazing in bed no matter who she was with. Willow blushes and thanks me. Through the conversation, Willow's hands have come to rest gently rubbing on our crotches. Oz and I start fondling her and she doesn't protest as our hands travel up her skirt, under her sweater etc. She's smiling and squirming, whimpering while we finger her pussy and grope her tits. She starts peeling off her own clothes and unzips both of us freeing our cocks into her hands. Naked now, Willow leans over to suck me off. Oz continues to finger her. She eventually switches over to suck him and I line her up and bury myself in her tightness. Willow gives a short little scream muffled by the cock in her mouth that almost immediately turns into happy moans as I saw in and out of her. After a while we switch around and give her a true spitroast as Oz fucks her doggy and I tangle my fingers in her long red hair and mercilessly pump her face. Tara walks in (are you seeing a motif?) to see her lesbian girlfriend getting plowed from both ends by her best friend and ex-boyfriend. I pull out of Willow's mouth long enough for Tara to hear her stuttering moans before I stuff it in Willow's mouth again. I invite Tara to join in and she smiles brightly and gets naked. waiting on her hands and knees for someone to start on her.

A follow up to the previous is Tara invites Spike and I to meet her at Willow's apartment. Once there Tara strips and throws herself at us, begging to be our fuck doll. Tara just wants to show Willow that she can be a nasty slut too. Willow walks in to witness Spike and I DP'ing Tara as she shrieks and writhes between us. Willow stares wide-eyed at us before someone invites her to join in. Willow smiles cutely and starts to undress...

I have a few more, but it's really late and I need bed. I know I didn't write any Faith scenarios, but with her there's usually no lead up. We just start out fucking.
 
I <3 Buffy and Willow was my favourite character. I used to read a lot of fanfic that was Willow based, some erotic and some not so. I would more often than not put myself in Willow's place I just identified with her the most, me being a nerdy shy girl IRL.

On your fantasies, they do sound kinda hot but the whole walking in on you with whoever and then joining in doesnt really gel with the world that Joss created. Well apart from Spike, I'm pretty sure he would fuck anything with a pussy.
 
I think any boy who ever saw Buffy liked it.

I instanly fell in love with all of the girls there :D

Buffy of course..

But also the bad girl, Faith.

Loved Willow to :)

Liked Cordelia better in Angel though :D
 
Mmm, that sounds heavenly! I've always been attracted to the woman of BTVS, me a "straight" girl and all.
Though I would not mind having angel and Riley. Might even have had
Erotic dreams about Giles once in a while.
Joss Whedon is a genius, absolutely love his work. Though most of it was cut off too early for my liking.
I'm glad people I found people on lit who feel the same about BTVS and Angel as me.
Whedonites unite :p

What would you do with the characters then :D

Personaly, I'd like to drive Willow so crazy with teasing stuff around the room will start levitating because she is losing control :)
 
Female Cast:

Sarah Michelle Gellar - Buffy - Great looking girl with good body but for some reason never really got my motor running. Though in real life very hot.

Alyson Hannigan - Willow - I have a weakness for redheads and this girl had an understated sexuality that really made for hotness. This little lady was also blessed with incredibly sexy legs. In real life very sexy girl

Charisma Carpenter - Cordelia - Arguably the best body on the show. Totally hot bikini body. My only problem with her was she played a bit of an airhead. Dumb girls turn me off. On Angel she became hot to me because her character evolved and became less dumb and a bit more complex.

Emma Caulfield - Anya - Nothing special on the show but attractive in real life,

Michelle Trachtenberg - Dawn - She was a cute kid on the show but due to her tender years I never thought of her sexually. She is now 25 years old and a total babe.

Amber Nicole Benson - Tara - Never much excited me. For me the only hotness she had was maybe licking willows sweet cunt.

Eliza Dushku - Recurring role of Faith - For me without doubt the baddest bitch on the show. Toned athletic body full of attitude. A girl you just cannot dominate. She will fuck you from the bottom then kick your ass to boot. This is a girl after you are done fucking her you leave batter and bruised but wanting more. (she turned down a spinoff show about Faith) Very hot in real life.

http://www.oneangryman.com/ken/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/Sarah-Michelle-Gellar-breasts.jpghttp://www.rumela.com/albums/alyson_hannigan/alyson_hannigan13.jpghttp://www.perfectpeople.net/photo-picture-image-media/Charisma-Carpenter-758x964-141kb-media-232-media-0370.jpghttp://www.timerthemovie.com/emma.jpghttp://www.gotceleb.com/wp-content/uploads/pics/michelle-trachtenberg/esquire-magazine-uk-2005-photoshoot/michelle-trachtenberg-esquire-magazine-uk-2005-photoshoot-01.jpghttp://cdn.mademan.com/chickipedia/images/6/62/405823_826.jpghttp://4.bp.blogspot.com/_DV8qAh2QWq8/TUSBilM1YdI/AAAAAAAAACI/jWMPkiEBqeg/s1600/109Still005.jpg
 
I only really liked Willow and Anya. The shy nerd gets me every time, and Anya was just brilliant on a lot of levels.

Plus they were just like, y'know... hot and stuff.

I think vampire Willow was the sexiest thing I've ever seen.
 
I love this thread!

One of my guilty pleasures is reading slash fic-- and one of my totally favorite slash pairings is Xander, the normal guy, with Spike is the little black dress of BTVS (you can imagine him with anyone and everyone) and having said that-- a lot of slashers bash the women on the show. Which doesn't make any damn sense to me, if they wanted as how without women there are hundreds. Buffy had good, strong women.

And Drusilla? Vulnerable, sweet, sad-- and scary batshit crazy? I loved that very first scene with her, when she strokes Spike's cheek-- and leaves blood running down his face.
 
I only really liked Willow and Anya. The shy nerd gets me every time, and Anya was just brilliant on a lot of levels.

Plus they were just like, y'know... hot and stuff.

I think vampire Willow was the sexiest thing I've ever seen.

Hell, yeah!

I was more of an Angel fan myself, though, and pretty much all the female cast were hot, Except for Harmony. Don't like airheads myself, either.
 
I love this thread!

One of my guilty pleasures is reading slash fic-- and one of my totally favorite slash pairings is Xander, the normal guy, with Spike is the little black dress of BTVS (you can imagine him with anyone and everyone) and having said that-- a lot of slashers bash the women on the show. Which doesn't make any damn sense to me, if they wanted as how without women there are hundreds. Buffy had good, strong women.

And Drusilla? Vulnerable, sweet, sad-- and scary batshit crazy? I loved that very first scene with her, when she strokes Spike's cheek-- and leaves blood running down his face.

I thought of Drusilla as an Angel character? She is very graceful and obviously ballet trained. Smoking hot women.

http://www.rexsikes.com/Rex_Sikes_Movie_Beat/Interviews/Entries/2009/12/20_Juliet_Landau___Actor___Director___Gary_Oldman_files/juliet%20landau.jpg
 
I hope you know Buffy fan fiction revolving around sex is (according to the show writers and producers) copyright infringement.
Now if you wanna make it teasing and seduction without sex, that's perfectly fine.

If you want it realistic to the characters (Buffy and Spike and Willow and Tara) that's also ok.

This is not bullshit, look it up (cease and desist order started in the 90s, lawsuit recently).

Note: Although Drusilla is Spike's girl, Angel had sex with her in the 18th Century.
 
Last edited:
Wow, I knew Anne Rice was very anti-fanfic but with the amount of Buffy fanfic out there I never dreamed they would be anti-fanfic. In fact I am sure I disctictly remember back in the day reading something about Joss Whedon enjoying the fanfic he had read.

Im pretty dissappointed if thats true :(
 
Here's a Tara fantasy I revisit every now and then. Actually I "began" this morning with this one.

Tara and Willow are a couple and Tara is well aware that her girlfriend is still in love with me. For herself though, Tara finally admits to feeling an attraction to me. Willow loves this and encourages Tara to start some one-on-one time, but Tara's nervous. I'm not sure whether Tara asks me out or Willow asks me for her, but Tara and I end up going on a date. Even though Tara's supposed to be a lesbian, she knows that if I hit on her she'll spread her legs in a heartbeat. If she doesn't find some exscuse to get naked first that is. Tara flirts with me for the whole night and we end up back at her and Willow's apartment trying out every position either of us can think of. For being dick-shy she sure knows how to suck and fuck a cock. After we've both had a fair amount of orgasms, while catching our breath, Tara manages to get out "wanna...(gasp)..try..(gasp)...anal?" We do and after how much more fucking we fall asleep together. Willow figures she's let us have the apartment to ourselves for long enough and comes home to find us snoring away and cuddling like we've been together for years. Smiling, Willow gets naked and joins us for some sleepy cuddling.
 
Of all the threads in this forum that have traction, this omw shocks me most of all. Lol. It's just SO specific. That said thanks for the Trachtenberg pic...gonna go clean myself up now....
 
On your fantasies, they do sound kinda hot but the whole walking in on you with whoever and then joining in doesnt really gel with the world that Joss created. Well apart from Spike, I'm pretty sure he would fuck anything with a pussy.

Hehe, I'm not entirely certain that dear spike was all that gender-particular. After all, once upon a time he was part of a triad with Dru and Angel.......

<fanning myself>
 
And Drusilla? Vulnerable, sweet, sad-- and scary batshit crazy? I loved that very first scene with her, when she strokes Spike's cheek-- and leaves blood running down his face.

My favorite is when Spike goes careening off after Dru, with his "I'll make her love me" speech, as he smokes sightly from the cracks in his blackened windshield. Best. Non. Shakespeare. Monologue. Ever!

Then again....this always keeps my fingers busy......

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zo5LAqjEU_w
 
Last edited:
Note: Although Drusilla is Spike's girl, Angel had sex with her in the 18th Century.
My bad, William the bloody saw him doing her in the 1800s not the 18th Century.

What I don't get is Angel is supposed to be two centuries old, but wouldn't the 1700s be three centuries?

By the way, this show is where I heard "Early One Morning" for the first time.
 
Last edited:
I really admire Joss Whedon as a writer and think that he writes very convincing and charming characters and relationships. He can certainly do sexy and I would love to see a piece of fan fiction that actually captures this tone rather than just puts the characters names into some generic fantasy sequences. It would be nice to see an erotic story that is true to the way that the characters have always been written, but with greater sexual content. There were quite a few scenarios on the show itself that could have gone this way if there was an adult version of the show!

I never got into the comics continuation of the story, so I think it would be good to see a fantasy fanfic narrative that went on after the end of the show that could fit in as an alternative storyline that actually works with the established TV canon. My suggestion would be to build a new storyline around Dawn. As somebody else mentioned above, on the show she was a cute kid living in her big sister's shadow, but now that she has grown up you could develop her character more freely than some of the others. Michelle Trachtenberg has certainly become quite a beautiful young woman, so I don't think people would have a problem fantasising about an adult Dawn and separating it a little from their memory of the teenage kid in the show.

I'd suggest a story series like - "Dawn, The Vampire Layer". In this story you'd develop on the last series' ideas about Dawn thinking she might be a potential slayer and then realising she isn't and her feeling a little jealous and excluded by Buffy training all the potentials. Like I said, I don't know how this progresses in the comics continuity, but in this version you'd have Buffy still training and leading her army of slayers now they've all been superpowered and Dawn wanting more and more to do her own thing. So, she, now a young woman, goes out to kill vampires herself. Only she's not so good at fighting them and, instead, distracts them by seducing vampires and killing them as they have sex with her. You could have her increasingly drawn to the dark and sexy side of sleeping with vampires, a little like what happened with Riley's relationships. Given Dawn was always very close to Willow and always rooting for Willow and Tara's relationship, a more romantic sexual relationship between Dawn and Willow could also develop in a way that would be more appealing than the existent Dawn-Kennedy relationship that seemed tacked on as it had no chance to develop. Dawn and Willow already have a bond that could be built on.

I'm busy with other writing at the moment, so I don't think I'll ever write this idea up, but that's the kind of thing I'd like to see from erotic Buffy fan fiction.

Apart from Willow, Faith was always my favourite character, so more of her would work, especially because she is probably one of the characters more likely to have a lot of erotic adventures.
 
I think vampire Willow was the sexiest thing I've ever seen.


Definitely one of the hottest TV characters ever.

There is an amazing amount of Buffy fanfic out there---a lot having to do with Dawn dominating Buffy (which I found surprisingly erotic).


I know that the actress with played Tara now writes semi-humorous horror novels. I wonder if she writes any of the erotic fanfic under a pseudonym?
 
Definitely one of the hottest TV characters ever.

There is an amazing amount of Buffy fanfic out there---a lot having to do with Dawn dominating Buffy (which I found surprisingly erotic).


I know that the actress with played Tara now writes semi-humorous horror novels. I wonder if she writes any of the erotic fanfic under a pseudonym?

To be honest, Joss himself is the kind of writer, a total pop culture geek, where you'd assume he at the very least would read some of the erotic Buffy fanfic, if not pseudonymously do a bit himself!
 
To be honest, Joss himself is the kind of writer, a total pop culture geek, where you'd assume he at the very least would read some of the erotic Buffy fanfic, if not pseudonymously do a bit himself!

I'll have to admit I did not do further research into writers/actors other then the stuff that was on the collectors edition.

But I like the idea of some pseudonymous erotic fan art :D

I wonder what it would be like to read fanart about your own character though. Would it be creepy, or really hot.
 
Back
Top