BAN eREADERS

Technology becomes obsolete

The book is about 1500 years old and at the time was a revolutionary innovation as a Codex.

Before then all written literature was on rolls and had to be unrolled carefully from one end to another. The technical term was 'scrolling' and we still have scrolling on our computers now (and a scroll lock function).

I worked on my first computer in 1963. That machine is now a museum relic, as are all the machines I worked on or owned up to about 2000.

Data storage on that first computer was on punched cards, themselves already an old technology dating back 50 years or more. Who (or what) can read punched cards now? Then tape reels were added - back to scrolling.

Later machines used 8 inch floppies, then 5.25 inch floppies on the IBM XT, followed by 3.5 inch not-so-floppies. My main computer still has a 3.5 floppy drive and I have a USB 3.5 floppy drive if I need to transfer information from a floppy to my laptop.

I have books I bought in 1963 that were already over 100 years old. I can still read them as easily as I could in 1963. I can't do that with the data storage from the 1963 computer.

Original music recordings were on cylinders. To play one now I'd need an antique machine. They were replaced by 78 rpm records. I can buy a deck that will play 78s now. Then 45s, 33s and for recorded speech there were 16.66 rpm records. I still have an ancient system that will play at 16.66rpm.

There were reel to reel tape recorders running at 15 inches per second, then 7.5 followed by 3.75 inches and finally cassette tapes running even slower (with 8 track as a side diversion).

CDs were to replace everything. But now they are obsolescent technology, being displaced by the download.

I paid for my old books in 1963. I still have them. I can still read them.

But if I had bought 'old' recorded music in 1963 I would have had to replace either the equipment or the media - several times over and pay each time.

Will your eReader work in 50 years time? Will you have had to pay several times to replace the media because the 2011 version won't work on the eReaders of 2021, 2031, 2041 etc?

Books might become minority items, collectors' pieces perhaps, but their technology will still work 50 years hence unlike the Kindle.
 


A printed book is forever. There is no obsolescence, no royalties, no new widgets. It is easily lent to friends. It is not subject to vagaries of ephemeral fads. I will never be the victim of the vapid majority's sheep-like behavior in adopting ill-considered new technology.


When navigating, I want paper charts available in case the vessel is struck by lightning and the electrics are fried. When reading, I want something that isn't dependent on the vagaries of batteries or buttons; I want to be able to turn the corner of a page to save the location of a previously unknown word or a clever phrase or a new insight; I want paper on which I can write annotations or use a highlighter. I want a real-honest-to-god book that I can put on a shelf so that I can find it easily in case of the need for subsequent reference.

A book always operates. It doesn't malfunction. It doesn't require an instruction manual. It will never become obsolete. It doesn't care if it's hot or cold or sunny or snowing.


 


A printed book is forever. There is no obsolescence, no royalties, no new widgets. It is easily lent to friends. It is not subject to vagaries of ephemeral fads. I will never be the victim of the vapid majority's sheep-like behavior in adopting ill-considered new technology.


When navigating, I want paper charts available in case the vessel is struck by lightning and the electrics are fried. When reading, I want something that isn't dependent on the vagaries of batteries or buttons; I want to be able to turn the corner of a page to save the location of a previously unknown word or a clever phrase or a new insight; I want paper on which I can write annotations or use a highlighter. I want a real-honest-to-god book that I can put on a shelf so that I can find it easily in case of the need for subsequent reference.

A book always operates. It doesn't malfunction. It doesn't require an instruction manual. It will never become obsolete. It doesn't care if it's hot or cold or sunny or snowing.



Books are already on the way out.
 
Millions of eReaders are sold every week in America. This must stop. This must stop because it robs printers and USPS workers and lumberjacks and paper makers and warehouse workers and bookcase makers of jobs.

They said that about buggy whip makers...roll with the changes, or be rolled over....
 
Books are already on the way out.

You, obviously, have not expended tens of thousands of dollars on vinyl LP records, record players, 8-track tapes, cassette tapes, cassette decks, Walkmans, reel-to-reel tape, reel-to-reel tape machines, compact discs and Diskmans/CDWalkmans.


For consumers, technology is not your friend.


Printed books are beautiful.


 


You, obviously, have not expended tens of thousands of dollars on vinyl LP records, record players, 8-track tapes, cassette tapes, cassette decks, Walkmans, reel-to-reel tape, reel-to-reel tape machines, compact discs and Diskmans/CDWalkmans.


For consumers, technology is not your friend.


Printed books are beautiful.



They are beautiful, and they are technology. With all technology, their days has come and they are on their way to being replaced.
 
They are beautiful, and they are technology. With all technology, their days has come and they are on their way to being replaced.


Portable, essentially immortal, nearly independent of civilization and idiot-proof is the better choice.
:) :)​



 
Could you pull the same text up online, theoretically if not factually?

Yes in theory. I haven't tried because the text is in French and Project Gutenberg isn't so good on French.

But whether I could or not, I wouldn't have the previous owners' annotations which are as interesting as the text.
 
Yes in theory. I haven't tried because the text is in French and Project Gutenberg isn't so good on French.

But whether I could or not, I wouldn't have the previous owners' annotations which are as interesting as the text.

If you scanned it into a computer you wouldn't have the annotations?
You would also be able to share & read reviews with others.
 
If you scanned it into a computer you wouldn't have the annotations?
You would also be able to share & read reviews with others.

The book is too fragile to scan. The paper and text is OK but I'd have to break the binding to scan the pages.

I do have a collection of 60 copies of 18th Century French revolutionary newspapers. They are available on line scanned from the reprints for their Centennial in 1889. But the scans aren't the same as holding the real things.
 
Why does this have to be an either/or?
I have my books, and I have my tablet with ereader on it.
My books are the ones I really love and reread constantly, and my tablet has the kind of books on that I read once and discard.
 
I'd like to be able to have all my books on an eReader but they aren't all available in downloadable form.

Even if they were, the expense of downloading 5,000+ books would be prohibitive.

I dream of the space I'd gain but I couldn't scan more than a dozen or so personally.
 

And you're part of the problem. Unless you're using scrolls & fountain pens.

If you click on the link above you, you will find where he is bragging about the Kindle he just got today as a gift. Just like all right-wingers on this website...nothing but hot air.

We add to the list of people who's head the OP went completely over...

Manfred Mann sings, "Blinded by the hate..."
 


You, obviously, have not expended tens of thousands of dollars on vinyl LP records, record players, 8-track tapes, cassette tapes, cassette decks, Walkmans, reel-to-reel tape, reel-to-reel tape machines, compact discs and Diskmans/CDWalkmans.


For consumers, technology is not your friend.


Printed books are beautiful.



Jimmy Page owes me large...



:mad: :mad: :mad:








:D
 
Here's what the Left needs to hear in order to get eReaders banned!

:D

The Kindle and Nook may make for not only the most important advance in reading since Gutenberg, but also, quite likely, a major lesson in unintended consequences. Especially for the educational establishment, because for the first time in history, Americans should be able to envision a future without public-school teachers -- indeed, a future without public-school administrators or state departments of education with their rigidly enforced, politically correct social-transformation curriculum. A future without onerous school taxes, "education president(s)," self-preening school boards, or million-dollar classrooms. But most happily, a future without a single supercilious finger wagging in our face as we're forever lectured about how much a securely tenured, part-time, self-important, overpaid class of public employees "cares" about our sons and daughters. Really, really, really cares. And, of course, knows much better than we do how to bring them up.

And it's all possible because these cheap, handheld, downloadable reading devices such as Kindle and Nook now give parents a choice between tutoring and classroom education.


Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/2011/12/a_world_without_schoolteachers.html#ixzz1he9jJCnX
 
Back
Top