An Expertly Crafted Historical Romance: Review of Warrior Princess

Ilfen1

Virgin
Joined
Nov 5, 2020
Posts
20
Warrior Princess by SpindleTop was just posted this past week, and I think it's a story that deserves your attention.

It's a story set during the period of the seven warring states of England at the end of the 9th century AD, when the Vikings terrorized the coasts and threatened to take over the scattered petty kingdoms even as they fought amongst themselves.

Frankly, it's very rare for me to come across such a well written piece of fiction on LitE. Usually the calibre of writing here is not enough to stand on its own unless it is there to amplify sexual/romantic tension, as to make the ensuing love scenes hotter.

When I do find the a story that's good enough to read on its own merits, I toss any expectations of sex to the wayside. If there's good love scenes, then all the better, and there certainly is a sizzler in this one.

Spoilers follow below, so go ahead and read the damn thing already and give it a rating :D

***SPOILERS AHEAD***
From a critical perspective, I find very little to fault with this story, and much to praise.

There is romantic tension established at the very beginning with the Heroines attraction to the male lead. I find that it's important to establish this in any story on Lit(and also in general if you're writing a Romance), to keep the readers interest especially if you have a lot of plot to go through.

The villains are also introduced right away, as well as the obstacles that lie in the way of our heroine. It all conforms well to Brandon Sanderson's rule about good writing being about promises and payoffs.

There's a lot of political intrigue involved, and though I'm not knowledgable about the history, it's clear the author SpindleTop has done his fair share of research and the sense of geography is conveyed convincingly.

I like that the story focuses mainly on our heroine and hero, without getting bogged down with any other characters. Too many long-form stories get in the readers way with throw-away characters that I personally often find myself skipping through.

Alfred, our hero and romantic interest, has many likeable qualities. From his acknowledgment of the heroines martial abilities to his cunning use of his wits to both goad the villain to defeat and solve a hostage situation at the same time.

I especially liked the part where he missed the target in an archery contest with the heroine intentionally. This is first gratifying to the heroine, then she may have resented being coddled, but then may have realized that this was done in consideration of her feelings, and so furthered romantic tension.

The "twist" concerning Alfred's true identity was admittedly obvious right from the get-go when he was mentioned. It's also kind of obvious to anyone who knows the history given that King Alfred the Great is the stuff of legends.

The only real flaw I have personally is when the heroine realizes Cedric's disguise. She goes through a very quick sharp U-turn in her attitude towards Cedric, only to quickly turn right back again. It can be a bit confusing to the reader, and I thought we would have been better served with some more paragraphs to show us how her thinking of him changed. Why exactly did she think that Cedric was on "her side"?


Overall, I'm off to read the rest of this guys writings. I think I learned more than a few tricks myself from reading this story. Please give SpindleTop credit where it is due :heart:
 
Last edited:
Interesting to learn about a writer in a category it almost never occurs to me to look in on. Certainly looks like SpindleTop is popular with readers there, good for them.

"Warrior Princess" isn't bad. I'm not as enthusiastic about it as Ilfen1, either. I'd rate it as fairly middle-of-the-road romantic historical fiction. I like historical fiction and I don't mind a touch of over-the-top romance as part of the proceedings, so I feel like I should be in the target audience... but neither the heroine nor the hero had caught my interest by the second Lit page, so I wound up skimming from there. It's certainly quality writing by the standards of a free erotica site, but even so, I've seen better prose on LitE.

One thing it did remind me of is that minor authorial tics can make a big difference in a story. I know roughly what my own tics are, but it's interesting to notice the specific things in another's writing that one just bounces off of.

In the case of "Warrior Princess," SpindleTop has deployed this odd stylistic affectation -- an affectation in which successive clauses are piled up behind dashes, like this -- and then like this. In successive sentences -- often where commas would do just fine. IDK what they're going for with this (it seems to be a deliberate choice, as it's not something they do in all their stories), but whatever the purpose, it didn't land for me.

With all of that said, it's a good enough story to warrant giving it a chance, for sure. People who really like historical romance in the style of, say, Diana Gabaldon might well enjoy "Warrior Princess" a lot more than I did.
 
Last edited:
I actually wasn't even aware till you mentioned that there is in fact a "First Time" category. Huh. I guess that is where all the romance stories go where the consummation of the romance spells the end of the story.

Certainly you would be right that there are better written stories around, especially in the Romance category which I admittedly haven't even skimmed the surface of. I guess I still have a lot of reading to do :)

About the em dashes, I actually didn't even realise they were there on my first reading. Goes to show how deep-seated our reading preferences can be. On second reading, it does seem a tad excessive, and I agree that more conventional punctuation would do.
 
Last edited:
About the em dashes, I actually didn't even realise they were there on my first reading. Goes to show how deep-seated our reading preferences can be. On second reading, it does seem a tad excessive, and I agree that more conventional punctuation would do.

SpindleTop just about had me: I almost didn't notice them. But once I did, I couldn't un-notice them. It's like when you're talking to someone who has a little piece of something wedged in their teeth, except you can't point it out to them and help them remove it. :D

I'm not trying to be too hard on SpindleTop, though. Notwithstanding the stylistic choices, whether the hero or the heroine engage a reader is much the more important consideration and entirely personal. So I would still second your recommendation that people give the story a look, even if it wasn't my bag.
 
SpindleTop replies

Thank you to Ilfen1 and CyranoJ for their comments - this is very useful feedback. Here are a few responses to some of the points that you have raised.

The em dashes.
- Firstly, there appears to be a technical issue with the scripts that format text into the final published version. I have never had a problem before, but this time they have rendered single em dashes as double en dashes. I agree that this is distracting (and looks a bit of a mess) and has the potential to spoil enjoyment of the story. I have submitted an updated version, which will hopefully not have the same issue, but it will take two weeks to post.
- Secondly, my aim in using dashes is to give the feel that the narrator is telling the story out loud, rather than that the reader is reading it off a page. As you know, in real life people do not speak in full sentences - they speak in fragments and unfinished clauses, with different inflections, at different speeds and with different length pauses. I use a dash where a pause longer than a comma, but less definite than a period, is required. I have seen several others using the technique, but possibly I am overusing it. Given that Ilfen1 did not notice, perhaps it is just the rendering into two dashes that is the problem here.

It would be useful if CyranoJ could explain what they mean by “I've seen better prose on LitE”. Was this related to the dashes or to another grammatical issue - or was this more to do with the rhythm and flow of the text?

I’m sorry to hear that CyranoJ did not feel that the “heroine [or] the hero had caught my interest by the second Lit page.” The first private conversation between the two takes place at the end of the first page. At that point, the hero is ‘disguised’, but it should have been clear that he is a main character and that there is a lot more to him than the heroine might have first thought. The aim of the conversation is to challenge some of the heroine’s assumptions as how her world operates and also to explain the broader political situation in England at the time to the reader. There’s a lot that needs to be conveyed in a relatively short space of time and it would be interesting to hear from others whether they feel that this section works.

I am very keen to hear the opinions of others and I take all feedback very seriously. Thank you again to Ilfen1 and CyranoJ for taking the time to read the story and for leaving their comments. :)
 
Last edited:
Oh, hello, SpindleTop! Pleased to meet you.

FWIW, the specific formatting of the dashes doesn't matter too much: it's their narrative function that ultimately flummoxed me. I get that you were doing a specific thing there, but for my money, it's not necessary. You simply don't need it to convey a conversational or oral-history style. But your explanation for the attempt does make a certain amount of sense.

I will duly attempt to offer some more detailed thoughts up about what makes quality prose and engaging characters in a bit. I hope you find them useful.
 
Almost feel it should be written in epic form:

In storm-lashed Morden I saw him first
midst the murmured agitations of lords
and unhushed whisperings of ladies too;
still, he knelt, that black-garbed man
as if the Benedictine cloth were a shroud to still
the gossip of the castle's great hall - calm
even beneath the gaze of my father's
fierce regard: "Speak, Lord Sigweard!"
 
Back
Top