Affirmative Action

Do you believe Affirmative Action should exist in its present form

  • Yes. Affirmative action in all jobs

    Votes: 4 10.8%
  • No. Affirmative action in all jobs except those where lives are on the line (Police, Firefighters, e

    Votes: 1 2.7%
  • No. Only in companies where it has been shown that racism is a problem

    Votes: 4 10.8%
  • No. Everything should be judged on ability alone

    Votes: 28 75.7%

  • Total voters
    37
Dantetier said:
I wasn't trying to make it an issue.. just trying to start another conversation.

Please, don't get the idea that I'm at all racist... I'm vehamently against any sort of racism

Oh, I didn't think that! I was just saying that black people make it an issue when it's not. Sorry if that wasn't clear.
 
I understand the need - perceived or otherwise - for AA. However, it is extremely condescending to minorities. AA says "Because you're black/hispanic/whatever, you aren't as smart as a white person, so you don't need to be as qualified." If anything, it should be used as a tie-breaker. If there are two job applicants with the same qualifications, experience, etc., and one is black, the other white, the black person gets it. I can't imagine there being very many cases of two otherwise identical applicants, though. Also, any companies found to be using discriminitory hiring practices should be dealt with severely.
 
Teachers Require Better Salaries and Working Conditions

Dantetier said:
agreed. schools should be good everywhere... unfortunately, they aren't. For a variety of reasons. In california, we have so many children that we hire "Emergency" Credentials...meaning, they aren't really teachers... it's like having a substitute permenently.

There is a test in California, I think it's the SAT-9, that showed that the schools with the highest percentage of EC teachers had the worst scores.

Also... teachers are paid FAR less, and are given too much shit for people to WANT to be teachers. I grew up in California's educational system, and I've had some really great teachers, and the ones I've had put up with no shit. If a kid was acting up. GONE... but I notice that far too often, they're required to take them back in. And Students have NO respect for teachers anymore. Japan's society has MUCH respect for teachers and education, and look at that society... some of the smartest people in the world come from that system. We need to take notes.

In summery *L*, we need to pay our teachers more, REQUIRE the students to respect them, and if they don't, severe punishment, and we need to let our teachers TEACH... not do all this buacracy bullshit. Give the schhols more money, and make it work. it can be done.

And so you all don't think I'm not a complete asshole... ONE of the reasons that Californian schools are so bad is that we're right next to Mexico, and with all the ILLEGAL (I have NO problem with mexicans, they're incredibly hard working, and most of the ones who crossed the border have great respect for societies rules... except the one they broke to get here) immigrants. We need to crack down on that shit right away and HARD...

Hi Dantetier, I hope your ideas spread far and wide to overcome the continuous degradation of public education systems by self-interested nutters "leaning" on weak-willed admnistrators more interested in preserving their pensions than maintaining educational standards.

In Oz teaching has become a female profession and so governments have allowed salaries to drop, or rather NOT increase at the same as other "male" professions . . . at present a desk-jockey public servant can pull 1 1/2 times a teacher's salary without the marking and unpaid ovetime . . .

But things will not improve in Oz unless the teachers themselves follow the Canadian example from the 70s and stay on strike until they get a proper working salary. :)

A friend of mine teaching in Darlington, an inner suburb of Sydney, had 27/30 kids from non-Oz nationalities and 19 different languages in the one class . . . at least Mexico speaks Spanish. :)
 
I remember a thread a while back that suggested the civil rights movement was the worst thing to ever happen to American blacks. In the early 1900's we routinely scored higher on intelligence and other types of tests. We had to work hard because no one else out there was going to help us.

We had our own schools, businesses and communities that pretty much thrived without any outside influences. Then, along comes desegregation and, eventually, Affirmative Action. Suddenly, it wasn't necessary to work as hard to achieve. The whole "you owe me" attitude became prevalent. It became acceptable for black youths to be underachivers because they've been put upon by the man.

Nowadays black schools are a shambles, people are poor, inner cities are warzones and everyone sits around waiting for someone else to solve the problem. White liberals have pretty much become the worst enemy of the black community because they foster the whole idea that we can't do anything for ourselves.

My attitude these days is: "Thanks but no thanks!" If I end up poor, broke and destitute, it'll be my own goddamned fault because I either gave up or didn't try hard enough.

And if some white man slams a door in my face then guess what? I'll go somewhere else and get an even better job then tell him to go fuck himself because he doesn't control my future.

(I've gotten way too political tonight. Someone please start a movie thread I can post on! :D )
 
AA is discrimination. You don't fight discrimination with discrimination.
 
medjay said:
I remember a thread a while back that suggested the civil rights movement was the worst thing to ever happen to American blacks. In the early 1900's we routinely scored higher on intelligence and other types of tests. We had to work hard because no one else out there was going to help us.

We had our own schools, businesses and communities that pretty much thrived without any outside influences. Then, along comes desegregation and, eventually, Affirmative Action. Suddenly, it wasn't necessary to work as hard to achieve. The whole "you owe me" attitude became prevalent. It became acceptable for black youths to be underachivers because they've been put upon by the man.

Nowadays black schools are a shambles, people are poor, inner cities are warzones and everyone sits around waiting for someone else to solve the problem. White liberals have pretty much become the worst enemy of the black community because they foster the whole idea that we can't do anything for ourselves.

My attitude these days is: "Thanks but no thanks!" If I end up poor, broke and destitute, it'll be my own goddamned fault because I either gave up or didn't try hard enough.

And if some white man slams a door in my face then guess what? I'll go somewhere else and get an even better job then tell him to go fuck himself because he doesn't control my future.

(I've gotten way too political tonight. Someone please start a movie thread I can post on! :D )

Hey medjay, in Oz we have indigenous Australians, aka Aborigines. The cargo cult, "somebody else will fix it" and "the world owes me a living" attitides are prevalent in those communities also. Now a very impressive indigenous leader, Noel Pearson, has said "No more welfare . . . we want economic opportunity and the skills to make our own living." Slowly, very slowly, he is making progress . . . but against considerable opposition from within the indigenous community, which has a problem with alcohol intolerance, apparently a genetic thing. There are a growing number of indigenous people who have taken on the "white man" at his own game and done well, making significant contributions to the total society . . . but they have overcome considerable prejudice to make their achievements.
 
medjay said:
White liberals have pretty much become the worst enemy of the black community because they foster the whole idea that we can't do anything for ourselves.

My attitude these days is: "Thanks but no thanks!" If I end up poor, broke and destitute, it'll be my own goddamned fault because I either gave up or didn't try hard enough.

And if some white man slams a door in my face then guess what? I'll go somewhere else and get an even better job then tell him to go fuck himself because he doesn't control my future.

Another excellent post.

I find it interesting looking at the poll results. So many who claim to be liberals at this forum but the results seem to favor a non-liberal opinion.
 
Affirmative Action is a vicious, evil, immoral and despicable practice. It is an idea born of moral and intellectual bankruptcy. It is a tool created by the collectivist mind for the specific purpose to punish and discourage achievement, to denigrate the concept of greatness and to smear the concept of self-esteem by virtue of one's efficacy.

By man's nature, his efforts in his life are to better himself, to strive for a higher level of existence, a better standard of living,

Man sets goals for himself as a plan for his life and measure of his success toward the achievement of his life's goals. His ultimate goal is his own survival for without his survival, all other goals become irrelevant. All other goals are toward that ultimate purpose.

Each man sets his own goals in accordance with his own vision of himself and his perception of his ultimate achievements. Each man, having a different degree of ability, knowledge, skill, motivation, determination and drive will achieve to his own level of capability and competence.

In many men, the inspiration to advance their achievements comes from their observations of others before them who have achieved the unthinkable, the inconceivable. Yet, unthinkable as were those goals, their predecessors did not give up, did not falter, but pressed on and succeeded where others before him perhaps had failed.

This is an attribute that is uniquely human, the ability to derive inspiration from others successes or even their failures.

When man is presented with obstacles, some give up and fail while others persist. Not all who persist succeed but some (or many) do succeed and in so doing achieve success for themselves but likewise achieve some advance for mankind as a whole.

In an environment of freedom, this entrepreneurial spirit is fed and encouraged. In an environment of oppression or slavery, it is punished, discouraged and stifled. This is the specific reason the United States of America has become the shining beacon of success to the world at large and the single greatest embarrassment and frustration to the proponents of collectivism.

What does Affirmative Action do? One thing it does is tell its beneficiaries that they are not capable of success or self betterment without some special concessions provided them by some noble beneficiary. Of course, those who sell it are not honest and thus do not tell the truth about their program. They have an assortment of lies and propaganda they use to brainwash people into accepting the validity of the victim mentality. These people then become dependent upon the collectivist and meager handouts for their sustenance and basic survival. And despite all the promises of glorious success, it has yet to be manifest.

Look, for example, at the black community and what happens to the achievers from there. Colin Powell was called essentially an Uncle Tom by Harry Belafonte.

Clarence Thomas, who was the first black American ever nominated for appointment to the supreme Court, was savaged by the proponents of Affirmative Action. He suffered character assassination and public humiliation for no reason other than committing the cardinal sin of achieving his lot through perseverance and hard work.

There are numerous other cases of similar ilk where the achievers among America's black population have been denigrated and publicly assaulted with lies and slander because they achieved greatness of success by their own efforts. This is not exclusive to black Americans but in that arena it seems more prominent.

This same community lauds Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton as praiseworthy leaders while they are both men who prey on others for their successes in life. Jesse Jackson has used the cover of race to shake down numerous corporations in America and is praised for it. Al Sharpton came to public prominence by committing a fraud using Tawana Brawley as a purported rape victim and brought various and sundry fraudulent charges against innocent people ruining or very nearly ruining their lives and he is now considered a potential Presidential candidate for the Democratic Party.

What can possibly be the rationale for elevating these latter two men to stellar levels of admiration while demeaning and denigrating men like Clarence Thomas, Colin Powell and other successful black Americans? It certainly is not to recognize and respect greatness or achievement.

In fact, it is precisely the opposite, much as were the efforts to draw some parallels between Clinton and Jefferson around the time of Clinton's impeachment.

The purpose is to demean and devalue greatness, success, achievement. Collectivism sees all men as equal in a physical sense, i. e., equality of outcome. No man should be richer than other, no man should have more or better food, homes, cars, etc., than any other. There is no allowance for the individual in collectivism, thus all must be restrained to the level of the least competent, except of course, for those speaking for the collective, i. e., the elite ruling class.

By setting criteria at a level where anyone may meet them, then one has demeaned and devalued the truly great, the achiever, the producer. The best is reduced to the equivalent of the least among us. This effectively erases the meaning of greatness.

I have respect for one who achieves greater things than I can or have achieved. They are an inspiration to me. They stimulate my admiration and respect for the heroic potential of mankind.

But the collectivist sees the great achiever as a threat. And the threat is to be eliminated, to be removed. Affirmative Action is a tool that permits just that.

Ayn Rand offered a magnificent insight into this mentality and practice.

She essentially divides men into two general groups she calls the producers and the second handers.

The producer, the achiever, the creator, the innovator, the man of greatness is a man who lives his life by the best application of his intellect, his mind. His achievements are the root of his evaluation of himself as a man, his efficacy, his self-esteem. His accomplishments declare to others his ability, his achievements, the reason he is great among men.

These are the few by and large, the unusual. These are the Archimedes, the da Vinci's, the Edisons, The George Washington's, Thomas Jeffersons, Benjamin Franklins, Albert Einsteins, Nikolai Teslas, Ayn Rands, Bill Gates, et al.

These are the men whose achievements are apparent to all but the most determined to ignore it. But these are also the men whose self-esteem is independent of the opinion of other men. Rather, their self-esteem is born of their knowledge of their own efficacy. They need no outside opinion to reassure themselves of their ability or achievement.

Conversely, the second hander is a parasite. His sense of self is in essence a fraud. It is derived from the opinion others hold of him, of the perception of others that he has achieved or accomplished something of value. The reality of any achievements is unimportant. What is important is the external perception others may have based upon whatever cause might be at play.

Since there is no real achievement in the case of the second hander, there is no confidence in their own efficacy or accomplishments for the very real reason that there are likely none which measure up under objective reality. Politicians, especially the career politician, are the quintessential example of the second hander. Their achievements or accomplishments are their exercise of power over the lives of other men. They achieve a position politically whereby they can dictate to others how they should conduct their lives, how they may deal with other men, what business they may operate, what prices they may charge in the marketplace, and a myriad of other dictates over the behaviors of other men.

They are the Hitlers, Stalins, Napoleons, Mao Tse Tungs, Pol Pots, Ghengis Khans, FDR's LBJ's Tom Daschles, etc.

But the second hander is always threatened by the men of ability, the creators, the producers. These men do not need the tyrant but the tyrant needs them. But they are useful to the tyranny only so long as their ability is not permitted recognition. Thus they are reviled and blamed for the failures of the tyrannical governments' actions through a program of disingenuous propaganda, lies and character assassinations.

This is the tool by which the great men are used but their greatness is obscured or demeaned as if they were terrible flaws of character rather than the beacon of human achievement which is the true source of the advances of humankind as a whole.

It is by the use of such tools as Affirmative Action and others that the collectivist creates the perception of equality in his concrete bound mentality, i. e., the equality of outcome. Another example that has become prominent recently in a few news reports is the practice of dispensing with a valedictorian in a graduating class. This action only punishes the achiever. He is denied the proper and moral recognition of his achievements for the very thin and fatuous reason that it may hurt someone else's feelings as if somehow feeling (emotions) are the proper standard of measure instead of one's achievements.

These are all tools for the punishment of achievement and the promotion of mediocrity to a praiseworthy position.

Conversely, the rational, intelligent man perceives equality in the only reasonable terms reality permits, i. e., the realm of rights and freedom.
Originally posted by Thrillhouse
... Also, any companies found to be using discriminitory hiring practices should be dealt with severely.
Do you have any idea just how ludicrous this statement really is? What is a hiring practice but a specifically discriminatory one? It involves choosing (discriminating) among the applicants on the basis of some criteria. By definition, it must be discriminatory
 
I'm a little confused about this arguement that Affirmative Action somehow encourages mediocrity or demeans minorities. It's not as if any of them are banking on AA to get them through in life. That makes no sense. NO ONE is sitting back aiming for a job or an admission or a contract (that they could just as easily lose to another minority) through AA. People are going to work as hard as they can to get the best possible job that they can, affirmative action or no affirmative action. Because there's always better out there. No one is ever going to be content with where they are.

Furthermore even when someone is benefited by an affirmative action decision, it's not like they get a stamp on their diploma or paycheck that says "Affirmative Action recipient." It would be either illogical or extremely racist to assume that any minority who received a position or a contract did so because of an affirmative action decision. But if someone receives an opportunity they are not going to know or question how they got it. They're just going to try to prove themself in that situation. It would be like saying anyone who received an athletic scholarship to a Universitiy should feel deameaned because there's no other way they could have gotten in.

Speaking of which, I also have a question for those who oppose AA in academic admissions: Are you as equally against Athletic Scholarships, the preferential consideratoin given to relatives of alumni, goals of academic diversity (i.e. trying to admit students of varying majors), or geographic diversity? All of which are common factors used in admission proceedures and none of which are academically merit based.
 
To the thinking man, affirmative actions, preferences based on some physical or ethnic trait, is condescending and demeaning because it is a tacit declaration that by nature of the preference chosen, be it race, religion, ethnic background or whatever, that he is somehow necessarily and specifically less capable than his fellow man with no other factor considered.

And Affirmative Action is merely one of the tools of the concept I noted.

The dispensing with a valedictorian or the selection of multiple valedictorians is another.

The awarding of grades for completion of a course when I was in school was fairly stringent. To earn an "A", you numeric grade had to be 95-100.

Today, there are situations where everyone gets an "A" just so no one's feeling are hurt. This is fraudulent because the grade is not earned. It demeans the value of the grade just as counterfeit currency demeans the value of real currency.

The lowering of SAT scores for "certain racial/ethnic groups" fr acceptance into colleges is another example. It is a blatant declaration that they are less competent.

The effect of all these types of actions and others are the effort of the collectivist mentality to eradicate the perception, concept and understanding of greatness, of achievement, of excellence, of the superb.

The result is that the "A" grade means nothing because everyone gets an "A". The acceptance to a top grade college is meaningless because anyone can get in if the have the right skin color, or some other arbitrary attribute the collectivist deems appropriate.

It is the abolition of recognition and rewarding of achievement that eliminates the visibility of the exceptional, the great which serves as an inspiration for others to achieve more than they have or had imagined.

By blurring, obscuring or obliterating the perception of the exceptional, the extraordinary among us, it promotes the acceptance, even the elevation of mediocrity to the ideal.

It is the collectivist fear of the exceptional, the superlative, that need for equality in concrete obvious terms that makes this important in their pseudo value system.

Collectivists are destroyers, not achievers or producers. They destroy the best in man, the motivation of the individual to be the best he can be, to achieve to the greatest extent of his ability, knowledge and aspirations. Why? Because the collectivist perceives himself as lacking efficacy to succeed in his own life, he senses the lack of an ability to achieve, to create, to produce. This is the basis of his need to control others, to derive his substitute for self-esteem by holding power over the lives and property of other men. And because of his own lack of self, of self-esteem, he must control in the only context available to his mentality, i. e., to hold everyone to the lowest level of competence.

This is the fundamental reason that no nation on earth ever achieved the magnificence, the greatness, the success of the United States of America before or since. We had a government created to stave off the collectivist control of the individual.

But with generations of politicians ignoring the Constitutional restraints on our government, we in America are slowly sinking into the quicksand of the collectivist swamp.

Edited to correct typographical error
 
Last edited:
Affirmative Action demise

Race relations will never improve in this country as long as discrimination exists. There will always be discrimination as long as there is Affirmative Action.
No matter how the liberals or the NAACP try to explain it away, Affirmative Action is reverse discrimination.
Discrimination is wrong and harmful against any race and should be totally abolished...This reverse discrimination has existed for well over thirty years..It should be totally abolished immediately....


~~~JABO~~~
 
Re: Affirmative Action demise

Originally posted by Jabo 69
Race relations will never improve in this country as long as discrimination exists. There will always be discrimination as long as there is Affirmative Action.
No matter how the liberals or the NAACP try to explain it away, Affirmative Action is reverse discrimination.
Discrimination is wrong and harmful against any race and should be totally abolished...This reverse discrimination has existed for well over thirty years..It should be totally abolished immediately....


~~~JABO~~~
Race relations will never improve so long as people tolerate the collectivist tactic of pitting one faction of society against another for the purpose of their acquisition and exercise of political power.

Discrimination is not evil. It is merely choice. By distorting the nature of language, discrimination is a term used by the political proponents of collectivism, of tyranny, to further their political cause.

Similarly, there is nothing inherently wrong with segregation IF it is volitional, i. e., people do it of free choice. It is merely the exhibition of their right to free association.

When segregation becomes a matter of law (as it was in the South), it is a monstrous evil because it is coercive. It is government by force of arms deciding who may and may not associate or in what manner or setting these associations may take place. For example, I recall growing up in the South and seeing water fountains, lunch counters and restrooms labelled White and Colored. In retrospect, ignoring the great immorality of the concept of coercive racial segregation, it was rather stupid from a basic economic standpoint because of the cost to build and maintain duplication of facilities.

The term "reverse discrimination" is meaningless, per se. Discrimination is the exercise of choice. If you literally reversed discrimination, you would eliminate choice, i. e., the reversal of choice is no choice.

And I do understand the common usage to imply role reversal in the practice of discrimination but again this is part of the effort to taint the language and make a perfectly routine and necessary facet of freedom and individual liberty seem like some horrific criminal act or conspiracy.

But again, this is the ploy of the collectivist, the tyrant to distort reality for the very ignoble purpose of advancing his agenda at the expense of everyone's freedom.
 
Back
Top