Affirmative Action

Do you believe Affirmative Action should exist in its present form

  • Yes. Affirmative action in all jobs

    Votes: 4 10.8%
  • No. Affirmative action in all jobs except those where lives are on the line (Police, Firefighters, e

    Votes: 1 2.7%
  • No. Only in companies where it has been shown that racism is a problem

    Votes: 4 10.8%
  • No. Everything should be judged on ability alone

    Votes: 28 75.7%

  • Total voters
    37

Dantetier

Literotica Guru
Joined
Apr 13, 2002
Posts
2,033
Call me a firebrand.. I know it's a topic that's gonna start shit, but I'm curious.
 
In my opinion, affirmative action is reverse racism, and I can't see how it does anything for the minorities except for show them that they only have what they have because rules and standards were altered for them. Hiring should be done on ability alone - colour of skin, gender, or race should not be taken into account. I do realize, however, that it has been set up for specific reasons, due to years of racism in hiring, but if I were one of those who benefitted by reduced standards, I'd find it demeaning.
 
I think that that the government should watch, and if a business is shown to discriminate against people, then SOMETHING should be done... against specific cases... if someone is hired or promoted where another person has shown to have better qualities... then yeah, I think something should be done. but other then that, I think it should be based solely on ability
 
Freya, you are so hot looking.....I've forgotten completely what I came into this thread for?????

Affirmative action? Oh yeah...don't we live in a meritocracy?
 
Dantetier said:
I think that that the government should watch, and if a business is shown to discriminate against people, then SOMETHING should be done... against specific cases... if someone is hired or promoted where another person has shown to have better qualities... then yeah, I think something should be done. but other then that, I think it should be based solely on ability

Punish offenders, don't skew the law...everyone should be equal under the law and everyone should have equal opportunity (means having good schools everywhere).
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
Freya, you are so hot looking.....I've forgotten completely what I came into this thread for?????

Affirmative action? Oh yeah...don't we live in a meritocracy?

supposedly... but places are REQUIRED to have a certian amout of minorities if their worker pool is over a certian amount of people.
 
umm Thanks guys. :eek:


Hiring a certain number of minorities is all well and good, as long as those people are qualified to do the job.
 
Red will give you a good argument.

There certainly is a variety of methods in law that have been established to rectify past discrimination. I'd like to go back to Martin Luthor's "dream" speech...I look forward to the day when men are judged not on the color of their skin, but on the content of their charactors. That's a good place to start.
 
agreed. schools should be good everywhere... unfortunately, they aren't. For a variety of reasons. In california, we have so many children that we hire "Emergency" Credentials...meaning, they aren't really teachers... it's like having a substitute permenently.

There is a test in California, I think it's the SAT-9, that showed that the schools with the highest percentage of EC teachers had the worst scores.

Also... teachers are paid FAR less, and are given too much shit for people to WANT to be teachers. I grew up in California's educational system, and I've had some really great teachers, and the ones I've had put up with no shit. If a kid was acting up. GONE... but I notice that far too often, they're required to take them back in. And Students have NO respect for teachers anymore. Japan's society has MUCH respect for teachers and education, and look at that society... some of the smartest people in the world come from that system. We need to take notes.

In summery *L*, we need to pay our teachers more, REQUIRE the students to respect them, and if they don't, severe punishment, and we need to let our teachers TEACH... not do all this buacracy bullshit. Give the schhols more money, and make it work. it can be done.

And so you all don't think I'm not a complete asshole... ONE of the reasons that Californian schools are so bad is that we're right next to Mexico, and with all the ILLEGAL (I have NO problem with mexicans, they're incredibly hard working, and most of the ones who crossed the border have great respect for societies rules... except the one they broke to get here) immigrants. We need to crack down on that shit right away and HARD...
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
Red will give you a good argument.

There certainly is a variety of methods in law that have been established to rectify past discrimination. I'd like to go back to Martin Luthor's "dream" speech...I look forward to the day when men are judged not on the color of their skin, but on the content of their charactors. That's a good place to start.

(RED will give an argument, yes. A good one? That is debateable.
I like RED but his opinions are diametrically in opposition to mine and we agree to disagree.)

Affrimitive action should not exist, should not be practiced. It lowers standards for all and encourages mediocrity in all. Where is the incentive to excell, when those of less caliber are raised above the best?
 
another point I'd like to make... people only bitch about AA when it affects the high paid jobs. Where are the people bitching that there aren't enough white fruitpickers? or dishwashers at dennys? No one complains when the minorities have the shitty jobs..

just making a point.

I work in a facotry that makes cheese. Decent wages, but mostly hard work (I got lucky, I got the cushy job *nods*).
 
Martin said it best...

"I say to you today, my friends, that in spite of the difficulties and frustrations of the moment, I still have a dream. It is a dream deeply rooted in the American dream.

I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal."

I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slaveowners will be able to sit down together at a table of brotherhood.

I have a dream that one day even the state of Mississippi, a desert state, sweltering with the heat of injustice and oppression, will be transformed into an oasis of freedom and justice.

I have a dream that my four children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character."

*How can anyone be equal if there is a program that encourages discrimination based on racial/sexual reward incentives? You get X amount of government $$ if you hire this person on appearance, while minimizing the accomplishments of that individual (token). Another benefit of such a program to the powers that be, is rational people see the injustice, creating a division, making a need for more intervention. It's sad to note that the King family after his death, has exploited race hatred and highlighted color difference to their own personal gain. They embrace the failed policies of the NAACP creating their own form of segregation, through race hatred, and victimization. They counter every criticism of their political objectives by labelling you a racist, while their own racism is the position of their agenda.



:D
 
Re: Martin said it best...

Lost Cause said:

They counter every criticism of their political objectives by labelling you a racist, while their own racism is the position of their agenda.
:D

Well said.
 
Dantetier said:
another point I'd like to make... people only bitch about AA when it affects the high paid jobs. Where are the people bitching that there aren't enough white fruitpickers? or dishwashers at dennys? No one complains when the minorities have the shitty jobs..

I'm not aware of affirmative action affecting high-paying jobs, unless they are government jobs. Nor do I have any statistics on white fruit pickers or white dishwashers at Denny's. But I did seasonal work in a potato cellar when I was in high school, and every one of the guys with me were my age — except the guy who grew the spuds and owned the cellar. It was a way to make money. The women culling the potatoes were local housewives picking up a few extra bucks.
I'd call that a shitty job, and like most shitty jobs it was a start. Career dishwashers at Denny's are there because they have no other skills, or maybe they've found their comfort level.

The real problem with affirmative action, though, is that it breeds a system where minorities know they don't have to excel, to do their best, to get into a certain college. This is the oft-mentioned "soft racism." It also makes the non-minority students wonder if the guy next to them in class deserves to be there or if he just "qualified" because of the color of his skin. That doesn't sound like a very good way to ease racial issues.
The fact is that black students who overcome peer pressure and do try often excel and rise to the level they deserve, just like the white guys. And no one (wishful thinking on my part, perhaps) is surprised or thinks twice these days when they encounter a successful executive who also happens to be a "minority."
 
I voted for the ability only.
Affirmative action has negative consequences on both sides.

Receiving consideration for a job only because a company has to make a quota is insulting and sometimes there is resentment because a minority receives the job. It's time to let AA go. It may have been necessary earlier on, but I think minorities can stand on their own without any more concessions.
 
I work in an industry that is predominately white. Every job and every connection I've gotten has been due to the fact that contractors both like and respect me and feel confident about the quality of my work. I'm well trained and good at what I do. I have never benifited from affirmative action and would probably feel insulted if I did.

At the same time, there have been plenty of instances where I've been on a job and it was made clear that certain people didn't like me because I was black and expected much less from me. They will spread rumors, make racist jokes and so forth. Sometimes they will even go so far as to try sabatoge just to make me look like some bumbling coon. But, desite all this, the quality of my work never suffers and I continue to get called back. I guess it's just one of those things that us black people have to go through. The trick is being able to handle it yourself without relying on others.
 
This arguement of lets all just play fair is a lot like a basketball game where one team has been cheating for 3 and a half quarters and the score is 100 to 20. And then when they are called on it they say, "okay, you got me. lets all play fair now." Well that's all great and good, but meanwhile the score (i.e. accumulated weath, land, assets, entrepreneureal expertise) is drastically out of balance. Success in this country is not just dependent on drive and ability, but also access to resources and experience.

The whole issue can best be viewed in terms of a supply and demand situation. Where the positions are in demand - be they for jobs, schools, or contracts; and the people are the supply. Affirmative action is basically a subsidy within this scheme. So the question is, are subsidies inherently wrong? And if not, when are they justified?

Well we support certain kinds of subsidies all the time - subsidies for farmers, subsidies for government contractors, subsidies of all kinds shapes and forms. So although subsidies are against the principles of free markets, we decide to allow them anyway in certain circumstances.

All this is basically saying is that I don't think Affirmative Action is inherently wrong. It can be good in certain situations. Anyone who thinks Affirmative Action wasn't necessary in the 60s and 70s after 100 years of segregation is crazy (just think about my basketball analogy). Furthermore, the fact is that despite laws preventing segregation, America is still largely segregated. You still have segregated neighborhoods, segregated schools, and in some ways segregated ways of looking at many issues. Having plurality in power positions, government representation, and workplaces is best for America.

And as for the claim that AA steals positions from more qualified candidates, that claim is very shakey in some cases. For instance in higher education. Most universities grade all the applications they get in some way or another. The first grade of applicants are basically the students who are so highly qualified they are just IN - no question about it. Then there are the students who are strong and very qualified candidate. And then the last tier of students are those who are qualified, but are otherwise indistinguishable.

There are often more students than spaces available for this last category. Those decisions come down to very intangible things. "This student plays an instrument. This student is from Alaska and we don't have many students from there. This student is the child of an alumni. This student is an athlete. etc etc etc." These are the cases where affirmative action can come into play. But the students from this category who are NOT admitted could just as easily be passed over for ANY other number of reasons and they never had a *stringent* right to that spot. And then considering at most major universities the number of african american students even WITH Affirmative Action is less than about 10%. That's less than the number of legacy admissions at most schools.

Okay. i've rambled on enough. I just thought I'd introduce a new way of looking at the picture. And share my insights. Ultimately I think Affirmative Action should be steadily phased out. But intrinsically I think there's nothing wrong with it.
 
Last edited:
There is something wrong with it.

Subsidies are based on economics, not racial prejudice.
I agree with the resources part of your comment though, because many times, it's who you know and how. However, if you have a reputation for completing hard work well and honestly there shouldn't be much of a problem because people, especially rich ones want to know that they're working with someone who produces honestly and gives results no matter what the colour.

Affirmative action isn't about getting richer quicker; its about working in a job that you tolerate (like who really loves their job right :D) with co-workers who are equally dedicated to getting it done.
 
sensational204 said:
This arguement of lets all just play fair is a lot like a basketball game where one team has been cheating for 3 and a half quarters and the score is 100 to 20. And then when they are called on it they say, "okay, you got me. lets all play fair now." Well that's all great and good, but meanwhile the score (i.e. accumulated weath, land, assets, entrepreneureal expertise) is drastically out of balance. Success in this country is not just dependent on drive and ability, but also access to resources and experience.


Drive and ability help create experience and open doors to resources. Accumulated wealth changes from generation to generation, and land and assets change hands.
Your own experience tells you that. Think of a group of people you know, college classmates for example. Some among them are doing very well, some aren't. Bill Gates was never on poverty row growing up, but certainly he didn't inherit the vast fortune he controls now. The opportunity Gates saw and took advantage of is available to anyone with the know-how, acumen and entreprenurial spirit.
For the most part, people in this country create their own uneven playing fields by their own decisions — dropping out of school, not going to college, getting married at 16. Those aren't necessarily insurmountable obstacles, but they aren't helpful.
Conversely, any student in this country with the brains and drive who applies himself has an excellent chance of getting that dream job, home, car, etc. — as well as falling into an incredibly high tax bracket that punishes success. But that's another thread.
 
Ham Murabi said:

For the most part, people in this country create their own uneven playing fields by their own decisions

I hate to come off like some kind of black conservative type but I just have to say: Black people are responsible for their own destinies. The cycles of inner city strife and numbing ignorance that we go through aren't going to be changed by anyone but us.

No one holds black people back as much as other black people. In my industry I can't even work for fellow black folks because they're intimidated by my education and afraid I'm going to take their jobs. Therefor, I'm usually underpaid and treated like shit.

In school I was the one accused of "trying to be white" for the simple fact that I was smart and could speak clear English (the ironic thing is, I'm way too "Black" in my attitutes and mannerisms to ever fit in as anyone's token :rolleyes: ).

What it really takes is the drive to be more than what anyone else says you can be. For too long it's been suggested that all black people are good at is playing sports, dancing and making rap records. The bad thing is that so many of us believe this true and don't strive for anything more.

We've got a lot of work to do unseating this long ingrained self-hatred and self-imposed ignorance. All the affirmative action in the world isn't going to help that.
 
How come speaking proper english is purportedly a "White" thing? I know many black and other ethnicities that speak perfect english.
 
Dantetier said:
How come speaking proper english is purportedly a "White" thing? I know many black and other ethnicities that speak perfect english.

As well as plenty of whites who mangle the language as bad as anyone, I'm sure.

It's such a ridiculous non-issue.
 
I wasn't trying to make it an issue.. just trying to start another conversation.

Please, don't get the idea that I'm at all racist... I'm vehamently against any sort of racism
 
Back
Top