Abortion

That's fine. The difference of opinion on when "life" begins is something I can accept because full of plenty of gray area. But the whole "only women should be able to decide on abortion" is ridiculous. Neither legality nor morality should be decided subjectively. I'm plenty capable of forming a coherent perspective on the matter -- just like I am on slavery despite being neither a slave nor a slave owner; just as I am on the holocaust, being neither Jewish nor Nazi.

See- I don't think I can. That's the reason I don't believe in reparations. I can't understand something like that unless I experienced it. You think you can- but the look that came into my grandmother's eyes when I mentioned the paper I was writing on the "Americanization" camps was enough to teach me that I couldn't.

And if you don't want legality decided subjectively- do you mind if I ask where you're from? I'm from America, where the laws are applied, at the highest level- subjectively; based on 30 minutes of testimony by 2 lawyers over a case that could affect the entire nation. Based entirely on the justices subjective, personal interpretation of the constitution. That's how we roll. And they decided that if you don't have a uterus- you don't get to say shit.
 
Abortion should be a crime.

Believing this is not dependent on gender. It is a biologial fact (only) that it is the woman carrying the fetus which is half derived from a male. One can not become pregnant otherwise.

If it is not life growing inside the impregnated woman please do explain what it is.

You can't.

Game over.:rose:
 
See- I don't think I can. That's the reason I don't believe in reparations. I can't understand something like that unless I experienced it. You think you can- but the look that came into my grandmother's eyes when I mentioned the paper I was writing on the "Americanization" camps was enough to teach me that I couldn't.

And if you don't want legality decided subjectively- do you mind if I ask where you're from? I'm from America, where the laws are applied, at the highest level- subjectively; based on 30 minutes of testimony by 2 lawyers over a case that could affect the entire nation. Based entirely on the justices subjective, personal interpretation of the constitution. That's how we roll. And they decided that if you don't have a uterus- you don't get to say shit.

Nearly all of that last paragraph is false. But you definitely seem certain about it.
 
While I believe that life begins at conception, I also believe a woman has a right to decide what to do with her own body. It's a quandary for me. What I hate is young girls using abortion as a means of birth control. If you slip up once, okay. After that, learn your lesson and use proper birth control. And I certainly don't think someone who's been raped should be required to carry the baby to term, though I applaud those who do.

I used to oppose abortion but now I'm all for it because of my support for eugenics and population control.

You are a good argument for eugenics, Mike.

So?

Murder is perfectly legal in some circumstances, so why not if a person's life is in danger (which is the cause for most abortions)?

Most abortions are not because the mother's life is is danger if she carries - unless you mean her lifestyle. Most abortions are voluntary.

Can there be life without conception?

Excellent question.

In my personal opinion, life doesn't begin at conception. Potential for life isn't life. And many of the things (most often a heartbeat) which are used to support an argument against abortion don't strike me as particularly "human."

When you put a sick animal down, the vet always administers the shot, waits a couple of minutes, then uses a stethoscope to check for...the heartbeat. So using that standard, if the heartbeat stopping is a sure indicator of death, doesn't it's presence indicate life? What else has a heartbeat? Plants don't. Trees don't. Only living things have heartbeats. Just because it cannot sustain life outside of the mother doesn't mean it isn't alive. A fetus is in the same position as someone severely injured and in a coma - they need support to live until they can do so on their own. If an injured person doesn't make it, we say they died. How can they die if they weren't alive?





Would it be ok if it was only tattood bikers who own business had them?

LOL!!! :D Good one.
 
I have never had an opinion regarding abortion till I joined Lit. After reading the combined stupidity of many Lit posters I am now in favor.
 
I love abortion threads. Helps you to sort out who is ignorant and who isn't.
 
I love how people claim that "life begins at conception" as if it was a scientific axiom. When in fact it's a talking point. "Life" is a vauge buzzword, and so is "begins".

Why should the splicing of a genome the starting point of personhood that grants rights? That process in itself only creates a condition that may or may lead to a fetus. Most of the time not. It's not magic. It's a biological function among many.

Why not the gestation of a zygote? Why not the fetal development of function X, Y or Z? Why not birth? Why not the cognitive development of self awareness?



And why do I bother?
 
Tough topic. What I don't like is the double standard when it comes to murder. Kill a pregnant woman and her fetus, get charged with a double homicide.

YOU CAN'T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS!!! Either it's a human being in the womb or it's not.
 
The Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003 was huge step in the right direction.

We need a Republican president to go the whole distance with the criminalization of all abortion, giving it the label of murder in the first degree!:rose:
 
I'm not sure an undelivered fetus has rights, that is the question I can't resolve for myself thus my leaving of the decision to the female carrying.

If I thought the undelivered fetus had rights my opinion would be anti-abortion.

I continue to debate it in my own mind.


Life is complicated, it's not always either-black-or-white.

It's mind twisting for me too.
 
The Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003 was huge step in the right direction.

We need a Republican president to go the whole distance with the criminalization of all abortion, giving it the label of murder in the first degree!:rose:

And I would invest in Canadian abortion clinics.
 
I love how people claim that "life begins at conception" as if it was a scientific axiom. When in fact it's a talking point. "Life" is a vauge buzzword, and so is "begins".

Why should the splicing of a genome the starting point of personhood that grants rights? That process in itself only creates a condition that may or may lead to a fetus. Most of the time not. It's not magic. It's a biological function among many.

Why not the gestation of a zygote? Why not the fetal development of function X, Y or Z? Why not birth? Why not the cognitive development of self awareness?



And why do I bother?

I can't answer why you bother, sorry. I do have a question though. If life doesn't begin at conception, when does it? Explain exactly when that 'biological function' becomes an actual baby. And your second paragraph - are you truly asking if we should move the consideration of something being alive to the point of cognitive self-awareness? So, a newborn infant isn't alive? At what point is it alive then? 2 days? 2 weeks? 2 months? I'm going to assume you aren't such a monster that you actually believe that, but if you do, please read the following article. It talks about infant self-awareness, which begins even before birth.

http://www.psychology.emory.edu/cognition/rochat/lab/5 levels of self-awareness.pdf

And why not say life begins with the biologic function of x, y or z? Because those functions are not a fundamental change of the fetus, but simply the natural growth and development of something begun earlier. When you have a bunch of parts lying around and someone asks you what it's going to be, you say it's going to be a car, or a machine or whatever. It isn't yet, because the parts aren't put together yet. When you have a sperm and an egg, they aren't a baby, because they aren't together yet. Putting them together is what makes a baby. No, it's not viable on it's own, but given time in the proper environment, it will grow and develop the ability to live outside the womb. It doesn't need any more parts to become viable, just time, it is already complete. This is why I believe life begins at conception. There is simply no other point in the development that is marked by such a fundamental change as when the sperm and the egg come together and merge their DNA.

And yeah, I know my opinion won't be popular here, but it's my opinion, and I have offered a reasonable argument for having it. I'd like to hear it if someone can give me a reasonable explanation for why I am wrong that doesn't involve just telling me I'm stupid or an idiot or racist (not sure how that last one would come into play, but it wouldn't surprise me.)
 
How about keeping it legal: ...but defund Planned Parenthood!

No more subsidizing abortions!

It's between you, God and your doctor.
 
Last edited:
Abortion is an essential tool in the eugenics war against the weak.
 
I'm glad partial birth abortion is illegal in America.

To me, the kid is too far a long at that point to abort. Who are these fucking nit wits and why wait so long?

I'm still not sure how I feel about it in the first to early second trimester. I guess it's OK.
 
How about keeping it legal: ...but defund Planned Parenthood!

No more subsidizing abortions!

It's between you and God.

Maybe because the funding they get for providing abortions is not from the government.. and for two, abortion only makes up 3 % of what Planned Parenthood does

but her.. why let facts get in the way of a good ole fashioned dumbass rant
 
Abortion is the result of debauchery.

The dreaded cause and end to all civilizations that have preceeded ours.

We must dismiss the pleasures and temptations of the flesh at the point in which our sanity is lost.:rose:
 
Abortion is the result of debauchery.

The dreaded cause and end to all civilizations that have preceeded ours.

We must dismiss the pleasures and temptations of the flesh at the point in which our sanity is lost.:rose:

Yeah, cuz that's gonna fly - especially on a porn site.
 
Unfortunately I have to say that abortion is legalized murder.

I do not want to blame anyone.

But It can hardly be anything else.


http://munkuvat.net/dm-01O4.jpg

Unfortunately you need the concept of minding your own business explained to you.
It's none of your fucking business, nor anyone else s what goes on between a person and their doctor

it would not even be an issue except for nosy motherfuckers like yourself.


Do fucking understand that?
 
Who are these fucking nit wits and why wait so long?

This is what I often wonder about.

I'm totally pro-choice, but I'm very against late-term abortions except where the mother's life is at risk, because I see them as YET ANOTHER instance of failing to plan ahead and be responsible.

If you're pregnant and going to abort, fine. Do it before it's obvious that you're pregnant and before the baby is viable on its own.
 
It's none of your fucking business, nor anyone elses
Do fucking understand that?

Sorry, you can not stop the discussion.

People have different opinions on this topic and they have the right to tell what they think.
 
Back
Top